Comments by "FiveLiver" (@FiveLiver) on "History Debunked" channel.

  1. Fairy stories? Germany not only began the war but also the bombing war with Warsaw and Rotterdam - Harris' statement is correct, not a falsehood. The Germans 'sewed the wind', even if RAF bombers did hit them first. What is the point you are trying to make here, that the Germans were the plucky ones facing a mighty foe? The fact that Britain had an Empire made it weaker not stronger, as those far flung places had to be defended and were a drain on resources. I've never heard of this 'David against the mighty Goliath' narrative you purvey - it was simply the fact that we had not listened to Churchill and were playing catch up in an arms race with Germany, especially as so much materiel had been lost in France. Britain did fight alone, surrounded by a ring of U-Boats and commerce surface raiders, such as Bismarck, Tirpitz, Graf Spee and Scharnhorst anxious to join in - Italy also had a navy, as did the Vichy regime, which could have been used against us. The Battle of the Atlantic is something you ought to look into as your grasp of military and strategic affairs appears to be weak. The Polish and Czech pilots who fought in the Battle of Britain didn't bring their own Spitfires and ground crew with them you know, and were grateful that someone was there to enable them to take the fight to the Nazis - they would have had no misgivings about sending RAF bombers over Germany to give them a taste of their own medicine. I would much rather our people had positive 'myths' in their heads than have no conception of what their forebears achieved in what is still living memory.
    5
  2. Anti-racists are just antiwhiteists, they are looking for any excuse to denigrate and erase white people and the culture they created.
    5
  3. The forgotten slaves of Scotland.
    5
  4. 'Far-right' like 'white supremacist' just means white person defending themselves.
    5
  5. Looking at the past to predict the future only goes so far. These are unprecedented times. Reform UK are the beneficiary of the groundswell of disgust at the uniparty that has gone globalist, Net Zero and woke, with no approval of the populace. It is not specifically about Farage, even though he probably thinks it is.
    5
  6. Sorry, but why would those who voted for Brexit feel 'silly' - 'betrayed' is the word you are looking for.
    5
  7. Put them in camps and save money.
    5
  8.  @insidiousantimason2025  Simon, who is David Irving?
    5
  9. No Christianity preaches love thy neighbour; Islam has no such instruction. Quite the contrary.
    5
  10. No doubt it will be put in every school library in the country.
    5
  11. 'Having a little punch up with the Ivans', sounds like a line from Hancock's Half Hour. Get serious mate, they are fighting for their national survival. it's nothing to do with British domestic policies. Russia IS an enemy - its not been 'worked up' - the invasion of Ukraine PROVES it. To say it has 'nothing to do with us' is totally absurd on many levels. It won't be settled until the 'Ivans' are driven off the land they have invaded and are committing war crimes on.
    5
  12. What on earth are you blithering about? Totally incoherent drivel.
    5
  13. Without lies, woke dies.
    5
  14. The SWP are antiwhite.
    5
  15. Simon's understanding of Islam is improving nicely!
    5
  16. He is an American Coptic Christian who speaks Arabic and knows the subject well. he has a website which documents the Islamic persecution of Christians world wide.
    5
  17. Diversity is an antiwhite concept, and antiwhites believe a white man like you has no right to draw attention to it let alone criticise it.
    5
  18. This is just standard Russian propaganda. The idea that the invasion of Ukraine was caused by events in the 1990s is childish. Russia was always a threat to its neighbours in Europe. Russia's greatest threat came from the far east and Islam.
    5
  19. Discuss white erasure with No White Guilt, Jason Kohne.
    5
  20. There is a little bit of self-hate coming from old Simon methinks.
    5
  21. Fascists will Fash! It's to be expected.
    5
  22. "as long as it’s part of their religion it’s ok" Sharia crimes are now not crimes. I think we need Reform.
    5
  23. Islam is not a religion. It is a political ideology. If the Qur'an was written today it would be banned for incitement. Where Islam meets the rest of the world there is violence. From c 1830s till 1979 our culture and self-belief was strong and asserted itself over Islam and kept it quiet. Now we stoke it up again with our weakness and lack of self-confidence. Today they are outside Hindu temples, tomorrow it will be churches, council buildings, police stations and schools, unless we get leaders who are prepared to assert the superiority of our culture and stop apologising for our great history.
    5
  24. Simon are you a pacifist? Were you ever in CND? What about Marxism? Did you sell copies of the Socialist Worker?
    5
  25. Islam is always on the march, whatever the makeup of the players, Arabs, Turks, Saracens, Berbers, Umayyads, Abbasids, Fatimids, Seljuks, Timurids, Mamelukes, etc etc are either fighting the unbeliever or each other.
