General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About

Posthumanist
Jake Broe
comments

Comments by "Posthumanist" (@thornelderfin) on "Jake Broe" channel.

Previous
2
Next
...
All

@hardtackbeans9790 Don't forget that it is very difficult to wage war on your neighbor when all your soldiers have been just killed in Ukraine. This breakup will not happen while Russia still has a military... it has to be ground down to nothing (which will take many years of war) in order for the regions feel safe enough to declare independence (Moscow not being able to send anything against them). Then it won't be easy for any of the breakaway regions to wage war on anyone. It might be less violent than you think. But it will definitely be chaotic, as all changes are.
3
Trump clearly signaled to Putin that he wants his companies to get fat contracts in Russia. That's what the Saudi Arabia meeting with Putin is about. Trump communicated it in his tweets that he looks forward to doing business with Russia, same with Marco Rubio - Lavrov phone call. Trump will get billions from Putin and then force Ukraine to lose.
3
USA criticizing EU democracy after South African billionaire bought very high position in US government for 270M. This would be completely illegal in Europe.
3
Yes, but the point was that 11k (before taxes) would not last even 2 days in that hotel. He could afford 1 night in the hotel + services and it would cost him his entire monthly salary. ... But of course we both know where is he getting his money from.
3
That entire area is thoroughly mined with millions of mines - it will be an absolute hell with or without cluster munitions (they are at least not designed to explode when pressured unlike mines).
3
Nuclear weapons cannot vaporize an island. These are just drunk old Russians who know nothing about physics. Nuclear weapons are overestimated.
3
@JJdV1980 I am sorry to hear that. That sounds horrible. I was living in Dakar, Senegal... near the monument. Very safe and friendly place. So that's probably not comparable to safety of your place. Do you see any chance of it getting better in South Africa in the future?
3
@sofiajohansson8537 You understand it well Sofia. I was born in Czechoslovakia and was forced to grow up under Russian occupation (with tanks and everything) - they killed quarter of my family (grandparents), took everything we had and sent men from my family to labor camps (fortunately not Siberia but local one - only torture and horrible labor, but they survived). They also destroyed our economy and part of our culture and mindset (lots of old people are permanently damaged by it). Never again! That's why Ukraine has to explain Russian colonization to the West Europe and USA (I don't blame them, they cannot know what Russia truly is, they were not occupied), but Ukraine needs not to explain anything to people from Poland, Czechia, Slovakia, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania - no words necessary, we know.
2
@wumbleisthebest3270 Every time a country agressively invades another one - if it wins, it can take all the territory, subdue people, relocate them forcibly, commit genocide - there is nobody to stop it. But when the invading country loses the war - it itself can be completely destroyed or genocided. I always marvel and the surprise of invading country when suddenly the war comes to their own homes and they are very very lucky to be even allowed to exist. Russians will be surprised in the same way in this decade.
2
@wumbleisthebest3270 My comment was aimed more at today's Russia than at your ancestors in Sudetenland. I agree with your statements that not all Germans were guilty (most definitely were, same as most Russians are today, but not all), and also with the statement that two wrongs don't make one right. You were not there personally when Nazis killed my grand-grandfather, and I was not there when my country kicked your ancestors out of Sudetenland. It was all a very long time ago and none of the people who did it are alive anymore. Let's not repeat the mistakes and horrible things our ancestors did, but instead build a better future with a clean slate. Germany moved on and is focused on its future. Czechia and Slovakia moved on and we are focused on our future. Russia didn't move on - constantly obsessing about what was (Russian Empire, USSR), wishing to return time back, instead of focusing on their own future.
2
@miroslavdusin4325 You are both arguing about something as old as Humanity itself. Larger nation or tribe invades smaller one, murders half the population, enslaves the rest, takes their land... and then 4 generations later you want to return land to the original smaller nation. But by that time everyone who commited the attrocity is already dead and everyone living on the stolen land has been born there (not their choice) and lived their entire life there - they didn't do anything wrong and had no say in what happened 4 generations ago. So this is a difficult situation, because the land was stolen and attrocities were commited, but by returning land you will severely punish people who didn't do it and are innocent. By not returning the land you will punish the true victims who lost their land and their families and everything. How to resolve this? There is no good solution. This is and always has been an extremely painful and difficult situation that has no good solutions. Thousands of smarter people than the three of us tried to solve this and never came with a good solution. That's why the two of you cannot agree, because you both have good arguments, but there is no solution.
