Comments by "Baha3 Alshamari" (@baha3alshamari152) on "Ukraine: A Demographic Tragedy" video.

  1. I know a tragic story about that It's just a failed state now
    90
  2. Why do they wish to return instead of actually returning
    85
  3. Actually Ukraine lost whole generation of women not men which is much more catastrophic
    63
  4.  @yakovlevskiy  Hordes??
    57
  5. Actually Russia demographic situation is much better than Ukraine
    54
  6.  @yakovlevskiy  What do you mean by hordes from the east ?
    42
  7.  @berjoxhn5142  Yeah but not as bad This was response to the original comment above He said Russia is in much worse shape
    31
  8. ​ @schneejacques3502  Countries future depends on females not males A society can survive losing 80% of its male population but not even 10% of its female population
    28
  9. Afghanistan birth rates were declining since 2003 however in 2023 they increased for the first time in 20 years
    24
  10. Afghanistan has the highest fertility rate in Asia so it can always recover unlike Ukraine
    22
  11. Russia will be in much better situation than Ukraine
    22
  12.  @FOLIPE  Ukrainian salaries aren't decent in most of those countries Also Ukraine is filled with mines and bombs and would require 700 years in order to ckean them up In most of those countries people don't have to worry about losing a foot because you stepped in the wrong place
    18
  13.  @9_9876  EU laws don't allow countries in active war to join
    17
  14. Increasing wages is very expensive and can't fix demographics anyway
    17
  15. EU can't even solve its own demographic crisis so how are they going to help Ukraine ?
    13
  16. He is from Czech republic
    13
  17. Germany demographic conditions after WW2 were much better than today Ukraine
    13
  18. They are doomed regardless of the war outcome
    13
  19. Kharkiv is Ukraine second biggest city so i don't see how depopulation of Kharkiv is positive for Ukraine Also wouldn't housing market become disastrous in western regions due to the influx of refugees ?
    13
  20. Scandinavian countries tried to increase their birth rates using money and financial incentives but failed miserably because having children is cultural thing
    13
  21. Doesn't the border patrol stop men from leaving ?
    12
  22. ​ @andrewrogers3067  1- Nagorno Karabakh is part of Azerbaijan according to international law Russia has no obligation towards it unlike Armenia proper 2- There is no way Russia can annex all of Ukraine or even half of it However their goal is just the strategic areas in the east and south
    11
  23. Paraguay solved the problem by polygamy but Ukraine case is hopeless because they have lots of men but few women
    11
  24. Ukraine mobilization is a failure despite being the most important issue in the country So you are telling me that everything else is doing better than EU 😂😂
    11
  25. Why would they want to live in Ukraine
    10
  26. There will be Ukrainians after the war but their skins will be darker more like brown or black if you know what i mean 😊
    10
  27. Does that include fighting in cold muddy Donbas trenches or are you just a coward keyboard warrior ? Be a man of your word
    10
  28.  @andrewrogers3067  Are you saying that Russia demographic situation is worse than Ukraine
    9
  29. ​ @Dan-u1e  Ukraine will be lucky to have 20 millions people by 2035 Without mass migration it will collapse due to its demographic disaster
    9
  30. So you turn terrible demographic disaster into much worse one
    9
  31. Males are always expandable Men can't get pregnant unlike women 1 man can impregnate hundreds of women in a year A woman can get pregnant only once a year even if she slept with hundreds of men so the value of men is always low
    8
  32.  @0815Catgus  Western Europe has better economic and stability and women Ukraine is worse than Africa
    7
  33. All the talking about development and returning of people and future is meaningless as Ukraine is stuck in a war of attrition In best case scenario it will destroy more land and kill more people and force millions to stay out and destroy the social order In the worst case scenario the destruction and casualties will be worse and Ukraine will shrink a lot and economy will never recover
    7
  34. Why would they migrate to a hellish corrupt active warzone in the first place
    7
  35. Ukraine threat isn't about its population but its location
    7
  36. Russia fertility rate 1.5 children per woman Ukraine 0.78 per woman Not the same
    7
  37. Why would they go to Ukraine
    7
  38. To be honest being pro Russian or pro Ukrainian is not the point of the video This is about Ukraine demographic crisis which started in 1991
    7
  39. AI is not reliable enough nor has the capability to replace humans in most jobs It's good for assisting human workers but not to replace them
    7
  40. ​ @morthim  Inflations eat savings That's why retirees will always need workers to support them financially then there's the need for young workforce to support them
    7
