Comments by "Sandy Tatham" (@sandytatham3592) on "Yishai Fleisher" channel.

  1. Mosab is a man with huge moral courage🙏. I also liked the way he said “Islamic” and not the usual obfuscating ‘Islamist’. Islam ☪️ only stays in power by trying to silence those who critically analyse the doctrine and its origins. Mosab exposes the dark truth of the ideology. I want the Arabs of Gaza, Judea and Samaria to live with dignity and love, not violence and hate…💙🇮🇱
    1
  2. Israel has two million Arab citizens!!! It took a few decades, but most of them are no longer hostile.
    1
  3.  @jchan9761 : A devout Muslim would deem it treasonous to be a citizen of the Jewish state. I believe that most Arabs in East Jerusalem who have a pathway to citizenship have declined, though this is now changing. The Palestinian Arabs want ALL of the land, from the river to the sea. And that's a separate issue to the LIE that Israel is an 'apartheid state'.
    1
  4. You are shining a light for other #indigenous groups in MENA to reclaim their ancestral homeland by rolling back Arab imperialism. Stay strong...🇮🇱🙏💙
    1
  5. I'm Australian and very sad to see the new direction of our current Labour government. The #ANZACs fought in the Great War to help liberate the Holy Land from the Islamic Ottoman Caliphate. The Allies won that war in 1918, a war they didn't start, and the Ottoman Empire ceded its Middle East land to the victors. The Hejazi Arabs fought with British Lawrence of Arabia and they were granted control in 99% of the carved-up land. Today their countries are Syria, Iraq, Lebanon, Saudi Arabia and Jordan. The Zionists also fought on the side of the Allies and they were granted the legal right to reconstitute their ancestral homeland 'from the river the sea'. Israel is a tiny <1% of the carved-up Ottoman land and the #indigenous Jewish people share their country with 21% Arabs, mostly Muslims, who have equal rights under the law and freedom of religion. I stand with Israel...🙏🇮🇱💙
    1
  6. The Jews no longer need to live as lower-class #dhimmis under the Muslims. And stop with the nonsense of “peace in Palestine for 100s of years”. The subjugated Jews and Christians had fewer rights so what else could they do but try and keep the peace? The Jewish state of Israel is the start of the #rollback of Arab imperialism… 🙏🇮🇱💙
    1
  7. You might like to check out what the Grand Imam of Al-Azhar University, Cairo, said about Hamas. Al-Azhar is the most highly-regarded centre of learning for Sunni Muslims worldwide. Al-Azhar's initial response to the sadistic attacks of October 7 was that it “salutes with absolute pride the resistance efforts of the Palestinian people.” Al-Azhar also sought to “strengthen the proud Palestinian people who have breathed spirit and faith into us and restored us to life.” Four days later, al-Tayeb spoke with Haniyeh, who sought to enlist the support of al-Azhar to end “Israeli aggression in Gaza.” Al-Tayeb responded: “Our hearts are with you. We are grieving over the slaughter [in Gaza]”. Does that sound like Hamas Muslims have deviated from Islam?
    1
  8. The majority of the world supports Israel. Hamas are to blame for this war and the tragic deaths. And Egypt is complicit by not permitting for a "secured" humanitarian camp to be set up inside Sinai where babies, children, mothers of small children, pregnant women, the sick and the elderly could be cared for in safety. Why is an Islamic country keeping their Muslim brethren TRAPPED in a war zone? It's because the Gazan people are just pawns for Muslims to use in their hatred for Israel. But Israel's not going anywhere... 🇮🇱🙏💙
    1
  9. Israel has a legal claim to the Holy Land after the Ottoman Caliphate was DEFEATED in 1918. The indigenous Jews fought with the British in WWI and in return for their support were promised the right to reconstitute their ancestral homeland. This pledge was adopted unanimously by the League of Nations in 1922. Finally we might see them take control of Judea and Samaria, and I suspect this will eventually extend to Gaza as well. The Arabs can live autonomously in their cities, but not be given full citizenship until they can pledge allegiance to the Jewish state of Israel.
