Comments by "Hakan Karaağaç" (@TheReaper569) on "CaspianReport" channel.

  1. "It was this first world infrastructure and third world worker costs that western companies found irresistible"
    354
  2. "although many indebpted nations blame washington for economic warfare, the truth is that this currency crisis is mostly of their own making." Good final touch, ı am from turkey and all of the news in my country now are about how evil america is and how derranged trump is and how they personally have hatred toward turkey. Basic fear mongering and paranoia runs rampand, fueling further nationalism, which in turn increases support for right wing parties, and AKP, the party of erdogan is one of them.
    353
  3. "Power doesn't corrupt. Rather power inevitably attracts the corrupted." excellent quote
    135
  4. SHIRVAN COME BACK, TAKE THIS TRY HARD OFF
    101
  5. Fuck off. Africa is owned by africans. Their failure is their own
    63
  6. Diplomacy: The art of possible, attainable and if all else fails, the next best thing. Where do you come up with these closures in all your videos?
    63
  7. "...with the experience gained dealing with hong kong protests, china will use the experience to bring taiwan back into the fold." -Caspianreport, in a video years ago. This is long coming. As you be foreseen it.
    62
  8. ah yes.. graveyard of empires... a place that has been subjegated completely 13 times but managed to fend off some commies and it has earned a reputation it never deserved...
    58
  9. The best channel on political reports you can ever find. FACT not a mere opinion.
    53
  10. they werent industrialized, they just had manufacturing power of 300 million people in a world with 1 billion. It was the ineffective and unproductive economy that relied on quantity of people on production that failed immidiately. Lets also not forget that french colonized india before english and they had large parts of it under control, they just lost it. It was true that victors write history, in a world of self loathing and hatred for ones own culture the main narative is victors are to be blamed, the rest are irrelevant.
    52
  11. Erdoğan also started talks about "mobilization" of the nation. Its still too early but it wasnt a slip of the mouth. It was a tactical move to see what kind of support such a move would get. If true and a full scale mobilization would take place, where i would be called into service, Turkey could be planning a "long term stay" in syrian territories.
    44
  12. i want shirvan back to be honest. Nathan is good but too generic and boring.
    41
  13. wants to ban the internet -Ok he is out too far gone crazy.
    31
  14. you must be new. Shirvan is always like this.
    30
  15. ah yes.. graveyard of empires... a place that has been subjegated completely 13 times but managed to fend off some commies and it has earned a reputation it never deserved...
    30
  16. exception that proves the rule.
    29
  17. i dont think the world is what you see it to be
    24
  18. All border guards are authorized to protect their borders with deadly force. This is true for all military forces for all nations in the world. Israel is no different. I have no sympathy for palestinians getting people killed just so they can show the people they killed to the world as if they are the victims. Its political manuvering at its worst.
    23
  19. İm not a russian so i dont really care but all of your maps show crimea as part of ukraine.
    22
  20. "Ok, I'm not an economist but" this sentence should never be followed by an opinion ..
    19
  21. no it isnt, recognition means little. in practice its run by russia, so its russia.
    16
  22. The one quote that signals the person who said it really understands politics "theere is no good or bad, it just is"
    15
  23.  Timothy Wei  calm the fuck down dipshit.
    15
  24. Get this generic voice actor out of here. WE NEED SHIRVAN NOW
    15
  25. You should have come to the conclusion that you know nothing.
    15
  26. hypocracy is a term people who dont know how the game works in politics.. There is no honour, there is no consistancy. There is no friend. There is political gain, and nothing else. Also stupid people who cry for these things . Who cares about them?
    14
  27. Rob Lynch dictaors are in the middle east because that kind of turmoil and a country that can plunge into civil war at any moment can only be rules by a ruthless dictator. Politicians arent bad people. They are what system requires to be
    13
  28. having your soldiers starve in world war and making the world submit to german domination is something that indians nationalists dont talk about
    13
  29. As a turkish, thanks for the awesome work!
    10
  30. citations needed
    10
  31.  Ambrose Burnside  no
    10
  32. hey nationalists ethiopia was colonized to bare bones.
    10
  33.  @cv4809  please add the later iranians, turkish khaganates, russo-asian kingdoms oh and the soviet union
    10
  34. if its on netflix,im out
    8
  35. There is no version of this where Russia comes out on top and be undisputed winner. Even the best propaganda victories, are short lived, will turn sour over time.
    8
  36.  @otomackena7610  dont get triggered you are letting your mask slide, french did try to colonize india as i said, they failed you dont know the details due to your superficial understanding or lack there of and declare french never did. 1-im not greek 2 reading what ancient greek historians had to say about indian economy to drive a conclusion about indian economy in 18-20th century is a non starter for me. I dont even argue againts that. its failed from the get go
    7
  37. Gairuntee why would they be accountable? They gave debts. Turkey and debted nations are accountable to pay. This has nothing to do with imperialism its just credit. When you give debt you reserve the right the demand it paid.
    7
  38. it is similar to the open veins of latin america. "we re poor, its their fault" dont fall for this rhetoric.
    7
  39. what is that? people who started slavery in africa were arab slavers and not europe? oh the more you know.. right.
    7
  40. thats what the worlds biggest naval re armanent program was for.
    6
  41. Ah... The Mini China
    6
  42. litteraly 2 minutes in and you can see why and how islam is not meant to be on the side of science.
    5
  43. wait let me get this straight you guys are confused that China being a totalitarian nightmare state, wanting to have its own silicon valley have no contradictory terms? You cant lock a 100 people into a room and order them to invent something, China's treatment of its minorities are brought as evidence to the level of government control. Innovation requires creativity, and freedom to express and share those creative ideas that came forth, in a state and a culture that promotes absolute docility that is obviously a problem. The issue of Hollywood is one and the same, the effort to create an environment where ideas are more freely exchanged, a creative culture, will encourage that endeavor. Such an environment creates and requires its own bubble culture (California vs rest of any town USA) therefore distance to political capital to maintain that bubble so it isnt too distracted by daily politics are all solid concepts.. I don't think many people of this channel have the necessary background understanding of statecraft to be viably here. I mean these are obvious. This channel is calculus, you need to learn how to add and subtract..
