Comments by "红火树 RedFireTree" (@firetree2007) on "NDTV" channel.

  1. this is the irony of so called "democracy" which simply mean "majority rule", however, history has shown "Majority rule" does not mean "rightness rule". Those who mindlessly support "democracy" will bite their own lips and as someone lift a rock to drop it on his own foot, for that as it is showing in India.
    41
  2. It is simple, the bridge can allow Chinese heavy tanks easily to get to Chushul front which is the defense line of India set before next in Leh. In 1962, November 19, Nehru wrote a letter to JFK begging for help, "In the east sector, equals 2 division of Indian army were surrounded, not sure if they can withdraw successfully to the south of Tezpur headquarter. In the west sector, the Chinese army has broken the defense line in Chushul, there is no effective defense line anymore before Leh"
    20
  3. simple, just means it smashed into pieces on the moon. it is a successful landing, just not soft-landing :))
    19
  4. it only shows that Modi and BJP do not know how to run a modern country, India's GDP growth drop started long before covid. from 8 to 4% under Modi. and now covid is out of control. India's long term anti China policy peaked at 2017 Doklam and 2020 Galwan created unnecessary tensions between India and China so India cannot focus on economical development but put limited resources into defense and military spending. India totally reject BRI while at the same time Bangladesh welcomed it and with investment of over $26 billion, it contributed 1.5% economy growth in Bangladesh and provide large number of job opportunities.
    17
  5. finally someone in India can tell the truth
    14
  6. ISRO director has confirmed lost contact with the lander
    13
  7. Democracy means majority rule, India's democracy shows that the majority of a less developed country with huge number of low level of education will make huge mistakes. India majority just elected a leader that shows who has no ability of improving India's economy, unable to provide jobs for large number of India youth, failed completely in the rural areas with people there cannot even afford to buy toothpaste and soap. This kind foolish "democracy", except with a glory name given by its westerners, has no good use but only suicidal, that is about all. enjoy it.
    12
  8. delicious tea is prepared for them in Pakistan
    12
  9. try "air strike" again, kill another crow
    12
  10. it showed: Indian army violated LAC entered China side and attacked China PLA first. Indian army got a befitting response from China, results were 20 killed 96 wounded, 10 captured.
    11
  11. This is for the new type of a heavy military helicopter, since old one with the same class of Apach,7-8 tons, is not good for the high altitude areas, new one is called WZ 21, more than 10 tons, with much more powerful engines, and can carry more weapons for anti tanks.
    10
  12. Tea party soon!
    9
  13. it is NOT true, It was INDIA who brought Kashmir Issue to the UN first, if India claim it is India internal affair, why India asked UN for help at first place?? The United Nations has played an important role in maintaining peace and order in Jammu and Kashmir soon after the independence of India and Pakistan in 1947, when a dispute erupted between the two States on the question of Jammu and Kashmir. India took this matter to the UN Security Council, which passed resolution 39 (1948) and established the United Nations Commission for India and Pakistan (UNCIP) to investigate the issues and mediate between the two countries. President Xi just just stated the China's position based on UN resolution, it is INDIA who changed its position on the Issue, and violated UN resolution!
    9
  14. yeah, right, China just reported the first half year with growth rate of 5.0%, with an economic size 5 times of India
    9
  15. last 5 km, it was off the course, which can only mean it was crashed.
    8
  16. after this war, there will be no more LAC, but solid border line, and China and India will live peacefully for the next 100 years until there is no India in the surface of the earth anymore.
    8
  17. 11 killed built by the Mumbai-based Anupam Cranes
    7
  18. oops. so disappointing to Indians (obviously he had lots of difficulties of understanding that English with very strong accent)
    7
  19. India government needs to cut down buying Rafale ($250 million each), save that money to subsidize farmers. calculate how many farmers it can help with $250 million just by cutting buying 1 Rafale.
