General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About

Perry Howell
Ryan McBeth
comments

Comments by "Perry Howell" (@user-ue4rd1mf1v) on "Ryan McBeth" channel.

Previous
1
Next
...
All

Ryan good quick synopsis. Keep in mind gaza and judea (the'west bank'- as in the west bank of jordan, following their illegal capture and annexation of it in 48) were occupied by Egypt and Jordan until the second war in 67. Neither Egypt nor Jordan offered them a state and palestnian nationalism wasnt yet a thing- it was created by Arafat at the bequest and interest of the Soviet Union who groomed him for the purpose, begining in 1964. He launched rockets into Israel and generally acted terribly from Jordan even though no palestiniam arabs were there. (Apart from 'Israeli Arabs' who make up 1/5 the population of Israel). Arafat was kicked out of Jordan in 72 after attempting to assasinate King Hussein. The borders with Israel were completely open from 67 onward and 'palestinians' mixed freely with Israelis inside Israel. Israel closed the borders 40 years later and built the wall following an Arafat initiated bloodbath that killed 1000 Israelis. Arafat having yet again just refused the state Israel offered the palestinians. The palestinian 'refugees' are the only refugees on the planet to have inherited the designation 3 and 4 generations from the event. This is a political manipulation designed to keep them fighting and lend their story legitimacy, but its a fraud as the refugee system does not work that way- after korea there were 3.1 million refugees, and 10 years later none, as they were settled into places they fled. That is the way its always done, except in this case, and it harms only the Palestinians themselves, because holding onto this prevents them from settling and move forward. As is the normal standard. Like most things about the generally accepted Palestinian narrative, it is a manipulation designed to serve the interests of those pulling the strings- namely the Soviet Union, the Arab League, and Iran. Read "russian footprints" by defected Soviet General Ion Mihai Pacepa, who had a direct hand in the manipulation of the Palestinian people through Arafat as well as several other Arab nations tied to the Soviet sphere of influence. Its 7 pages long, and you can find it in 'the national review'. Thanks as ever Ryan.
40
 @johnnyspin6346 try to avoid them while freeing them from Hamas. That's what.
31
@JabranImran No. The target of the operation was stated as the Kibbutz. They intended to attack civilians, that was the intended target. The complete notes on the military were there to maximize the time they could spend on the citizens of the kibbutz. The proof is the 18 and 24 hour hostage and torture sessions they carried out on the women and children. If maximizing hostages were really the main goal they wouldn't have spend any time torturing and killing them in their own homes. They would have spent the time moving as many of them as possible back into Gaza until the military closed them down. These people are absolute animals.
21
 @johnnyspin6346 who started that? Who INTENDS to kill children and who is trying to save them? Grow up.
19
@johnnyspin6346 israel is unpopular with its neighbors because of religious and ethnic racism. No other reason.
17
 @mkyfinn73 There's no Fing genocide. Knock it off.
11
@jannegrey it's already at max radicalization or Oct 7 wouldn't have happened. There's nothing there to save.
11
@hansolowe19 I've only watched the first bit but I can tell you what's already clear. The misuse of the label 'aparthied' means at very least this group is involved not just in protest against Israel but of indoctrination against it. Combining that with community support programs is a commonly used and very cynical tactic among Islamist groups, including Hamas and Isis, among others.
10
@theichione1827 your sources are faulty and highly politicized. As an example, the founder of Human Rights Watch broke all ties with his organization and speaks against it, citing all kinds of problems and failures, one group of them specifically about its ridiculous treatment of Israel. Gaza has a blockade because 20 years ago a thousand Israelis died in yet another wave of uneccesary, Arafat initiated violence. Until then the borders had been wide open and Gazans moved freely in and out of Israel. (Despite constant suicide bombings etc by Soviet backed Arafat and his then small group of radicals. Mighty good of them) Gaza is also bordered with Egypt who also maintains a blockade, for the same reasons. I notice you (and all those like you) have nothing to say about that. Finally you fail to recognize a key issue- THE key issue, which is that the actual founding charter of the Gazan sovereign, Hamas, has as its stated goal the violent destruction of the state of Israel and the construction of an Islamist Republic on its ashes. None of your 'human rights' groups acknowledge this reality nor what it means for both Israelis and Palestinians alike. The acceptance of manipulated propeganda which was manufactured at the outset by the Soviets for that very purpose appears to blame. Lenience and apology for them only makes them more violent and aggressive. That IS where it's at.