    5
  44.  @perc7226  i see no information mentioning that EU is defcon 2., and ı doubt Europe uses defcon system for deterrence readiness, its an american system. So prove once again that Europe is in defcon 2, if defcon even aplies.
    5
  45. dumbest comment ever .
    5
  46. National sport of tax evasion :) hahaha. Also im turkish and there is no need to be hostile. Video didnt say anything offensive. We are neighbors for more than 600 years. Respect that history. If that doesnt make turks and greeks brothers, i dont know what would. Ελλινηκος και τουρκος ειναι αδελφος.
    5
  47. problem is country somewhat worked, it is bein sabotaged to make it not work to justfy secession.
    5
  48. Dude you are great.
    5
  49. Yes he seems insane and that world-island theory seem unfounded madness.
    5
  50. KURD MEANS STRONG! Calm down. No need for racism.
    4
  51. the title sounded like a parody porn
    4
  52. I am just surprised that no one is discussing nuclear energy as an alternative.
    4
  53. 2:31 THE CONFUSING PHİLOSOPHY
    4
  54. Deterrence is a stupid policy. It’s essentially to deter the deterrence of the enemy from detering you. And it makes no sense
    4
  55. no army may enter that land that is protected by polish men unless you are 40 to 1 your force will soon be undone!
    4
  56. Profit is fine, when producers compete for profit, marvels happen, politics is different , it is a system that incentivisez corruption and it is a system for destroyers rather than producers.
    4
  57.  Alex Atrocity  then why did they use a military campaign to get in? Bad propaganda.
    4
  58. please stop using imperialism because no one understands what it is.
    4
  59.  @adithyakm9958  India has more population over all by a huge margin so it is not really smart of you to compare direct population count. The ratio of populations would be better. And in that aspect Pakistan wins
    4
  60.  @rejvaik00  exceptions that broke the rule... You compare number of wars declared vs.... Your 3 examples... Learn what anecdotal evidence is
    4
  61.  @rejvaik00  again i think you miss the point. Statistics isnt a numbers game.
    4
  62.  @rejvaik00  also some of your examples are flawed. For one example, Atatürk defecting in his trip to samsun and the start of the independence war are a bit far apart. Rather than direct causal links
    4
  63. Maybe he did.. how do you know
    4
  64. Yet another example of my country supporting extremist militia terrorists.. Turkey
    3
  65. Thank you for even more history. Good content. Dont mind the hate.
    3
  66. Another well informed video, thanks.
    3
  67. Excelent video. İ will show this to people who yell "they took our jobs"
    3
  68. Great video. Perhaps some of your narration can be argued but you did better than expected in remaining objective.
    3
  69. Chinas GDP is 21 trillon dolars? How ? America is the current largest economy with 14trillion GDP, Entıre european union is with 18 trillion GDP.
    3
  70. You just see it? YOU HAVE TO WATCH OTHER VIDEOS.
    3
  71.  cheese n' cheese mapper  same reason people are afraid of planes but drive. as if its safer.
    3
  72. my expriences tell me to be sceptical everytime a government announces a new huge project. It is usualy an elephant in the room / bread and circuss
    3
  73.  @perc7226  I see no information on that. I do see American Forces IN EUROPE use that. I mean the European armies, doesnt seem to use defcon independently.
    3
  74.  @evuldeluxe  "Ever since 1962, the US/NATO has been on DEFCON 3 indefinitely. " -Wrong.
    3
  75. sorry it doesn fit your ideologoical buble, retreat to safe space
    3
  76.  @prashanthb6521  things are not as simple as you understand form a wall of text in a white screen. Obviously reading a comment leads to assumption that people know less than they actualy do. Give the benefit of the doubt. " There are well documented historical accounts of India's economic might" -i didnt say india was economically poor, it was simply in efficient in comparison to industry, that is was traditional hand craft. And that tradition dates back hundreds of years so no wonder people got good at it, thus explaining the quality of indian silk and wool, while i previously explained the quantity part. "And you dont know this....according to geopolitics...every developed society falls prey to invading barbarians. Because the natives become complacent. This is a repeating pattern everywhere." -This pattern was described by an islamic historian whose name i forgot but his book got a showcase right in this channel, i knew it before i met here so when your basis of knowledge is a series of youtube videos dont make assumptions, you look stupid. As to the idea, i m not certain that historical patterns if there is any can be degenerated to win and conquer, live rich and wealthy due to wealth gained, get decadent and degenerate in rich life and get conquered by someone else. Im sure history is a bit more complicated than what a medieval historian thought it to be, that its more than strong man create good times lines of thinking.
    3
  77. You are an idiot capitalism need not rely on over population
    3
  78. GO BELT AND ROAD !
    3
  79.  @panoskat6910  i think he is turkish. What he is saying is the rhetoric on the news right now.
    3
  80. Western Left intellectuals are going to love this so much as a gift from god.
    3
  81. Scramble for Africa 2: geopolitical bugaloo
    3
  82.  @narsimhas1360  they did surrender tho
    3
  83. kurdistan is like israel. imagigary. KEK
    3
  84. the exception that proves the rule.
    3
  85. I didnt like it. It looks unprofessional.
    3
  86. i would like to sign up but masterworks gives an error
    3
  87. Osman Oglu that must have taken years of buying into state propaganda to say all that in one comment. Brainwashed nationalist spreading whatever the tv told him so. Turkey failed itself because it took a path of statism. The end.
