Comments by "Sar Jim" (@sarjim4381) on "Drachinifel"
channel.
-
20
-
20
-
19
-
19
-
19
-
@Charles Yuditsky Yes, the RN strapped a bunch of L1A1 LMGs to ship rails and pipe mounts during the war in an attempt to throw up some kind of fire since most RN ships had very little in the way of AA guns at the beginning. Even if some of the ships had the original Block 1 guns in 1982, they wouldn't have been very effective against the low flying Argentine attackers since the Phalanx was only optimized for sea skimming missiles at the time.
The introduction of the Block 1A and particularly the Block 1B models have allowed the Phalanx to respond to everything from small fast boats, low flying aircraft not using radar, to supersonic missiles. The Dutch Goalkeeper system has many of the same abilities, and both are installed on RN ships today.
Perhaps in recognition of the Falklands problems, even the most modern RN ships, like the Type 45 "destroyers", in reality the size and displacement of a light cruiser, go to sea with a pair of Oerlikon 30 mm guns, a pair of 7.62mm miniguns, and mounts for six of the ubiquitous 7.62mm GPMGs, in addition to a Block 1B Phalanx. If another shooting war develops, you can be sure RN sailors will be on deck throwing up all the lead they can, in addition to the Phalanx.
19
-
19
-
@jballaviator One of the reasons why my dad joined the Navy was he heard the food was good, and he loved food! The guys flying the Hump lived on K and C rations for sometimes months at a time and lost an average of 25 pounds. There weren't enough calories in the earlier rations like the C ration, and some of the food just didn't taste good, so they didn't even finish the inadequate meals they were given. Things started to improve about mid-1944 when rations started to include a greater variety of food (K rations expanded to 12 different menus, four each for breakfast, dinner and supper, the military terms for the more common lunch and dinner.) The greatest morale boost for the troops wasn't food, even the much loved hot chocolate drink. It was the four cigarettes that came with each meal. For smokers, it was a familiar way to finish off a meal. For non-smokers, it gave them something to trade for food they liked. I'm not aware of any other military that included cigarettes with each ration. Not PC today, but it was a big lift for soldiers right up until 1975, when the busybodies and pearl clutchers got them removed.
19
-
19
-
19
-
18
-
18
-
18
-
18
-
18
-
17
-
17
-
17
-
17
-
17
-
17
-
17
-
16
-
16
-
16
-
There was Project Hulu, the transfer of 149 vessels to the Soviet Union from Cold Bay, Alaska in 1945. The Soviet crews under training were under the command of the USN base commander, an arrangement made clear by Admiral Kuznetsov. Hew told all the Soviet sailors they were under the command of the Americans, and their orders were to be obeyed instantly. USN and Soviet sailors made up mixed crews of most of the transferred vessels before the formal transfer, and several of the first large ships, like the 34 patrol frigates, had mixed crews all the way to Kamchatka to make sure the Soviets really understood how to operate the ships. The transferred ships were then convoyed part of the way by USN ships, and some Soviet officers were transferred from the escorting ships back to the new Soviet ships by highline transfer. So, while this wasn't really a formal mixed crew ship, many of these ships in effect were mixed crews, at least for part of their service. It was certainly the largest transfer of vessels from one navy to another in WWII.
16
-
16
-
Thanks a lot of for answering my questions about the Vanguard. As a Yank, I don't always understand British thinking about what ships were built and what weren't. All your reponses make sense. It's unfortunate that the British government never saw the possibility of the Vanguard being more than the world's largest and most heavily armed royal yacht, her main use until she was placed in reserve in 1955. It's unfortunate that she never participated in the Korean Conflict. The RN might have gained a new appreciation for the need for shore bombardment even without another world war
After a fairly comprehensive and expensive refit, and being placed into reserve in 1955 , Mountbatten and Anthony Eden came to power and seemed to be bent on disposing of half the RN fleet. After just four years in reserve, the decision was made to scrap the Vanguard and, by 1960, she was gone. The USN/US government maintained many ships in reserve postwar, some of which were war weary and completely obsolete, like the USS Wichita, for fifteen or more years before the mass scraping program set in from 1960 to 1962. I guess the end of empire, in some people's minds, also meant the end of the need for the RN beyond nuclear submarines, and that the USN would become the protector of the UK itself. It was a decision that would come back to haunt the British in 1982.
16
-
16
-
16
-
16
-
15
-
15
-
15
-
15
-
15
-
15
-
15
-
15
-
15
-
14
-
They were also lacking in good quality anti aircraft batteries. The original C/30 20 mm guns were very poor guns with a small magazine of just 20 rounds. That made them have a practical rate of fire of only about 120 rounds a minute. The C/38 models was a much improved gun, especially when used with the sophisticated quad mounting. It had a 40 round magazine and doubled the rate of fire per barrel compared to the C/30. Allied airmen soon learned to give German vessels used to escort submarines in and out of the Bay of Biscay a wide berth to avoid the fire of these guns. However, it was only when the German Navy started manufacturing Oerlikon 20 mm guns reverse engineered from army models that they had a truly effective single barrel hand swung model. It had a rate of fire of 450 rounds a minute, twice as fast as any German designed gun. As usual,, there were too few produced too late to make much difference.
The 37 mm SK C/30 guns were hand loaded with very slow rates of fire and a poor mounting with a failed triaxial mount. The later KM 42 and KM 43 37 mm FLAK versions were much improved but came very late in the war when most of the surface fleet had been lost or decommissioned.
The 105 mm guns had the potential to be excellent antiaircraft gun but, once again, they were in a triaxial mount that was too difficult to manufacture and just didn't work well in practice. The gun housing was poorly designed, being open at one end and allowing water to get in and ruin the electrical systems. Too few were manufactured to replace war losses as the war wound down for improvements in the 105 mm gun housing and fire control system to make any difference.
In addition to luck, the Prinz Eugen survived as the only large surface vessel of the German navy by continuing improvements in her anti aircraft batteries. All the 37 mm guns were replaced with the German version of the Bofors 40 mm gun and the earlier C/30 and C/38 20 mm with the FLAK 28 and 29 models covering any empty spaces on the deck. While operating in the Baltic in the closing moths of the war, she was able to do impressive shore bombardment missions against the advancing Russian army while fighting off hordes of Russian aircraft due to her much improved anti aircraft batteries and radars.
14
-
14
-
14
-
14
-
14
-
14
-
13
-
13
-
13