Hearted Youtube comments on Drachinifel (@Drachinifel) channel.

  1. 862
  2. 861
  3. 860
  4. 857
  5. 855
  6. 853
  7. 853
  8. 853
  9. 850
  10. 849
  11. 845
  12. 844
  13. 843
  14. 843
  15. 843
  16. 842
  17. 842
  18. 841
  19. 840
  20. 839
  21. 835
  22. 834
  23. 834
  24. 834
  25. 833
  26. 829
  27. 829
  28. 827
  29. 826
  30. 824
  31. 824
  32. 823
  33. 821
  34. 41:02 Lee's recommendation against a night surface action at Philippine Sea is one of my favorite moments of the Pacific War history, and says so much about Lee's intelligence and character. There's so much to unpack in Lee's brief communication to Spruance: "Do not - repeat not - believe we should seek night engagement. Possible advantages of radar more than offset by difficulties in communications and lack of training in fleet tactics at night." Lee was getting the chance to conduct exactly the sort of action a surface commander would dream of, and he was unquestionably the most qualified U.S. admiral to lead such an action at the time. However, that intelligence and experience told him that such night actions were chaotic, unpredictable, and tended to offer many chances for a supposedly weaker force to turn the tables on its notionally superior counterpart. He knew firsthand the skill of the Japanese Navy in night actions, and recognized that his own ships would have at best a minimal advantage over them in training and capabilities. Thus, he recommended that the USN avoid playing to the IJN's greatest remaining strength, foregoing the chance at a victory exclusively for his own ships. Instead he recommended (in effect) that Spruance fight an exclusively carrier-based battle, which would minimize the role of his own ships but play to the overall fleet's greatest strengths and give the best chance for overall victory. This was a commander who could be brilliant in his particular sphere of naval warfare while still clearly understanding the overall picture, and acting accordingly.
    817
  35. 815
  36. 813
  37. 812
  38. 811
  39. 811
  40. 810
  41. 809
  42. 809
  43. 808
  44. 807
  45. 804
  46. 801
  47. 801
  48. 799
  49. 799
  50. 794