Comments by "Phoneybeetlemaniacxs" (@Phoneybeetlemaniacxs) on "Women Sue Their Own School To Get Trans-Player Kicked From Team." video.

@sommebuddy what high school boy has ran 10.49 they would be a top prospect college men don’t start running sub 11 till their second d year don’t talk rubbish
7
The issue is that people fetishise trans women. If a trans woman I’d hide it who the hell wants to go through this. Every thing I do get scrutinised and then I’m used as a scapegoat for women not playing when they played with me fine last times we did. It’s funny it wasn’t an issue till you found out
4
What about inane h Khalif
2
@twitch7515 I was comparing the achievements not the genders. There have been several men who have not fit near him. The point I made was to show this whole conversation is sexist women are not weaker than men
2
Here’s the dialogue or at how it will break down we on the trans side it should e assessed on a person as not everyone’s physiology is the same there are people who are different therefore there should be sone metric on how we allow people into sports. This volleyballer could have been a ciswiman and generated just as much power as she was standing until way of a spiked ball that was being volleyed the speed of the call doesn’t go up that drastically when sone by women. But again people wanting to push a sexist narrative want it seem like such this is what keeps women out of men’s sports
1
They are bigots not courageous. If they actually spoke about about actual issues they have people like you would say they shouldn’t say that
1
@hhiippiittyy it’s not an argument. I think you getting it confused it’s just a fact. Ok let’s put the argument in terms we can accept that’s scientific ok humans are evolved species as such we replicate when we breed as in any process the replication proved has it problems one of them is the misalignment of hormones snd neurons. Now instead of accepting this and the issues it causss when they are forced to go the op gh the wrong puberty we could help them but again it’s more about ideological or being right then what’s best for the patient which should be the issue
1
@No_Boxing_No_Life25 she is a woman for heavens sake I mean what evidence do you have they she’s not
1
@tr4l1975 I call bullshit sub 10 is rare for make athlete to hit consistently and secondly actually inhibits the factors rww we win why any trans women runners aren’t competitive
1
@sommebuddy I have trans people make up 0.21 of the population elite athletes make up a smaller demographic than that so how many elite athletes do you think are trans
1
@PapaGigi_House oh really because because sub 10s of thst nature you said high school that would break records you know that if that was true which isn’t because if you look they are projected times for when they get older not the actual ones
1
Secondly trans women don’t run sun 10
1
Yes I could point out there are sports where men and women compete against each other already and Thst categories were created Brcause women were beating men in thrm but things like facts 😊
1
@aaronrhodes7268 Ice skating, I believe there was a woman collegiate wrestler who wanted to wrestle men and they came up with she’s too weak.
1
@JUGGERNAUT____ my point is that trans athletes aren’t trying to dominate women’s sports they just want to take part and if you look their performance is usual on par with other women
1
@aaronrhodes7268 volleyball is non contact unless apathy from the hall. Even in that it depends because what soccer/football there are trans women who are about the size that f a small woman and there are trans men who are about my size I’m 6 2
1
@aaronrhodes7268 yes I did watch it my point is a cis woman could have injured her it was the speed of the ball not the person doing it
1
@JUGGERNAUT____ it should be free for all therefore who gets scholarships should be moot secondly yes occasionally a trans person. Will win a race but then we don’t talk about the other 12 rested they run when that didn’t happen why is that? Or we don’t talk about how Caitlin Clark a cis woman just beat pistol Pete Maravichs record for points in college history Brcause it’s more important to push a sexist and transphobic narrative then deal with reality
1
@aaronrhodes7268 actually I do ok let’s take for example Lia Thomas a trans athlete. She won the ncaa championship in a record time now they don’t talk about the rest of her female college career so they? This Brcause she finished in the top 5 4 times didn’t qualify for the finals twice and in her last race finished 12 Pitt of 12 now if this advantage exists what happened magic
1
@Samuria86 I’m saying trans people are such a small minority that it’s not an issue as long as they are tabling the medication. To make sure their physiology is similar to their counterparts and their performance is in line with other women then I do t see why that’s difficult
1
⁠ @goldenlizard92 Barry bonds never played for the dodgers so how he accomplished that I’ll never know. Right but you and riggers say it’s as advantage what I’m saying is don’t be lazy and train harder
1
@twitch7515 bring trans is not like taking a performance enhancing drug. It’s more like if you could make a drug to make your abilities less that the reason why Lia Thomas went from a record time to not qualifying. The problem you side has is that you need to show it’s S freequeny issue and isbt
1
⁠ @twitch7515 it’s not a false claim. Its trying have a civil discourse on the matter. As it has to happen more civilly than has been even now see what this is degenerating into. So there is a saying be part of the solution. The problem o have is this that people seem to think trans people transition in mtf cases because they failed as a male athlete. Which is horrible to think and is bigoted because trans is a compulsive thing they have to be, it’s not something they can decide it is a part of them. Now we can measure times and things why can’t we set reasonable parameters for trans athletes to compete out their gender without it degenerating into this fetishisation that occurs. We have made it ok they a person and litter to look at another person genitals and people think of this person is a hero for women’s rights. What the hell are we doing were anyone thinks that’s ok. Secondly this person is hurt Brcause they finished joint 5th with the trans swimmer that’s what they are upset about. This is the reason this has been framed as destroying women’s sports Brcause sone cis people don’t like anything trans. The things you s women have and do it perform men in sone sports and trans women are outperformed by cis women consistently because pool if this advantage narrative was true we should see it in a consistent bias. You don’t seem to get my argument it is that if this advantage is inherit as you say why is it that cis women can beat trans women regularly. Know we could talk about the logo of funding for women’s sports or legitimate coverage I mean that’s how you help women’s sports ploys this talks hurts cis women look at Imane khalif she’s having to fight a legal case to prove that she was defamed
1
@twitch7515 I’m not making false claims the anti trans side is
1
@redubd a race
1
Trans girl I fix it not a man. Trans people are legally accepted as the gender they are they were under obligation to tell anyone
1
It’s because we can’t have the discourse rationality it degenerates into always no. Plus who wants to be fetishised I imagine this athlete wants to be treated like any other woman, o think this case proves her point
1
@musicmaniac8787 right but if you are beaten by a trans woman train harder
1
Because it’s the frequency bias and we trans allies point out places it dies t happen or cis athletes beat trans ones or like ignored. If you are right you should have a valid reason why those are anamolies
1
@metsr18rhq yes it almost if excluding people based on be is a bad idea it’s not like we’ve done it. Iefiye oh we have
1
@wallyman292 actually you are the cherry picking you pick out the trans athlete who win one race or did one thing that’s not their career now is it? Btw trans woman =\= male athlete
1
@leevy6753 I am saying this ok a person wins a race let’s call them Lia Thomas for fun and then all people talk about is that one race. They don’t talk about the other races she swam let’s call them I think 17 others. Where she is as beaten by cis women Riley Gaines actually beat her 4 times in those races. Now no one talks about that because it’s more important for bigotry than facts to assessed and discussed.
1
@leevy6753 the problem is and see if you spot trans women are out performed by cis women because like in life there a lot did bye before she transitioned she was a good make swimmer and I know they destroys your narrative but the truth doesn’t care
1
@thundersmite2162 I’m 42 so a millennial
1
Yes there is but transphobes ignore it and facts that show they are wrong
1