Hearted Youtube comments on Sam Aronow (@SamAronow) channel.

  1. Screw Netflix, this series is where its at!
    125
  2. Sam, I don't know if you hear this very often enough, so I'll say it here. You have become a truly amazing storyteller. 8 haven't been watching your channel from the beginning, the first video I watched is one you've since taken down, the one on Hebrew linguistics (I think the relationship between it and the other Semitic languages, but I can't recall exactly), which, despite your misgivings 8 enjoyed greatly. After that, I proceeded to watch your entire backlog up to that point, and have watched every new video nearly as soon as it comes out. It didn't take you long to hit your stride, but you've never stopped improving. Keep up the good work. Now, I'm going to rewatch this video, because you've reached the point where it's both very enjoyable to do so, and practically necessary to actually absorb everything.
    125
  3. Fun fact: Former PM Ehud Olmert’s (Kadima, 2006-2009) grandfather was from Harbin and spoke his last words in Chinese!
    123
  4. The Tel Aviv frame in 16:45 made me laugh really hard. I love how your videos not only teach me so much (even as an Israeli Jew, let alone one who learned about this topic in middle school) but also integrate subtle jokes into them. Take a bow
    120
  5. Mexican Jewish history is just one of many lost aspects of this country's evolution. Not lost in the sense of being fully forgotten, but in the sense of being often overlooked, at home and abroad. Hopefully this will give us here on Youtube the chance to eventually explore those other aspects. Greetings from Mexico!
    119
  6. Maybe the real messiah was the friends we made along the way...
    117
  7. אני לא מבין למה לא אנחנו לא לומדים את זה בבת ספר, זה ממש מדהים כמה אנחנו לא מודעים להיסטוריה של עצמנו, גם העובדה שהערוץ הזה לא יותר מצליח די מפליאה אותי.
    114
  8. I am an orthodox yeshiva Jew and I must say i thoroughly enjoy your history. Even if at times I learned something a bit different I am so glad to hear it coming from different point of views. I wish you only further success and to go from strength to strength. God bless.
    111
  9. Hey Sam, as an Israeli Arab I noticed that amba has been very widely adopted among us to the point you will always find it served at Arab Israeli restaurants in diaspora and the way I grew up it was mandatory to have it on shawarma.
    109
  10. Incredible work Sam. We're so lucky to have quality content like this. What a gift to public scholarship. Thank you.
    108
  11. This was certainly one of the most fascinating episodes. The story of Shabtai Zvi gets crazier the more I learn about it. To be perfectly honest I kinda hoped we will hear more on this channel about the Jewish life in Poland-Lithuania before everything went downhill in 1648, for example about the forms of Jewish self-government: the kahals and the Council of Four Lands (and the separate Council of Lithuania since 1623), but maybe there will be an opportunity to mention this institutions latter, before or as they will be dissolved? Or maybe a mention of the Karaim (Karaites) community. BTW did you count the Karaites among the Jewish population of the Commonwealth? I was really surprised by that part about inbreeding (and the soundtrack was a very funny touch). Describing the Cossacks, specifically the Zaporozhian ones, as "Russian-speaking" at 4:27 might be very problematic to some, I think that Ruthenian or East Slavic would be safer terms (Ukrainian might be a bit anachronistic). Interestingly, I remember reading in Timothy Snyder's The Reconstruction of Nations: Poland, Ukraine, Lithuania, Belarus, 1569-1999 that during the Pereyaslav Council of 1654 Khmelnytsky's Cossacks and the representatives of the Russian Tsar discovered they need translators, despite both calling their language "Ruski/Rusky", because the forms that became modern Ukrainian and Russian were already becoming significantly different. I assume that the ending was a foreshadowing of Hasidism, but was the foreboding "for the most part" at 27:22 a foreshadowing of Frankism?
