General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About

Al Jazeera English
comments

Comments by "" (@bdinaz) on "Israel recovers bodies of six captives from Gaza | Al Jazeera Newsfeed" video.

What kind of therapy have you gone through to get to them point that killing hostages is the rescue teams fault?
11
Hey Al Jazeera, were they MURDERED by the Hammys? Come on, you can admit it in your headline.....
9
@katina55312 You do realize taking hostages is a war crime? Murdering those hostages is another war crime?
7
DUDE, they were murdered by the Hammys.....
7
@blackllama4602 So the Arabs will quickly depart for Saudi Arabia, right?
6
@AhmedSayed-gt5xg glad you brought up the Arab conquest. When do we get to handle those refugees?
5
@AhmedSayed-gt5xg Cool, well, the Saudi Royal family can house them all in Mecca, Medina, Riyadh, Dhahran, Ad Dammam, etc. They built huge spartment blocks to house the Bedouin in the 1970s that went unused except for Desert Storm. They will do admirably. Enjoy!
4
@AhmedSayed-gt5xg something I find is accurate and not changed since 1943 "To me it seems certain that the fatalistic teachings of Muhammad and the utter degradation of women is the outstanding cause for the arrested development of the Arab. He is exactly as he was around the year 700, while we have kept on developing." - George S. Patton Jr.-
3
@shortfattoad7317 Hey, ya'll are holding 5 US citizens hostage. That could be BAD come 20 January. Wanna go that way?
3
@shortfattoad7317 and the Pallys could be living in Mecca. What's your point?
3
@denis-florian_0.57 don't worry, they are just envious that the westernized Israeli citizens are successful. And they are not...
3
@ifterock4931 He led the attack on the Rock Concert on 7 October? WOW, HE GETS AROUND!
2
@katina55312 So taking hostages is acceptable to you?
2
@AhmedSayed-gt5xg personally l prefer the writings of Nathan Bedford Forrest- "Get there furstest. With the Mostest." Boy, that sums it up nicely.
2
@blackllama4602 yup, and I estimate i have had contact with over half of them. The military kept me busy in that region for much of my career. They dislike each other to a pathological level. Genuinely enjoy seeing each other get ground up by the strongman in power. The only thing they seem to agree on is a pathological hatred of the Jews who show them up.
2
@blackllama4602 Being censored for saying i spent many years in the middle east. I estimate i interacted with about half of the tribes.
2
@blackllama4602 another thing I learned is that all those tribes are all hyper envious of the jews.....
2
@blackllama4602 being censored for saying one thing I know is that those various tribes enjoy seeing each other get ground to dust by the strongman. (Hama in 1982 comes to mind).
2
@blackllama4602 Another thing I am being censored for saying is all those tribes are universally envious of the Jews.
2
@samirpilipovic2885 6.) It could get real ugly come 20 January.
2
@samirpilipovic2885 7.) MOABs make a big bang.
2
Funny, I have been to Mecca, Medina, Riyadh, Ad Dammam, Dahran, Hafir Al Batin, and a whole pile of other eminently forgettable places in the KSA. Spent FAR to much time there. Now that I am retired I ain't going back there either.
2
@Saba-fn5ub Target the doctors? Bubba, you got it wrong. The hammys took off their snazzy green uniforms on 7 October and have been fighting in civilian clothes. And the hug the civilians to provide lots of video worthy casualties. The Hammy leadership already said the consider the civilians to be nothing more than walking propaganda ammunition.
2
@Saba-fn5ub my reply explaining Hamas in civilian clothes hiding amongst the civilians keeps getting censored. WHY?
2
@hooglieable Which is of course a war crime. Taking hostages is a war crime. Killing said hostages is another war crime. And some how THIS is the IDFs fault?
2
@nurp4904 Why was she a hostage? Taking of civilians as hostages is a war crime.
2
@AmeenPirbhai After 24 years in Uniform, and Decades spent over seas including time in the middle east I would hardly call ME gullible. But the thought that taking hostages and then killing those hostages is defendable in any way is ludicrous.
2
@nurp4904 And your point is exactly what? Hamas is good while they kill hostages?
2
@doseckes3183 when a kidnapper seizes someone who is killed in a rescue attempt, the kidnapper goes to capital crime status. While no one wants it to happen, the Kidnapper brought this 100% on themselves.
