Comments by "Deborah Freedman" (@deborahfreedman333) on "J-TV: Jewish Ideas. Global Relevance." channel.

  1. Why do so many left-wing Jews feel the need to kiss the ring of the Arab colonizers of Israel. If this director is so upset that the Arab occupiers of Gaza are dying in a war they started, he should be castigating Egypt, for not taking their own people back.
    151
  2. Which is over 3/4 of ancestral Jewish land, That is more than enough for the Arab colonizers.
    46
  3.  @stephendoherty981  Many are living in the US and Europe. They aren't really refugees from a country where they never lived, or for most, where none of their ancestors ever lived.
    37
  4. Free Kurdistan from Turkish and Arab colonization. We all saw how Kurds saved the Yazidi. It would be good to have two moral countries, Israel and Kurdistan, in the middle east.
    31
  5. I disagree with Dershowitz. The Arabs occupying Judea and Samaria (including eastern Jerusalem) invaded from Jordan (which comprises 78% of the ancient Jewish homeland). The Arabs occupying Gaza invaded from Egypt. Just as Germans who invaded Poland, were forced out of Poland, the Arab occupiers should be forced to return to whence they invaded. Israel is too small to give up any land for a 34th failed Arab state.
    28
  6. What Murray says is so true. I've never understood how people could excuse conquest, of another people's land, through the most heinous war crimes ever, could be considered "resistance". The Arabs have so much land, and so many resources, most stolen from the indigenous people's that had lived there. Why can't they abide one native people living on a quarter of their homeland?
    25
  7. And don't forget the oppressive dhimmi law imposed on Jews and Christians.
    21
  8. Such an amazing and rational conversation. I'm sure all this truth will not sit well with the haters, who love to believe lies. Well done. Thank you.
    20
  9.  @markwalker4485  Yes, Canada uses drip irrigation developed by Israel, so does the US. So what?
    19
  10.  @dipdopity  Their homeland is Arabia, which doesn't want them. They invaded Gaza from Egypt, which doesn't want them. Why should Israel have to put up with them, when they places they came from, won't.
    18
  11. The US should kick the UN out of NYC. New Yorkers would rejoice, as the hate the traffic jams, the UN cause. Also, most of the delegates are scofflaws, who commit petty crimes, because they have immunity.
    17
  12. The Arab colonizers didn't adopt the false name Palestinian until 1964, when the Egyptian, Arafat, told the Arabs occupying Judea and Samaria, if they called themselves by that name, people would forget they were recent invaders. Why else take on a name you can't pronounce.
    17
  13.  @AlShahariar-ex3gr  False. There were no muslims or christians, 3000 years ago, but there were Jews. And they lived in Greater Israel.
    17
  14. In 1964, the Egyptian, Arafat, trained in propaganda by the Soviets, created the previously nonexistent identity of "Palestinian". He told the Arabs, occupying Judea and Samaria, to start calling themselves "Palestinian", so that people would forget they were not from the land they had driven the Jews from, and occupied. When Putin calls the Russians, occupying Donbas, Donbasian, he does the same thing. Both are phony identities, invented to excuse colonization of others' land.
    16
  15.  @GenyneG  If you go to the commenter's channel, he has a whole series of history lectures. As for books, my favorites are old ones, before historical revisionism reared its ugly head, like Barbara Tuchman and Joan Peters.
    15
  16.  @bandanakabana4494  No, the native people, the Hebrews, called it Judea. You're wrong.
    15
  17. And secondly, most the Arabs living in Judea and Samaria came by their land by ethnically cleansing it of the Jews, when the Jordanian army invaded in 1948. And those in Gaza stole the land after the 1929 pogrom, genocide and ethnic cleansing. You'd think she'd be against such war crimes.
    14
  18. I never call the Arabs, illegally occupying Gaza, Judea and Samaria, "palestinians". They are Arab colonizers, and that is what I call them, or Balestinians. But then, I'm old enough to remember when Palestinian meant the native people, the Jews, before the Egyptian, Arafat. appropriated that term, so fools would forget they were recent invaders.
    13
  19. You heard that British interviewer, already spouting the racist and false Arab line. Where was the compassion for Jews, who had lived in cities in Tunisia, Iraq, and other Arab colonized countries, long before the Arab invasion. There were many more of them, than itinerant Arabs, who left Israel.
    13
  20.  @mariahewitt9787  Stop lying.
    13
  21.  @toosiyabrandt8676  Don't just read one chapter, read the whole thing. Then you'd know that chapter 53 is referring to the travails that the Jewish people will face, as we are facing now.
    12
  22. Most artifacts, with Hebrew and proto-Hebrew, are much older than 2,000 years. But, you're correct, there is no evidence of the palestinian state that never existed.
    12
  23.  @trevaudio  Pure deflection on your part.
    11
  24. The Arab homeland is Arabia. Nobody has expelled them from Arabia. But, numerous Jews were expelled from their homes in Tunisia, Yemen, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, and many other places in Africa and the Levant, where they had live long before the Arab invasion. Yet, even though there were more than twice as many more real Jewish refugees, than Arabs who falsely claim to having been expelled, no special UN agency was established to aid them.
