Comments by "Sim Ko" (@simko8665) on "AP Archive" channel.

@user-or1rm1ol3q Are you insane? Winning the war? What achievements they gained? One, please.
1
@user-or1rm1ol3q And you call it a victory? If the Israelis were defeated in the battles, then how come they managed to cross the Sues canal and to advance toward Cairo destroying the Egyptian second and third Divisions? How come they manage to throw the Egyptian Army back to the opposite side of the canal and gain back Sinai?
1
@user-or1rm1ol3q Is that your best respond? Aren't you ashamed of this "victory"? Israel was fighting on two fronts at the same time. In the Golan Heights, the Syrians managed to break through Israel's lines, but at the end of the war, the Israeli army reached almost all the way to Damascus. In Sinai, the Egyptian army succeeded in crossing the canal with 650,000 soldiers and 2,200 tanks. 423 Israeli soldiers with six tanks fought against them for 160 km, and at the end of the war there was not a single Egyptian soldier in Sinai, while the Israeli army reached a distance of 80 km from Cairo. This is not shown in the war museum in Cairo. In your opinion, why is this major defeat not shown there? The Israeli victory was much greater than in the Six Day War. These battles and the Israeli victory are taught today in military schools all over the world.
1
@user-or1rm1ol3q Read a book and try to bark under another tree.
1
@shmedddddoo Where did you take this nonsense? Can't you Arabs admit the great defeat of both of your Armies? You can see it it the October museum in Cairo. It shows only the first six hours of the "victory". The war didn't stop then. Why don't they show the rest of it? Why didn't they show how the Israelis crossed the Suez Canal and putting a siege on the 3rd Egyptian Division? It's like saying that the Germans in WW2 invaded Russia in 1941 and won. The war then went on and at the end of it the Russians arrived in Germany and took Berlin. War is made of battles. You cannot win one of it and say we won. Israel stopped 80 K'm from Cairo and 40 K'm from Damascus. Now will you say it was an Arab victory?
1
@mohammedhagag8841 Why can't they?
1
@Shmeddoo First, you cannot rely on un testified sources out of Israel. You can rely on Israeli sources. There was no one case in the history of Israel that Israel lied about the numbers. till now here are about 4,850 wounded Israeli soldiers and 504 killed soldiers. there un known numbers of Hamas wounded Terrorists, but there are about 7,860 killed Terrorists. As for the "Victories" in the October 1973 war, It's true for the first two weeks of it. My brother was there and he had to replace six disable Tanks. Egyptian Armies and crossed the Suez Canal and was forced by the US to stop its gallop 70 Miles from Cairo and put these two Armies under Siege. My brother told me that they pitied the starving soldiers and threw to them Oranges.
1
@arnaldogonzalez1678 Not of pity. They got it back only after signing a peace treaty with Israel, about five years after being defeated in the October war.
1
@Egyptian_comrade They won the war? How come that Israel found itself on the other side of the Suez canal only 60 Miles from Cairo. How come the Egyptians begged for cease fire when their two main Armyias were souronded and put in siege and almost die of hunger and thirt? Their success crossing the Canal doesn't mean winning the war. Israel did.
1
@AlphaBravoCharlie777 Israel did. How do think they manage to cross the Canal and stop only 60 Miles from Cairo after the Egyptians brgged for a cease fire?
1
What bacame of them, where Israel bury them?
1
It's not too late to get rid of Hezbollah the Parasite which sucks the blood of Lebanon.
1
😂😂🤣🤣
1
Then how come that Israel had it back in no time and even gotwardin toward Cairo. Only the cryings of the poor Egyptian made the US and Russians made the IDF stop only 60 Mills from Cairo. An did yes, it was one of the greatest wars. 650,000 Egyptian soldiers and 2,000 Tanks against 432 Israeli soldiers with 6 Tanks. Yes, a great victory. Aren't you ashem even calling it a war?
1
@osamamousa7157 1. Israel had no intention to take Cairo. What would they do with it? Crossing the cannal and stopping 100 k'm from Cairo and getting back Sinai was more thean enough for them. All what Israel wanted is to push out Egypt from Sinai and then to sign a peace treaty with Egypt and give them back Sinai which was hold as a bargain card. 2. Egypt was the one which begged on its knee for a cease fire after their two Armias which were under siege with no food and no water. Also Russia and the USA put Israel under pressure to stop fighting. 3.I visited the 1973 war museum. Very nice, but why show only the beginning of the war and not what was the end of it and how the Egyptians were defeated. It's like Germany was showing how succesfull they were by taking over all Europe and not show the end of it.