2
@simukhkhirani606 You miss the point. At the time of the 7 October atrocity there was a ceasefire which was broken by the hammys. Either everything before that is moot or ceasefire has no meaning.
2
@simukhkhirani606 there was a series of ceasefires starting in 2005 when the IDF withdrew and took with them all civilian jews. The Hammys would then periodically pop off rockets and the IdF would respond in a limited way. But there was not a large scale violation of the ceasefire until 7 October.
2
@simukhkhirani606 What? For a country supposed causing A genocide they are dreadful at it. In 1984 there were 1.5 million Pallys. Today there are 5.5 Million Pallys. So who is genociding who?
2
@Vorname_Nachnahme no, I enter, then come back ten minutes later. If it is deleted, I rebuild the entry using other terms as replacements. Then I come back ten minutes later. If it is really bad I break it down to numbered sentences to see what fails censor scrutiny. It is usually the result of a discussion of the Hammy actions on 7 October that trip the censors.
2
What is it with the Arabs that taking hostages is a religious right?
1
What is it with the middle east that hostages are a religious right?
1
@katina55312 Have you ever worked in Counter terrorism? It is difficult. THis aint the movies bubba... What is it about the Arabs that they think taking hostages is some sort of religious right?
1
@StrygwyrBS What can you expect? Their leadership thinks of their civilian population as unexpended propaganda ammunition.
1
@katina55312 My reply citing the difficulties of Counter terrorism efforts is being censored. I guess they only want to hear the chorus?
1
@katina55312 in 1948 a two state solution was created. But sadly they allowed the Arab nations to attack. They lost. They lost land. Thems the breaks as we say here in Arizona.
1
@katina55312 naw, you guys can malign Isreal and the US at will, but defending them gets erased.
1
@katina55312 i have had to break paragraphs to numbered sentences. They are supposed to only filter profanity. This goes to control of opinion.
1
@irfannawas5878 Rigghhttt... Its all Israel's fault. Let me guess, Netanyahu snuck into the rock concert hours before the attack and personally killed 600 victims with a butter knife to make it look like the Hammys killed people.
1
@joancooley1387 how and where am I off Track? Please be precise.
1
@joancooley1387 And what is so unusual about that? The Brits had a choice, they could install the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan over the whole region formally known as Transjordan. Make it another monarchy that the democratic west disapproves of But the Arabs favor culturally. (They always prefer the tribal stong man approach) But tribal kingdoms fell out of favor in the democratic west so a compromise was set out in a two state solution. Israel and the hashimite kingdom of Jordan. Jordan invaded seeking to take it all. They lost. And they lost turf. It happens. Speaking of exiles.... the jews of the whole middle east were exiled to Israel from Algeria, Jordan, Lebanon, Egypt, and even Iran. Essentially punted out. RIGHT OF RETURN FOR THEM?
1
@Saba-fn5ub frogish?
1
@Sindy-r2k my reply explaining the legality of an Al Anbar Awakening type movement keeps getting censored.
1
@Sindy-r2k thats ok Come for a visit. Walk you down Allen Street in Tombstone. Go see the OK Corral. You will understand.
1
@Sindy-r2k my invitation for you to visit Arizona keeps getting deleted? Why?
1
@NoisesofArchitecture being censored for recounting details of how the bodies were discovered. Such bravery by Al Jazeera to censor the truth.
1
@samirpilipovic2885 hate to say it, we in Cochise County care nothing about your casualties. You killed 31 US citizens. And hold 5 hostage. And you think we will reward you for that?
1
@samirpilipovic2885 being censored here. Read by paragraph numbers.
1
@samirpilipovic2885 1. To Americans the only number that is important....
1
@samirpilipovic2885 2.) Is the number 32.
1
@samirpilipovic2885 3.) That is the number of US citizens killed....
1
@samirpilipovic2885 4.) ...by hammies on 7 October.
1
@samirpilipovic2885 8. And we owe you....
1
@nurp4904 hummies equal hommies? What does THAT mean?
1
@nurp4904 So you hypothesize that the IDF broke into Hammy controlled turf in order to kill the hostages? Wow, the suspense of disbelief in Pally land is overwhelming.
1
@nurp4904 yes.
