General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Philip Rayment
travelingisrael.com
comments
Comments by "Philip Rayment" (@PJRayment) on "10 Questions PRO-Palestinians Can’t Answer (Can You Prove Me Wrong?)" video.
Actually, it's what often happens when you lose a war, but the principle is true. The Arabs lost the war they started, so have no reason to complain.
20
@Jdudec367 "Except they never started it" False. Israel didn't attack. Israel was attacked. "who did the land belong to before that if that's true?" It's not true. The land was given back to the Jews. It had been controlled by the Ottoman Empire before that (although there were Jews there then), and before that by other Muslim groups after they conquered the land in the 7th Century, and before that by the Romans (as a Jewish province), and before that, by the Jews themselves.
1
@Jdudec367 "No they stole the land first." False. Or can you provide evidence? "Israel then forcefully removed many Palestinians from their own country." False again. To this very day, there are Arabs living and working in Israel, including being in Parliament. "No it was stolen and given to them." First you claim that they stole the land, then you claim that it was given to them! You can't seem to make up your mind. "That wasn't what the gaza strip and other Palestine land originated as though." What do you mean by "Palestine land"? There was never a country called Palestine. The people living in Gaza are Arabs.
1
@Jdudec367 "Can you prove it belonged to the jews first?" Read a Bible. "Yeah you can't really prove it's false." So that's an admission that you have no evidence. "There being some in Israel doesn't mean none of them were forcefully moved frrom their home locations though." True. But given that there are plenty there, what's your evidence and logic that others were forced out? "I can make up my mind, it was stolen and given to Israel who further took it." They took what they were given? And who "stole" it? The British, as a result of winning a war? Or the Ottomans before them? Or other Muslims before them? How far back do you want to go? "There was a county called Palestine" Evidence please. There was never a country called Palestine. The name was given to the area by the Romans to annoy the Jews who were living there. "... and even before that the land there still existed." Of course. "Yeah they are arabs your point?" That's a more accurate name than "Palestinians", which can include Jews, and which includes the occupiers of the lands all around Israel, which only has a tiny bit of the land, and which you want to begrudge them even that little bit.
1