Comments by "agon noga" (@agonnoga6100) on "45 years to Zia’s coup u0026 how his is the most lasting impact on India, Pakistan u0026 the world" video.

  1. You have not explained the root cause behind why Pakistan from a liberal and moderately Islamic country took a turn for hard Islamism after 1971. Pakistan turned to Islamism not out of choice but pressure from Saudi Arabia. Pakistan became bankrupt after the crushing defeat in 1971 and lost East Pakistan from where Pakistan used to get 70% of its foreign exchange and was almost 50% of Pakistan's GDP. Pakistan with its huge military could in no way fund its budget after separation of East Pakistan. This is when they turned to the Saudis to bail them out. The Saudis agreed to help them on the condition that Pakistan became a real Islamic country. This started the process of Islamization of Pakistan. 1978 civil war in Afghanistan only helped this process further setting Pakistan on a course 180 degrees different from what Jinnah had envisaged. Pakistan's economic stability was ensured by massive aid from USA and Saudi Arabia. With the exit of USSR from Afghanistan and collapse of the Soviet Union USA started tightening the screws on Pakistan from the 1990s. This is when the economic woes of Pakistan started which was kept afloat with aid from USA and Saudi Arabia not because of its inherent strengths. Sept 11, gave another brief respite to Pakistan but now with complete withdrawal of USA from Afghanistan Pakistan is back to square one. Now even the Saudis are reluctant to fund Pakistan generously as their own economy dependent on petro dollars is in decline. In a nutshell, without the crutches of Saudi Arabia and America, Pakistan cannot go far as a nation. It simply doesn't have the resources to fund its government a trap which is also applicable to Afghanistan making these multi ethnic countries highly unstable.
    3