    3
  88. İ m from turkey. İ want my country to be strong but I also want peace in the Mediterranean. Turkey and greece are major players in the region. Strengthening the relationship between these two countries and leading to an alliance, would overwhelm all other players in the region. Why share among libya, Israel, lebanon, egypt and everyone else, when you can only share among 2.
    3
  89. they dont? lol
    3
  90.  wargent99  much free er under british rule than you can ever be under Chinese rule.
    3
  91. this has been the dumbest thing ive read in this comment section
    3
  92. it was a local event that took place in middle east not a global event.
    3
  93.  @Tessali666  highly unlikely as today structure of systems are highly stable, resources to combat calamity abundant, communication to coordinate collective effort very easy so no we wont have disasters like the bronz age. You have to count extinction level events to get trough all the barriers of civilisation
    3
  94. Wtf is this generic explanatory voice? COME BACK SHIRVAN
    3
  95. you are overly optimistic. Argument is much more about weather or not its a real thing.
    2
  96. that statement is inherently racist. X is dicks to Y. Replace them with any other name you want and you still get a sentence that appears valid. so whats the point? point is you are stupid.
    2
  97. The most objective and informative politics channel i ve ever known.
    2
  98. We must build a wall to keep russians out
    2
  99. 3:30 another example of my country supporting terrorism. Turkey. I made the same comment in the previous video. Can anyone find a terrorist group that Turkey doesnt support?
    2
  100. i needed shirvan
    2
  101. so what is wrong here?
    2
  102. @Free Markets This is a stupid comment with no basis other than showing your bias for west-hate. Suck it up because we fucked you up. İts not up for debate its historical fact. and it wasnt the other way arround.
    2
  103. i disagree with some of the principles of kemalism. Roast me
    2
  104.    only 5th? Pff France is a joke.
    2
  105. The only thing i need to point out that israelis either agreed or directly proposed to PEACE 2-3 times before the arab revolt wars.. Muslims refused, even when the palestine zone like gaza strip today was 2-3 times bigger than it is today, it was a bad deal for israelis but they said ok we want peace, muslims wanted nothing but war againts the jewish people. I am not tryign to turn this into a race or religious issue but history is history.
    2
  106.  @here_we_go_again2571  Why would NATO come to aid anyway? Internatinal defense pacts works againts nations with formal declarations of war.
    2
  107. I dont understand russia. They are all for invading ukraine which a country that they guaranteed!. And they invaded a country they supposed to protect, ( ukraine traded their soviet heritage nukes to russia as part of good a deal and protecition and peace) finland and sweden join nato and other neighboring countries see russia as a belligrent force. russia "surprised picachu face"
    2
  108.  @antlerman7644  what is masterworks
    2
  109. Great thing that you uploaded a video. But the news are worrying. I hope we can come out of this one alive. A lot of people dont remember that we came so close to self anahilation during the cold war and now some jackasses want round 2. edit: well lets be honest was civilization going anywhere? i mean a cold war nationalist ferver could save us from the cancer of social justice .
    2
  110. @Anierutan Balaji i already know everything you said... and agreed.
    2
  111.  @otomackena7610  This is really strange because then we are in agreement. They did try to expand their colonial holdings in india but failed and english succeeded. Dont make that follow with " dont make up stuff" because no one did. Yes indian economy was "good" even in ancient times, however as there was no unifying body there was no manifestation of that economic power. Same thing with a twist can be said about china, china was doing quite good, but they also succeeded to unify china in one kingdom, in the 15-16 centuries their economy would rival europe combined as well, it is then denegrated that china being a colony or vassal in practical terms destroyed it as the same argument "drain theory" is made for india, i dont buy that its that simple. In china's case the emperor fearing a rise of a faction that he is not allied with, the merchants just banned all out bound international sea trade and exploration where as prior they would have massive fleets of 300 ships and explore africa, east indies, india, japan, sibiria, madagascar. So i think there was a failure on the part of india as well when that great economy was in the same age as that there was nothing but celtic and britonic tribes in the UK, centuries later it was the oppossite. Tribes were warring for dominance while British empire was on the steps of world domination. I see the same with other nations that were colonised as well. They failed themselves way before any european came to them. As the saying goes a great nation cannot be conquered from outside until it is conquered within.
    2
  112. @Anierutan Balaji do you know what industrialised means? India had the manpower that constantly produced with old school methods, they had no concept of factories, just hand built wooden tools for spinning ropes and not much more, thats not what industrialised means. I mean machinary. Look up on date of tool usage by year, and you see that they had no methods beyond what they were allready doing for hundreds of years. "But had a manufacturing force of 300 million and unproductive" its not an oxymoron or dychotomy as you think it is. you can have 300 milion working and barely produce anything.
    2
  113.  @commandercoop2921  exactly what i was trying to point out. but we agreed nontheless.
    2
  114.  Maz Peters  my point was that even with unproductive and ineffective economy they shared a 23 percent, its just that internet "intellectuals" cant read and it devolved into a shit storm.
    2
  115.  @talking_folk  and we are talking about the 1800s.. at least we were, until people who are dependent on wiki started copying numbers and blamed others for reading wiki... oh yeah there is a pattern here. you
    2
  116.  Maz Peters  you can't wake others when you are dreaming. Pretend to be woke then and miss the point we aren't talking about ancient India it's pre colonial and colonial era so miss the entire topic and you are on it. Go back to wiki
    2
  117.  Bidu Bidu  you must be indian, i dont care nor am i interested in your subjective opinion of beautiful or glorious... what the fuck is colorful anyway.. colorful culture? But, you are wrong, the education system in your country must suck badly. Glorious?Highly doubtful you got colonized, thats not some glory there. oldest? is definitely not because mesopotamians beat everyone to it.
    2
  118. Great analyses as always. I hope germany can stop hating itself though. A lesson for easterners: Central planning never works get a hold on to that idea.