    1
  10. David Friedman's #OneJewishState proposal is to give the Arab occupants of Judea and Samaria equal CIVIL rights, and relative autonomy in their own areas, but not NATIONAL voting rights. There would probably be a pathway to full citizenship for the next generation but they would have to pledge allegiance to the Jewish state of Israel. The birthrate of Jewish Israeli citizens is as high, or higher, than that of the Arabs, and every year more and more Jews take up citizenship of Israel.
    1
  11. In 1918 the Ottoman Turks and the Arabs of the Palestine region were defeated by the Allies. Wars have consequences. The Ottoman Caliphate land was ceded to the Allies as part of the surrender agreement. In 1922 the League of Nations acknowledged the connection of the indigenous Jews to the Holy Land. As per the Balfour Declaration, the Jewish people were given the legal right to reconstitute their ancestral homeland in the British Mandate for Palestine. The League of Nations also granted the Hejazi Arabs self-determination in 99% of the Ottoman Middle East land, today's Syria, Iraq, Lebanon, Saudi Arabia and Jordan. Israel is a tiny 1% of the Ottoman land, and one-fifth of Israel citizens are Arabs who have equal rights and freedom of religion.
    1
  12. The Arabs have to EARN citizenship, as happens in every other country around the world. There must be at least eight years to prove they can coexist with Israelis. How many Arabs do you think would ever pledge allegiance to the Jewish state of Israel? Until then, equal civil rights for them all is a great idea.
    1
  13. The Arabs of Palestine don't have a legal right to a state (they rejected the 1947 partition plan), and they've now #forfeited any moral right.
    1
  14. Yishai is quite clear that all Palestinians who want to be residents of Israel, who respect Jewish rights, who are loyal and lovers of the land of Israel, can keep their identity whatever that is. It's all about respect. Last year I met a man from Gaza in my hotel in Downtown Cairo. He was attempting to resettle his whole family in Turkiye because life under Hamas was impossible. He said his first choice would be to live in Israel because he loves the land and the people. I'm sure there are plenty of Palestinians who have a similar outlook.
    1
  15. They also need to be taught about the defeat of the Ottoman Turks and the Arabs of Palestine in 1918. Out of the collapse of the Ottoman Empire, the Hejazi Arabs were granted self-determination in 99% of the carved-up Ottoman land (Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Saudi Arabia and Jordan). Israel is a tiny 1% and one-fifth of its citizens are Arabs whose families accepted life in the Jewish state in 1948.
    1
  16. Jews always lived as subjugated #dhimmis in Muslim lands. Now the Jewish people are back in control in their ancestral land…🙏🇮🇱💙
    1
  17. ​ @brianbeag : I agree that the demographics are very delicately balanced. A few thoughts: - Extending sovereignty over Judea and Samaria and offering the Arabs "permanent residence" status in Israel would send a strong message that there will NOT be an independent Palestinian state, nor would the so-called 'right of return' hold any credibility, hence many Arabs would look for assistance to be resettled elsewhere. A large proportion of devout Muslims could never agree to coexisting in the Jewish state of Israel. - The fertility rate of Arabs is probably not higher than the Jewish people today. Times of Israel said in January 2024: "Between 2018 and 2022, the average fertility rate for Jews dropped from 3.17 to 3.03 children per woman. Among Muslim and Christian women, the decline was greater — from 3.20 to 2.91 among Muslims, and from 2.06 to 1.68 among Christians." - Israel would control the pathway to full citizenship. An increasing number of Druze in the Golan Heights and Arabs in East Jerusalem do want to pursue this, but mechanisms can be in place to ensure that only those who pledge allegiance to the Jewish state would be accepted, and it can take years to be processed. - I've read that the permanent population of Arabs in the 'West Bank' is probably over-estimated, with the purpose of strengthening the political case for 'Palestine' and to boost numbers to receive more foreign aid. If Arabs live outside Israel for a period of time, they should lose their "residence visa" and only be allowed to return on tourist visas. And any who have citizenship of another country would not be offered "residence" status. - As for your comment on "new Palestinian leadership to emerge", have you watched Yishai's video entitled "SOLVED! It Could Be Over Tomorrow if this happens"? The last minute and a half are classic, relating to the Arab honour-shame culture. With the right Jewish leadership I believe this one Jewish state plan could come to fruition.
