Comments by "Ying Yang" (@yingyang1008) on "TIKhistory" channel.

  1.  @Calbeck  You blaming WWI on them now as well? Not a question of sympathy, it's a question of getting away from this good vs. evil propaganda BS and having an adult discussion about history
    34
  2. Was wanting more land for your people really so insane?
    32
  3. Judged by the standards of the day - desiring more land and believing in the supremacy of your people was pretty much par for the course As for hating Stalin and being petrified of Communism - that seems pretty reasonable to me
    27
  4. The enigma codes were cracked at the start of the war - we knew everything the Germans were doing and saying
    26
  5. TIK knows what side his bread is buttered on
    25
  6.  @extrahistory8956  we're lucky to have had such a reliable ally as Stalin to tell us what happened
    18
  7.  @Xoruam  all countries are in debt, usually to the exact same people
    16
  8. Truth is the enemy of the winners of that war
    15
  9.  @schibleh531  Apparently it wasn't important enough to be worthy of mention in Churchill's 1,200 page memoir on WWII And it was never mentioned during the war at all (in the media, etc.) as a motivating force - bit weird
    15
  10.  @extrahistory8956  Interesting that all of those camps were behind the Iron Curtain
    15
  11. Try converting to Judaism - good luck
    15
  12.  @stephenroney2366  Yeah, but that wasn't an extermination camp - and no one ever claimed it was Those camps were only 'liberated' by Stalin
    13
  13. I don't think that was a death camp, they were only liberated by Soviet troops
    12
  14.  @petriew2018  He was greeted as a liberator by the Slavic peoples who had been enslaved by Stalin (eg Ukraine)
    11
  15. Just to remind you all that they threw David Irving in jail as an old man for what he said - should we not be outraged about that more than some mistakes or lies he may or may not have made in some of his books? We are lied to everyday by politicians, academics, historians, etc.....
    11
  16. Well what we know beyond any doubt is that the 'official' historians lie for a living and that the winners write the history books So, of course be skeptical about Irving, but he should still be read as some of his work is remarkable His book on Dresden was regarded as a classic worldwide - it was only when he went 'off message' about Hitler that his career was destroyed I have no doubt that his books contain some mistakes (perhaps even deliberate) - but our newspapers and official historians lie to us all the time We live in a world of mass lies and propaganda - best to have an open mind
    10
  17. . mainstream historians lie for money, in comparison Irving is a fountain of truth
    8
  18.  @penguzpingas5833  history is written by the winners
    7
  19.  @ccdsds3221  loooool
    7
  20.  @bakters  Stalin attacked Poland at the same time and enslaved it for 50 years, performing attrocities like the katyn forest massacre I'd say that proves that WWII had nothing to do with protecting Poland Germany made repeated attempts to avoid war with the British empire, none of which were reported in the media Similarly, none of Stalin's attrocities were reported either, he was called uncle Joe In fact the katyn forest massacre was blamed on Germany for decades, despite it being well known that it was Stalins doing
    7
  21. Why did he no also make a film on the millions killed by Stalin? Because he would have been thrown in a gulag
    6
  22. a few hundred people died in Coventry - Britain deliberately murdered around half a million Germans by bombing
    6
  23. It was the UK and France that declared war on Germany
    6
  24.  @jurgnobs1308  WWII was a disaster for Europe and completely unnecessary Unfortunately it's illegal to discuss the event you say I deny in my country, and also on this platform, so can't talk about it
    6
  25.  @Necromancer_88  The Bolsheviks engaged in the biggest human slaughter in world history, then created a despicable gulag police state - the ethnic make up of most of its leaders (especially NKVD) is there for all to see They then took over and slaved dozens of satellite nations before WWII, and then took over half of Europe, sending it into a dark age it is still only just recovering from 80 years later Only when facing defeat from Germany did they start to play the patriotic propaganda card I'm not defending Germany, but let's not forget just how despicable the Bolshevik regime and Stalin the Georgian were
    6
  26. 400 deaths vs. 40,000 deaths
    6
  27.  @bakters  don't think Germany had any interest in western Europe to tell you the truth, until France and the UK declared war on them The last thing they wanted was another two front war The east is obviously different though, Hitler had a beef with Stalin obviously
    6
  28. Oh the horror of being forced to control a country's banking and media industries
    6
  29.  @norbitcleaverhook5040  they were greeted as liberators because of the horrors committed by Stalin To not mention this makes it propaganda
    5
  30.  @mateuszplatt200  The USSR killed tens of millions of people before the war even started and put untold millions more in gulags
    5
  31. If you are happy to see historians in prison, you're on the wrong side Just saying
    5
  32.  @TeaParty1776  lol, yeah whatever Your average German wasn't reading philosophy They're the best soldiers in Europe, the best engineers, among the best artists, and tend to be polite and very hard working Downsides would be them being kinda boring and less independent, more likely to follow rules, etc.... The number of advancements that came from Germany is mind blowing
    5
  33.  @johnstirling6597  yeah, basically the winners write the history books
    5
  34. If deliberately creating a firestorm in a city in order to incinerate as many civilians as possible isn't a war crime - then what is?
