Comments by "LancesArmorStriking" (@LancesArmorStriking) on "Why Do Russians Hate Other Post-Soviet Countries?" video.
-
3
-
3
-
Have to disagree, the idea that the Soviets started the war is bullshit.
Hitler, if given the chance (which, I mean... he tried about 4 years later) would have taken over all of Europe. Partitioning was the only logical choice in the face of Germany's ambitions. It's not like the Soviets approached them and asked to do that. Hitler himself said, "When Germany's life is at stake, even a temporary alliance with Moscow must be contemplated".
So if you're going by that metric, no, the Soviets did not start it. Ribbentrop pursued negotiations with Moscow, not the other way around. And, in case it wasn't obvious enough, Hitler invaded first!!
What you said reminds me of neo-Conederates who think the Union started the American CIvil War because they responded to the Confederates... shooting first.
As for liberation... yes. Putin had 15 years to diversify the Russian economy and yet he didn't. With the enormous natural wealth he could have created a wealth fund that would dwarf Norway's (their plan is similar, but more beneficial to the common people). Instead, it went to geopolitical strategy and military.
I don't think he'll be leaving anytime soon, but hopefully he'll pick someone who understands that soft power (economy) = power. Before it's too late, and we're all in China's pocket.
2
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@05KAR
I don't think so. Certainly, the Soviets acknowledged that, among the Polish, there was a higher number of people who opposed the Soviet system and sought to destroy it. That being said, the Soviets didn't target people because they were Polish. They targeted whomever posed a threat, and if more Poles posed a threat, then... you see my point.
You're looking at the results and working backwards.
And even the most brutal famines like Holodomor affected not only Ukrainians but also millions of Kazakhs and southern Russians. It had nothing to do with ethnicity, sorry. Ironically, the Soviets were non-discriminatory, in spite of all their other flaws.
And even at the end, you highlighted my point. That someone would consider themselves Polish was more important than their actual ethnicity (or genetics, if you see it that way.) All Soviets were to consider themselves Soviet first, so the emphasis on identity was what became problematic for the Party.
Hitler explicitly wrote about the biological and mental characteristics of certain ethnic groups by blood, not allegiance. Stalin was a monster, but he was not Hitler. Not even close.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1