2
Most importantly - there are people living there. Millions of people will be living under occupation (they are already) in Russian hell. I know, I grew up in a communist country occupied by Russia. You don't want that for those millions of Ukrainians. It's not just about giving up territory.
2
@kai223noa6 They barely have any nukes. They need extremely expensive maintenance and complete replacement of the fissile material every 10 years. Russia has economy that is smaller than Canada, too small for their nuclear ambitions... they can spare 3-4 billion on maintenance and absolute majority is stolen by their generals, colonels and oligarchs... just look at the rest of the Russian military - it's all stolen ("transformed" into superyachts). Plus if they used the very small number of nukes they can afford to maintain and let's say the budget was not stolen (it was), Putin, Peskov, Lavrov, Shoigu, Gerasimov - all dead, 100% they would not live next 12 months. And they would lose all their fictional allies (like China), but then again, Russia is stupid enough to do almost anything. It is more realistic they would just blow up Zaporozhia nuclear power plant... which means it will reach me and my family in 1-2 days. NATO should stop toying with Ukraine and just obliterate Russia. NATO spends 240x more on military than Ukraine. Russia has problem fighting 1 Ukraine, imagine fighting 240 Ukraines at the same time. The military aid sent to Ukraine is just 0.2% of our GDP. Russia can't even protect their borders ...or their capital city from toy drones. This is outright cruel letting this war on when we can just end it.
2
Exactly the same here (disabled), only I live right next to Ukraine (I grew up under Russian occupation) so it's more personal (and I have 6 Ukrainian refugees in my house, 2 mothers 4 kids), but otherwise the same. Jake did an excellent job here. My respect!
2
@GeorgeGzirishvili I wouldn't be happy about China dominating. They are exactly like Soviet Union on the inside, just 10x larger in every way. The horrible things happening inside China today, you don't want that. We are alone my friend, against USA-Russia-China. Maybe we can rally together all the free democratic countries around the world and defend ourselves, but it doesn't look very good.
2
@Fromleftfield01 Little bit of context from Slovakia: Fico is not pro-Russian by nature (he has no personal beliefs, he is your typical extremely corrupt political operator who is also very capable orator and political manipulator, extremely capable). 4 years ago, police (under new government) started serious investigation into massive corruption of previous government officials (dozens of people involved, including Fico). That meant Fico had to win this election (1 year ago) otherwise he would go to prison for the rest of his life, and many many powerful people around him. The already present and pervasive Russian propaganda came in handy and he used it as a tool to get back to power and replace prosecutors and police directorate. He is pro-Russian because it was politically profitable for him to be (I suspect similar motivations in many of the pro-Russian populists in the EU countries). Russia has been brainwashing us through social media for 10+ years, and if these politicians come to the scene and say "USA bad! NATO bad! EU bad!" stupid people brainwashed by Russia vote for them because "He's the only one saying it like it is!". I will not blame USA for stupidity of my people... but this could all have been prevented if CIA or NSA came to the offices of Facebook and YouTube/Google, and forced them to not actively promote Russian propaganda in allied countries. Even today if I open YouTube without signing into my account, YouTube actively promote pro-Russian propaganda in Slovak language non-stop from every side, it's like 30% of all recommendations I get. Most of this propaganda is anti-American (anti-USA)... actively promoted by an American company (Google, Facebook). I don't understand this.
2
@gerrylee1687 Because China is too busy stealing Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan from Russia :D
2
@bc4life862 Russians are just terraforming Ukraine to look like other Russian derelict cities (Norilsk). I still don't understand why people don't want to be a Russian colony. Must be the Russophobia.
2
Just give Slovakia 2 more years and it will be back inside EU not causing any trouble. Slovakia had very pro-western and pro-Ukrainian government until last year. It's just politicial games, coalitions and fracturing of the opposition that lead to election of Fico (with just 23% of the votes). That would be like prosecuting USA because they elected Donald Trump. It's temporary and it's not like entire country supports everything Donald Trump says or does.
2
When you finally confront China, you will need all the allies you can get.
