Comments by "Brad Williams" (@samsabastian5560) on "Biographics" channel.

  1. Aaron but its full of mythological nonsense.
    1
  2. Robert Sever, this video follows the mythological nonsense that distorts the truth. It is a very poor presentation and not factual at all.
    1
  3. 243WW Nope. It was government versus a serous criminal outbreak led by Ned Kelly.
    1
  4. Anne Scholey Why not? They were the ones who were stealing most of the poor settlers horses.
    1
  5. That Guy, but that movie is full of myths and fiction. Not worth watching at all.
    1
  6. Andrew Ned Kelly did not say those words on the gallows. Another Kelly myth.
    1
  7. PrinzPaul. Not quite true. His father was in Jerilderie at the time and got caught up in the robbery, but John Monash was with his mother in Melbourne at the time.
    1
  8. rocket both photos are of Ned
    1
  9.  @Threeredbells  Not sure where you are, but at the 4.40 mark or thereabouts that photo is of Ned.
    1
  10.  @Threeredbells  No debate at all. That photo was taken the day after he was released from prison for feloniously receiving a horse, and it is of Ned.
    1
  11. ckbs Only bogans and low lives would ever consider a murderer, thief, who held up banks, took hostages, stood over people he had stolen from and lied throughout his life could ever consider Kelly to be a hero.
    1
  12. kombi k So who was Ned Kelly wronged by? There is not a shred of evidence anywhere that the police or the government wronged him. He was just a full blown low life criminal.
    1
  13. beauson Get your facts straight sport. Red Kelly stole 2 pigs and immediately took them to market to sell, not to feed his family. It was the second time he was caught, so he got transported for 7 years.
    1
  14. DeltaFrost117 But it's almost totally fiction from top to bottom.
    1
  15. Josh. Now that IS a stupid comment.
    1
  16. Malcolm - hero's do not murder, hold up banks, rob from poor settlers, use stand over tactics, take hostages or lie. Your comment is nonsense.
    1
  17.  @jamesstevens8009  That fiction was investigated by Dr. Stuart Dawson PhD. He found that Monash was in Melbourne at the time. Cannot put my hands on the research at this time, but it is clear that Monash was not in Jerilderie when Ned Kelly was there. Monash was a scamp and often told lies in fun.
    1
  18.  @joshtowns5630  It did not happen.
    1
  19.  @joshtowns5630  If necessary, I will email the author and put it up online myself.
    1
  20. Caper. here That movie was a load of rubbish from top to bottom. It was a box office flop.
    1
  21. Ned Kelly. Well didn't Ned Kelly murder 3 Irish police officers. At the time Kelly was hanged, the Premier of Victoria was IRISH. So tell us Ned, where were the British?
    1
  22. Mark Kelly. Actually 2 Catholic and 1 was Protestant.
    1
  23. Biorichina Ned Kelly is NOT a national hero. He was just a serious criminal.
    1
  24.  @jlord9638  Do you know what decadent means? This is what is means. "characterised by or reflecting a state of moral or cultural decline". Does that fit you J Lord?
    1
  25.  @jacolitethepumpkin765  You haven't got a clue what you are talking about. Stealing more than 280 horses from poor settlers was 'good', as you claim? Your comment is delusional.
    1
  26. DarkRonnie RUBBISH. Extra Credits presentation is made up rubbish through and through. Tis garbage.
    1
  27. Calvin That fight may well be a load of fiction.
    1
  28.  @tyronemalone4158  Only people who are ignorant of the facts would ever consider that a murderer was a hero. You are way off track with that comment, Tyrone.
    1
  29.  @jornavyr2459  Not so. I suspect the historians you are referring to are the likes of Ian Jones, who wrote a load of codswallop regarding a very serious criminal He hid his real criminal and thuggish behaviour to present a very distorted picture and denied you the truth. Try reading The Kelly Gang Unmasked by Ian MacFarlane which is extremely well researched and very accurate. Clearly you have been badly mislead by the fiction you have been reading.
    1
  30. deborah barry Jesse James tortured and murdered a number of people.
