Comments by "adamnesico" (@adamnesico) on "Whatifalthist" channel.

  1.  @Munchausenification  we are already in an age of exploration and science.
    118
  2.  @popkhorne5372  UE is just a copy o USA.
    59
  3. Many of those of course not, buy dont say any. He said lot of stuff, by simple chance he should acert some.
    48
  4.  @merothehero6359  Israel represents the mirror in wich muslims can watch themselves. They have given the muslims the same choice they gave: Dimma or ruin. That muslims reject their own offer is the best proof of how unfair they are.
    41
  5. Corn farm in Mars? You read too much NASA propaganda.
    34
  6. Hi. I agree that alGazali is unfairly accused of hate science, when he was himself a scientist too. Then why do you think the intelectual reform of Nizam al Mulk and alGazali had such a terrible efect in scientific development? Maybe was that alGazali said that if science cant proof the existence of Allah, then is a lesser discipline? What do you think?
    26
  7. Its true many others were evil, but Columbus was evil. When he just found the taino and described them as friendly and good, he immediately was planning to enslave them.
    25
  8. Cant you find a better boss and serve him? A bad boss doesnt deserve a good vassal, even chinese knows that.
    20
  9. I heard it isnt even the biggest problem of the country, that more people are dying because of the fulani attacks vs the other religions farmers due to overpopulation. And that president doesnt care because he is a fulani.
    19
  10. He clearly suposes that in this timeline, being more succesful, philistines would have a better economy and more sea trade, so when assyrians would arrive, many of them would flee by sea as phoenycians did.
    13
  11. Your country totally hates kids. In mine nobody calls the cops for noisy kids.
    13
  12. ¿? I read that chaldeans wer semitic. The ones who came from zagros were the cassites, be4 the chaldeans. Cassite Babylon was invaded by Elam, after that chaldeans invaded.
    12
  13. Meh, according to that comparison, samurais were nazis.
    12
  14. Industrian revolution was triggered by german mining. That thing of english steam engine is the own english national myth.
    12
  15. Many says USA is too a lot like Carthage. I can see the paralels. A video analysing them would be interesting, altgough wont be a long one like this.
    11
  16.  @ehsankabir9621  Indoeuropeans never mixed with austronesians. Celts were another indoeuropean people.
    10
  17.  @chrisamon4551  not, german mining far predated steam engines. There was a catalogue of industrial machines even be4 the steam engine was invented in England. So, the revolution started be4 the engine.
    10
  18. No, but the left is becoming full of crazy people like he signaled and this crap is becoming institutionalized.
    9
  19.  @Phaenes  Maybe not prosperous for mankind, but yes for american culture. USa is destroying itslef, when it dies, China will colonize it. Iw wont be USa anymore, will be a China colony.
    9
  20. Even in most of medieval Europe serfs werent sold.
    9
  21. We can see it too with democrst anti family politics and propaganda.
    9
  22. Hehehe, yeah, i call the southern half of Nigeria AfroEngland.
    9
  23.  @Terranallias18  Because he thinks they are totally insane and refuses to accept them removing the other males rights and most of things he values? He isn't defined just by his sexuality.
    9
  24. They were facing food problems? Form what ive read, their agriculture was really advanced.
    8
  25. So, I wouldnt say that the thing is decadents defeat barbarians, more like Empires defeat barbarians.
    7
  26.  AileDiablo  another wahabi apologist. What arabs did was achieved too by others. Macedonians, romans, mexicas, mogols... started too as minor players.
    7
  27. By the time of Muhammad judaism was succesfully spreading between arabs. So I guess Islam still would exist in this timeline, more similar to judaism. A jewish caliphate? XDXD I love alternate history.
    7
  28.  @harveybeaver9731  Have good marks in those exams may not mean that the person is honest, simply that they know the expected answers.
    6
  29.  @SamSepiolTheHeretic  barbarians made the roman empire fall and ended the muslim golden age, didn’t revitalized them.