2
@martinaasandersen3775 I spent some time in Taiwan and talked to many many local people about this. I cannot vouch for their bravery (you never know what you would do yourself until it really happens), I can absolutely tell you they don't want communist China in any way or form over there. Land belongs to the people who were born there, lived their entire lives there, died there, and their children lived their entire lives there - and they all want to be left alone and nothing to do with communist China. People there were so nice to me, going so much out of their way to help a stranger. Only they can decide what to do with their own land. China wants to come in there and kill them to take that land from them. Simple as that. I am afraid Macron and Scholz don't care about human lives at all, they just care about money. China has more money. Same with Russia and Ukraine.
2
@silsternensand And how many Russian billionaires you see in Africa? None. That is just your mental fantasy. ... There is nothing wrong with Africa (I love it!) but these oligarchs desperately need company of their peers - other billionaires. They don't want to spend their time with us peasants. They want to be in Monaco or Florida and brag about their new superyacht. The only place where they can go now and meet other billionaires is Dubai. But that's just one place - they are very limited now.
2
@ashroskell I agree with everything you wrote. Revolution is possible and internal collapse in Russia is likely. But I belive it won't change much on their foreign policy. Fundamental problem is they have been brainwashed since birth that Russia is the most powerful and most important country in the world - a superpower. This is the very core of their identity. They cannot exist without it. They will rather die than to not be a superpower. Even if there is a revolution in Russia, someone like Prigozhin will just replace Putin. Even in the very unlikely event that Navalny becomes their supreme leader, they will go back to their old ways AGAIN in a decade or two. We are just kicking the can down the road for our children. Russia has to be completely dismantled as a country and broken up into 30 small pieces (which will be better for most of those new countries frankly, oil and gas producing regions will finally have roads and toliets). This is the only way to secure peace in Europe for the future generations. Russia has to be completely defeated and conquered like Germany and Japan (look how imensely beneficial it was for both these countries).
2
@QuotidianStupidity The paradox is that a lot of Russians are incredibly racist (outright, without even hiding it). If only those people in Africa who support Russia (out of spite against the West) knew the truth about Russian incredible racism, they would change their mind very quickly.
2
Also on top of suffering of your people and military disadvantage, who believes that Ukraine that had its power plants bombed by Russia and power grid under repeated attacks will blow up hydroelectric power station that supplied 3 million Ukrainians and endager their nuclear power plant supplying millions of Ukrainians. That's not even shooting yourself in the foot, that's shooting youself in the head.
2
Trying to protect your family from FSB / KGB / NKVD doesn't mean you automatically succeed and your family is safe. Do not underestimate KGB / FSB / NKVD, they have been doing this evil shit for more than 100 years.
2
It's EU fund money stolen from the government. But potato potato. Same thing. He was already investigated for corruption and would have gone to jail, but then he used Russian propaganda as a propeller to get him to 23% of votes and politically maneuver to form a dirty alliance and become prime minister, and he replaced key people at the police and justice. Now it's 100% assured he won't go to prison for his corruption. He made sure of that.
2
If dissolution of USSR was illegal that puts Russian Federation on the same level of illegality as Ukraine or Kazakhstan. In that case Russian Federation doesn't legeally exist.
2
But that means the president of Afghanistan was a dictator (he probably was, no wonder his people didn't even bother to fight for him).
1
@AstroGremlinAmerican You are ruled by Billionaire president Musk, billionaire face president Trump and billionaire Peter Theil and Andressen and your inauguration had chicken hen full of billionaires... and you say Zelensky is in it for the money.
1
@salzysisters5799 I don't think people dispute what alliances are for (you are right), but that every single day on Russian state TV they all pretend like Russia is the strongest military in the world that can conquer all of Europe all the way to Lisbon on a whim, they just chose not to. And that they could destroy USA if they wanted to. ... Yet they can't even get their own territory back (Kursk) from the poorest country in all of Europe (Ukraine). Like he said, pathetic performance from Russia given their resources and manpower.
1
Trump's voters don't remember what he did yesterday. They perform extreme mental gymnastics to defend his every action. It would be a stretch to expect them to remember Trump was even a president and is responsible for party of the situation today.
1
@retiredrn1873 That's different! Elon is not a foreigner begging USA for tens of billions of dollars... in subsidies and contracts for his compani.... oh wait... nevermind
1
@Phonehomefool West and allies are 67% of the world economy, Russia is little bit above 1%. NATO is 1 billion people, Russia is 0.14 billion. NATO spends 24x more on military than Russia and 240x more than Ukraine (Russia has serious problems fighting 1 Ukraine, now imagine fighting 240 Ukraines at the same time). NATO has 22000 military aircraft. Some people don't understand how absurdly one-sided NATO vs Russia is. These are just hard factual numbers. The West is sending 0.2% of GDP as military aid to Ukraine. Would you like to see the remaining 99.8%?
