Comments by "AFGuidesHD" (@AFGuidesHD) on "How German Submarines Almost Defeated the Allies - Battle of the Atlantic Documentary" video.

  1.  @Mr.Soggywaffleafagous  I was responding to the "we're so back baby" comment. It's obviously a comment I made based on alternate history. There was no guarantee that Japan would mess up so badly so quickly.
    3
  2. Most posts on the internet are bunk. There's so many realistic alternate pathways Germany had to victory it is quite astonishing that the Americans won as much as they did. Unlike the common assumption about simply american industry == guaranteed victory. American war planners in "Strategic Planning for Coalition Warfare" paint a very bleak picture. Pretty much every American victory scenario relied on the Germans losing or remaining in Russia. My favourite bit is that they explain how D-day should not be attempted if the Germans have more than 14 divisions in the Le Havre area. IRL the Germans did have 16 undermanned divisions. I just love how less informed people think the allies could have overcome even 30 well equipped divisions. Never mind the 250 they had in Russia.
    1
  3.  @DomWeasel  "as happens in most alternate scenarios" Only Hollywood tier productions lol No serious scenario of Germany winning WW2 includes an invasion of the US. As AH himself addressed such a ridiculous notion in American propaganda in May 1941.
    1
  4.  @Brslld  meanwhile in another universe "The allies had no chance of winning"
    1
  5.  @mynamejef7963  Churchill in June 1942 after the Japanese wipe out the remaining USN carriers in the pacific: ....oh.
    1