8
 @pablosalazarsojo3877 HTS stands for "Free the Levant". Thryve already started talking about invading Israel in line with their Islamist religious "duty". Things don't look good..
7
@johnnyspin6346 no. So draining you are.
7
 @thomaslunde5014 nope there aren't plenty. There are very few.
7
@andromilk2634 you're brainwashed.
7
@SirAntoniousBlock quit watching Al Jazeera, Jewish Palestinians never stole anything. Share? Israel has offered them their own state 4 separate times. And the response was no every time coupled with terrible violence. Just like when they refused their own state from the UN the first time in 48. Jihadists gonna jihad. The question is why do people like you not bother looking into it, but instead keep making apologies for it.
6
 @wasimmtwari4769 no they aren't.
6
@glasrazuma933 different geography. They'd also have left the west bank anyway had Gaza not turned out as it did. They can't risk leaving now as it is because it existentially jeopardizes their security. Then theres the state Israel offered them 4 separate times, and the UN once. Israel has done all it possibly can. You don't understand the issues or the nature of this conflict at all.
6
 @meirm471 you are VERY smart. I hope you develop a channel. You understand this dynamic well abd describe it very effectively.
6
@captainchaoscow it was part of the original intention. They were there for 24 hours and made sure they would be uninterrupted with the civilians of the kibbutz for most of it. They took 'only' 120 to 150 hostages of the 5000 they encountered after all the time they gave themselves. (1300 dead, the rest injured.) They knew before they went what they'd be doing.
5
Ryan this issue is really not one of homeland. If it were actually about homeland their leadership would have accepted the partition in 47, or any of the 4 states Israel has offered them since. And, the charter of its sovereign leadership wouldn't call specifically for the violent destruction of the Jewish state as it literally does. (Sharing this with Hizbollah, who has 200k rockets aimed at Israel and just turned Lebanon into a failed state.) This is about Islamist Jihad, full stop, and the failure of the West to recognize that is one reason it has become so pernicious and entrenched. The 'homeland' argument is just one more part of a manufactured palestinan narrative designed to lend them credibility and legitimacy they do not (unfortunately) deserve. Giving it credibility only emboldens the jihadists who are directing the show. (Originally it was Jihad at the tip with Soviet geopolitical influence at the handle. Again, read "Russian footprints" by General Ion Mihai Pacepa.(defected) to get some of the picture. (It's in 'the national review') Thanks again Ryan.
5
@theichione1827 ideally so but that's not a given and in this case you are not correct. I wish it were the case but it's not. Just as many think the UN has credibility, In fact you'll find it largely does not- awareness of the reality has not caught up with its branding. Why don't you try looking into the example I gave as a starting point? If this issue is important enough to weigh in on, certainly both the Israelis and no less the Palestinians who suffer for the same reason deserve no less. Politics and information war has invaded everything. The affixation 'human rights group' has become just another meaningless casualty of an information war. Very unfortunately. Why don't you also check out the speech given at the UN by the son of the founder of Hamas? It's only 2 minutes long so not too big an ask. He grew up in it, and his bona fides are legit. You'll find it on unwatch.org. Good luck to you.