    6
  30.  AileDiablo  No, the problem is that you as muslim don’t have an objective view and you are forced to think that you are better than the rest. Hehehhehe Wrongs: -Mogols made war in diferent fronts, they attacked the jurchens, the kwarazmisns and more at the same time. Napoleon too fought against coalitions of empires. The combined efforts of 3 of the 5 biggest empires were needed for defeat him, and if not for the russian campaign in wich winter defeated him, he would have died succesful. So don’t say the only ones. -No idea? Guy, you are forgetting generations of pillaging and invade. Zaynab and Zenobia already prooved how adept they were centuries previously. -Although enemy numerical superiority is undoubtable, it wasnt so much, arabs greatly exagerate it, and isn’t so surprising, sweds routinely defeated armies twice or three times bigger be4 the great northern war. Arabs had a similar quality advantage. Alexander faced in Issos and Gaugamela armies bigger than any army the muslims faced, neither romans or persians were in shape for muster so much. Arabs were unable of defeat the inhabitants of the plains, the nubians or the franks. The mamluks did. So its evident wich were the best warriors.
    6
  31.  @oneing4206  yes, with a fraction of the power that umar had, zaynab would have conquered eastern rome if not for aurelianus. That showed that an united araby would achieve far more. Im speaking of militar conquests, not faith spreading. Budda made buddhism for certain time the most spread religion without impose it though colonialism. He was able of convince people without violence. Unlike you. And your hate to anyone who thinks diferent made you ignored by the world until the discovery of petroleum.
    6
  32. Great advice. But. That doesn’t serve me. I was always lonely, so i chose lonely hobbies. The only sharing hobby that comes to my mind is sex, i love it, but ive already experienced its not easy to find a hooker that u can trust and engage. Ive already found one who seems loyal to her word and caring, but she already has 3 sons.
    6
  33.  @Trapset_Agent  Ukraine, USA, UK, North Korea, URSS, Australia, Norway, Switzerland, Italy, France... all of them westernnized societys with feminism, nothing to explain there, we already know those. Why you didnt mentioned Vietnam? We dont know if the scythian fighting women were a defensive militia or true warriors, but I dont think they were soldiers. So, in the end the only non western female soldiers presented are the agoji. Why you didnt included the army of Nzinga? Or the female guard of the mauryas? They were the indian version of the agoji.
    6
  34. That world mixed race could be still n northamerica.
    6
  35. Its a video that would be probably censored. It can’t be said there is just one african civ. Bantu And ethiopians look quite different, both deserve a separate video.
    5
  36. Well, its true that elamites were wiped as civilisation by the assyrians. But as culture, they still survived as peasants as quechua and aztecs still survive today. Elamite language was still spoken until the arab conquest, and Susa kept existing until the mongols.
    5
  37. 28:22 Guy, that map really lacks the genocide of the siberyans at the hands of the cossacks. And no, scientific method was invented by muslims. Probably the greeks too invented it, but we have no proof.
    5
  38. As statistic its not surprising. Those decadent societys were usually big empires. Although in decay in many ways, they still had an advantage in numbers, weapons, logistics, fortress, and many other things compared with the free men. But yeah, thats why I say anarchism is useless, fails in the military.
    5
  39. In wich cesspool of country do you live? Those cyphers don’t describe the one where i live.
    5
  40.  AileDiablo  and do you undertand that previous arabs achieved things in far numerical disadvantage? Queen Zaynab of palmyra invaded the romans, just defeated by the powerful aurelianus. Queen Mawiya of the tanukhs became a pain in the ass fir eastern Rome and forced them to the peace that she desired. That clearly showed that an united Araby would have a huge potential. And too, Rome got great wealth from red sea commerce. Once muslims got yemen, that comerce benefited them. You know history?
    5
  41.  @anotherguycalled6253  A muslim said something that dimma is take responsability. Its close to the muslim dimma. How are they gonna vote to a govern they dont have citizenship because they reject it? The arab israelis can vote, a pair of years ago, for first time, an arab party was part of the ruling coalition. Is sad that the coalition didnt lasted :(
    5
  42. Reason is simply that there was no genocide in muslim conquest. Natives remained.
    5
  43. Most of Canada is barren land.
    5
  44. What problem do you have?
    5
  45. He totally spotted the date of invasion of Ukraine.
    5
  46. An still not as sexist as mithraism o Islam, there were strong queens through Europe history.
    5
  47. Female soldiers????? In how many societys.
    5
  48. There was no maya empire, just city states.
    4
  49. I don’t know if good or bad, but sure, nobody likes to be colonized.
    4
  50. Water of irrigation is a breeding ground for mosquitos and many parasitic worms.
    4