    2
  119. Hating kurds? Something everyone does? Like breathing
    2
  120. I dont like the new editting design. It looks like those popular channels that think they are in some intellectual circles in youtube. Go back to actual maps. Maritime traffic map on google maps for example is alot more effective than this editting. Its lower cost, does the same if not more.
    2
  121.  @hanskover  how long exactly? 20-30 years? if so then it is a perfect transition source.
    2
  122. Shirvan should have made this.
    2
  123. Ethiopia was the only country in Africa that wasn't colonized did you buy your history lesson from a gang or something? ethiopia was colonized. liberia wasnt.
    2
  124. kashmir is china.
    2
  125.  @knasiotis1  now. η Τουρκία καί ν Ελλάδα είναι αδέλφια.
    2
  126. Osman Oglu ben ogrenciyim arabam felan yok kendim icin calisiorum simdi siktir git
    2
  127. +zendiablo unemployment is down, GDP is up, gdp growth is highest in recent years, production is up , taxes are down, regulations repealed and the dollar is currently crushing every single currency out there, especily lira but not only lira. Trump's plan worked great for the economy. Now if we could have a president that is less strong on speeches and more on being an actual president than Turkey can do great.
    2
  128.  @sinu0us  as i said. Two major players. The alliance of other countries wouldnt be strong enough.
    2
  129. you have the best book reviews.
    2
  130. you mean.. taliban?
    2
  131. You talk alot about china but dont have a lot of videos about it. Can you do analyses on chinas economic growth, how it started, its geopolitics. ETC.
    2
  132. I dont see how transforming a desert the size of a country into a arid lush land to produce food is "damaging the enviroment" and thus not good especially in an age where agricultural products are low and food product inflation is very high.
    2
  133. Mad lad shirvan. Excellent video.
    2
  134. no
    2
  135.  @Karmic89  becouse they were there and still are today? just look it up at africa witch trials and magic.. dumbfuck
    2
  136. Come back shirvan
    2
  137. As a turk i must say that majority of people on either side don't care. Only the people propagandized by television ignite comment wars. ειρήνη στο Αιγαίο. οι Τούρκοι και οι Έλληνες είναι γείτονες και αδέλφια.
    2
  138.  wargent99  so that's why hong kong people are at the streets protesting not to unite with China... Are you getting your info from Chinese national television? Also not free. Free er. Learn to read.
    2
  139. NO
    2
  140. 6 months? You mean only 2 weeks later. Afghanistan collapsed.
    2
  141.  @Tessali666  we are not agriclture based communities. Climate didnt push people away because it was hot or cold, its because it killed the crops. Modern agriculture is much more resilliant especily greenhouses. about mass migration we can do a lot of things.. housing facilities, welfare for migrants, or closing borders and building walls. We can track people that come and go in national borders, something impossible in bronze age
    2
  142. another great wide
    2
  143. not really, games have advanced in writing in quality to challenge most well books today. Video games are now in my eyes at least an honorable artistic field.
    2
  144.  @ahmadfrhan5265  You have a very poor understanding of the world.
    2
  145. can ethiopian nationalists fuck off? you wre colonized by both italy and ottoman empire.
    2
  146. Communist party is worried about economic growth? How is this communism? Is china communist only by name? Please explain Shirvan.
    1
  147. Too long didnt watch: Africa was a shithole and still is a shithole.
    1
  148. im not sure on gaddafi would single handedly be able to stabilize whole africa.
    1
  149. calm down people. İ am from turkey and i say that "shanks" is retarded.
    1
  150. I wanted to hear it from shirvan :(
    1
  151. Shirvan please come back and voice your owwn videos.
    1
  152. are you in denial? democrats are being shattered. not only in US but everywhere LEFT IS LOOSING.
    1
  153. Best history video. Subbed. keep it comşng.
    1
  154. they dont know..
    1
  155. Not enough.
    1
  156. Crimea in your videos appear to be part of ukraine. The maps are from google earth but putin will dislike this video. Just saying.
    1
  157. Socialism at its best
    1
  158. İf the stats you gave is true than africa will eat itself and rip itself apart due to uncontroleld population growth.
    1
  159. as always excelent video. Go shirvan.
    1
  160. Simply the best politicis channel ever.
    1
  161. General Hux no
    1
  162. "generic exposition voice"
    1
  163. machine overlords are coming.
    1
  164. stop blaming the mongols you islam apologetic twats. İslam brought it about itself. it wanted a fucking dark age and it got one. Cure? Get rid of it.
    1
  165. Unless they are proggramed to surpass their programming, than your argument is just bad.
    1
  166. I want shirvan. Only
    1
  167. war never changes.
    1
  168. Shirvan's SOUND IS BACK WOHOOO
    1
  169. Şirvan can you do a short episode on the politics of several countries? Germany france and spain are left out as you mentioned a lot about britain america and russia. As well as the upcoming referandum in turkey about the presidental system.
    1
  170. NO THERE İSNT
    1
  171. you are a problem.
    1
  172. Why does greece having a problem with people identifying as macedonian? It ıs 2018 and people willingly identify as philipino black women, trans gender , queer, disabled and as an attack helicopter. Does greece have a problem with diversity?
    1
  173. This is a great book and an excellent follow up to guns germs and steel, reading two of these books back to back gives you a great insight.
    1
  174.    nukes mean nothing. Try using them.
    1
  175.  @oscarmike1594  Join the Ukrainian Armed Forces, they gather vollunteers and Ukrainian army has some hot chicks. ENLIST NOW
    1
  176. Edit, i only saw one shady post from reddit and no official announcement, and further research confirms that DEFCON is a NORAD system, mainly american forces. "Europe is officially in DEFCON 2, i doubt Russia is at 4." this is a false statement.
    1
  177.  @perc7226  what meanningless argument, you are wrong, its nothing to be ashamed of. That DEFCON is a US system and that Europe nor european command of US army is in defcon 2. You are simply wrong.