    7
  20. Birender Singh Dhanoa should be fired long time ago, under his leadership, IAF got nothing but losses and humiliations. No need to mention large number of crashed of IAF jets under his leadership which showed that he has no idea how to manage the service and maintains part of the IAF jets , just in 2019 alone, IAF's so called "airstrike" showed very poor plan, and even worse execution, totally missed the target, not killed a single "terrorist" but a poor unlucky crow and some pine trees with so called "smart bombs" with huge jet formations with Mirage 2000, su-30 MKIs and early warning planes, and even right after that, the air battle again lost everything did not achieve anything except the pilot was invited unwillingly to have "delicious" tea in Pakistan, with a Mig 21 shot down, a helicopter was shot down by India's own missile, to save face and whole India made a lie saying they shot down an F16, which cannot fool anyone buy themselves, it showed a total mess of IAF under Birender Singh Dhanoa's leadership.
    7
  21. India's problem is more fundamental, they are: 1. Hinduism ,there is no science and logic in it, those are the key essential factors for building a modern country. 2. western style "democratic" political system, under this system, not very intelligent people get elected, since in a society most intelligent people is not majority, in a developed country with highly educated population, it could be fine, but in India with huge uneducated and less educated population, they would elect what they like or sound good to them, not a really intelligent one, Such as Mr. Modi, obviously most of his policies are failed, however, he claimed he had the most votes in the world, but if he cannot run a country well (already past 5 yrs), what most vote good for?? also under this system, people judge by western standard, not by reality in India as, Author pointed out, for all regulations that restricted the release the energy for productivity, however, under western style "politically correctness", no one can change those unrealistic rules.
    6
  22. what is the evidence, you have a photo image of it?
    6
  23.  @sidkapoor4713  :)) with your mouth?? go to threat 3 yrs old
    6
  24.  @SKumar-mj6gf  nonsense, Shimla agreement is just for cease fire, nothing to do with status of Kashmir, India changed Status quo unilaterally on Kashmir.
    6
  25. and some Chinese submarines you do not see under water. Under Modi, India military getting weaker and weaker compare to China daily. China just sold dock lander with 25000 tons to Thailand (China will build it for Thailand the contract was signed a few days ago). Beside over 50 type 052 frigates with over 8000 tons, China will have 8 type 055 with over 12000 tons, India do not even have this kind warship in paper. India navy just no match to PLAN, India navy is welcome to SCS, but will be totally useless, not a threat to China at all but only practicing targets.
    6
  26. the problem is India's wallet is very small.
    6
  27. India's scientist's level is so low, there is no water lake in the moon, only water molecules were found, 40 yrs, ago with Soviet Union's Lunar 24 program in 1978.
    6
  28. globe hunger index just released, for total 117, India is very near bottom at 102, Pakistan is better than India at 94. China at 25.
    6
  29. compare India GDP under Congress and BJP, from 2007-2014 under Congress, India GDP increased 1.68 times, from $1216.74 Billion to $2039.13 Billion from 2014-2020, under BJP, India GDP increased 1.29 times, from $2039.13 Billion to $2,622.98B.  considering affected by the pandemic, so just compare to before the pandemic, from 2014 to 2019, it is 1.41 times, still less than the growth under Congress.
    6
  30.  Manoj Reddy  that is why it crased
    5
  31. ooops, now In dians should know what "freedom of navigation" means, it happened in SCS, now in Indian Ocean, meaning, US warships have total freedom to go anywhere they want to, no laws from any other country for them to follow, does not matter you are in Quad or not.
    5
  32. this shows how stupid the 2017 Doklam incident caused by India was, at that time, China's road was just for a patrol since before the patrol was on foot, with the road PLA can use patrol cars, no importance in war since is it only 150 meters from the border, in war the first thing will be destroyed. However, the over reaction of India made China realize India consider this is essential for India, that why India stayed there for over 2 months no matter what China said to them they would not withdraw until China seriously prepare war for it, anyway, from that time, thanks to India's reaction, China put a lot of efforts in building Doklam into a solid military base and in war certainly it will be used for China to cut off Siruguli corridor
    5
  33. "The analyses find that India’s cumulative COVID deaths by September 2021 were 6-7 times higher than reported officially." _____"Science" Jan 6, 2022
    5
  34.  @thomasranjit7781  why it is your business?? i am here, means I can be here, so what can you do?? nothing.