    5
  26. Nobody was 'invited'. We were never asked, we never gave permission.
    5
  27. Yes the resurgence of Islam today is the fault of the west in the way opening a lion's cage tends to be life threatening to anyone near the lion after it emerges. Metaphorically, we have forgotten that the lion is dangerous, and will act in a way that is in its nature. Bluntly, colonialism kept Islam in its cage, but now while we reproach ourselves for our racism, white supremacy and Eurocentricity, Muslims do what Muslims do, which is to assert 'Allah is greater than you (Allahu Akbar), your religion and your culture', and act accordingly, as we shrink from opposing it. Its time to close that cage once again.
    5
  28. 'Irrational' dislikes of other groups? In Islam dislike for other groups is mandatory. You really ought to know that.
    5
  29. Almost right. Of course the police go easy on the 'palestinian' protesters because they are Muslim, because Iszlam is political; it's just as much a political ideology as it is a religion. The police are heavy on so called right wing or patriotic protests because they see it as part of their anti-racist programme. They are anti-racist and antiwhite.
    5
  30. Yes No White Guilt talks about the differing bio-spirits of different people groups.
    5
  31. ANTI-RACISM = ANTI-WHITE
    5
  32. I hope the penny has dropped, but his first encounter with Islam would have been the beguiling lies from the lips of someone he met in the middle east - that will be difficult for him to shake off.
    5
  33. 2:00 'The Holocaust is a particular interest of mine...it's something of a thing in my family.' In all your books on the subject, did you come across any evidence for a certain number of victims, and a certain mode of dispatch which is equally seared into our conscience? As a debunker I'm sure you scoured the pages for just such material.
    5
  34. 12:06 Simon you accept the UN definition of genocide as requiring: 'intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a... group', and 'deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction, in whole or part', but feel justified in stating that Kitchener committed genocide, without proving that there was deliberate intent or calculation on his part to bring about the destruction of the Boers. The fact that most of the group in the concentration camps survived them proves there was no intention of genocide, so 'most people' would be wrong to believe the charge.
    5
  35. The British reaction to this war isn't about 'phoney morality', it's about making it clear to a land grabbing dictator, who is threatening nuclear war, that we oppose him. You keep imagining that war is about 'displaying anguish and grief' about the suffering of other countries; it is not, it's about stopping that suffering coming to our door. Remember the words of Churchill: “An appeaser is one who feeds a crocodile—hoping it will eat him last.” Your pacifist attitudes need to be stated plainly, instead of hiding behind accusations of hypocrisy. Sargon demonstrates his utter uselessness in printing this drivel.
    5
  36. The difference is ISLAM - any more questions?
    5
  37. "An attack on civilisation itself" - yes, white civilisation. That's why it's allowed and cultivated by the antiwhite elite.
    5
  38. Israel is always covered for the reason that it gives the BBC and Channel 4 an opportunity to attack it and put it in the wrong. Your belief in "The mad obsession with Ukraine" says more about you than it does about the media. Turkey and the Kurds, or Saudi in Yemen is Islamic internecine strife, it's being going on since the start of Islam. Examining it might produce more unpalatable facts about this war-like belief system, which is not politically correct.
    5
  39. It started in America.
    5
  40. They flourished because the early 'Islamic world' was in fact not Islamic - most of those populations were Christian, Jewish and Zoroastrian - Islamic decline happened when those populations became dhimmified. We were lucky in that the people of Spain and the Balkans did not, as a whole, succumb.
    5
  41. The Bolshie students of the 1960s are now in power, their 'change in society' has been achieved, and they don't want it reversing. Free speech and anti-censorship were good for them then, now its bad. The white Establishment of the old regime was brought down by do gooders and human rights fanatics who now have installed an anti-white Establishment to crack the whip over us. This is their social justice, their equity,
    5
  42. And Jesus is NOT Isa.
    5
  43. Why are the Ukraine refugees likely to be here for good? They are real refugees, real refugees go home.
    5
  44. Islam + psychosis = crime
    5
  45. Of course an English youth causing the death of a Syrian old man in Syria would not be able to claim 'mitigating factors', and would have had a life sentence if he escaped mob justice. We need racial sovereignty returning to our people by either denying citizenship to foreigners or having degrees of citizenship. That Syrian youth was privileged over the Englishman he killed and he knew it.
    5
  46. The solution is easy: kick them out of NATO, they are not our allies. If they are supposedly needed as a counterpoint to Russia, they will be that anyway they always have been. Unfortunately, part of Turkey is in Europe: the hinterland of Constantinople.
    5
  47. What has Tommy ever written or said that is not correct? Or do you mean politically correct?
    5
  48.  @jhonfrancis7.0  Trump was voted in and so was Brexit. Do, don't doom.
    5
  49. 'We' aren't ready to abandon our traditions, it's the antiwhites in authority who think its the morally correct thing to do.
    5
  50. Spain survived as Christian where North Africa and Turkey did not was because the northern coast protected by mountains never fell, and also there was Frankia to escape to or get aid from. Likewise the Balkans had Austria and Poland - Russia - to aid their liberation.
    5