Comments by "agon noga" (@agonnoga6100) on "How RSS helped saves lives of Hindus, Sikhs during Partition" video.

What was RSS role in independence of India??
5
Shivam Sanatani by not doing anything against the British while marching with lathis and worshipping Adolf Hitler. Also read Savarkar's letter imploring British to release him.
4
Shivam Sanatani my question is very simple. What role RSS played in independence of India??
2
@rohithsharma1476 bhai, since you have read that book and watched that video, why aren't you able to say even one word about the role of RSS in independence of India??
2
Shivam Sanatani if any organisation is against 200 million Indian citizens, it's not only anti national but a threat to the country.
2
Shivam Sanatani People in bed with the British helped protect India?? Why aren't you able to say role of RSS against the British?? Our #1 enemy was the British not Muslims who alongwith Hindus Buddhists Sikhs Christians are Indians.
1
@daddy2694 you think majority of muslims who are Dalits or backward castes who converted to Islam to escape casteism are not Indians?? Jinnah, himself a Hindu baniya like Gandhi who converted to Islam, wanted implementation of cabinet mission plan of 1946 for strong states which was opposed by business houses backing Congress due to which Congress had to withdraw it's consent to the cabinet mission plan which led to the partition and not Hindu Muslim divide that we have been led to believe.
1
Shivam Sanatani Did you know maximum number of troops and officers of INA were Sikhs, Muslims and Hindu Tamils?? Also go and check the names of people incarcerated in cellular Jail where real freedom fighters were incarcerated. You will find many muslim names. For this, unfortunately you will have to visit cellular Jail in Andaman and Nicobar Islands which few can do.
1
@daddy2694 sardar Patel was a lawyer and advocate of big business houses who were profiteering under the British. Like Gandhi, Patel and Nehru's role in India's independence is next to zero. Patel only became hyper active when it came time for the British to leave India thereby putting the Marwari Gujarati Parsi business houses at risk in an India not ruled centrally by the British which is what cabinet mission plan intended. If cabinet mission plan of 1946 was implemented, today, India would have been united and not broken into three parts with insurgencies at several places. Patel, Gandhi, Nehru to protect few business houses sacrificed united India. This you won't get to read in any history book. And, btw, Rajputana aka Rajasthan, Gujarat, Kashmir weren't parts of British India but people from these places ended up dominating India's politics and economy during British rule a legacy which continues till this day. Did you ask how and why this happened?? The answer is pretty uncomfortable which you won't read in any history books.
1
Shivam Sanatani you people?? Lol! I am a general category Hindu from a defence family. And, btw, my father was a war hero.
1
@daddy2694 I don't know much about Mopalah as I am not from that part of India. My "divine knowledge" only comes by piecing together different bits of information to get the whole picture. People talk about Hindu Muslim divide, but except Ayesha Jalal an academic from Pakistan, no one talks about cabinet mission plan of autonomous states which was opposed by Indian business houses tooth and nail which led to the partition of India. Both India and Pakistan are collection of nations and not a nation state. Which is why our constitution defines India as a union of states and not a nation state.
1
@daddy2694 yo, you need to live in a place to know what's happening there otherwise your knowledge will be from whatsapp University. Ayesha Jalal is hounded in her own country for being pro India and anti partition. She frequently speaks in literature festivals in India. It is Kashmiri Hindu Nehru who is the principal architect of article 370. Without Nehru Gandhi parivar, Kashmir would have been integrated with India just like Hyderabad which has become Mecca of IT companies. India is Greek name of area around Indus which we call Pakistan today. So, who is an Indian? You need to meet people different from you to know them.
1
@daddy2694 it seems you don't follow defence expert and spokesperson of Hindus Abhijit Iyer Mitra who himself advices no one book as a source for his knowledge. Similarly, my knowledge has been gleaned from connecting the dots from various sources which is why I have been saying that you won't find these covered in any history books. Do you need to be an Einstein to figure out who had given the name Indian Ocean?? Several Hindu leaders are against the way article 370 has been abrogated and the way an extremely flawed Ram Mandir judgement was given. Is India limited to Kashmir and Ram Mandir?? Large parts of India with majority Hindu population these are irrelevant issues. Go and do Ram Mandir, Kashmir in North East, Central India, South India and see the type of response you get
1
Shivam Sanatani that's why people call you andh bhakts.
1
@daddy2694 how many died from 1947 till date??
1
@daddy2694 that's the crux of the problem. ASI clearly mentioned of no temple existing beneath the mosque. Yes, I don't support 370 or an such articles anywhere in India including north east. You can't have different laws in different places. How is it, under 60 years of a Kashmiri Hindu family's rule, their own state has never been integrated during their rule?? Why did it need a Gujarati to scrap these articles after 70 years of India's independence?? But, the way article 370 was abrogated, was done in an illegal manner as India is a union of states where center can only take actions wrt bifurcation of a state only when a resolution to this effect is passed in a local state assembly. India has been under foreign rule for more than 1000 years and after 1947, been ruled and looted by those who were helping the British loot and rule India and Indians. Which is why people close to the British are still ruling India and Indians. Questioning this will make those who have been profiteering under this system uncomfortable. Who is an Indian when the word itself is Greek origin for people whom we call Pakistanis today??
1
@shalivahana1300 bhakts like burnol. When they run out of argument they rush for Burnol.
1
@daddy2694 provide me a credible link which mentions ASI providing proof of a temple beneath the mosque?? Yes, they did find a structure beneath the mosque but it is not that of a temple. Read, ASI's report which you are quoting. This is why the Ram Mandir judgement from supreme court has been criticised by many people who are impartial in this matter. That site is not open to visitors. So, how did you visit some place not open for the public?? Constitution mentions India as a union of states. When you break apart a state without its consent it is violation of this union of states. Any change in the state has to be moved by the state's assembly. This is what the law is. Tomorrow, Kashmiris will breakup Gujarat into ten parts just like Congress did to politically powerful Andhra Pradesh. Gujaratis cannot breakup Kashmir without the consent of its people. This is the law whether we like it or not. India is the Greek name of porkistan whether you like it or not. So, what does that makes you??
1
@daddy2694 if you call Pakistanis pigs why should that infuriate me?? You are not able to provide one link which mentions ASI has provided proof of a temple under the Babri mosque. I am not an archeologist. That is the specialisation of ASI who have clearly mentioned of no temple existing beneath the rubble of the mosque. Yes the mosque has been built upon an existing structure but whether it was a temple, there's no proof of that. Using emoticons instead of facts and logic shows the level of your maturity.
1
@daddy2694 if that be the case, why are you failing to provide one link validating your claim?? Forward me one link where ASI validates presence of a temple beneath the mosque?? Either we have a nation with law or we end up with a nation with kangaroo courts and tinpot dictators.
1