    1
  178. Geo politics of everywhere: politics elections budget Geo politics of Africa: war war war
    1
  179.  @TheEmadia  stereotype s exist and you re not wrong about turkey but you should add Erdoğan to the mix.
    1
  180. Here is an unpopular truth, the fact that africa is this is because the nations are filled with high state authorithy giving politicians the incentive and ability to suck off wealth at the expense of everyone else. "oh no its the west" wrong "oh no its the corporations" wrong "oh no its colonialism" wrong "oh no its.." shut the fuck up. Many nations today have come off from worse statuses than any african nation is in today and grew wealthy. South korea was poorer than africa for example. its the freedom that capitalism requires to function, makes the wealth of nations or the failure of nations. Guns germs and steel, the wealth of nations, why nations fail read these in order.
    1
  181. Fly Beep dont make him talk, do you really think his opinion is any good, better than caspians research?
    1
  182. And... Afghanistan collapsed.
    1
  183. well lets be honest was civilization going anywhere? i mean a cold war nationalist ferver could save us from the cancer of social justice .
    1
  184. trolls?
    1
  185. sociaty of assholes, no offense but it sounds like it comes from someone at the bottom of dominance hierarchies.
    1
  186. Peterson did not establish the idea, merely more populirized it, yet the underlying psychology was there, had you bothered to read something in your life, other than comment section. :)
    1
  187. Why does everyone who gets a response says that? Primary expectation of youtube today sems to be say anything you want, if anyone reponds, assume its because they are offended or stuck. "rigid social structure leads to stagnation since wellfare of the species as the whole is not a primary concern of it" if you could open up on that perhaps this can turn into a meaning discussion? So you dont have to ask my trust to know that you do read.
    1
  188. speech has consequences, that ones should not be legislative, is what the position of free speech is. I believe you misunderstand the opposing position if you think this.
    1
  189. " the right wing hype wagon" i believe you mistaken me on this. i am really not, it is possible i mis represented myself so big fault lies with me. İ have read why nations fail and i would love to talk about it. From my perspective the foundation of virtuous circles is the hard part since virtuous circle can protect itself similar to vicious circle. The author does rely heavily on intervention and moderation by goverment to save capitalism from capitalists. I think more in line with chicago school of economics. Intervention for the most part does more harm than good. Lessons of milton friedman explains this perfectly.
    1
  190. what is power? power to influence the public? power to influence politics? power to influence market forces? power to cheat out of law and elections?
    1
  191. in that aspect power is a combination of of resources and ability to efficiently allocate them to proper areas. So, power is money+good money management in pursuit of a said objective.
    1
  192. You dont have to guess my position before mentioning them, like you did in north korea example thats just a bad argument you ll lose a lot of respect for that, even though i do agree with you. Second there is NO such a thing as too big to fail. its a rhetoric used by big corps to scare the congress into bailing them out. Free market capitalism without intervention lets them fail, yes there will be ripples and after shock but the world market is bigger tthan any very large corporation, it iwll recover and grow, even healthier i might say. So the problem is not that there is no goverment intervention, problem is precicely the intervention when there is none needed. You let banks and big corps to fail because of bad management hundreds of smaller corporations and small buisnesses whose names you never hear about will find themselves a niche of market and thrive. No corporation no matter which field is too big that entire economy would fall with them.
    1
  193. You fail to take into account of the free market forces and insist of a cospiratorial world view that with money you can do anything you want and get no reprecouchions, think again sweetheart, there are numerous examples where people with all the money they wanted still couldnt get away from the things they did. I mean come on read some economy world is big, and your view have to be bigger than the thickness of why nations fail, its a good book, its not the only book. grow up.
    1
  194. Your insight into pareto is dissapointly limited. Sure the basic outset is true but you fail to notice that that small top, where resources are accumulated, are not static, check top 10% or 1% of the population or the stock market, corporation shares, you will see top positions shift rapidly. often between people with differing interests, preventing natural cabal of elites agreeing on world domination despite what conspiracies would ave you believe. "Even the very basics of economics follow the idea of that demand precedes the supply, " -except in cases where supply creates demand.. if we are to teach basics to another perhaps it should be the other way arround? Lets tlak about failsafes shal we , it is proven time and tme again that so called fail safes like minimum wage laws, anti trust, social security, retirement benefits, diversity quotas and what not did anything except the desired affect. Listening to lectures of thomals sowell or milton friedman will better help you understand this, goverment is people, and are just as fallable as any other, perhaps even more so lookign at the number of ways goverment fucks up everything. "Also free market is not very good at dealing with long term issues like climate change or geopolitcal conflict" Actualy it is, you should read on transiiton from coal to oil, or how farmers of far east got to use solar energy.
    1
  195. Actualy no, Friedman was criticized for precicely not holding that view, people who think like you say friedman thinks are anarcho capitalists, Friedman is a minarchist, he believes that there should be a state to govern and protect the market, he also supports some goverment welfare programs, very rarely but it does happen, he is the one who proposed the idea of negative income tax. Welfare for people who were making money but not enough to take care of the entire family, like family with 3 kids, he proposed that goverment can fill in the gap, like a subsidy to keep them well off. On part of recession i make no comment because i am kind of in between between camps of goverment fixes it and goverment makes it worse. friedman is of the camp that say goverment makes things worse. Peter shicfh and others believe that goverment caused it in the first place but i wont go as far. On f-35 its actualy the best f-plane on the planet, of course it had huge set backs but its a prototype, what public doesnt know is that its expected to fail from a prototype thats why its a prototype. Lockheed after fixing them presented a new generation fighter plane, and thats that. What is hard is that the politicians are not military man nor engineers, so they dont understand it and just repeated after the public outcry, im glad that they were ignored because now its the best goddamn plane on the planet. What you also dont know is that corporations or private buisness has no corruption, they dont need to have it so they dont, corruption comes into place when they need the approval of some politician for licence and contract, than bribes are necessary, so they have it. Politicians are corrupt because the system they are in benefits ALL in the buisness to have corrupt politicans and we cant really use them to fight corruption now can we? Because while public calls it figh corruption, it would be in reality eliminating compettion.