1
@andersgrassman6583 A lot of people are asking how can so many people from Central and Eastern Europe support Russia (it's not majority, but in Slovakia it's almost one third), if they have felt Russian occupation and the destruction. What people from the West do not know is that all these older people were severely brainwashed as children by Russia. There was a system during the dictatorship were all children were completely brainwashed. And parents couldn't do anything against it because if they told the truth to their kid it could talk to other kids at school and they can report it to the authorities (which happened a lot) and the parents could be taken, never to be seen again. So most parents preteneded, and by the time kids were grown up, they were severely brainwashed. Those kids are today's 40-90 year olds. This brainwashing didn't work on most (I can see it in my family, somewhere between one third to one half of the people are still brainwashed). I just wanted to explain it to you, why in the hell would anyone who survived Russian occupation support Russia like a fanatic.
1
@andersgrassman6583 A lot of people are asking how can so many people from Central and Eastern Europe support Russia (it's not majority, but in Slovakia it's almost one third), if they have felt Russian occupation and the destruction. What people from the West do not know is that all these older people were severely brainwashed as children by Russia. There was a system during the dictatorship were all children were completely brainwashed. And parents couldn't do anything against it because if they told the truth to their kid it could talk to other kids at school and they can report it to the authorities (which happened a lot) and the parents could be taken, never to be seen again. So most parents preteneded, and by the time kids were grown up, they were severely brainwashed. Those kids are today's 40-90 year olds. This brainwashing didn't work on most (I can see it in my family, somewhere between one third to one half of the people are still brainwashed). I just wanted to explain it to you, why in the hell would anyone who survived Russian occupation support Russia like a fanatic.
1
I think all the Musk cultists already unsubscribed from your channel 3 years ago, so they are not here anymore.
1
@Amokhunter You: "What to do with the Nukes? Where to draw the State-lines?" -- The most important thing is that WE decide nothing. Only people living there have the right to decide what to do with their land and to what state or country they want to belong to. Let's not be colonial powers redrawing borders in faraway lands yet again. They have to sort it for themselves. Civil wars are inevitable. They won't be nuclear, they can't launch anything without Moscow and they can't maintain anything without insane expenses, which they cannot afford. No worries.
1
I don't think Elon takes drugs. I think he has some serious mental defect. Exactly as you wrote "immature psychotic decisions" and everything he does is "weird" (little weird is ok, but he is non-stop weird). I think being so extremely popular on Twitter and in the media made his mental state even worse - he ist like a drug addict for people's attention and approval (especially on Twitter, this reminds me little bit of Trump and his addiction to Twitter). I also wouldn't say it's Elon's Falcon 9 (it is, but he didn't design it... he cosplays an engineer, but read quora testimonies from engineers working at SpaceX (even as far back as 2014), how ruthlessly capitalist Elon is and unpredictably fires people on a whim and then claims all the credit as if he invented SpaceX and Tesla. It's the incredibly hard work of hundreds of engineers working 6 days a week (Elon always trying to force them to 7 days per week). ... He lost all my respect 3 years ago when he forced thousands of workers into factories when he was strictly prohibited to do so by California government. He went on TV and said he takes full responsiblity. Well, absolutely nothing happened to him, because billionaires are untouchable (like aristocracy). If you did the same thing you would be rotting in jail. He endangered thousands of people and possibly even killed some. That was when I realized he absolutely doesn't care about human lives, he cares only about his companies and his personal goals. No empathy. No compassion. This thing with Ukraine just reinforced it. I love how he pretends he is saving Ukraine, when in fact Pentagon is paying for everything and even at extremely overinflated prices (more than 1 thousand per StarLink per month when commercial price in Ukraine is 70 bucks per month - and it is the same StarLink, it is not some "improved military version". And then he joins Pentagon's tender for military Internet in Ukraine, wins it, and then writes to media that StarLink is for peaceful purposes only... sure... then why do you apply for extremely lucrative tenders at Pentagon with it? Also offering Pentagon to build another StarLink specifically for military purposes (so is he a pacifist like he pretends in the media, or does he want those fat billion-dollar contracts at Pentagon?).