5
@glasrazuma933 yeah I know about Judea and Samaria. I call it that mostly. Israel offered well over 90% of the requested territory to the Palestinians on at least 2 occasions. In one of the offers there was going to be land swaps to account for the existing communities in Judea. It's actually crazy, given Israel's geography, to offer a state in those borders. Especually to such radicalized people. But they did, numerous times. Despite their attachment to the land. Peace is what they want. They gave back the Sinai for it. You don't know that? How do you not know that? (And if not- if that is the level of your awareness on this topic, why do you feel it's important to have an opinion about it?)
5
 @Stinger913 you are indoctrinated. Please step back from the issue. Nobody needs to have an opinion and opinions aren't benign.
5
@faisaldmdmalupco the Romans persecuted Jesus. Jesus himself was a Jew. In any case why does it matter either way??
5
@MEstylz descriminate blaming. Either the IDF made a mistake, which happens, or someone was in the car who shouldn't have been. That also happens. The IDF is <2:1 civilian to combatant in this war. This is UNPRECEDENTED. You need to redirect your hatred where it belongs
4
@octagonPerfectionist listen. Go outside for a walk. Don't waste your life following the crowd toward fetishized hatred of an entire nation as a pastime. It's a dead end and it hurts everyone - most of all the people you think you're helping . Don't waste your life on hate. You have no idea what you're talking about and if you hate already you never will. Let it go. This situation doesn't need more noise and heat. And there are better ways to spend your life.
4
@spaceman9599 the Mufti was a rabid and brutal anti-Semite. Not just a pragmatic strategist.
4
This is on track to become one of your most popular videos. The fixation, outrage, and hyperfocus on Israel by so many Jihadis/accomplices tells us a lot about whats actually happening there, its a sort of illustrative case in point.
4
I'm sorry to say I just saw reports that HTS has been abusing Christians and Kurds. Theyve also sworn to drag Syria into war on Israel. I'm sorry to inform you of this. I'd hoped for a better day..
4
It's so draining with people like you. YES the IDF follows the Geneva convention. If you're actually interested and want to learn instead of just hating and throwing shade, look up reports and interviews about the reports pertaining o the previous Gaza flare up, produced by the High Level Military Group. They are a group of generals from a dozen countries of 3 stars or higher who go to conflicts around the world to make assessments and try to learn lessons from them. Their report on the previous Gaza crisis concluded that Israel takes exceptional care to protect civilians- "more so then any other army in the world and possibly in the history of armed conflict". Look them up and read the reports. And please stop being so flippant about saying things like that. Theres been an information jihad waged against Israel for 60 years beginning with Soviet state backing. That's likely why you feel the disdain you expressed to begin with. It's certainly why hating Israel is such an irrational yet common social contagion. It gets people killed, so please don't contribute to it.
4
 @sketchyvasectomy no it isn't. Israel has zero responsibility for them. Any more than Japan pr hamas has responsibility for you.
4
@puckluck2357 the situation with Americans in Iraq is not close. And a plan that has no chance is no better than what we have at moment.
4
@mathiasmajslott9363 theres no genocide, no matter who says there is.
4
@kylehenline3245 the annexing of Judea (renamed ' the west bank' by Jordan- it's hard to argue Jews shouldn't be in Judea) and the cleansing of Jews from there was not recognized as legitimate by the international community. It was held until 67 when Israel again had to defend itself against several armies at once. Jordan refused to repatriate it's people after losing the war. (who now began calling themselves "Palestinians" as per the efforts of Arafat.) Israel allowed the inhabitants to stay and offered them open access to Israel, and they and Israelis got along well for decades. ( despite steady violence from Arafat and a small number of militants.) They finally closed the borders after Arafat initiated yet another wave of suicide bombings, this one resulting in 1000 deaths. (And just after saying no yet again to the state he was offered. (That also was always the plan. Keep offering peace and coming to the table and then keep saying no. You can read about the discussions to enact this strategy between him and his Soviet bosses, I'm trying to remember where.)) This has never been anything but a jihadist conflict, stoked initially by the Soviet Union for its own ends. It never mattered what Israel did or didn't do. It still doesnt- it has nothing to do with it.
