Comments by "John Burns" (@johnburns4017) on "Military History Visualized" channel.

  1. +James Robert The Axis in Africa most of the time had superior numbers of men. 75% of all supplies got through from not far away Italy. British supplies came from around the Cape - a long way. The Germans had the 88mm gun which gave them a fantastic edge over British armour, especially in the early stages. Their tanks generally had bigger guns than the British until the 75mm and 6 pdrs came along. Rommel, an overrated general, was famous for extending his supply lines - that is a no, no. And then he was pushed back again. Not very bright. No one ever pushed Monty back.
    3
  2. Just to declare war on Britain and France was madness at the time.
    3
  3. lostwars price You are not very intelligent.
    3
  4. uxeivuda You obviously speak only for yourself.
    3
  5. uxeivuda You are an idiot.
    3
  6.  @anhchinhluong9279  The Soviet KV1's had no radios (or few had) with very poor battlefield control. If the Soviets had the control they had in 1945 in 1941 the Germans would have been defeated very soon. The Soviets had a large number of KV1's, which the Germans admired as they were well armoured with an effective gun. Then the T-34 came in around October 1941. The KV1 was an advanced tank for its time. Torsion bar suspension, the V-2 diesel engine, the lot. It lacked in some areas but overall the best of the early war. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ctAv5RafuWw&t=2s
    3
  7.  @pexxajohannes1506  So the Sherman was a highly reliable hearse then.
    3
  8.  @Slayinator96  None of those were deliberate atrocities.
    3
  9. David Hamilton Reference please.
    3
  10. Scott Humphreys "Germany is half the size of Texas." Nope! Texas is 2/3 of the size of Germany. But Texas is barren.
    3
  11. welshpete12 "As one who was a live at the time , yes we did and thought it would be within 3 weeks of Dunkirk" HMG kept saying that to keep people alert. HMG thought differently about any successful invasion.
    3
  12. Steven Rowlandson The British were aware of that and had a whole raft of minesweepers including converted trawlers for the job. Mines laid by the Germans would also impede their concrete barges as well.
    3
  13. Adam Anderson The German economy was just not big enough to sustain a long war - as the case proved.
    3
  14.  Dillon Mcconnell  You need to read some good history books.
    3
  15.  @Brian-om2hh  Some RAF pilots were getting leave at the height of the battle.
    3
  16.  Dillon Mcconnell  This idiot needs to find out how many U-boats Germany had in 1940.
    3
  17.  Dillon Mcconnell  Bonehead, right after small British force (only 9% of all allied forces in France/BeNeLux) retreated at Dunkirk, up until early 1941, the British had: • Destroyed the German surface fleet. • Neutralised most of the French fleet by sinking or starving it of fuel. • Disabled a major part of the Italian fleet. • Freely moving around the Mediterranean. • Starving Germany of food and resources   with the effective Royal Navy blockade. • Beat the Luftwaffe over Dunkirk. • Beat the Luftwaffe in the misnomer the Battle of Britain as Britain was never threatened. • Pushed the Italians out of East Africa. • Decimated the Italian army in North Africa. • Were about to take all the southern Mediterranean coast. • Germany was being bombed from the air with raids   of over 100 bombers - 150 over Nuremberg - using  the new navigational device, Gee. • A massive air bombing fleet was being assembled. • A matter of weeks after the US entered WW2 the RAF launched  a 1,000 bomber raid on Cologne. • The RAF shot down over 700 German fighters over Continental Europe in 1941. After the small BEF (only 9% of all allied forces in France) left France in June 1940, the British went on the rampage. So much so Franco told Hitler the British would win and he would not join in with Germany, fearing British occupation of Spanish territory.  The Turkish ambassador stated Britain will win as it has a pool of men in its empire to create an army of 45 million (later an army of 2.6 million moved into Burma). In 1941 the British: • Suppressed an uprising in Iraq; • Beat the Vichy French in Syria; • Secured Iran and the oil by invading. The British determined where the battlefields with the Axis were going to be.  After France 1940 Germany never had a significant campaign victory over the British Commonwealth ever again in WW2. The Germans FAILED: • To win the Battle of Britain in 1940; • To win the Battle of the Atlantic in 1940/41; • To control the eastern Atlantic ; • To control the Mediterranean in 1940/41; • To control North Africa and the Middle East in 1940/41.  The British Commonwealth stopped the Nazis/Axis achieving all this well before the USA joined WW2 or even sent Lend Lease. Even the expensive pyrrhic victory in Crete meant little in the end to the Nazis because the Royal Navy still dominated the Eastern Mediterranean with Crete not leading to any campaign winning difference.