1
@nurp4904 wait a minute... On 7 October they crossed the border into Isreal, nor to atrack some vital military target, but to raid a rock concert. They started the raid by firing RPGs into the crowd to stun them. Then machine gunned those who fled with AKs. Those who froze in place or were wounded were then taken hostage. At a housing area rhe Hammies lit the houses on fire burning those who hid inside to death. Is that Homey or what?
1
@nurp4904 wait a minute... On 7 October they crossed the border into Isreal, nor to atrack some vital military target, but to raid a rock concert. They started the raid by firing RPGs into the crowd to stun them. Then machine gunned those who fled with AKs. Those who froze in place or were wounded were then taken hostage. At a housing area rhe Hammies lit the houses on fire burning those who hid inside to death. Is that Homey or what?
1
@nurp4904 being censored. Will reply in paragraph form. Read by numbers...
1
@nurp4904 1.)wait a minute... On 7 October they crossed the border into Isreal, not to attack some vital military target, but to raid a rock concert.
1
@nurp4904 3.) Those who froze in place or were wounded were then taken hostage. At a housing area the Hammies lit the houses on fire burning those who hid inside to death.
1
@nurp4904 4.) Is that Homey or what?
1
@nurp4904 AL Jazeera does not want a historical recounting of the actual raid and it is being.censored Such bravery....
1
@doseckes3183 What? Wait a minute. They were killed by the Hammies. Do you want to blame the LAPD for the Manson Family murders of the Tate and Lobianco families? Do you want to blame the Atlanta police for the murders committed by seriel killer Wayne Williams? The NYPD for the Son of Sam killings?
1
@nurp4904 2.0) The hammies used anti tank rounds to stun the crowd.
1
@nurp4904 2.1) when the concert goers began to flee....
1
@nurp4904 2.2) they were fired upon....
1
@nurp4904 2.3) by hammies carrying AKs.
1
@Saba-fn5ub why would they kill them? Why did they take them? Arabs believe there is some sort of religious carve out that permits hostages to be taken. The rest of the world wonders what is wrong with them....
1
@Saba-fn5ub Why do Arabs believe they have a religious right to take civilians hostage? The rest of the world looks on in disbelief. It is completely out of bounds in accordance with the LoLW. But they do it.
1
@simukhkhirani606 it did not matter as a ceasefire was in place.
1
@Saba-fn5ub my reply is being censored.
1
@simukhkhirani606 yup, the Hammys started their rocket program bout then. Lots of mad mullah money....
1
@simukhkhirani606 What percentage of transjordan was owned by Jews in 1940? Where was that percentage located? What percentage was owned by Christians in 1940? Where was that percentage located?
1
@simukhkhirani606 So, there were no jews in Transjordan in 1940? There were no Christians in Transjordan? I WILL GIVE TOU AN EASY ONE. How many Jordanians were In Transjordan in 1940?
1
@simukhkhirani606 Roughly 490,000 were in Transjordan . Mostly west of the Jordan River. That help? Oops, almost forgot the second question. Right now there are roughly 9,400,000 Israelis. 2,300,000 of them are muslim Arab Citizens . Maybe 20% of the population.
1
@simukhkhirani606 My earlier reply was censored. Will try in seperate paragraphs to get past censors.
1
@simukhkhirani606 1.) In 1940 there were roughly 480,000 Jews living in Transjordan, mostly west of the Jordan river.
1
2.) In 2024 there are 9,400,000 Israelis.
1
@simukhkhirani606 3.) Of that number roughly 2,300,000 are Muslim Arabs who are citizens...
1
@simukhkhirani606 Me not listening to the truth? What, Are my statistics in error?
1
@simukhkhirani606 1.) In 1940 there were roughly 480,000 Jews living in the Transjordan (For some reason this stat keeps getting thrown out by censors)
1
@nurp4904 the Kibbutz was further south and east. And the Kibbutz is a housing area for civilians any way. Why did they target it? And is Hammy Intelligence so bad they did not know a very loud and light filled concert was happening? That beggers disbelief.... They purposely struck it.
1
@nurp4904 This the same Hindustan Times that says the Russians have destroyed the Ukraimian Army, and that they have been kicked out of Kursk? We find them entertaining The fires were purposely set by the Hammys to burn the buildings down before the Hammys withdrew. Tanks are not the first thing I would use to set fires. After all, why hasn't Gaza burned to the ground? Face it, the Hammys got hurt in the propaganda world when the scope of the atrocity was revealed and are now trying g to blame everything g up to and including suicide of the Civilians
1
@nurp4904 my comment outlining my skepticism of the hindustsni times is being censored...
