Arnold Hubbert
CNA Insider
comments
Comments by "Arnold Hubbert" (@arnoldhubbert6779) on "Does My Chinese Family Have Caucasian Ancestors? | On The Red Dot: Family Mysteries | Full Episode" video.
3
2
2
1
1
1
@Iflie
Again, Swedish Vikings didn't go west and there were no Finnish Vikings. Why does Finnish dna also show up in some Japanese or Chinese people without any south asian (Indonesian, etc.) or any other possible European ancestry? You're missing an important logical point. IF it were true that some Asians had actual Finnish ancestry as a result of a supposed connection to the Norse (Scandinavians/Swedes), that connection would be so minimal that you would have to have a lot of actual Scandinavian dna first, in order to show even the smallest amount of Finnish dna. I'm mostly Scandinavian (Norwegian, Danish, and Swedish and some English) and I have NO Finnish dna. So, if a typical Viking had even a little Finnish dna, if you were descended from him, you would still show a lot more Scandinavian, long before you would have retained any Finnish. So again, it's impossible to have Finnish dna through some supposed 'Viking" connection, without also having a lot more of Scandinavian first. The only way for an asian to show Finnish (and in reality, likely not Finnish but Sami, who also live in Finland (especially so little) is by being descended from distantly related common asain ancestors.
And again, I've never heard Dutch containing any Finnish dna, though it's common to have Scandinavian (like I mentioned, my largely Dutch and German wife has a significant amount of Norwegian and Swedish but NO Finnish).
Let's figure this out. Do you have ANY Scandinavian dna? Better yet, what are all your dna percentages? If you don't have any Scandinavian, there's no way you would have any actual Finnish, even in miniscule amounts, from "Viking" (or Dutch) ancestors. Not 1 in a million chance. More like 0 in a million.
1
@Iflie "That would assume DNA had to include certain things to have others. It doesn't work like that." Even if you were Finnish it's extremely rare to have 100% Finnish dna without having some Scandinavian too. So, the chances of your having Finnish and no Scandinavian too, especially in the way you're claiming (through Frisian Vikings), there's no way you're actually of Finnish descent. It's literally impossible. Btw, why are you so determined to try and believe in the impossible rather than the extremely likely (and biologically proven and accepted, of common descent from asian ancestors)? Again, besides my wife, I've never heard of the Dutch having any Finnish dna. However, let's assume some Dutch have 2% Finnish. You'd have to be pretty much 100% Dutch for any amount of Finnish to even register. How much Dutch dna do you have?
On the other hand, if you have a significant amount of Baltic dna, then it is possible to have Finnish ancestry through them, without having Scandinavian dna. However, there are different kinds of Finns. If you have "Finnish" dna through baltic or eastern European it would be through eastern or Karelian Finn, which is more asian and less European, rather than western Scandinavian/Viking connected Finn (especially with no Scandinavian dna).
1
1
1
1
1
1