    3
  18.  Dillon Mcconnell  Read it again. Move your lips as you are reading.
    3
  19. Rommel, like many British generals before Monty constantly overran his supply lines. Monty never - not once, hence he never lost a battle and went through 9 countries defeating the Germans. The finest general in WW2.
    3
  20. Deus Vult You must stop making things up. Some facts for you. The British were the single biggest agents in the defeat of Nazi Germany. They were there from day one until the end. The so-called "invincible" Germans army tried and failed, with their allies, for two years in WW2 to defeat the British army in North Africa. The finest army in the world from mid 1942 onwards was the British. From El Alemein it moved right up into Denmark, through nine countries, and not once suffered a reverse taking all in its path. Over 90% of German armour in the west was destroyed by the British. Montgomery had to give the US armies an infantry role as they were not equipped to engage massed German SS armour. Montgomery stopped the Germans in every event they attacked him: ♦ August 1942 - Alem el Halfa ♦ October 1942 - El Alamein ♦ March 1943 - Medenine ♦ June 1944 - Normandy ♦ Sept/Oct 1944 - The Netherlands ♦ December 1944 - Battle of the Bulge Not on one occasion were Monty's ground armies pushed back into a retreat by the Germans. The US Army were struggling in 1944/45 retreating in the Ardennes. The Americans didn't perform well at all east of Aachen, then the Hurtgen Forest defeat with 33,000 casualties and Patton's Lorraine crawl of 10 miles in three months with over 50,000 casualties. The Battle of the Bulge took all the US effort, and vital help from Montgomery and the British 21st Army Group, just to get back to the start line. The Germans took 20,000 US POWs in the Battle of The Bulge in Dec 1944. No other allied country had that many prisoners taken in the 1944-45 timeframe. The USA retreat at the Bulge, again, the only allied army to be pushed back into a retreat in the 1944-45 timeframe. Montgomery was effectively in charge of the Bulge having to take control of the US 1st and 9th armies and parts of the US air force put under RAF command. The 9th stayed under his control until the end of the war just about. Normandy was planned and commanded by the British with Montgomery leading, which was a great success coming in ahead of schedule and with less casualties than predicted. The German armour in the west was wiped out by primarily the British - the US forces were impotent against the panzers. Monty assessed the US armies (he was in charge of them) and had to give them a supporting infantry role, as they were just not equipped to fight tank v tank battles. On 3 Sept 1944 when Eisenhower took over overall allied command of ground forces everything went at a snail's pace. The fastest advance of any western army in Autumn/early 1945 was the 60 mile thrust by the British XXX Corps to the Rhine at Arnhem.
    3
  21. Deus Vult You are an idiot.
    3
  22. Deus Vult I find it is best not to engage with idiots.
    3
  23. ilija stankovic Another uninformed idiot.
    3
  24.  @gw7624  About one third of the equipment at Dunkirk was successfully taken back to England. The BEF was only one third of the British Army. In about a month all units were fully re-equipped with factories turning out the latest armaments 24/7. The regular army had near two million with the Home Guard one million. Right after the retreat at Dunkirk, up until early 1941, the British had: • Destroyed the German surface fleet. • Neutralised most of the French fleet by sinking or starving it of fuel. • Disabled a major part of the Italian fleet. • Freely moving around the Mediterranean. • Starving Germany of food and resources with the effective Royal Navy blockade. • Beat the Luftwaffe over Dunkirk. • Beat the Luftwaffe in the misnomer the Battle of Britain as Britain was never threatened. • Pushed the Italians out of East Africa. • Decimated the Italian army in North Africa. • Were about to take all the southern Mediterranean coast. • Germany was being bombed from the air with raids of over 100 bombers - 150 over Nuremberg - using the new navigational device, Gee. • A massive air bombing fleet was being assembled. • A matter of weeks after the US entered WW2 the RAF launched a 1,000 bomber raid on Cologne. • The RAF shot down over 700 German fighters over Continental Europe in 1941. After the small BEF (only 9% of all allied forces in France) left France in June 1940, the British went on the rampage. So much so Franco told Hitler the British would win and he would not join in with Germany, fearing British occupation of Spanish territory.  The Turkish ambassador stated Britain will win as it has a pool of men in its empire to create an army of 45 million (later an army of 2.6 million moved into Burma). In 1941 the British: • Suppressed an uprising in Iraq; • Beat the Vichy French in Syria; • Secured Iran and the oil by invading. The British determined where the battlefields with the Axis were going to be.  After France 1940 Germany never had a significant campaign victory over the British Commonwealth ever again in WW2. The Germans FAILED: • To win the Battle of Britain in 1940; • To win the Battle of the Atlantic in 1940/41; • To control the eastern Atlantic ; • To control the Mediterranean in 1940/41; • To control North Africa and the Middle East in 1940/41.  The British Commonwealth stopped the Nazis/Axis achieving all this well before the USA joined WW2 or even sent Lend Lease. Even the expensive German pyrrhic victory in Crete meant little in the end to the Nazis because the Royal Navy still dominated the eastern Mediterranean with Crete not leading to any campaign winning difference, merely tying up men.