    1
  18. The Holy Land was #liberated in 1918 by people like my New Zealand grandfather who fought the Ottoman Turks and the Arabs of Palestine in WWI. Please do NOT give up any of the land that belongs to Israel and thus make his death seem meaningless (he's buried in the British Military Cemetery near Jerusalem). I know the British later reneged on their Balfour Declaration pledge and the League of Nations vote for the Jewish people to reconstitute their ancestral homeland, but it happened regardless (by the grace of G-d) and it will only get better if people like Yishai and Malkah keep educating everyone on the realities of #jihad...🇮🇱🙏💙
    1
  19. What was the alternative to alleviating the dire humanitarian situation under Hamas? Israel should extend sovereignty over all of the disputed territories and give the Arabs "residence status" with equal civil rights, relative autonomy, and a travel document. That way you keep your enemies close.
    1
  20.  @angelahorsburgh9954  : 🙏
    1
  21. ​ @joesilver4376 : Exactly. This is what I've been saying too! Egypt could easily have permitted the international community to set up a 'secured' humanitarian camp just inside Sinai for babies, children, mothers of small children, pregnant women, the very sick and elderly to be cared for there. Hardly anyone talks about this, so thank you. The main complaint by Egyptians to me is that Israel won't let them return to Gaza, and maybe there is some risk. But keeping vulnerable people TRAPPED in a war zone is despicable, and against international law. The Egyptians seem to support the war strategy of Hamas which is to use the human death toll as negative publicity for Israel. A large number of Gazans are from Egyptian families who moved to Gaza during the 1948-1967 Egyptian occupation, so it's doubly awful that they want to use them as cannon-fodder in this way...🙄
    1
  22. It's hardly a "greater Israel" when they are just talking about the land 'from the river to the sea'. That land was promised to the #indigenous Jewish people after the DEFEAT of the Ottoman Turks and Arabs of Palestine in 1918. The British were 'trustees' until the Jewish state of Israel could be founded. The Arabs were given Jordan, plus Syria, Iraq, Lebanon, and Saudi Arabia. Israel's population is one-fifth Arabs!!! How is any of this evil? Wars have consequences. The Arabs of Palestine have been on the LOSING side in each war beginning with WWI which the Germans-Ottomans lost. If they are still hostile to Israel, they should be assisted to resettle elsewhere.
    1
  23. Thank you, Prime Minister Netanyahu! Israel, and God, will win…🙏🇮🇱💙
    1
  24. Why does the Qur'an have such horrible rules for females? Why does the 'god' of Islam in Qur'an 65:4 permit marriage-sex-divorce of #prepubescent girls? Why are multiple wives still permitted for one man at the same time? Why is beating a wife is permitted even if the husband only fears her disobedience? Why is no consent for sex required in marriage? These rules are not "so deep". Islam has just codified 7th century Bedouin Arab culture. A person who is not literate can still hold political power as he has people close to him who write down what he says. As for "Islam the fastest growing religion in the world", birth rates in the Muslim world are decreasing, and access to the internet and social media is opening the eyes of those born into a Muslim family. The only reason many people stay in Islam is because they can be severely punished if they are critical of the ideology, or want to leave it, due to strict blasphemy and apostasy laws. Thankfully the #AbrahamAccords are changing the face of the Middle East.
    1
  25. DNA is not a criteria for belonging to an “indigenous” group. It’s all about the connection to the unique culture and practices of that group. People can convert into a group.