  41.  @Free_Russian  After the war Ukraine is the worst option even compared to Bulgaria After the war ends Ukraine will have to spend 20 years to rebuild infrastructures and damaged cities 700 years to demines bombs and shells and mines and during that time people and animals and vehicles will continue to explode Ukraine has the worst sex ratio imbalance in the world (1 femake for each 2 males) who would migrate to a country full of men and fewer women where they have an epidemic of single men Another thing about the list of countries that you mentioned (Croatia , Poland , Czech republic ....) all of them have fertility rates below replacement rate for almost 3 decades so they can't sustain Ukraine demographic crisis since they too have it The only countries with above replacement rate fertility are Bolivia, Peru, Haiti, Dominican republic (but their rates are declining too and close to 2.1) Indonesia Kazakhstan Uzbekistan Kyrgyzstan , Afghanistan , Pakistan Mongolia , Yemen , Syria and all of Africa Africa in particular has the highest birth rates in the world and can sustain immigration to other countries without causing local demographic crisis in return
    7
  42. There's a Ukrainian woman in Germany who wanted to divorce her Ukrainian husband so she can marry her Germany boyfriend but can't because he is fighting in the frontline and can't be present in the court
    7
  43. You can always join the army if you want to fight back but remember that Russia won't disappear it will always be there They have tens of millions of people who believe in Russian identity and culture and will fight for it
    7
  44. There's certain level of damage where a country can't sustain and recover from Ukraine may reach it
    7
  45.  @Admiral_Jezza  I didn't say anything about that
    6
  46. I think my comment was deleted by YouTube
    6
  47. When will you get drafted ?
    6
  48. Ukraine downfall started years before the war
    6
  49. The average fertility rate in Latin America is 1.8 which is below replacement rate and is still decreasing Most of Latinos also immigrate to US and Germany and Spain so Ukraine can only receive few of them after the war but nobody wants to move to Ukraine since it's downgrade unlike other countries
    6
  50. Bulgaria didn't suffer a destructive war like Ukraine Without war Ukraine is similar to Bulgaria
    6
  51. Women and children aren't meant to fight
    5
  52.  @Mniuff  And you think Ukraine can survive the war for how long ?
    5
  53. Ukraine demographic crisis began years before 2014 and war casualties aren't the cause of their demographic crisis The main reason is people who left by the millions to other countries
    5
  54. Russia itself has a demographic crisis Fertility rate of 1.5 which is way below replacement rate
    5
  55. Russia demographic situation is similar to Germany Ukraine on the other hand is a disaster
    5
  56. You obviously didn't watch the video
    4
  57. He is Czech
    4
  58. Ok , But what's your opinion about the video content ?
    4
  59. Nobody wants to migrate to such warzone
    4
  60. Ukraine demographic crisis started way before that
    4
  61. ​ @tylerprudhomme  Russia fertility rate 1.5 Ukraine fertility rate 0.78 Russia has much better demographics than Ukraine
    4
  62. At this point it doesn't matter Ukraine demographic collapse is inevitable without mass migration
    3
  63. Russians are also more connected to the west than you think Now , population decline is impossible to stop in liberal societies without influx of migrants Liberalism is the biggest birth pill in history
    3
  64. The video represents the reality of Ukraine demographics Of course we can't know what will be the situation in post war but the war is most likely to continue for another decade at least thus Ukraine demographic crisis will be worse
    3
  65. ​ @andrewrogers3067  Russia is centralized and has the biggest reserves of natural resources in the world and so many allies so they won't collapse The Soviet union was too decentralized and was ruled by the biggest traitor in history (Gorbachev)
    3
  66. War casualties doesn't have significant effect on Ukraine demographics Ukraine loses 0.3% of its male population in the war per year Their birth rate even though is small is still big enough to replace them and even give extra males What screwed up Ukraine however is young women and children leaving in millions to other countries
    3
  67.  @indeoo_  And what i don't understand is why is Ukraine mobilization policy a failure ? The president talked about needing new 500000 men but then didn't follow suit and as casualties are increasing and troops are getting tired and need rotations they failed to take serious measures to mobilize more men even though Ukraine has 14 millions military aged men
    3
  68. ​ @tommykarate9397  98% of Ukraine casualties are military so civilian casualties have barely any effect on the demographic situation
    3
  69. Muslim population is not growing in western Europe
    2
  70. Russia is not an ethnicity Russia is a country
    2
  71. ​ @love__and__hope__  They won't take care of war disables There was a video of a man who lost his legs in the frontline and the Ukrainian government didn't bother to give him any reparations or care
    2
  72. ​ @neocortex8198  " Retirees should fend for themselves " Emanuel Macron had this idea but people didn't accept it
    2
  73. Why would they go to Ukraine
    2
  74. Then imagine Russia with 190 different ethnicities and India with 2000 ethnicities and Papua guinea with 700 ethnicities