    107
  12. Felt like it was a good time to revisit this video... happy Chanukah to those who will be celebrating!
    106
  13. Mostly here to see Jarrett Ross drawn in Sam Aronow style.
    104
  14. Sam, the work you’re doing providing not only top tier educational content but also making it entertaining and a pleasure to watch while learning is a gift to all of us. Thank you for all your immensely hard work, your integrity and your quality scholarship. It’s a pleasure to work with and along side you. With Love, Zevi
    104
  15. Well lads, don't come onto that Torah scroll... She's spoken for 😂
    100
  16. Linguistic stuff is absolutely as interesting as battles (even if I understand like half of it).
    99
  17. As always, such a high quality video. It's amazing that this stuff is free to watch. Much respect :)
    97
  18. Since comments are turned off for your latest video, "The Damascus Affair: 1840," I decided I'd stop by here to tell you how much I enjoyed it. Yet more history I never knew about. Thanks for all your efforts.
    94
  19. This was when my father’s family left the Russian Empire for East London. And then a large part of the extended family moved from there to this new town everyone was talking about; Hollywood.
    94
  20. these are amazing videos, please Keep up the great work! watching you from Egypt
    93
  21. “Jake Aronow died from complications of Tuberculosis” it’s always tuberculosis!
    93
  22. Sam, I am a casual student of history, and I'm becoming a student of our shared history - something I was a bit too shy to learn. Your videos are a joy because they are thoughtful and easy to understand. Keep up the good work. Shabbat Shalom.
    92
  23. Thank you Sam for covering this sad and difficult history. The quality of your content is astounding. It’s an honor to work alongside you.
    92
  24. 11:37 Looking at the maps of France, northern Italy, and Germany is painful. Attention to detail 10/10
    88
  25. One of Casimir's laws was against the desecration of Jewish cemeteries (including capital punishment if I recall correctly) which I assume means that this ugly behavior was a problem in the middle ages too. Such desecration happens just about every single year across the world to this very day.
    87
  26. I thought that maybe I will give some additional context for the "Orthodox" part in the official name of Berek's unit you can see at 16:44. In original Polish, it's Starozakonny - a traditional Polish synonym for "Jewish" (particularly in the religious sense), which can be literary translated as "of the old order/law", referencing the Christian concept of the "Old Covenant". I think that in time it perhaps become especially associated with Orthodox Judaism but simply "Jewish Lighthorse Regiment" might be a better translation. Maybe one could experiment with some neologisms to create a perfect translation? I'd say that something like "Oldcovenanter Lighthorse Regiment" would sound really badass.
    86
  27. "Rashi script" isn't actually Rashi's personal handwriting. The script was commonly used by the Jews of southern Europe during the early renaissance. Since it was such a common script, it was set to type in one of the earliest Hebrew printed book, Rashi's commentary on the Pentateuch, and it continues to be used in hebrew printing up to the present day.
    85
  28. Always look forward to the next video! Awesome content, from a Muslim fan ❤️
    84
  29. I finally decided to check out your work and I have to say that it's pretty great! Honestly, I'm starting to feel a bit overwhelmed by the number of interesting channels about history but I guess that is a good kind of a problem to have. I assume that you are planning to present Jewish history throughout the ages. I would love to see you cover one day such things as the Statute of Kalisz, the Council of Four Lands or Berek Joselewicz.
    83
  30. Hi Sam, coming from Kashmiri and Kurdish family. I can say amba is still quite commonly found in northern region of the Indian subcontinent and Iraq. It's even common enough for me to pick up at my local supermarket Waitrose in UK. Keep up the interest and informative videos.
    83
  31. Blue, from Overly Sarcastic Productions, titled his History Summarized video on the history of Judaism the "Persistence of Judaism". With each new video you make the more I realize the deep meaning of that title.
    83
  32. Your content is incredible, It's inexplicable you have only 100 subs.
    82
  33. Such a fascinating period, you did a great job recounting it!
    82
  34. The face I made when you revealed Green's Hebrew name lmao, must've been how some of your commenters felt when you revealed Ulyanov as Lenin
    82
  35. Getting Jack Rackam to reprise his Talleyrand? Nice lol! Love hearing you feature other Youtubers for the various voiceovers.