    1
  26.  @PersonOfNote : His name is Basel @basel.pal95 , and his little daughter's name is Lulu. I think some Israeli leaders are very aware of the Islamic ideology and its goals. But many Israelis look at things through 'western eyes' and don't want to believe that the goal of fundamentalist Muslims is to retake what has been taken from them, as in Quran verse 2:191 "drive them out from where they drove you out.". Gazans are heavily influenced by the Muslim Brotherhood which was set up in Cairo after the Ottoman Caliphate was defeated by the Allied Powers in 1918. The goal of the Muslim Brotherhood is to restore the Caliphate. H*amas states that it wants Jerusalem as the capital of their restored Caliphate. I believe that it should be made clear to the people of Gaza that the indigenous Jewish people are back in control in their ancestral homeland, but that the Gazans can live in peace with the Jewish people if they choose to...🇮🇱🙏💙
    1
  27. Islam has a bastardised version of Jesus. Can you count that?
    1
  28. ​ @australiaprisonisland9156 : Considering that there's no hard evidence for the existence of either the prophet, or the Quran in the first 100 years after Islam began, I'm not going to put much credibility on your scriptures. Islam also has its own version of Abraham, and a very different concept of God to that in Judaism and Christianity. Islam seems to be an #imposter religion, a reaction to Christianity. I'm not a Christian but I believe that our planet has free will. If people need to learn things through personal sacrifice, or the example of sacrifice by someone else, then so be it. Our Creator-God has given ALL of us free will in order to evolve in consciousness, to expand in love and compassion. PS: I've got nothing to do with YouTube removing your comments. It happens a lot to me too.
    1
  29.  @australiaprisonisland9156 : My reply got deleted too! I'll try again later.
    1
  30.  @australiaprisonisland9156 : Considering that there's no hard evidence of the existence of either the prophet of Islam or the Quran in the first 100 years after Islam began, I'm not going to put much credibility on your scriptures. Islam also has its own made-up version of Abraham, and a very different concept of God to that in Judaism and Christianity. Islam seems to be an #imposter religion, a reaction to Christianity.
    1
  31.  @australiaprisonisland9156 : Our planet Earth has free will. People learn things through personal sacrifice, or through the example of sacrifice by Jesus or some other high value person. Our Creator-God has given us all free will in order to evolve in consciousness, and expand in love and compassion. I don't think Islam permits free thinking, or free will, so I guess it's hard for you to understand this?
    1
  32. ​ @mannymannyson6720 : You've just made my point that Islam is an INVENTED religion. There's no hard evidence of any of the sources of Islam. It's all copied, then changed, from the scriptures of Judaism and Christianity. It has an invented 'prophet'. The purpose of this new ideology of Islam was to unite the Arabs to invade and conquer the Christian and Jewish lands. And it was very successful until the last Islamic Caliphate collapsed about 100 years ago. Now Islam is losing power. The growing trend is for Muslims to leave Islam, and my guess is that one day it will disappear.
    1
  33.  @mannymannyson6720 : You've just made my point that Islam is an INVENTED religion. There's no hard evidence of any of the sources of Islam. It's all copied and changed, from the scriptures of Judaism and Christianity. It has an invented 'prophet'. The purpose of this new ideology of Islam was to unite the Arabs to invade and conquer the Christian and Jewish lands. And it was very successful until the last Islamic Caliphate collapsed about 100 years ago. Now Islam is losing power. The growing trend is for Muslims to leave Islam, and my guess is that one day it will disappear.
    1
  34.  @mannymannyson6720 : You've just made my point that Islam is an INVENTED religion. There's no hard evidence of any of the sources of Islam. It's mostly copied from the scriptures of Judaism and Christianity, then changed a little. It also has an invented 'prophet', similar to Jesus.
    1
  35. ​ @mannymannyson6720 : The purpose of Islam was to unite the Arabs to invade and conquer the Christian and Jewish lands. It was very successful until the last Islamic Caliphate collapsed about 100 years ago. Now Islam is losing power, and there is a growing trend for Muslims to leave Islam due to their access to information through social media.