    3
  25. Ohlourdes Padua The critical lend lease was by the British prior to the USA entering the war, that aiding the vital Battle of Moscow. US lend lease never really started to flow until 1943. Its worth at shortening the war? Probably by about 6 months.
    3
  26. weirdshibainu "The raf was literally at the point of destruction" The RAF had more planes at the end of the Battle of Britain than at the beginning. They also defeated the Luftwaffe over Dunkirk. Read some history please.
    3
  27. Somerville did send out a task group to find the Japanese fleet, but failed. If the Japanese fleet sinks a lot of British ships they could not follow up with any land invasion. Just reducing the large British fleets compliment. They had to get back as they were running out of fuel. The Japanese fleet's sail into the Indian Ocean was a waste of time achieving nothing, with no firm war progressing objective, but risking valuable ships.... and they could have lost a lot if matters went slightly against them, as you pointed out it could have. Their carriers had wooden decks like the US carriers. The Japanese fleet should have only been used in attacking other threatening ships and/or support land operations. The British did not go sailing off Italy within range of land based planes for fun. Carrier HMS Hermes (WW1 era) was used for carrying planes rather than an attack ship. It was sunk with no operational planes to retaliate.
    3
  28. I like the camera dolly. Very effective. What do you think about the museum?
    3
  29. Theodore Roosevelt Normandy came in ahead of schedule (the allies were way ahead at D-Day plus 90), and also less casualties. All run by Montgomery as he was ground forces commander..
    3
  30. The me262 came too early. It was a prototype rushed into service, when it was unsuitable for service.
    2
  31. The Tiger tanks were not available in Dec 1941. They came when Germany trying to hang on.
    2
  32. +3vr1m " since the allied Planes werent as far as advanced as the me262" Quite the opposite.
    2
  33. @B Mc The British were not attempting to break out of the pocket via land, they did via sea.
    2
  34. I want the real source, not an off the cuff comment in a popular book.
    2
  35. Chocolate Eclare The Tiger had an amazing success rate. However this was due to it being used mainly in a defensive role. Hand held PIATS disabled them.
    2
  36. Craig Thompson I do believe the English first spotted and charted the islands. The Argentine claim the islands is so thin it is not worth debating.
    2
  37. Autism Is Unstoppable The islands are Britain's, they have no need to claim them.
    2
  38. The USSR was a disaster in WW2. They should have stopped the German advance quickly and pushed them back to Germany. The USSR had twice as many tanks as the Germans and countless more men. The Soviets were a shambles, with the Germans capturing millions of Soviet men.
    2
  39. +Mr SmersH I am saying how bad the Red Army was.
    2
  40. Overall, it looks like the IS2 was the equivalent to a Tiger1.
    2
  41.  Dillon Mcconnell  Such random drivelous nonsense.
    2
  42. Another arm waver.
    2
  43.  @DC9622  What is the great Swan? Tiger B? Is that King Tiger? I think Chieftain maybe using Zaloga as the source.
    2
  44.  @DC9622  The British and Canadians took on 90% of the German armour in Normandy. Eight Panzer Divisions and 3 Tiger battalions: 21st Panzer Division (117 Panzer IVs). Panzer Lehr Division ( 101 Panzer IVs, 89 Panthers). 2nd Panzer Division (89 Panzer IVs, 79 Panthers). 116th Panzer Division (73 Panzer IVs, 79 Panthers). In reserve just behind the front. 1st SS Panzer Division (98 Panzer IVs, 79 Panthers). 9th SS Panzer Division (40 Stugs, 46 Panzer IVs, 79 Panthers). 10th SS Panzer Division (38 Stugs, 39 Panzer IVs) . 12th SS Panzer Division (98 Panzer IVs, 79 Panthers). Tiger Battalion SS101 (45 Tigers). Tiger Battalion SS102 (45 Tigers). Tiger Battalion 503 (45 Tigers). Sources: Panzers and the Battle For Normandy by Georges Bernage.  Normandy 1944: German Military Organization, Combat Power and Organizational Effectiveness by Niklas Zetterling. In Normandy the Americans only faced one battalion of 40 assault gun in June (Stugs of 17th SS), apart from a few insignificant early war obsolete French tanks, and only one panzer divisions (2nd SS) in July. The only time the Americans faced tanks in any numbers in Normandy was during the August Mortain counter-attack. Even then, the panzer divisions had been reduced in strength after engaging British forces around Caen being nowhere near the strength they were when fighting around Caen.