    79
  36. Correcting your correction with a minor correction: Russia didn’t become a republic in March 1917. The haphazard provisional agreement following the February Revolution was that a new constituent assembly would eventually write a constitution for the Empire under which the tsar’s younger brother may or may not be invited to take the throne as figurehead monarch. Russia wasn’t declared a republic until several weeks before the October Revolution.
    77
  37. One important correction: Not all new recruits are sworn in at Masada. I know, because I served in the IDF and know many people who did and I attended a few swearing in ceremonies. Some recruits are, and I spent quite a bit of time trying to figure out which ones. But it seems to be that it is only used once in a while for some units. Units that I have found being sworn in there are caracal, nahal and possibly tanks, but only rarely, or perhaps even not at all anymore (well, none lately because of covid-19, but even before that). While researching this, I did find something interesting. A MK in the knesset was on record in a knesset meeting asking that the minister of defense ensure that despite the erosion of the myth of Masada's popularity that he ensures that military ceremonies will still happen there.
    75
  38. Ladino is fascinating, I made a video on it.. And it is rare that a language is able to keep itself in such an urban environment without a rural hinterland to draw from. A shame the Jewish Ladino speakers of Salonika suffered so badly later, gutting the core of the language and its demographic base.
    74
  39. "Every Friday night in the synagogue, the rabbi would recite a prayer for the emperor." The standard practice is to say this prayer during the morning service. Thank you for the great video!
    74
  40. 30:17 I did not come into this expecting a steamed hams reference but I am so glad to have received it
    73
  41. Your content is Legendary with a capital L. Keep ‘em coming. Educational content at its finest. A pleasure to be creating alongside you 😘
    71
  42. Truly amazing video! The 'Polish aspect' of it was presented very well. I'm glad you mentioned the service of Berek in the Polish Legions (BTW it's fortunate that he wasn't among the majority that got shipped off to Saint Domingue/Haiti in 1802). You even pronounced Kock right! And on the map you marked such details like the area around Krakow, where Prince Józef Poniatowski was haistaly rebuilding what was left from the army of the Duchy of Warsaw after the Russian campaign of 1812. A couple of (hopefully fun) additional facts: - Berek's son, Józef Berkowicz (aka Joseph Berkovitz or Berkowitz) fought under his command at Kock and survived. We potentially could hear about him in a future video. - Polish national epic, Pan Tadeusz by Adam Mickiewicz takes part in author's home parts - the former Grand Duchy of Lithuania, modern Belarus in the years 1811-1812. It presents Napoleon's invasion of the Russian Empire as a war of liberation (admittedly heavily romanticising it) and features an important and clearly positive Jewish character named Jankiel.
    71
  43. This guy would have so many frequent flyer miles today
    70
  44. I just did a short paper on Karaite Judaism and I almost lost it when Anan ben David was brought in
    70
  45. My great-grandfather, Victor Perez from Thessaloniki, served (and got injured) in the Zion Mule Corps. Interesting video!
    69
  46. Sam Aronow is a certified amba-compliant YouTuber.
    69
  47. last time I was this early, I was still studying in the Hebrew University, and that's because I finally got my letter of finishing studying for my degree in the Email yesterday. And throughout my studies all this years I would be watching your videos. how times fly.
    68
  48. I love how you changed the Gaon's hair color throughout the video as the years progressed. At one point when you mention "The American system" I was, like, oh right! This is after 1776! There's a US now! When are we going to cross the Atlantic and look and Jewish history in the Americas?
    68
  49. Last year was my first attempt at making latkes. I grated way too many potatoes and didn't cook them right away and therefore they went bluish brown. They looked awful but tasted great. Hope to do a better job this year!
    67
  50. As someone more familiar with Bundism and its path, I am very excited to see how things on this parallel stage of Jewish politics developed. I had family who fled in 1905 from Russia who were Bundists. While most of the family papers are with my aunt, a few are with me, framed on my bookshelf. Its not a part of family history most of us know about so I gave my self the task since ~2021 to look into what my great great grandfather was working towards. Love your videos and keep it up!
    66