    1
  196. these are factually wrong. I wont even argue, you need to get into military writing other than watching youtube videos and tv programs. "f 35 which is a worse plane than F22" All prototype programs ARE EXPENSIVE, do you understand that. ITS WHY THEY ARE CALLED PROTOTYPES .its really annoying that i haveto lecture you on definiton of words that you are ignorant of being ignorant on them. Its the point of prototypes to stabilize and min max economy and performance so they are ready to mass produce, mass production from prototype stages starts in more than 10 years.. 10, f-35 is arround for what? couple of years? You really need to understand basics before watching biased documanteries and think you have some insider knowledge on this. Your second point relies on weak dodge with jumping from meaning of other words, primarely away from corruption and its filled with idealogical rhetoric devoid of any sensible of personality or information behind them. so that doesnt even deserve a response.
    1
  197. ​ @leodarksam6230  "i would be called into service"
    1
  198.  @leodarksam6230  and you are offended because...
    1
  199.  @N3XYF  sensitive nationalist, leave him alone lol.
    1
  200.  @leodarksam6230  its simply really, i dont care. im interested in political implacations not chest pounding.
    1
  201.  @leodarksam6230  it will also strenghten the position of syrian government as weaking the opposition will allow the government to re establish it self, as it should. However just because there is an operation with a purpose doesnt mean it will succeed without long term consequences. Afghanistan and Vietnam are examples to that.
    1
  202. And the Americans thought "but the US has never lost a war before", it happens. When hubris takes hold it is only more likely to take place the first time. "Are you seriously questioning Turkey's military capabilities while being Turkish yourself? " --They are soldiers not miracle workers, Turkey just as America can win every battle but still lose the war. Being a free thinking citizen, scary but will broaden your vision. And for the rest.... The US the most powerful miilitary machine on earth, lost the war to vietnamese rice farmers.
    1
  203.  @leodarksam6230  logic is blind faith patriotism isnt going to award you any medals. get lost.
    1
  204.  Boris Erdogan  i wouldnt use "distance travelled" as the measure of success if the battlefield are mostly easly traversable plains..
    1
  205.  Boris Erdogan  yeah thats how the idiots at 'nam did it .
    1
  206. One more reason why central planning of big systems is inefficient and out done by smaller systems.
    1
  207. nein
    1
  208. Another great video as always.
    1
  209. alt right types are offended that global trade works?
    1
  210. Don't make deals with the terrorists Afghanistan
    1
  211. best channel ever
    1
  212. Turning the north sea into a fresh water lake would possibly destroy utterly or severely affect the eco systems of entire northern europe at best, and would cascade to surrounding eco systems to all over europe at worst. Bad idea, dont do that.
    1
  213.  @Azknowledgethirsty  it does to the people. Culture is here for a reason, the globalisation is inevitable that is fact, however there must be a comprimise to keep the culture and structure relatively stable over periods of time, long enough for people to adapt to the changes. Pursuit of progress at the expense of the past has always produced disaster.
    1
  214. nothing wrong with it, being a proud capitalist.
    1
  215. ı swear when it comes to politics most people have no idea what they are talking about, and no people is worse at it than us, the turks.Erdogan was elected, like it or not, and no he didnt do good work, Turkey is heading for bankrupcy, Turkey started trading with other nations with its national currency because it no longer can afford to do it.. Do you know what this means? Its what weimar did, its a symptom of a failing nation.
    1
  216. they have a right to do that.
    1
  217.  @Mrjmaxted0291  you mean the comment? its there. mr attorney.
    1
  218.  @ggwpoleg6600  you are unworthy of response
    1
  219. @Anierutan Balaji ugh i dont follow how quantity of people follow that they must be qualitative as well. When that many people work, even in worst of productivity rates per worker you will get immense surpluss good total as compared to europe, but on the rest agreed.
    1
  220.  @ArawnOfAnnwn  i really dont know what the purpose of most internet arguments are, mostly based on misunderstandings, since it is difficult to argue on pure text.
    1
  221. @Anierutan Balaji i dont think you understood a single word i said, you took it personal that i meant individual people like you were worthless or something... Internet arguments...
    1
  222.  @prashanthb6521  i agree.
    1
  223.  @prashanthb6521  its a bit more complicated than you think about the pattern of civilisations.. also warfare rockets to britain.. eleborate?
    1
  224.  Bidu Bidu  there is a link above, you should check that out showing french controlled teritory., its not that indian history worths much anyway.
    1
  225.  Bidu Bidu  you dont know what industrialized means
    1
  226.  Bidu Bidu  "when you started saying that we must refer to wiki for the map of french controlled territory of India" i said no such a thing, you cant quote me on that, i said we can refer to a map created to demonstrate french colonial ambitions in india." "narcissism and arrogance" This is you indulging in your psychological reflection. "you still believe wikipedia tells true History.." -They have errors, but still far better than whatever shit you learned and didnt know enough to not call it education. And i didnt talk about portugal.. ever.. maybe you should respond to comments you see and not the comments you imagine. İf your education comes from indian government curriculum than there is a billion more people just as idiot as this example.
    1
  227.  Bidu Bidu  please look up psychological reflection. Other than that, you are beneath notice.
    1
  228.  @ifori4856  yeah... no the issue is much deeper than you think it is, soviets were prepearing for war not spesificly germany but all of europe, germany attacked first but that doesnt change the fact that war was pretty much ineviteble. wait for russians to build up their army? or attack now?
    1
  229. Best political analysis
    1
  230. One of the most channels
    1
  231. As someone who studied cold war. Nuclear hypersonic weapons race is worrying. Even more with pre emptive strike and first strike doctrines. In the cold war radar operators had enough time to warn command and re run scans to confirm threats. This time to re check allowed them to identify many false positives and possibly saved the world from apocalypse on numerous occasions.
