Comments by "Cole Behnke" (@colebehnke7767) on "So, Hitler was a Communist in early 1919" video.

  1. Why did the Soviet Union do the same thing?
    10
  2. Who was he spying on exactly?
    7
  3. Uh, the Nazi Party had the largest trade union at the time.
    6
  4. Yeah, tell me you haven’t watched the video without telling me you haven’t watched the video. Though to be honest a lot of that isn’t covered in this one, but has been refuted in his other videos. Hitler did seek economic leveling, but deciding to fight all your neighbors tends to put a stopper on that. He was a race based socialist, class wasn’t an issue for him. And one of the first things he did when coming to power was suspend private property. He was supported by rich industrialists, after he came to power, if they didn’t support him, they would’ve been replaced. As did happen on numerous occasions. Before he came to power rich industrialists didn’t support him in any meaningful way. If destroying trade unions and forcing workers to a national one made one not socialist, then what of the Soviet Union that did the exact same thing? Can you provide evidence for the claim that they used socialism in the name just to attract workers? Cus that would be like a Christian nationalist party claiming to be the National Muslim party. Strasser and his side of the party had the same exact views on race and nationalism as Hitler, so by saying he was Socialist is admitting that race based socialism is a legitimate form of socialism. Where Hitler and Strasser disagreed was on whether there should be a peaceful revolution (Hitler’s stance) or a violent revolution (Strasser’s stance). How is his definition, “the science of dealing with the common weal.” contradictory to the definition of socialism?
    5
  5.  @hobbso8508 yeah, you should actually watch the video. Hitler was in a German military, the Bavarian military, so somehow he was spying on his own team?
    5
  6. So he was sent to spy on the Bavarian socialist army that was controlled by a socialist?
    5
  7. Yeah, and most of them were released… TIK talks about this.
    4
  8.  @vasconcelossentimento where did he privatize? To whom? Socialists kill other socialists all the time.
    4
  9. ⁠ @WARPDremora did Marx introduce the idea of class analysis and class conflict to socialism? And the Soviet Union was vary imperialistic for all of it’s history…
    4
  10. So when he told the public he was going to kill the Jews?
    4
  11. @Vesta_the_Lesseryet you have no facts to back up your claim, like the DAF was one of the largest workers union in history. For someone who banned trade unions they sure had a big and influential trade union.
    4
  12. “Private ownership” band in the reichstag fire decree of 1933. “Racial discrimination at the heart of policy.” Unlike class discrimination at the heart of communist policy? “Massive debt spending.” Any examples of socialist states not also doing this? “Nationalistic rhetoric.” Uh you do know about the great patriotic war? Basically watch the video before you make such uneducated takes.
    4
  13.  @alejandroz1198 who was he informing?
    4
  14. So you didn’t watch any of his other videos?
    4
  15. So reactionary socialism?
    4
  16. The anti communist right who voted for the national socialist party?
    4
  17. Yet he wasn’t supported by the capitalists? And while he was against communism, he was a socialist.
    3
  18.  @WARPDremora so a social system with clear classes is can be socialist?
    3
  19. What makes someone a real historian?
    3
  20. Yet his ideology is based out of it
    3
  21.  @alejandroz1198 but this was before he was hired for the Reichswehr.
    3
  22. Modern socialism?😂
    3
  23. No, this was before that.
    3
  24. After the Bavarian Soviet fell.
    3
  25. How so
    2
  26. For whom? The army he was in was a socialist one.
    2
  27. @Vesta_the_Lesserwow, and it turns out that the Nazis never relinquished their privileges in United Steel. Looks like you got hoodwinked, just like all the people they sold it to. So did you actually watch the video?
    2
  28.  @kafkaMt there is plenty of evidence of capitalist abroad supporting his party, but out of thousands of rich capitalists in Germany, only two can be said to have actually supported him before his rise to power.
    2
  29. This was before he became a “V-Mann” And isn’t social democrats another form of socialism?
    2
  30.  @JesuzPrice222 can you provide the documents where they say they lied? Or were the lies actually that American propaganda said the Nazis were capitalist in order to align with Soviet propaganda?
    2
  31. What exactly does he mean by far right extremist?
    2
  32. So an anti communist names his party the national socialists?
    2
  33. So if the Soviet Union was state capitalist…
    2
  34.  @vasconcelossentimento because that’s what socialism was like at the time, just replace race with class.
    2
  35. How so?
    2
  36. More like he shifted his view slightly, before he was a nazi he believed that other forms of socialism were capitalist plots to keep the workers divided.
    2
  37. ⁠@Vesta_the_Lesseryeah, but what do communists think social democracy is but a tool to placate the working class and keep them from uniting under socialism? Oh his actions? You mean the totalitarian government he created? How is that not social control over the economy, aka socialism?
    2
  38. But this was well before he was an agent for the military.
    2
  39. Socialism says nothing about what collective should rule, its Marxism that introduced the whole workers ownership idea.
    2
  40.  @vasconcelossentimento tell me you haven’t seen any of TIK’s videos.
    2
  41.  @gorkri9215 how so exactly? If they really were as anti-communist as you say where are the millions of dead German socialists?
    2
  42.  @gorkri9215 and how is that different from what any other socialists were doing?
    2
  43. Have any actual arguments?
    1
  44.  @Voidmutant what misinformation exactly?
    1
  45.  @esbenm6544 why not?
    1
  46. What evidence do you have that Hitler kept capitalism? Doesn’t the term totalitarian say the opposite? Socialists like to divide people into categories, you know workers vs capitalists? He did not get support from the rich, at least not in a way that would make him capitalist. The Nazis were races based socialists, not class based socialists like Marxism Socialists kill other socialists all the time.
    1
  47. How so?
    1
  48. How so?
    1
  49.  @gorkri9215 where else would one get funding from exactly?
    1
  50.  @gorkri9215 before or after it was certain he was going to win?
    1
  51.  @gorkri9215 so who’s bidding did Hitler do exactly? What were these biddings?
    1