    2
  75. How do you convince women to do so ?
    2
  76. Fertility rate depends on women not men So the question is how do women there view having children ?
    2
  77. Ukraine situation is much worse than Yugoslavia
    2
  78. The highest HIV rate and the highest divorce rate in Europe
    2
  79. It's as hard as banning alcohol
    2
  80.  @MrDude826  Drugs are illegal and people are still getting them even in rural areas A ban doesn't work
    2
  81. ​ @TonyMontana57442  When you throw a ball upward it doesn't fall to the ground despite gravity being the only force applied to it because of the initial velocity given to it however at some point as the speed of the ball slows down it will reach its maximum height then stops before going down eventually India has initial velocity due to high fertility rate in the past so even if fertility rate declines below replacement rate of 2.1 the initial push will keep the population growing for years until it reaches its peak and then it starts declining
    2
  82. Not possible for so many reasons
    2
  83. Most Asian countries fertility rates are below replacement rate
    2
  84. Germany imported millions of Turkish migrants due to post war reconstruction and demographic crisis despite its fertility rate being above replacement rate of 2.1 Ukraine is in much worse position than that and the war may last for another decade so demographic collapse may occur before even starting the reconstruction
    2
  85. ​ @elliotbacklund8529  Doesn't work because low birth rates are result of cultural issues not genetics so natural selection doesn't work
    2
  86. Sending troops is not an option
    2
  87. Women no longer wait for anyone They spend their lives partying and sleeping around until they are too old to have children or get married and with so many traumas they got due to their lifestyles they ended up as cat ladies
    2
  88. Poland has demographic crisis and without immigrants they can't fix it Either they accept Ukrainians or Africans and Arabs The choice is theirs
    2
  89.  @unknownunknown-os4ue  AI can't replace humans It can help but not replace
    2
  90. Why would they want to live in Ukraine and why would Ukrainians allow them in
    2
  91. Do you think that he is telling the truth or is he just exaggerating ?
    2
  92.  @neocortex8198  Do you think retirees can carry 16 kg of equipments while running in the battlefield or that they have the physical and mental capacity to handle war
    2
  93. If you are woman then it is easy to do
    2
  94.  @andrewrogers3067  1- The region of Nagorno Karabakh is recognized as Azerbaijan not Armenia On the other hand NATO recognized Algeria as part of France in 1949 as it was part of France according to UN and French constitution but in the war of 1954 NATO didn't fulfill its obligation towards France and in 1962 France lost Algeria after 7.5 years of war
    1
  95.  @andrewrogers3067  Algeria wasn't invaded but it was nevertheless French territory according to international recognition and French constitution besides NATO included it when France joined If armed separatist rebels in Italy or Germany took arms against the government does NATO have an obligation to help the government to defeat them or not ?
    1
  96. ​ @brianbadonde8700  Actually it's less than 6% in France and 4% in UK
    1
  97. They come to settle in Russia not to go to Ukraine
    1
  98. ​ @антонантон-ы7ш  The paraguayan scenario was much better than Ukraine Paraguay lost 80% of its male population but that's manageable and attractive to migrants Ukraine is the opposite , They destroyed their future completely when they allowed women and children to leave but men were banned from leaving although hundreds of thousands of men escaped illegally their numbers are nothing compared to millions of young women who left This created the worst gender imbalance in demographics There is no way migrants will move to a country full of men and barely has any single woman left
    1
  99. Ukraine doesn't have societal collapse yet It would take at least 10 years more of war for it to happen Without western aid it would have occurred in 2022
    1
  100. ​ @GothPaoki  Ukraine is actually worse than Greece but unlike Greece they have to send more young people to die in war too
    1
  101. ​ @ПавелКрот-х5ы  In 2023 the average EU fertility rate was 1.51 In Ukraine 0.78
    1
  102.  @schutsheer_des_vaderlands  Actually what you are saying is already implemented in Europe and resulted in lower birth rates
