General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Byron
VisualPolitik EN
comments
Comments by "Byron" (@byron-ih2ge) on "The Problem of Radical Islam in France - VisualPolitik EN" video.
france: trying to assimilate islam with french culture and values but instead gets villified as a minority abuser and an islamophobe india : first time ?
239
@abhimanyujha5550 india as as a single political entity didnt exist before 1947. It was just a geographic area where hundreds of warring kingdoms sharing somewhat of a similar culture lived just like europe .
16
@Smile-ow4xj cough cough it didnt include tamil nadu , kerala .cough cough the tamil and kerala kings have remained independent forever before the british came in , also kerala was independent even during the british just under a subsidiary alliance thats it .
6
@thedamnedatheist even in this case france and india share a unique similarity.if france stopped the caliphate from expanding further west , india stopped the caliphate from expanding further east .
5
Are u guys having some problem in understanding English, because what i meant is pretty straight forward . when someone was referring to india in ancient times , he would be reffering to a geographical region known as india , a place made up of hundreds of war waging kingdoms but all sharing some kind of cultural similarity just like europe
4
@zeeeb3959 what do u mean, i cant understand what you have written
4
@emmekae6772 pakistan secular 😂😂, done we wont proceed any further i agree with everything u said.
4
@rahuljha6627 ya true just like europe .it was just an idea a geographic identity before the british came in
3
@d.3052 read again what i have written, understand it and then comment .
3
@rahuljha6627 the british was the closest india came to reunification. Had the british not come in there is a high chance that india would be a much more of a developed area and there is a possibility that india would become something like a European union but the india we see today in which thousands of ethnicities hundreds of languages and 10s of religions are united under the nationalistic spirit of india , this would be impossible without the british.
3
@emmekae6772 but yes i agree bjp can become supremacist if it stays in power for too long. A state named up is already being ruled by a mad monk
2
wahhabism/salafism is literally the way muhmadd and his companions followed islam.the true islam before it got diluted by humanity and local influences
2
@heblegirish there are much more differences than commonality between kashmir and kerala or bombay and bengal. See u can assume whatever u want but it wont change anything the marathas at the last stage had become so power blind and depended on loot based soldiers that the marathas destroyed sringeri one of the cardinal maths of advaita vedanta .the tamils and kerala were always allies and considered both the arabs and the mauryas equally foreign . the rajputs sided with the sultans rather than there fellow indian kings . all this doesnt happen if india even had 1 percent of the unity ur talking about.if there would have been even a bit of unity the british could have nvr taken over india .u dont wanna face thw truth not my prob.bye
2
@heblegirish no thats not true the frankish empire was present so was the tamil empire or the kannada empire(vinaynagara) or maratha empire but no indian empire ever existed because its just too diverse of a region to govern theough a monarchy
2
@emmekae6772 they are right aligned but in no way are they supremacists on a national lvl .
2
@emmekae6772 first and foremost there is no conversion in hinduism, they artificially created that gharwapsi for those who voluntary wanna return to the path of there ancestors.show me one article of forced conversion in india with proof of forced conversion.hinduism isnt a propagating religion like islam or christianity.christianity till date does the highest number of conversions in india majority through luring and islam reports the highest number of forced conversions in india . they target the poor, vulnerable and the weak.
2
@heblegirish no so many countries existed
1
@emmekae6772 comparing india and pakistan isnt fair because india is a secular democratic republic whereas pakistan is an islamic hybrid regime .if conversions happen they happen almost proportionally between Christianity,islam and hinduism in india . the same cannot be said about the other two states
1
@morganseaman4557 just like mauryas were considered as unifiers of india ,but neither of them are the reason why india and china exist like this today the india 's reason is the british whereas china's reason is the qing dynasty which was even bigger than the present china . also nearly 80 percent of china is han and 95 percent know mandarin whereas in in india no ethnicity crosses even the 40 percent mark, if we group the hindi speaking people as one community , (even though there are hundreds of ethnicites present there)even after that hindi speakers account only for around 42 percent of india
1
@rahuljha6627 sorry but you are wrong it cannot be considered unification because marathas were more like a Confederacy and had vassal states , the vassal states were always trying to ambush the marathas if given a chance. the mughals and the Maurya's were much more successful in unifying india than the marathas .
1
@thedamnedatheist ya franks saved europe from gettimg arabised and islamised . how brutal it would have looked , we have an example of islamic spain
1
@heblegirish ya just like the british empire or the french empire is a european empire.
1
@acidtechno8545 ashoka united 90 percent of what was known as india and thats the highest till date .
1
@muditshrimali and what i have written in my last comment is what i have written in the first comment
1
@emmekae6772 ya that was enough zia ul haq destroyed pakistan , before that pakistan was an islamic republic just for namesake, this is what islamic republic is all about in the modern world but dont worry your pm wants to make pakistan into riyasat-e-medina. fool doesnt know stoning people to death, cutting hands for stealing , no freedom to women and tons of other beautiful rules when imposed on present day pakistan only then can pakistan become riyasat-e-medina 😂, i am pretty optimistic that pakistan will become riyaset -e -medina, this is what world should do let muslims practice 100 percent pure islam, they would leave islam themselves.
1
@emmekae6772 spain had lost its identity and it was successfully restoreed thats it , moreover everybody can surely say that if spain was muslim today it would be no way near as good as today's spain. no body has any problems with muslim its just islam
1
@emmekae6772 people's republic refers to communist authoritarianism btw
1
@emmekae6772 this is the reason why christianity or any other religion isnt hated the way islam is brutally hated and deserves to be hated : 1.christianity went to primitive lands to spread christianity it didnt destroy powerful ancient civilizations like persia, india,assyria,egypt or greece. Did nothing wrong to my homeland so i dont care 2. Jesus had nothing wrong with him but muhmadd had everything wrong with him 3.the initial stages of all religion show whats there true nature of that religion because thats the purest form of that religion. Christianity not a single time did Resort to violence in its initial days ,they were heavily persecuted by romans but they just defended themselves it was only later during the middle ages that christianity became barbaric 4. The most important one the abrahamics as a whole are a destructive and dangerous ideology but christianity and Judaism have reformed themselves to fit modern standards .they no longer have an offensive tendency , islam still continues in its original form as it was 1400 yrs ago. Christians clearly acknowledge all the mistakes and problem they have caused to this world a christian world no more exists ,its a secular progressive western world . jesus wasnt an arab 😂, he was a jew from judea . in order to break the morality of the jews the romans named that area as syria-palestina . read something other than propoganda before commenting
1
@emmekae6772 what a literal human! Understand the context , communism has nvr existed in reality but in the real world people's republic refer to communism just for namesake .its socialist dictatorship who actually call themselves communists, they arent actually commies but just called commies
1
@emmekae6772 i never moved any goalpost but surely u dont like the truth .
1
@emmekae6772 arabs and jews are different, jews living in the fertile crescent and israel gave birth to the abrahamic religions, tribal desert dwelling arabs gave birth to a political ideology named islam . it just claims the abrahamic lineage in order to make itself look relevant and gain importance in the global world and thats it .
1
@emmekae6772 if stating facts about islam without any bias is islamophobia then yes i am biased
1
@emmekae6772 this isnt about rightwing i hate hindutva and majority consider me a left aligned person. if you can pickout onething i have stated wrong about islam i will agree to you
1
@emmekae6772 so prove me wrong if you think that way
1
@koushikvijayakumar7924 they were very small kingdoms waring against each other
1
@muditshrimali i have edited just my last comment .others were edited long back
1
@-_- right yes
1
try viewing the lady of heaven trailer
1