4
@BB-mr3vy Netanyahu himself has had to authorize many strikes. Save your disdain, it's not deserved. This is either a tragedy plain and simple or else someone was with that convoy that really shouldn't have been.
3
 @robertaylor9218 Al Jezeera? Are you serious?
3
@johnjones_1501 Israel's people are free. Many are athiest- most in fact, and it's a secular state. Muslims in the region are not commonly athiest. And in most of their countries there's very serious trouble for insulting the Koran. The Palestinians have been led by jihadis since the 1960s, they are extremely radicalized as a population now. There really is no desire for coexistence within their society, they mostly want it all with Israel destroyed. And if any leader came along trying to campaign on the basis of true peace and acceptance he'd be killed long before he had the chance to try. That's the reality. The talk of two states when seriously considered is always understood to be a stopgap on the way to taking the whole place. But mostly it's not considered at all - it's been refused over and over while the violence never ends.
3
@alto5593 I feel very sorry for Lebanese Christians and Druze, at the mercy of outside forces as Hizbollah builds it's military into Lebanese civilian infrastructure and guts their economy. You suffer greatly from a genuine neighborhood parasite, and you have my sincerest sympathy. I wish you and your family all the best.
3
@GARDENER42 and that's assuming people are attempting to be honest about it. Which... Especially when it comes to this subject.
3
@theichione1827 you don't ever read what people suggest to you it seems. Ryan himself instructed you that Amnesty International is not reliable, and I pointed you to the founder of one of your stated sources who has discredited his former company. You are committed to hatred, pure and simple.
3
@theichione1827 continuing to use them to support a faulty claim after you've been reliably informed that their credibility is an issue suggests you refuse to consider anything but the antagonistic attitude and mentality you arrived with. In other words, hatred, yes. "🙃"
3
@rushfortacos lol.
3
I agree with your assessment of the impact of this conduct. Though the fact that you refer to their behaviour with the term "resistance" suggests you don't understand the driver of this conflict, but are familiar with the propeganda.
3
 @Mandems973 Violence motivated by Arab leadership long predates the occupation. And Gaza wasnt occupied the last 18 years but the violence only escalated.
3
@Joesolo13 the person hacking me won't let me tell you why they destroy some Palestinians homes. I invite you to discover the reason, it's not at all flattering to the Palestinians. (which is why my hacker won't let me post it) As for Gaza, it's blockaded at Egyot too. Why do you suppose that is? It wasn't always blockaded. And the borders once weren't even closed, for about 30 years they were open. What do you suppose might be behind this increasing isolation? Hint: look at Egypts blockaded border, and consider the events of Oct 7. The borders were once wide open into Israel. So what do you think might be constantly changing that would bring these things about?
3
@meirm471 you do it well. You are perceptive and effective at unwinding the knots. I'm burned out. I'm no longer effective at it, and fighting the onslaught has changed me after all the years. I no longer have the tolerance or grace for people and it's clear given the money spent on disinformation they deserve it- I'm just fed up. Long may you contend with it, we need millions of you. All the best to you, keep up the good work.
3
@ravenward626 reasons are never moot, even in death. Take care.
3
 @noobienoobie6358 Israel could deal with it alone.
3
@specialingu no it isn't. And the palestinians themselves are responsible for the blockade, of which Egypt also participates..
3
@johngalt5072 yes absolutely, and thank you for your post. What I meant by that was that he was engaged by the Soviets and the KGB to carry out their agenda, Romania then being something of a Soviet satellite. (I don't recall if they were ever directly swallowed by the Soviet Union. I'll refresh memory.) Really as thousands now march here in support of Hamas, it's very comforting to recieve your post and realize that a minority of people at least still do exist that can see this for what it is. Sorry to not recall the specifics of your homeland, I'll go now and refresh my memory. All the best to you.
3
@taylorc2542 you couldn't possibly be more brainwashed.
3

Previous
1
Next
...
All