    1
  103. The only country in Europe where fertility rate is above replacement rate is Kazakhstan
    1
  104. Small population is not a problem but high percentage of old people is
    1
  105. Will you get drafted after 3 years when you become 25 or will they lower the age to 23 before that ?
    1
  106.  @danilakosobokov5365  What matters is that you have to be prepared for the trenches The living conditions and the battle life Even for the frontline troops battle fighting is just 10-15% of your time unless your position was surrounded from multiple directions
    1
  107. That's not the point of the video Watch again
    1
  108. ​ @georgesibley7152  Ireland didn't suffer sex ratio imbalance like Ukraine
    1
  109.  @bullshitdepartment  Polygamy is practiced in modern societies actually Half married men have a wife and a mistress and a lot of deadbeat fathers have kids from multiple baby mamas and the top 10% of men in dating world sleep with multiple women at the same time
    1
  110. ​ @Nordbon1523  So what ?
    1
  111.  @Nordbon1523  If they truly hate life in Canada and wants to go back to Ukraine then they should be brave to fight for Ukraine and then enjoy life there after the war instead of being cowards who will wait for someone else to sacrifice and then go back afterwards
    1
  112. Greece demographic situation is still better than Ukraine
    1
  113. India fertility rate is 2.15 Also fertility rates don't affect population growth until 30-40 years later
    1
  114. ​​ @lembitmoislane.  Do you know the country that has the lowest fertility rate in Asia and the country that has the highest fertility rate in Asia ?
    1
  115. Russia despite its size is almost landlocked The northern arctic ocean is frozen icy water and the far eastern Pacific ports are too far away from Russia main economic and demographic centers in the western part The Baltic sea is under siege by other powers so they can barely maintain Kaliningrad and have no access to global trade from there The only access they have to warm waters close to the western part is the black sea So Crimea is very crucial for the survival and stability of Russian economy Securing Crimea is impossible without the land bridge (Donetsk , Zaporizhzhia , Kherson)
    1
  116. If they are fighting by themselves then yes they can't win But they are supported by NATO
    1
  117. ​ @NLTops  Ukraine doesn't have the resources and manpower to defeat Russia quickly Both sides are so stubborn so the war will obviously last longer
    1
  118. ​ @alexbayer2365  Global shadow government does exist Look at Gaza for example
    1
  119.  @iscuit  No amount of money can get people to want more kids It's much cheaper and more efficient to just import migrants on mass
    1
  120. ​ @elliotbacklund8529  Immigration keeps people with few birth rates around for generations
    1
  121. NATO won't send troops nor they can accept a country in active war
    1
  122. ​ @Microphunktv-jb3kj  The problem with low birth rates is not a population collapse (except in Ukraine case) but the aging population crisis Old people (+60) used to be 8% now it's 23% in Estonia and it will reach a much higher percentage in the next decades Also low birth rates cause a single men epidemic since it causes the number of male to outnumber females by a lot
    1
  123. Why would they migrate to a warzone that gets bombed by tens of thousands of shells and missiles and bombs every day Ukraine is also Europe poorest country and is full of mines and explosives that require hundreds of years to demine Nothing about Ukraine is worth migration
    1
  124. ​ @atherzaidi5871  If attracting pensioners is your strategy then you are an idiot Ukraine has already the highest percentage of pensioners in Europe so making the population even more older is very harmful to society Also Ukrainians abroad still produce more value for the host countries and spend more money there than they send to Ukraine so for Ukraine they need those people in Ukraine rather than abroad or else it is net lose You said that Indians abroad send 100 billions yearly to India meaning that they produce hundreds of billions of dollars per year but only small percentage is sent to India while most of their productivity is given to the host countries despite India spending billions on their education and healthcare and childhood while the host countries didn't pay anything for them so India is losing a lot because of them and not gaining as you imagine
    1
  125. ​ @underarmbowlingincidentof1981  Maybe you and the likes of you will flee but the ones who remain will have high birth rates
    1
  126. ​ @chsgrate5362  Forget about the comments and bots Just tell me what did you learn from the video and what's your prediction
    1
  127.  @miloudxxi6527  Long before that
    1
  128.  @TheJosman  Yes which means that Ukraine is truly f*cked
    1