    1
  232. Uh no. Laws passed by who? On whose behalf?
    1
  233. in Turkey i think it is closer to original Varşova War-sho-va
    1
  234. holy shit we have witnessed the fall of afghanistan and now ethiopia.
    1
  235. then you wont like the book, telling it like iti s...
    1
  236. Editting error, music doesnt fit, its a happy light undertone when you are talking about global thermonuclear war.
    1
  237. Ok. Local greek propagandist.
    1
  238.  @loulakion  turkey does not demand an archipelago. Also that's not how continental shelf works.
    1
  239.  @loulakion  no as in you can't claim an archipelago because it is off shoot on the continental shelf. Turkeys claims revolve on meis island blocking turkeys Mediterranean maritime navigation and blocking EEZ from potential natural resource sites in the Mediterranean Sea. And maritime security in the aegean especially for civilian trade and naval navigation. İ think meis island issue will be resolved in the upcoming greek turkish negotiations but the aegean part is a massive issue. Turkey is not alone in not accepting it. No nation in that circumstance would. Similar situation happens in south china sea.
    1
  240. its not as alarming as you think
    1
  241. @Citizen elon musk is an idiot and no its not an effective way
    1
  242. What made this channel good was the good guy Shirvan, not this extremely generic voice narrator.
    1
  243. On september fucking
    1
  244. Majority of russians supporting putin is a false statement
    1
  245. Perfect vid shirvan
    1
  246. Well, is it time to admit that you guys were better off in colonies?
    1
  247.  @goste4  Mr. Poe? Is this your law speaking?
    1
  248.  @goste4  ok this isnt poes law. "Anybody who studies history should know that I speak truth.""nothing extreme about my comment at all." You just declared yourself the prophet of truth that is pretty extreme. How come mongols are"greatest" their empire litteraly died after 1 emperor.. if you have asystem that sucks so bad that it dies with its founder, its NOT A GOOD SYSTEM. thats litteral fact. We had empires that lastes millenias. Mongols were some hill bill nobodies that for some cosmic accident they had one genius with ambition and no one else even moderately competant that system died with the guy.
    1
  249.  @goste4  you have 0 history knowledge.. or the way you look at it is so schewed that it is screwed. i am aware mongolian empire didnt die after genghis khan but its golden age sure ended and the problems of running it came ever apparent, that its destruction was a matter of when and not if, so can be traced to the great khan's death. another. "China, Russia, Mughal, Seljuk/Ottoman" were NOT the remnants of mongolian empire by no way.. I have no idea how you drew this idea but some of the empires you listed preceeded it and some FOUGHT againts it. The only thing impressive here is your ideological lenses that choose and kick facts of history to fit a narrative that mongolians were the greatest. Not that facts come and ideas arise from them as they should in mature in both body and mind people.
    1
  250.  @majormarketing6552  who cares? Romans are gone.
    1
  251. that is because of yellow river connecting to the sea. so. Coastal prospects stand
    1
  252. Editting error, music doesnt fit, its a happy light undertone when you are talking about global thermonuclear war.
    1
  253. Mendicant Bias i would unsub. Seriously if you think lewis wasnt distracting by try harding sounds this video would have been better.
    1
  254.  @ruffy657  no.
    1
  255. Bridge shaped sea barrier againts ukrainian ships.. Thats a dick move
    1
  256. students are economicalyl inactive? In what universe? Students do and should work... Government is lying...
    1
  257.  @NihilistAlien  hated? Yes. Anything more practical? No.
    1
  258. 11:05 mispronouned or mis typed province? Shirvan please.
    1
  259. its generic narrataion.
    1
  260.  @TheJunaid15  "A nation having nothing literally, no army, no unity, no economy, no weapons, have managed to secure 70 percent or more of Afghanistan" bitch thats the taliban. a nation controlling 100% of its territory is not a success by the way, its the standart of being a NATION.. if you fail that you by definition re a failed state
    1
  261.  Mosquito Creations  difference is.....?
    1
  262.  Mosquito Creations  no you just repeated the terms.... Stop... Afghanistan got conquered many times period.
    1
  263.  Mosquito Creations  no one now because its a shit hole.. and people who did back in the day did conquered it. There is nothing special here unconquered Afghanistan is a big myth.
    1
  264.  @masyaf897  ur dumb if you think most of the belligerents had intentions of annexation for their war....
    1
  265.  @GangBlud  uh no. Strongest and richest army? By far no. And not in the 19, 18. Century
    1
  266.  @GangBlud  because they weren't committed.
    1
  267.  @GangBlud  yes.
    1
  268. @Meep P yes 13 out of 13 times when belligerent parties had intentions to go trough with it and look at it now. So called graveyard of empires is itself a graveyard
    1
  269. @Meep P small number of 13 times? Yes because circumstances are rare when afghanistan id worth invading. 13 times it was successful... You do realize its %100 failure to defend the country right? İts about time that the myth of Afghanistan is recognized as the bullshit it is
    1
  270.  @amazingamx1255  it did pretty much, the country imploded and collapsed to its own dissident faction...
    1
  271. russia has only one leader to choose. so it chooses that leader.
    1
  272.  @Bee.Holder  True words. Once the war dissipates and propaganda is cold and media shifted narrative to another problem of the new day, cold truths will emerge.
    1
  273. This is really screwed up hardcore dystopian real politik on the side of Australians.
    1
  274. Well without it, you don't exist.
    1
  275.  @sumkindacheeto  what electric trains....
    1
  276. This wasnt so interesting... Shallow
    1
  277. cry
    1
  278. Just nuke the middle east to oblivion and there wont be any problem there for millenias to come. Mainly beause there wont be any place for any problem to be in.