    1
  31. Australia - so let's hear your reasons as to why a murderer, bank robber, hostage taker, thief, stand over thug and liar is a hero?
    1
  32.  @australiaisnotrealjustaska4379  Well those people are ignorant aren't they, as they do not know the truth.
    1
  33. MsMp15 Excellent? It is fiction through and through. Kelly was a monster, you are right with that comment.
    1
  34. Daniel Pity most of what is presented is fiction.
    1
  35.  @idonhaveanyideawhattocallm1472  I am not telling readers that. I am correcting the mythological rubbish presented on sites like this that paint a picture of Ned Kelly being downtrodden and abused by authorities and police. The facts are that Ned Kelly was just a serious criminal, and behaved as such. He was a stand over thug, murderer, who held up banks, took hostages and threatened them with death, stole from poor settlers often sending them bankrupt, and he was a prolific liar.
    1
  36.  @captainrisky6561  It's English spelling, not just Australian spelling.
    1
  37.  @theurbangoose4126  Educated people still use gaol.
    1
  38. SaltGamer78 Why would you say that? Ned Kelly never uttered those words on the gallows. It was made up fiction.
    1
  39.  @mickypoole9226  Ian Jones wrote a book of complete and total fiction. Lies, fiction and made up nonsense throughout.
    1
  40.  @mickypoole9226  Well, maybe you should learn some facts and start telling truths, instead of fairy tales.
    1
  41.  @shebbs1  Hero is not a word to describe a murderer, hostage taker, who held up banks, was a stand over man, a thief and a liar.
    1
  42. Tiana Wang What a stupid comment.
    1
  43. John Smith That's nice to know, seeing the Royal Commission found the police acted with integrity regarding the Kelly's criminal behaviours.
    1
  44. zember9 Your comment is nonsense. Kelly walked out the back of Ann Jones hotel as he was severely wounded. There was a total of 30 police at Glenrowan. Hardly an army.
    1
  45.  @zember9  There were 4 members of the Kelly gang, not one.
    1
  46.  @zember9  Byrne was shot at about 5am., so up to that time 3 murderers left to shoot at the police from Ann Jones Inn. Ned Kelly had walked straight out the back of the hotel and went for about 150 metres before he lay down behind a log and remained there until about 7.15am at dawn, when he rose and approached the police from behind. He had been seriously wounded twice in his left arm and through his right foot, and was losing a lot of blood. Why was Ned Kelly at war with the police? The police were properly paying attention to him as he bragged to having stolen 280 horses. Was it reasonable for police to be paying attention to him for that thieving?
    1
  47. Wendigo 82% of the police in Victoria were Irish. They kept their towns safe from the scourge of the Kelly's and the Greta Mob. Here is what the Royal Commission found regarding the rank and file police. "It may also be mentioned that the charge of persecution of the family by the members of the police force has been frequently urged in extenuation of the crimes of the outlaws; but, after careful examination, your Commissioners have arrived at the conclusion that the police, in their dealings with the Kelly's and their relations, were simply desirous of discharging their duty conscientiously; and that no evidence has been adduced to support the allegation that either the outlaws or their friends were subjected to persecution or unnecessary annoyance at the hands of the police." There are the facts for all to see Wendigo. Your research is sadly wrong.
    1
  48. Phil Ned Kelly was never dealt a rough hand. In fact in his early teens police tried to put him on the right track, even giving him money to go to a job they organised for him. He discarded the job and turned to a life of crime all of his own volition.
    1
  49. Y K A very uninformed comment on your part. Ned Kelly's father was rightly charged with having a calf skin in his possession. He was fined 25 pounds. There is no written record of Red Kelly ever being in a gaol in Victoria. Red Kelly drank himself to death. He did that all on his own Y K, nothing to do with the police. Ned Kelly was born into a criminal family, and he is first mentioned as a thief when he was 5 years old. The only reason Ned Kelly opposed the police was because they were rightly interfering in trying to stop him thieving other poor settlers only horse. Your understanding of Ned Kelly is sadly lacking.
    1
  50.  @HULK-HOGAN1  Your inference that the police were to blame for Kelly turning to crime is fiction. You are out of touch with the true story.
    1