1
Brother, I agree with everything you wrote, but one big correction. Only 23% of people voted for Fico. For example Hlas pretended to be pro-EU and pro-Western. Of course that was a lie and Hlas was just servant of Fico to soak up all the votes of people who are on the similar side of political spectrum as Fico, but didn't want to vote for him because of the anti-EU rhetoric. But I wouldn't say that all that 15% of people who voted Hlas are anti-Ukrainian or anti-western. They were just easily deceived (as usual).
1
It is actually very simple to understand. Russia just fights for its interests every single time and wants to win everything all the time no matter the cost. It doesn't matter whether there are some treaties, principles, honor, values, laws. Nothing matters to Russia - only to win. Now, when they promote their propaganda outside, they have to pretend, but on the inside, they understand. It's not complicated.
1
Trust is built over 100 years and can be lost in a single day. The US allies are gone. Forever. It's not so much about one many - every country can get horrible president. It's about how incredibly fast has significant part of USA turned on their closest and most loyal ally (Canada) and on all other allies (Greenland / EU, Panama, Mexico). If you can love someone and 2 weeks later show extreme hatred for the same country, USA can never be truest ever again - no matter who is the president, because these people who now hate Canada and EU will always stay.
1
Russia had a chance to win this war and still has. Not on the battlefield and absolutely not economically, but though propaganda in the West, brainwashing people to vote for "disruptive" candidates, ultra-nationalists and Kremlin sponsored politicians. Please, do not unerestimate this. Russia can still win this way, dismantling us from the inside.
1
Russia and China are eating popcorn watching potential USA vs EU fight. We have to stop this. Words matter too.
1
This war has been a stalemate for more than 2 years, war of attrition. It will not be won on the battlefield. It's now about who's economy or will to fight will collapse first will lose the war. If we fully support Ukraine, Russia cannot afford to finance this war for more than next few years.
1
Trump is not incompetent... his goal is to extrat billions and billions for himself and his donors - from every country where it's even remotely possible (including USA). In this sense, he is competent. Putin has obviously promised him corrupt deals, so he will destroy Ukraine too and will try to take down the EU.
1
@istvanglock7445 China is already taking advantage from behind. They are just not using military to do it. They are buying businesses in Russia, overtaking makrets, exploiting Russian natural resources for extremely low prices. Everything is cheap for China now because of the sanctions on Russia. No military invasion necessary (at least yet). But we should all be aware... China has same ambitions as Russia to dominate all, and sooner or later we will have to fight them. China is 10x larger economy than Russia and 10x larger population, with same levels of corruption and military incompetence. This will not be easy at all and I am not looking forward to it.
1
But Jake said that they should be "mobilized" into the war economy (manufacturing drones, cybersecurity, logistics, etc..). You don't need military equipment for that.
1
@richard_from_england333 But USA signed the Budapest Memorandum. Is written word of the United States worth nothing? If you take someone's 1000 nuclear weapons in exchange for protection, then you are bound to protect. Same goes for Europe of course. Otherwise US has to tell the whole world to never ever trust any contract with the US so that we all can start mass producing our own nuclear weapons. It's fine. US just needs to be clear with us.
1
@mitchellhawkes22 Slovak government will do nothing to her or the other protestors (that has never happened in this century). We are not a dictatorship (yet), the institutions are still working, and the elections were free (votes counted honestly). However there is MASSIVE Russian propaganda here comming solely through YouTube, Facebook and Twitter. These American owned social media are actively promoting Russian propaganda in Slovak language non-stop and anti-American hate (US government should probably have a talk with them, this is against US interests and even a security threat as Slovakia can veto in EU and NATO). All that Russian propaganda has brainwashed around 1/3 of the population of Slovakia (I am deeply ashamed of them, I don't even want to admit I come from the same country as them). 1/3 of the population was enough. Fico won the elections with only 23% of the votes by political maneuvering, but mostly because his opposition is so incompetent you wouldn't believe it, and they all have tremendous egos and boundless personal ambitions and are fractured into 15+ political parties. I don't see how we can get rid of Fico even if there were new elections today. There has to be someone who can overtake the opposition. We had an amazing president, but she refused to run again after very serious death threats from Fico's fanatical voters to the life of her daughter and her family. Anyone who was decent didn't survive in our politics for too long because of how toxic and dangerous it is. I don't know how to fix it... so I just protest so the world can see that 60% of our country have not lost their minds. Fortunately, we are too small and too irrelevant to cause any real trouble for Ukraine.
1

Previous
2
Next
...
All