    1
  279. peter , can we look at the countries now to see if which one was colonized and stripped? oh yeah. the shit hole you defend was.
    1
  280. Kurdish Aryan Median Hurrian Hittite great kurdistan? Is that like palestine? Fictional lands
    1
  281. As a turk, we have the same rhetoric from the opposite side. But both nations are maximalist here.
    1
  282. D3C3n50r 1. Point fine 2.you are wrong lots of nations are with mixed people and culture 3. Renewable energy is inefficient unreliable
    1
  283.  @goblinsdammit  not really
    1
  284. Germany is weak and spot on that it shot itself on the foot
    1
  285. "Remember the Maine! To hell with Spain!" Slogan repeated by Media just prior to spanish-american war, blaming the sinking of USS Maine on Spain. Slogan was populer especily by the time magazine and the journals of william randolph hearst. Later report by US Navy engineers found that tropical heat had ignited an unused depot which in turn ignited the ammunition storage.
    1
  286. big surprise. who actualy thought it was happening? ideolouges?
    1
  287. But why is russia so paranoid about the west? İ doubt nato is going to mobilize for a full invasion.. Also a 100 year old geo political theory is no basis for a successful statecraft.. To me russia looks like following its own self fulfilling prophecies.
    1
  288.  @justinfarquhar8299  WRONG
    1
  289.  @lefouduroi9980  is it so bad?
    1
  290.  @lefouduroi9980  thank you. For the record i dont see any make money easy purpose. İ just want more platforms to diversify my investments, thats it.
    1
  291. Its called Anime, Dad! You arent informed.
    1
  292. +seasonal.lawnchairs dont worry i didnt claim that americans actually hate turkish people. Its just media always telling us what to think. I ve heared media went bat shit crazy in America so i guess you know what i mean bro. +Osman how can i be believing in state propoganda then? State never tells you that its doing a bad job. You would know this.. woudlnt you
    1
  293. Taylan Kirdag we arrested a us citizen without due process, we violated our contract for arms sales. We failed to pay due debts from USA. And lira failed because FDA withdrew all foreign credit and asked due payment as well as other currencies. As the video says, we blame usa for economic war this is but our own making. “We” are not right. We are not the heroes here. Turkish government is guilty of those i stated above and lying to public so uninformed like you comment like you just did.
    1
  294.  @George_Washington_  politics is not friendship.
    1
  295.  @gencfblienes  our government is accountable and responsible to combat foreign monetary intervention. Everyone looks after their own interests, enemies and allies change daily. We have to play politics as well to keep nation strong and stop crying because others looked after their own interests which conflicted with ours.
    1
  296.  @gencfblienes  about infrastructure yes but about universities you re wrong. All newly built universities are useless.
    1
  297.  @gencfblienes  turkey also needs to fix brain drain
    1
  298. NEVER LEAVE THE NARATION SHIRBOY
    1
  299.  @savvas666777  statecraft.
    1
  300.  @savvas666777  statecraft has no outdate. Or moral checks for right and wrong. Only that it works, or not.
    1
  301.  @nasraabdullah6935  see my previous comment. Your morals or understanding of what belongs to who mean nothing.
    1
  302.  @savvas666777  not according to me. İt's not an opinion. Merely an observation. Learn political science and how damned and so called outdated concepts like Machiavellism and real politic control modern politics.
    1
  303. No
    1
  304. Reunite the raj.
    1
  305. This doesnt explain anime. Whats wrong with them?
    1
  306. What
    1
  307. please dont... why WHY.. SHIRVAN .. you sponsored raid shadow legends........... oh my god we trusted you
    1
  308.  @bimbowithadegree420  i dunno it doesnt take Christian base to know that animal sacrifice and virgin blood for spells is something WRONG TO DO
    1
  309.  @мувн-ш4ы  we never claim to be european. We are turk. Thats it. We dont have an identity crisis. You being resentful however is pitiul.
    1
  310.  wargent99  oh no evil nation destroyers in the us.... İs that the boogeyman Chinese TV wants you to fear today?
    1
  311.  @yerri5567  hk er that was appointed by china. Lol. Not voting is better than a false voting.
    1
  312. KommentarSpaltenKrieger 129394032 he wants to ban the internet. He is crazy and wrong
    1
  313. warning: established titles is a scam, disawoved by the scottish parliment, they issued a decree saying you wont be referred to as lord or lady, scottish law does not recognize your right.
    1
  314. trump derangement syndrome appears to be international now... Also like what? What did he do last time that was so bad that the "world needs to prepare" first of all USA aint that important, sescond, Trump did nothing wrong.
    1
  315. i dont really see eye to eye with protestors here, break everything down, property of people who had nothing to do with their problems? clash with the police? get upset over spending cuts? It seems like failed generation dependent on government.
    1
  316. 1 dictator went down. Here comes the savior peaceful military general right?? Fuck no. You fucked up
    1
  317. CASPIAN REPORT STARTED IN VIDEO ADS
    1
  318.  @ArawnOfAnnwn  your examples are from early 20th century and i am speaking of today.. thats not how you present a counter argument. go back to 1910s then.
    1
  319.  @ArawnOfAnnwn  You cant read... Despite acting ilke a posh internet intellectual. i said a calamity of extinction level is required to destroy civilization as we know it. A Katrina or a Indonesian tsunami would destroy any civilisation out right in the bronze age or medival ages, now we only have a year work and everything goes back to normal. Not the same as a calamity wont happen. Also there you go examples. I don't make the mistake of bringing out examples a century ago to judge today, im not that stupid.
    1
  320. Tarik360 the last part, is that a quote? If so from who?
    1
  321.  @BlackR65  With geography on your side, you do not have to deal much in differences and uprisings, as transportation is easier so it is to transmit ideas, or if necessary, exert force.
    1
  322. your brain is smaller than the dishes in your plait.
    1
  323. nah
    1