    1
  36. Why is that so bad? A good proportion of them are from Egypt!!! They have families in Egypt. Egypt gets plenty of funding. It could be paid to absorb them.
    1
  37.  @MENSA.lady2 : That's a question I'm trying to get my Egyptian friends to answer. Maybe it was similar to Jordan, which gave citizenship to the 'Palestinian' Arabs when they were occupying the West Bank after 1948. Then Jordan revoked their citizenship. Many Egyptians were economic migrants to Gaza while Egypt was also in occupation of that strip of land, and maybe their citizenship was also revoked when Israel kicked Egypt out? Or maybe their IDs expired long ago and they didn't think to renew them? Or maybe Egypt just won't let anyone back through the Rafah border crossing even if they have documents? It's a mystery.  I'm in Cairo now and the people here are adamant that no-one from Gaza is coming out even if they are Egyptian citizens, or if they have family in Egypt. They don't care about the people of Gaza. They just hate Israel. They want Israel to deal with the Gaza problem.
    1
  38. The #indigenous Jews have a legal claim for all of the land from the Jordan River to the sea. It was a grant from the League of Nations in 1922, which incorporated the Balfour Agreement of 1917. The Zionist Jews fought with the British in WWI and, in return for their support, they were promised the chance to reconstitute their ancestral homeland. The Arabs of Palestine fought on the LOSING side, with the Ottoman Turks. Losers of a war that they started don't get to choose. It's time the rest of the world stopped appeasing the so-called Palestinians.
    1
  39. I'm very confused. I've just watched Caroline Glick post a short MEMRI video of Erdogan saying he wants to take down the evil Western civilisation and replace it with "the divine and humane love-centred civilisation of the East". Erdogan can't be both a friend to the West and an Islamic #jihadist hater of our values, can it?🙄
    1
  40. Exactly: "Islam has everything to do with Islam ism..." I hope Rabbi Shmuley gets properly educated about Islam from the right sources. Maybe Yishai could be the one to educate him?
    1
  41. Well said...🙏 I hope the Israeli government has learned that it's not a good policy to keep placating people who have a dangerous ideology. I'm in touch with a very nice young engineer in Gaza and he tells me this... "Religion is not represented by Hamas and others. Hamas has made many mistakes and I am not one of its supporters, and this caused me troubles earlier, but I am speaking to you as a Palestinian whose land has been occupied and it is the duty of every person here to defend their land." "It seems that you have forgotten that Palestine is our land and every individual is required to defend it, and this is not only a national duty, but a religious and ideological duty that every Muslim in every country must have."
    1
  42.  @yuzuruotonashi659  : I'm not sure what your point is. Egypt also blockaded the border with Gaza. The problem is security. Hamas turned out to be an Islamic jihadist terrorist government. They turned Gaza into the largest terror base the world has ever seen!!! If Gaza is "dependent on Israel for water, electricity, telecommunications, and other utilities" it is because their leaders personally made billions from the global community funding of Gaza, and because they diverted the rest of the funds to build their terrorist infrastructure. They are reaping what they sowed.
    1
  43. Exatly. The best that the Arabs of the disputed territories can hope for now is to be offered "permanent residence" with equal civil rights in #OneJewishState as proposed by former Ambassador David Friedman. Israel must extend sovereignty over Judea and Samaria, and eventually over Gaza too...💙🇮🇱🙏
    1
  44. I support "indigenous rights" so I'm happy that the Jewish people have reconstituted their ancestral homeland. The Arabs were granted self-rule in 99% of the carved-up Ottoman Middle East land (today's Iraq, Syria, Saudi Arabia, Lebanon and Jordan). I'm sad that the Kurds, Assyrians, and other indigenous groups had no-one to speak for them at the San Remo Conference in 1920.
    1
  45. Some of the Gaza people are desperate to leave!!! Why keep them trapped in a war zone? It's inhumane. They have been paying people smugglers to get them out if they can come up with the money.