  129. Governments have to pay for police, public transportation, education, infrastructures, military, foreign aid and policy , social programs and welfare, bureaucracy, justice system and jails ..... They also can't tax people over 60% in the highest case scenario So incentives for women to have children will always be very limited The best solution for a liberal country is to rely heavily on immigration
    1
  130. Most Ukrainian refugees are children so of course they don't have jobs
    1
  131. Most Ukrainian refugees are children
    1
  132. Russia goal is to extract the natural resources (gas , agricultural land , Titanium ...) so they will populate the new territories with young Russians from other regions The elderly people there are already dying out and won't cost a lot The other benefit is the warm waters for both tourism and ports for global trade But the Russian army had already destroyed some touristic sites like Askania Nova due to bad leadership and lack of discipline
    1
  133. It's worse than south Korea
    1
  134. I doubt Ukraine will even exist in 2044
    1
  135. ​ @bookinsights1092  Ukraine is destroyed and heavily mined with highest male surpluses male population in the world and the war is still ongoing so there's always chance of getting bombed Nobody will want to migrate there
    1
  136. ​ @hodisfut  Actually the Mexicans will accept it because they can't afford a war against USA
    1
  137.  @mastomax  That's nothing compared to what will happen to Ukraine 10 years later if the war doesn't stop until then
    1
  138.  @neocortex8198  Those young people won't stay young for ever Eventually they too will be old then they will need young people to support them
    1
  139. Daycare harms the mother child bond It's necessary for single mothers who need to work in order to support their children but couples shouldn't be allowed to have children in daycare
    1
  140.  @againstviralmisinformation510  1- only 2% of Ukraine population is war casualties, 98% are people who left to other countries like Russia and Poland and Germany and Canada.... most of them are women and children so Ukraine has much more males than females 2- 1 man can impregnate 100 women per year while a woman gets only pregnant once per year even if she slept with 100 men , So even if Ukraine lost all men older than 27 their birth rate won't be affected, In 1868 Paraguay lost 70% of its male population in the triple alliance war but solved the problem when the church allowed each man to marry 1 woman officially and 2 others unofficially 3- Ukraine wants to encourage women to return and telling them that they can be drafted to the cold muddy trenches of Donbas will discourage them 4- It's easier to get male immigrants than females so they can import men after the war
    1
  141. Slavic countries ? Other than Russia and Belarus there are no slavic countries and both won't move to Ukraine at all anyway
    1
  142. They are going to be fucked if they lose but if they won they can still recover Ukraine is fucked anyway especially if the war continues for another decade
    1
  143. If you mean by " Russia will win " 10 more years of fighting and losing men and resources and equipments and economic struggles then yeah it's possible if Russia is willing to pay that price but is it worth it ?
    1
  144. ​ @ElTigre12024  Or children
    1
  145. Ukraine can fix its demographics by mass migration but can they attract immigrants in such high numbers
    1
  146. ​ @MonsieurDean  Ukraine future is Indian/African
    1
  147. Russia is the biggest country in the world and the most diverse country in Europe so they can handle mass migration better than homogeneous Ukraine
    1
  148.  @neocortex8198  Retirees can't run while carrying 16 kg of equipments through the battlefield They don't have the mental and physical capacity to handle the war
    1
  149. ​ @komisossoutsidi5801  People in Europe and America have better living standards than Ukraine and low fertility rates so obviously not from there
    1
  150. ​ @dimieneyitemi1721  That's why they are sent to the frontline while left leaning ones are used as border guards and western cities garrisons and logistical units
    1
  151. There was no holocaust in Israel Back then the holy land was under British occupation and didn't suffer from WW2
    1
  152. ​ @MrJigssaw1989  If you think most Ukrainian women care about the nation survival then i have a fire breathing dragon to sell you 😂😂😂
    1
  153. Holocaust occurred in Europe Israel wasn't affeced by it Back then the holy land was under British occupation
    1
  154. Crimea is the only access Russia has to warm waters and in order to secure it they need the land bridge (Donetsk , Zaporizhzhia, Kherson) Other than Donbas , Crimea , the land bridge, Odesa the rest of Ukrainian internationally recognized territories are worthless
    1