Comments by "" (@Cloud_Seeker) on "National Socialism WAS Socialism | Rethinking WW2 History" video.

  1. Nationalism does not mean you are racist you know.
    2
  2. It seems you are implying it. Why else do you call "socialism but only for real Germans" = "actual nationalism"? You are making assumptions here. Nationalism is neither socialist or capitalist. When a US citizen wave the American flag, singing the national anthem and shoot guns on a gun range all at the same time. That citizen is most likely a patriot and a nationalist. You are claiming that "actual nationalism" involves socialism, which it doesn't as many Americans can be extremely nationalistic. As you are implying that "actual nationalism" is "socialism but only for real Germans" you are pretty much only pointing at a few examples in history which is either Nazi Germany or Benito Mussolini's Italy, but we both know that German is only the real example here. This means you are implying that only "actual nationalism" is "nazi nationalism" which is racist as Nazi ideology are very very much racist.
    2
  3. You literally equates nationalism and socialism. I am not assuming anything, that is what you are saying. If you are not you can not say ""it's socialism but only for the real Germans". So actual nationalism you mean? I do not read that as a question, I read it as a rhetorical question which is a statement. "And if you think this is pointing to only a few examples in history, you are wrong. Just take a look at the policies of several European nations with nationalists in the government (or even Israel)." - Such as? I live in Europe you know. At the moment pretty much all of Europe is Globalistic, not a single nation in Europe is nationalistic. The closest you will get to a nationalistic state in Europe is the UK, and by the way it is going right now it will become a vassal state to the EU
    2
  4. Can you stop dodging my question and list these European nations that are nationalistic?
    2
  5. "Why should I answer you when you try to put words in my mouth every time?" - I am not. You are giving "several European countries" as examples of nationalism and nationalistic states, but you are outright refusing to name a single one to back up your claim. That only means one thing, you do not know any that will support your claim which is why you make the statement but refuse to source it. The reason I brought up the UK was because they are leaving the EU. The European Union is something which is trying to create a new federal super state just like the United States of America is a federal government. If you support the EU, you can not be nationalistic. If you think you can, you do not understand Europe nore its history. Europe have had such a long and strange history that there is no national belonging across the continent. The EU is more and more trying to take over the sovereign power to the point the Union will have its own Military loyal to the Union and not the member nations, there is no way this is just a organisation to make trade, trade regulations and movement easier. You site Poland, a country within the EU as nationalistic when it is actively being incorporated in a project to make Europe a single nation. You site Hungary as a nationalistic nation when they are also being incorporated into a project that is aimed to make Europe a single nation. Just because nationalistic parties exist within a country does not make it a nationalistic country. Every single country in Europe also have communistic parties. Does that make Europe communistic as well? With your logic, yes it does. That is why I ask you to point the countries out. You can literally only point to a few statements made by a few politicians and a few pushes which doesn't in any way show that each nation as a whole is nationalistic. It is most likely the only reason you can give your examples because people are pissed about being forced into globalists politics just because they are being forced into a European super state. Are you going to tell me that the idea that countries should have boarders, and everyone shouldn't be able to live in any country they want freely without the approval of that country first is a nationalistic agenda? If it is, then you have just gone so far into globalism that literally everything is nationalistic to you. Also. Scotland had their opportunity to leave, they choose to not leave. When they voted for Brexit, they voted as Englishmen just as they voted for. That they have regrets is the result from their own stupidity. But hey, they rather want to belong to a project that wants to make Europe as a continent a nation so they will absolutely not have any power. You can't get fucked by the same mistake twice right? When you give away your sovereignty, don't complain when you don't get your way.
    2
  6. "You Americans av no idea what NS is & Like the other comments I totally agree" - HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!! "You Americans"??? I am European you git. How about instead talking shit, you learn how to spell so this dyslectic non-native English speaker doesn't correct you on how to write English. I am pointing out how you can't even form a sentence and you go on a rant with writing only you can read if even that.
    2
  7. Wow. Was that the best you can do? Come on, that isn't even impressive. Are you trying to be offensive? I am almost offended if you think that will offend me.
    2
  8. You do know that Fascism is just a part of socialism right? Socialism is about taking the means of production and gathering it into the hands of the state. The communists was just lying about what they did by claiming they represent the people, while the fascists was just honest and said all that shit is now theirs.
    2
  9. Are you claiming that National Socialism and Fascism support small government and private ownership of production? Also National Socialism IS fascism. Maybe you can explain what "right wing ideologies" are because it seems you do not know what you are talking about.
    2
  10. I have no idea what you are even trying to say.
    1
  11. Apart from that the nazis are still socialists. Nationalism is has nothing to do with nazism. To think it is is just fear mongering and propaganda. Why should the neo-libs ever disagree with the idea of nationalism being a bad thing? They want internationalism so they can control the world through large union blocks.
    1
  12.  @azerty8866  Doesn't matter. You are very much wrong. Nationalists isn't pretty much like nazis. If you think that you don't understand what the word Nationalism means. Nationalism means: "a nation's wish and attempt to be politically independent" or "a great or too great love of your own country than other countries" Nothing in this means you hate other people. Want to take over and enslave anyone else and so on. Nationalism means you care more for your own tribe than other tribes. Or wish your tribe is not ruled by some other tribe as you wish to act independently. Nationalism is not equal to nazism. That is propaganda put in your head by people that wish your country to not have a seperate sense of belonging from every other nation. In short. People that wants to erradicate your culture and your nation so they can mold you into a big collective.
    1