1
@osamakhalil5366 The numbers of the lot of Israel seems to be right except the number of the aircrfts. 102 Israeli aircrafts are the right number. Israel didn't posses the highier number, even today. Now, what about the Egyptian Army? I gave you some numbers, what about the others according the least you made for the Israeli Army?
1
@osamakhalil5366 Your first two comments are one big lie or you are not aware of the real numbers. Here are the real numbers(wikipedia): dead soldiers Israel 2,700, Egypt-11,500. Wounded Israel 7,250, Egypt 25,000. Captures - Israel 300, Egypt 8,300. As for the weapon, you told about the US weapon but you "forgot" to mention the Russian weapon. One thing you have to know. The Israeli soldier is much better than the Egyptian soldier. The Israli soldiers fought for his home and the Egyptian one has no interest in it. That's the reason why Israel won the war even one of his hands were tied behind his back.
1
And how the IDF found themselves on the Egyptian side only 60 Milles from Cairo.
1
@mando73204 Why do you have to show your ignorance in public, and tell me to read a book? Inventing a new history? Israel started the war 70 Miles from Cairo, which means when they already ceossed the Cannal and advaced to Cairo. Israel wasn't trapped, on the contrary, Israel put two Egyptian Armias under siege letting them die od thirst and starvation. They two events made Egypt to ask for a cease fire on their knees. Egyptwasn't given back any Inch of Sinai to Egypt for six years after President Sadat arrived in Israel for peace talks. Only in 1982 all sinai was given back to Egypt. Read a book, if you can. BTW. The "victory" Museum of war in Cairo shows only the first days of the war. Why don't they show how the Egyptian Army was defeated and how Israel crossed the Cannal on their way to Cairo? Do you have an answer for it?
1
I don't know how the Egyptians crossed the canal in the beginning of the war, but I know how Israel did it and in a short time they took the Egyptian's side of the canal, putting two Egyptians Armias under siege. I also know that Israel stopped advancing toward Cairo in about 60 Miles to it after the Egyptians begged for cease fire. I also know that the Egyptians built a Museum in order to show how great was their "victory". They just forgot to mention that they were defited at the end of it and gained nothing. Then Sinai desert remained in the hands of Israelfor more than six years till the Egyptian president begged for a peace treaty. What a great victory is was....😂😂
1
@saadtaleb1113 Nobody denied that it didn't belong to Egypt. Sinai was held a bargain card by Israel in order to sign a peace treaty with Egypt. All the yeas since 1967 till 1977, Egypt refuses to it till President Sadat, Allah ierahmo, arrived in Israel and the rest is written in the pages of history. As for stealing land, you have much to keeo up to see how wrong you are. Read a book and get wiser.
1
@mohammadtalalqureshi4464 Can you tell me please, how apartheid is expressed in Israel?
1
Israel didn't lounch strikes on Lebanon. Israel did it on Hezbollah. Are heart broken???
1
@nemaproblema6879 I do not believe him reading the Quraan. If he did, he could have see that its written that the land of Israel belongs to the Sons of Israel. I asked that question other Muslims but I didn't get an answer. I asked them also if the believe that Allah knows what he is doing, if so then why they resist his wish to establish Israel? I got the same answer.
1
Typical Arab reaction.
1
@Badranltd אני לא מבין מה הקשר של הכתבה הזאת למה שאתה כתבת??
1
@JunkYard-omarnour You can tell yourself stories as much as you want. The facts are telling another story. You're right in one argument. In 1971 Sadat offered Israel to sit down for peace talks. Israel agreed to give him back Sinai which was held by Israel as a item for negotiation with Egypt for a peace agreement. It didn't work out since Sadat demanded also Israel to go back to its borders with Jordan and Syria before 1967 and to find a solution for the refugees of 1948. For Israel it was a Suicidal move. Thats the reason for Sadat to start war against Israel which came true only six years later when Sadat arrived in Israel.
1