    11
  25.  @everythingandmore5537  So the police should only do their job after a nap? If he's too tired to work, he shouldn't be out there, in uniform.
    11
  26. Actually, although their damned mosque is built on Har Habayit, the Temple Mount, it is kipat hasela, dome of the rock, that is built where the temple once stood. And that was originally a church, built by the Crusaders.
    11
  27.  @jahelation8658  Because last names had to be adopted when Jews were living in the diaspora, they didn't reflect our history, and mattered little. More interesting is that all of the Arab colonizers have names that demonstrate they are foreigners in Israel, with last names like al Masri (from Egypt).
    10
  28.  @isthisviolence  "genocide enablers" would describe anyone who supports the arab colonizers.
    10
  29. Jews built the city of Yithrib, now called Medina. Where are the calls to let Jews return to that city? Where are the calls to allow Jews to return to Iraq, to live unoppressed by the Arab colonizers? Where are the calls to their land to all the native peoples, of the Levant, Jews, Kurds, Yazidi, Copts, Maronites, etc., so that they can live unoppressed by the islamic invaders?
    10
  30.  @sunrise1975italia  Sadly, Lebanon, when it was a Christian country, was quite advanced and beautiful. But, Islamists invaded, and brought her back to the stone ages.
    10
  31.  @Faouzi-xl9ix  Only the Arab colonizers intentionally target civilians, never the IDF. Stop deflecting your evil deeds onto your victims.
    9
  32. One correction. the Arab colonizers didn't start using a Roman name, that doesn't really apply to them, until 1964. It's true that Arab armies invaded Israel, the minute she became a state, but they still just called themselves Arab, or by their clan name.
    9
  33.  @Faouzi-xl9ix  Do you live in opposite land, or are you just lying to defend a fellow muslim liar?
    9
  34. Problem is, the US justice department has decided that no lawsuits may be brought against UN personnel, because they have immunity for their war crimes.
    8
  35.  @FaniBarliya  Call the area Judea and Samaria, not by the foreign invaders' name.
    8
  36. I thought she was Persian. My bad.
    8
  37. The Arabs were already unjustly given 70% of Jewish land, to form Jordan. That is your two state solution, Jordan for the foreign Arab invaders, and lands west of the Jordan river for the indignous people, the Jews, with all the "palestinians" returned to Jordan and Egypt, from whence they invaded. As to apartheid, only the Arabs do that.
    8
  38.  mysteriousman8769  Keep repeating that lie, it still remains a lie. The people who are most closely related to Ashkenazi Jews are Mitzrachi Jews, and then Arabs, because we don't come from Europe, but from Israel.
    7
  39.  @keepussafeUSA  The elite minority, of Israel, supported the idea before. The Mitzrachi majority always knew it was a suicidal idea.
    7
  40. Free the Levant and Africa from all Arab colonizers and occupiers. Let the native people live in peace, unoppressed.
    7
  41.  @thegalaxylab  There is no "palestinian land", it is all Israel, even the parts occupied by Arab invaders. The rabbi is not ignorant, but you clearly are.
    6
  42.  @bandanakabana4494  In other words, according to Hamas.
    6
  43.  @Elaiyel  It isn't long standing policy. Stop lying and covering for that cackling incompetent.
    6
  44.  @compositestechbb9087  There aren't just biblical references, to the Jewish identity of Eretz Yisrael. Contemporaries, like the ancient Egyptians, Greeks, Medes and Romans recorded the fact of the Jewish presence in the land. (No mention of any Arabs there.) And wherever one digs, in Israel and Jordan, ancient relics, with Hebrew (not Arabic) are found.
    6
  45. When the Romans realized that monotheism was turning out to be stronger than paganism, and they chose to adopt this new Jewish sect, christianity, in a way that would allow them to maintain power, turning local demigods into saints, they couldn't cast themselves as the 'christ killers', so they scapegoated the Jews. And, both organized christianity and islam cast themselves as the replacement for Judaism, so saw the continuation of Jewish practice an insult. We have the writings of both Mohammed and Martin Luther. They thought the Jews would gladly accept their new religion, as it was mostly based upon Jewish stories, both oral and written, then became angry and vindictive when the Jews said, "no thanks". Jews rejected their ideas, so they hate the Jews. Hell hath no fury, like a false prophet scorned.
    6
  46. Shame that enough people didn't vote, to get rid of the current mayor of London, and his two tiered policing. Sadly, your next PM probably won't be Farage. But, hopefully the Labour government will be so weak, there will be new elections in a year or two. But, weren't the French elections encouraging?
    6
  47. Well said. A phobia is defined as an irrational fear. Considering the horrors seen in the colonized lands of the Levant and northern Africa, a fear of islam, at least arab muslims, is entirely rational.
    6
  48. Yes. Gush Katif must be restored.
    6
  49. He seems quite horrid, in every way, and quite evil.
    6
  50. The Balfour Declaration was the reason the British were given the Palestinian Mandate, with 3 provisos, 1. The land cannot be divided, 2. Any Jew will be allowed to return to any part their homeland, 3. Foreign Arabs will not be allowed to invade. The division of the land, to create TransJordan came later, and broke all three promises.
    6