    1
  46. Not the "whole world". Only the useful idiots and those who are anti-Israel and anti-semitic.
    1
  47. ​ @Knowledgeequalspower1 : I am from New Zealand and Australia, and in both of my countries the indigenous peoples have been given recognition, autonomy, support, and sometimes full control of their ancestral land. That doesn't always work out well but the invasion by Britain happened far too long ago to reverse it now, and I doubt that the Aboriginals or Maoris would even want that to happen. The US has the same situation. I believe the Native American Indians have been given recognition, autonomy, support and sometimes full autonomy in their ancestral lands. In both NZ and the US, the people we call "indigenous" today only came relatively recently from other lands, but the Aboriginal peoples had been in what we today call Australia for around 50,000 years so they absolutely must be taken care of. In the case of Israel, there was a relatively recent "window of opportunity" for the indigenous Jewish peoples to return to their ancestral land. After the Jews fought with Britain in Palestine, and the Allies DEFEATED the Ottoman Empire in 1918, the Ottoman land was ceded to the British, French, etc. They didn't have to give up that land to anyone, but they did. The Hejazi Arabs also fought with British Lawrence of Arabia and they were given self-rule in 99% of the Ottoman land. Today those countries are Syria, Iraq, Lebanon, Saudi Arabia and Jordan. Much of it is land rich in oil. Israel is less than 1% of the carved-up Ottoman land. It has almost no resources, and one-fifth of Israeli citizens are Arabs who accepted life in the Jewish state of Israel. It's my guess that most of those Arabs who stayed with Israel had been there for at least a century, so they were not leaving. Those Arabs who did flee when the Arab countries attacked Israel in 1948 ended up being #displaced because Israel unexpectedly won that war. A large number of those fleeing Arabs only arrived AFTER 1920 when the British and Jews created 'economic opportunities' for them. By now they should ALL have been absorbed into those neighbouring Arab countries which caused the catastrophe ('nakba'). But because the Arab countries have oil, and because #antisemitism is a very real thing, the international community has kept the displaced Arab 'Palestinians' as pawns to use against Israel. When the Ottoman land was carved-up in 1920, representatives of the Kurds and Assyrians also lobbied for control of their ancestral land, but sadly it was all given to the Hejazi Arabs. Those same Arabs who had invaded and conquered the Levant in the 7th century. It is my hope that these conquests can be reversed in time, and that we will see emerging countries which the Kurds, Assyrians, Yazidis, Berbers, Balochis, Persians, Copts, etc. call their own, just like the Jewish state of Israel today.
    1
  48.  @stormz761 : I'm not exactly sure what point your are making. Hundreds of thousands of Jews were taken to Europe in the year 70 as SLAVES by the Romans. Those Jews who survived remained scattered throughout Europe. It is THEIR descendants who have now returned to the Jewish ancestral home of Israel. They are Jewish by ethnicity. Just like 170,000 Ethiopian Jews and 80,000 Indian Jews have returned to Israel because that's where their ancestors came from. After the DEFEAT of the Ottoman Caliphate in 1918, Arabs were given self-rule in 99% of the Middle East Ottoman land. And one-fifth of Israeli citizens are Arabs. Is that not good enough for you? You want NO Jews at all in Israel?🙄
    1
  49. The one true God, the God of Israel and the Jewish people, will prevail...🇮🇱🙏💙 Islam is now growing weaker, as prophesied.
    1
  50.  @Ibrahim_12468 : It seems to me that it is those countries which are moving away from Islam that are doing well, while the rest are failed, or close to failing, unless they have oil or other resources. I'm in Egypt and Islam is definitely NOT the solution here! I'm starting to believe this Sahih Muslim Hadith which was quoted to me by a Kashmiri Muslim just months ago: “Verily Islam started as something strange and it would again revert (to its old position) of being strange just as it started, and it would recede between the two mosques just as the serpent crawls back into its hole.” Things are changing all over the Islamic world, due to access to information via the internet.
    1