    2
  45. The Last tank Battle of WW2. King Tigers devastated American armour in the last few weeks of the war: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t11hGZvvTLg Part 1 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ubhf96HSA9c Part 2 The King Tiger was a devastating tank. It was well designed as well. The engine and transmission were not up to it being too small and temperamental. After the war the British assessed all German tanks. They even had the factory make a few new Panthers to assess. They compared the Panther, Tiger 1 and King Tiger to their own Centurion. The British did not adopt anything from German tank design concluding that their own Centurion was better than the German tanks. The King Tiger at Bovington Tank Museum was to be analysed. As it was laying about over the years the engine and transmission were taken out, probably to be used for something else or broken down for parts. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QuDuBwAhRa4 The Chieftain and the Challenger tanks were all extensions of the Centurion.
    2
  46.  @pexxajohannes1506  T34 greatly superior to Sherman.
    2
  47.  @Slayinator96  Name these so-called atrocities.
    2
  48. Blah B The M10s in British service had the US guns ripped out and 17-pdrs fitted - renamed the Achilles. They were used mainly with Churchill infantry tanks, which were not pitted against tanks. The turret traverse was unpowered and slow. The US forces in Normandy mainly had an infantry role, so the US M10s would rarely be meeting tanks. From a distance they looked like tanks with the long gun making them a target.
    2
  49.  @EdgyNumber1  Again.. Just for you.... Germany had no realistic ability to overrun the UK. The British knew what sort of chance the Germans had. The reason the Germans had no chance was that the British were ready and waiting with factories turning out the latest equipment 24/7. During the so-called Battle of Britain, the Royal Navy had a mass of ships at Gibraltar ready for offensive operations against the Italians, they took the invasion of Britain really so seriously. The German Navy was near non-existent. The single battleship the British kept in Portsmouth was quite able to handle everything the Germans had on the surface, together with the four flotillas of destroyers. I'm not counting the Home Fleet, which had additional powerful ships. In other words, the British kept plenty of naval force at home. All they needed to deal with the Germans with a good deal to spare. Also, 55 Matilda 2 tanks, which was immune from German anti-tank guns, were sent to North Africa, the Brits took the invasion so seriously. Admiral Raeder said he could not guarantee putting down an invasion force, even with German air superiority, when the Royal Navy was still there. General Jodl talked of his men going through a British mincing machine. In Churchill's memoirs, he says that he was prepared to defeat tens of thousands of Germans if they invaded (take that as slaughter). Presumably even if they arrived with weapons and not half-dead from seasickness in a 24 hour sea trip in barges being attacked from sea, land and air. The British kept plenty of force at home, all they needed. And what were the Germans supposed to do? Sortie with two or three heavy cruisers, and blast their way through the Home Fleet or the Channel defences? At that point in the war, Bismarck was still under construction, Scharnhorst and Gneisenau were under repair from the Norway operation, two of six heavy cruisers sunk, two of six light cruisers sunk, and only five of those could be considered modern warships, a large number of their destroyers were sunk at Narvik. The repair status on the rest of the ships wasn't real good. The Germans never even had an effective torpedo plane. The Stuka dive bomber was predictable in that it dived vertically. It was easily shot down and suffered so many losses in the Battle of Britain it was withdrawn from the battle. So, with the German navy whittled to almost nothing, and the army incapable of crossing with enough force to win, the only threats was the then small U-boats force and the Luftwaffe. The British were therefore sparing about sending the RAF overseas. I don't know of any significant deployment of Spitfires outside the UK until the second half of 1942, and escort vessels kept on being built. The RAF defeated the Luftwaffe over Dunkirk, so the Germans knew they were no push over. If anyone thinks that operation Sealion was a serious attempt at an invasion they are deluded. Even German generals never took it seriously. An invasion in concrete barges towed by tugs and no navy to speak of? The Germans knew the UK had a large industry working 24/7, the same size as Germany's, and the largest navy in the world to their virtually none. The RAF was large with a large bomber force, which the Germans could not knock out. Any invasion at the few suitable invasion beaches would be met at the beaches by all types of aircraft. These could be based out of Me 109 range. State-of-the-art fighters would still be produced 24/7. There would always be top line fighters around. According to Guderian in "Panzer Leader", and by pretty much any historian to follow, Sealion (Zee Lowe?) could succeed only with complete air superiority over the invasion areas, and at least naval equality in the Channel. Hence the air Battle of Britain, hard fought and clearly won by Britain. Naval equality was a pipe dream for Germany, but a pipe smoked only if the Luftwaffe could attain a decisive victory. Given the failure of the prerequisite, there is really no point in debating the if Germans could invade the UK.
    2
  50. The Swordfish plane, which operated more like a helicopter, as it could take off into the wind also vertically. It sank more ships than any other WW2 plane.
    2