1
@nurp4904 My comments regarding my extensive experience with tanks is being censored.
1
@nurp4904 Tanks don't start fires as well as gasoline....
1
@nurp4904 i actually watched the interview with the Company Commander who maneuvered his Merkavas into position as the Hammys began fleeing back to Gaza in trucks. What he said was at some distance he observed pick up trucks with people in civilian clothes in the bed of the truck going back to Gaza. Since the Hammys had attacked wearing civilian clothes he assumed they were the Retreating Hammys and opened fire upon them. He did not have identification of the people in the beds of the trucks but his rationale is plausible to this old tank commander. I would probably have done the same thing. Naturally the press attempted to paint him as willfully mowing down hostages, but at the time that was unknown. Maybe next time tell the Hammys uniforms on combatants exist for a reason.
1
@nurp4904 The Hammys attacked on Yom Kippur. Like 1973 the IDF relaxed manning requirements for their holy day. It would be like someone attacking much of the West on Christmas Eve. Attacking the US on Superbowl Sunday. Or specifically attacking a Muslim nation at the height of Ramadan
1
@simukhkhirani606 Dude there are half a dozen prayer times each day. Used to drive me nuts hearing the Muizens on the speakers when I was trying to sleep.
1
@nurp4904 Were they taking fire from inside the house?
1
@nurp4904 last year?
1
@simukhkhirani606 1.) Which statistic is wrong. 2.) What is the IDF doing wrong (please refer this comment using references from the LoLW.) 3.) What am I personally doing that is wrong?
1
@nurp4904 Right, so the forensic analysis of the victims on 7 October stated that the majority of casualties died fromneither RPG fragmentation or gunshot wounds caused by 7.62mm projectiles. Neither of these are caused by Apaches.
1
@nurp4904 have i mentioned that? But I will mention that the six hostages killed this past week were killed by shots fired to the back of the head execution style. But then again I have seen Hammy supporters say they were killed by IDF snipers who shot them on purpose to give the hammys a propaganda loss.
1
@nurp4904 The three shot in the friendly fire earlier this year? Friendly fire ain't. I could also mention the Hammys little accident with their rockets about the same time that waxed a crowd when it struck a hospital. But they just claimed it was the IDF in the face of overwhelming evidence.
1
@simukhkhirani606 i take it you do not agree with the 480,000 number? Fine propose a number and please justify it. I have heard Pally enthusiasts who say there were no Jewish people in the region because they all mysteriously originated in Central Europe. Nonsense of course.
1
@simukhkhirani606 So, if they decided THEY were not Palestinian, who are you to say they were? Is it only about the naming convention?
1
@simukhkhirani606 question for you: In 1948 when the British Empire left, should the entire land area known as Transjordan been turned over to the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan?
1
@3311atl its gonna get UGLY.
1
@3311atl my reply stating Hamas has killed 32 US citizens is being censored.
1
@3311atl is it the number which is now 32?
1
@3311atl or is it that they are US citizens?
1
@basilminhas7179 are you saying rhebHammys have not killed 32 US citizens since 7 October? That would take quite the suspension of disbelief....
1
@basilminhas7179 my reply stating you are not admitting the truth is being censored.
1
@ammt7692 there can be no deal. Not after the Hammys violated a ceasefire and killed 1200 people. No ceasefire is possible after that
1
@Vorname_Nachnahme Very naive story.. They could have simply evacuated all hostages to the US over the shore pier and handed them over. But they didn't. A civilian hostage gets more press than a military prisoner. EVERYONE KNOWS THIS.
1
@aurancrash4654 It is immaterial what happened before. There was a defacto ceasefire on that day that was violated by the Hammys. If you go "1948", then there cannot be a ceasefire ever again. Ceasefires lose meaning when one can violate it based ona perceived transgression in the past.
1
@aurancrash4654 It is like saying the Germans were right in 1939 because of transgressions in 1918, or even worse 1890. There is peace now, and you cannot go all 1918 on us.
1
@Vorname_Nachnahme my reply explaining the fallacy of your argument regarding military prisoners versus civilian hostages keeps getting censored.
1