    5
  35. Patton realized too late that we fought the wrong country
    5
  36. It's a simple fact that the wealthiest capitalists in the world at that time were Jewish and that Marx and the leaders behind the Soviet Communist revolution were Jewish Could just be a coincidence of course, but a fact is a fact
    5
  37. How come you didn't rise up against stalin?
    5
  38. TIK doesn't care about facts bro - just clicks
    5
  39. Literally every single policy he introduced was socialist in nature - he was one of the most left wing politicians in all history, he basically invented the welfare state Left wing politicians from all around Europe visited him to witness his socialist reforms, all of which were incredibly popular among working people He was in power for a long time before the war and to claim what he did wasn't left wing in nature is to deliberately deny reality for propaganda purposes
    4
  40. Imagine allying with Stalin, letting him take over half of Europe - then pretending the war had something to do with fighting evil lol
    4
  41.  @norbitcleaverhook5040  If he made such a film, nothing would have happened to him If he made a film about the tens of millions of Russians killed by Stalin he would have been gulagged or executed
    4
  42.  @Pyotyrpyotyrpyotyr  I assume you agree it was at least millions?
    4
  43.  @johnhough4445  There weren't many innocent parties in that war The British Empire had slaughtered and enslaved hundreds of millions of people and was suppressing multiple struggles for democracy around the world The USSR had slaughtered and enslaved tens of millions of people, and invaded dozens of countries before the war even started and invaded Poland at the same time as Germany - yet was supposedly an ally The US was timing its entry just right to win the day and replace Britain as the new global imperial power Everything we learn is mostly nonsense
    4
  44.  @dennisweidner288  Lol, take a step back and start learning some real history - not this propaganda garbage from the visdtors If we cared about democracy and saving innocent people, do you really think we would have allied with Stalin and allowed him to enslave half of Europe Just to remind you, Stalin had already killed tens of millions of people and created a hideous police state full of gulags before the war even started
    4
  45.  @dennisweidner288  First of all you say the 'forces of democracy' - And yet Britain was an imperialist power that had the world's largest ever empire, throughout which democracy was mostly prohibited While the USSR was a hideous police state dictatorship that had killed tens of millions of its own citizens Then you say that the Nazis were the 'primary threat' - primary threat to who? Germany repeatedly pleaded Britain and France not to declare war and to be allies in the war against Communism In 1939, the USSR had already killed tens of millions of people, whereas Germany had essentially killed no one The USSR also had a very clear expansionist policy and had already taken over numerous small countries As soon as you stop reading the official propaganda, this all becomes clear
    4
  46.  @dennisweidner288  Hitler had no desire for war with Britain or France- he literally begged for peace His beef was with Russia, we let the USSR enslave half of Europe and we have the gall to call it victory for freedom
    4
  47.  @moniker2804  yes I agree My point is that we never seem to mention the tens of millions killed by Stalin And the fact that we gave him half of Europe
    4
  48.  @penguzpingas5833  no I'm not I'm pointing out that Stalin killed tens of millions of Slavs and sent millions more to the gulags And that we gave him half of Europe and called it a victory for democracy and freedom
    4
  49. It's illegal in many countries to question certain aspects of WWII - that alone should make people think
    4
  50. You find it difficult to view children innocently? Maybe you had a sadistic childhood as part of a particularly broken family?
    4