Comments by "红火树 RedFireTree" (@firetree2007) on "Hindustan Times"
channel.
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
Ladakh is only a place to draw large number of Indian army, this is a place India had to defend, since it is only 400 km to Delhi, so even though China's main attacking is not there, but India needs to keep a huge amount of troops (200,000 and more) in there, just in case, China' s main aim is in the eastern sector, by cutting off Siliguri corridor from Doklam (80 km to Siliguri, with PHL 03 rocket artillery range 140 km) , to attack from Tawang all the way to Tespur, to make whole Assam under control to make sure this time South Tibet is completely back to China.
7
-
India real GDP is only $1.8 trillion. To judge a country's real GDP not by what its government claimed, but what the government can spend, that is reflected in the total budget of a country, US $6 trillion, China, $3.85 trillion, UK $1.3 trillion, ........India?? $400 billion, why? because India does not have the money as it claimed. or the budget should be more than UK's $1.3 trilloin but in fact it is less than 1/3 of UK's budget, the real number of India GDP is only $1.8 trillion, you cannot spend the faked GDP number.
7
-
7
-
7
-
Modi took all the chances to attends all kinds of meetings, such as quad, G7, "democracy", brics, ..................SCO, but he can never fulfill any of his promises he made to Indians in the election. Sheikh Hasina, did not go any of this kinds meetings, she just made Bangladesh average income higher than India.
When Modi flight to these meeting, he uses his $1.1 billion Boeing 777 India 1 fancy jet. When Xi goes to abroad, he needs to rent a passenger airplane from Air China.
7
-
7
-
India is a country makes mistakes all the time, they do not know what is their defense priority. to face China and Pakistan, India needs most is air interception capability and air fighting , not ground attacking, therefore, what they need is good fighter, and AWACS, for drones, they should learn from Turkey and Iran, develop low cost suicidal attacking drones, $4 billion can buy them or make them tens of thousand, ($4 billion can make 40000 attacking drones with $100 k each) Houthi drone (made by Iran) cost only $2000 each, $4 billion can make 2 million of it. well, it is your money, waste as much as you like
7
-
7
-
Of course, that is a gap difference. Only India in the stealthy fighter era spent so much money on un-stealthy fighter to fight a country with stealthy fighter, the kill ratio for a stealthy to un-stealthy is 1:100, now stealthy fighter is about $100 million each, India bought Rafale for $250 million, so simple calculation, enemy uses $100 million can cost India, 100x$250 million, that is $100 million to $25000 million, or $100 million to exchange India $25 billion, haha :) good deal.
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
India is a country without any vision, in both its domestic and foreign policies. China always has a long term plan, from 5 years to 20-30 years, and work to fulfill the plan, and basically accomplished all of them successfully, India, as contrary, did same, had a 5 years plan, but could never finish it, so India gave it up, no plan any more, instead, Indians have dreams replace any plan, they dream, such as India superpower 2020, and waited there for it to happen, then they dream more about 2030, 2040.........if there is still an India by that time.
It is the same in foreign policy, "India does not have a foreign policy and does not have a forward looking policy that is designed to have some control the external environment to shape that environment in way to raise India's interest , India becomes a passive observer of what is happening" , ____Fareed Zakaria, CNN
7
-
7
-
Modi is not good at wa.r at all, here is the proof,
All of the Indian Army's victories occurred under Nehru's leadership, not the BJP's. These victories include reclaiming Goa in 1962, securing Bangladesh's independence in 1971, and the success in the Kargil War in 1999.
In contrast, the BJP's actions have been less successful. For instance, in 2017 during the Doklam standoff, the army withdrew following China's final warning. Today, the Chinese PLA remains stationed in Doklam, transforming it into a fortified military base and constructing multiple villages in the area.
In 2019 Barakot air strike totally failed, with no target destroyed but with a mig 21 shot down, with its pilot invited to taste Fantastic tea, and lost a helicopter with total 9 on board, completely a disaster for IAF.
Furthermore, in May 2020, 72 Indian soldiers were wounded by PLA forces and hospitalized at Pangong Lake. Then, on June 15-16, 20 soldiers were killed, and 200 others were captured by the PLA. This information was reported in The Express Tribune article dated October 10th, 2021, titled "Indians furious..."
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
let me explain why we build the birdge, In China side we have a strategic road called G 219, which is why China fought India in 1962 to get Aksai chin back to China, G219 is a major reason, since it is the road connect Xinjiang and Tibet, G 219 pass right at the east bank of Pangong Lake, from there the paved road to the finger regions, and from the bridge build, PLA heavy tanks, such T99A and T96B can get to the area near Chushul and Rezang La quickly.
then next stop will be Leh, ....................then Delhi.
7
-
7
-
7
-
India army in history won over much weaker army, in 1971, very difficult even today to fight a war with so much distance in part, in 1999, due to the forbidden of US would not allow PAF to use US jets in fighting, in much claimed 1967, it was not even qualified as a war, it was a border skirmish with each other side shot some shells to each other, no ground attack what so ever, but since India has nothing else to boast, in 1962, ok ok no need to mention it, but in coming war, we will not take any POW this time, since it will be too much of a burden to feed 200000 of them.
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
In India, only the party with big words of nationalism will win election, such as make India a superpower 2020, and such, with this kind slogan, it is impossible for any party, either BJP or I.N.D.I.A to show any weakness to China, otherwise it will not be elected. so China and India relationship will not get improved under either party, it is the basic national policy of India, with the support of most Indians, so called "democracy". Anti China policy is good for China, we do not want to have any good relationship with India, due to it lacks any real sense of strength of hurting China in anyway (except with big empty words), at this stage, we will just keep India as a huge market for China's products, and later, after TW, we will take back our territory of South Tibet with deadly force, :))
7
-
7
-
Modi failed almost all his promises for the first 2 terms, now, for the third term, his major promise is to make India the third economy, well, it is an empty pie again, and here is why:
The United States spends 23% of its GDP, which is about $6.5 trillion. China also spends 23% of its GDP, totaling $4 trillion. India, with a smaller economy, spends less, allocating about 15% of its GDP, which amounts to $580 billion for 2024. Although India's total GDP is $3.73 trillion, roughly 1/4.6 of China's, the amount it can spend is about 1/6.9 of China's expenditure.
How much money a country can spend is crucial for its development and national defense, as it reflects a country's real strength. While you may inflate your GDP numbers to make them appear larger, you cannot spend inflated figures. You may claim that you surpassed the UK in GDP, but the UK's budget is $1 trillion a year, which is 1.72 times that of India. Therefore, for India, its GDP number does not mean much since it cannot reflect its real strength, if we assume India actually also spend 23% of its real GDP, then the real GDP of India is $2.52 trillion. Rank number 8 in the world, after France 's $3.1 trillion, therefore, Modi's promise to make number 3 will remain as a dream
7