    5
  35. If your SSN strategic road is with so much importance to India, why you let it built so close to Chinese LAC?? in war it will certainly be cut off?? is it your faulty or China's fault?? as you said yourself, Galwan river valley was occupied by PLA since 1962, not just now. Galwan river is only 80 km long and it get into shyok river, China PLA is right there right now, your SSN road is just at west bank of Shyok river, only separate with China's position with the width of Shyork river. India is building a bridge ?? sounds like a complete service for PLA also you just showed at gogra post. that means you spent so much money and time for nothing since the road cannot be used or can be used by PLA to move their tanks and vehicles so you are helping China, since with this road China PLA can get into Daulat beg oldie quickly to seize the air port and may capture some C130s
    5
  36. congratulations, what a great achievement.
    5
  37. in international relationship, nobody really trusts anybody else. especially for India and China, for China, India is still occupying part of China, called Tibet South. for India, China is all weather iron brother of Pakistan, if war broke out between Pakistan and India, China will surely full heartedly support Pakistan to win the war against India. therefore, we do not expect trust from India, same is true, we do not trust India, or until our land get returned.
    5
  38. just do a very simple math, for reach $5 Trillion from current $2.6 Trillion, India needs to have a growth rate of 14% per year for 5 years. current third quarter growth rate is 5%, India never had growth rate of 14%.
    5
  39. this is one of Indian problems, do not know its status and position in the world. It is None of India's business as what China is doing in HK, since HK is just of city of China.
    5
  40. a very common knowledge in every country is NEVER listen to economists, they are totally useless.
    5
  41. it is crashed, lost, gone
    5
  42. From this channel: first 43 Chinese killed then 35 Chinese killed, then 16 Chinese killed, ... now 1 Chinese killed, do you have a photo to show ?
    4
  43.  @worldpeace5853  yeah, yeah, yeah
    4
  44. Mamata Banerjee is very good. Judge him not by what he said, but see what he did on 1. economy, jobs, 2. how he controlled pandemic. Clearly he failed
    4
  45. 1. USA does not pay too much attention to India, Trump does not even bother to visit India despite the invitation from India but he visited China. 2. USA just achieved first phase of trade deal with China, in which China and USA get agreement on intellectual property and currency. China agrees to double purchase USA agriculture products for up to $50 billion 3. China and Nepal just announced to establish strategic partnership during the first day of formal state visit of President Xi (Xi to India is informal). 4. India, under Modi, initiated Dolkam incident did not achieve anything, but through the failure of it, Modi learned a lesson, i.e, challenging China by force is useless and stupid. 5. China tried to be friend with India right after the establishment of PRC at 1949, however, India's behavior showed it does not cherish China's friendship, as shown in 1962 Nehru's forward polity by sending India troops into China's territory. China was forced to have war with India and defeated India, and learned that India is not friend of China. for now China just wants to make the Sino-India situation at peace and focus on the eastern side of China, once that issue settled (will not take too long) and turn back to the west, since India is still occupying about 60,000 s km of China's territory, we call Tibet South.
    4
  46. no comparison to China's, Vikrant is 40000 ton, China's 2 AC, both 65000 and 70000 tons, both are in service already, much larger than India's, the third China AC with 85000 tons will be completed soon equipped with electro-magnetic catapult
    4
  47. do not worry, as Indians like to say, failure is the mother of success, now India accumulated a lot of mother of success, just no children come out.
    4
  48. seems the 20 died for nothing, everything comes back as before as nothing had happened.
    4
  49. his big mouth: "Aksai chin belonged to India" is the part of reasons for the current border tension.
    4
  50. listen to Russel is very interesting : Q: China think India change the status quo first? A: India-China Relations Entered Downward Spiral Before Galwan, since Modi claimed JM Kashmir and specifically Ladakh Q: economical strategy will be successful? A: Sino-India investment is very low already, cannot even meet their trade targets, China respect power, national strength means economy, for development of India's national economy will an indicator of national strength in the eyes of Beijing. haha :)) this guy's talk is so diplomatic, to interpret it: 1. India changed the status quo first. 2. Economically India has NO strength can do China any harm.
    4