General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About

Дмитрий Трудов
DW News
comments

Comments by "Дмитрий Трудов" (@user-xg6yq8rh6n) on "DW News" channel.

Previous
2
Next
...
All

@Crashed131963 == I'm looking at Ireland being invaded 800 years ago by England. It took awhile but just make it to costly to occupy over time and the invader will move out. I can wait and fight along time to not be part of Russia if they invade my country. == has Ireland had common roots with England for centuries?
1
@Crashed131963 ==All that can be said about the 800 year occupation of Ireland by the English. The hate went generational . Same can happen in Ukraine , they will never like Russian and at 40,million people not all the Ukrainians are moving out, like the Irish did not all move.= maybe it was worth thinking about before bringing your tame fascist killers to the Maidan? a third of the "Russians" fighting in Ukraine are former Ukrainians. from onr, dnr, Crimea.. whom the "defending" manual fascists of the West have been killing for 8 years, for not agreeing with the coup you staged what kind of compass do you use to measure skulls to distinguish a Russian from a Ukrainian?
1
==They want it because they want to make gains somewhere. Taking Bakhmut would help them occupy some stated war goal territory, allowing a potential face saving option if they can hold it and negotiate a cease fire. But Ukraine is unlikely to allow them to keep it even if they manage to take it.= Ukraine cannot do anything by itself. she "can" only distribute cannon fodder for killing. this is exactly what the current fascist Kiev regime was created for in 2014 - to kill and die for the interests of the United States. like any other corrupt fascist regimes, he is good for nothing.
1
@stupidburp ==Saving face can be a matter of life and death for Russian politicians. Those that lose face tend to get tossed out of windows== saving face has absolutely nothing to do with it. Russian politicians are also corrupt (for the most part), as are Russian oligarchs. The West, being in a multi-year crisis, really wants to take EVERYTHING away from the Russian oligarchs. so this whole war is a matter of trade. the oligarchs and their pocket politicians would gladly sell part of Russia. but yours needs EVERYTHING, not some part. so "saving face" has nothing to do with it at all. not this type of conflict.
1
@MetaView7 ==At the beginning of February 2022, even before the start of the war, I had already predicted that if war ever broke out, Ukraine would become like Aleppo. It's such a sad reality.== Why not to Raqqa?
1
@fordfokus9408 ==RIENDS, BROTHERS, VOLUNTEERS FROM EUROPE, ASIA AND THE USA ❗ UKRAINE NOW VERY NEED YOUR HELP IN BAHMUT, SOLEDAR❗THANK YOU, SLAVA UKRAINE ✊== Bandera people now badly need your help to continue killing Ukrainians... as in 1946-1956 until the 46th year, Bandera had other owners... but this is not important, neither for "democracies" nor for corrupt fascists Glory to Streshinsky!
1
@JamesSmith-je7vf ==There is a growing danger that Russia may strike back, as Germany struck back in 1915, using its submarines to destroy neutral ships that supplied the Allies during the First World War.= it is hardly worth equating Russia with the "civilized" West. and the current logistics, either European, or, if from the USA, then by air, basically YAO doesn't bother you?)
1
==2 hours ago THE RUSSIANS OCCUPIED SOLEDAR!== they liberated Soledar from fascists in the service of NATO
1
==Kick Them out ! If they support dictator , they do not deserve to live in democratic nation !== Kick Them out ! If they support dictator , they do not deserve to live in democratic national ! of course. direct presidential elections are a dictatorship , whether it's Germany, where the head of state has never been directly elected. right? or monarchical Great Britain with the House of Lords or the USA, where the dead support dementia democracy to dictate where the right political system is, and where the wrong one is, is to consider oneself exceptional, above others.. I welcome you "civilized" fascists have you not noticed that your old colonial habits have not corresponded to your decrepit capabilities for a long time and have long been rotten by themselves?
1
==Why russian peoples who live outside Russia are with Russia ? Then they must move back to Russia, if they like it so much. When you live normal you don't have any right to make others live not normal== of course! "how Putin is to blame" that for 8 years they tried to negotiate with the puppet Ukrainian fascist murderers, then with their lying masters from Europe and the USA
1
@28704joe =="Ukrainian soldiers are dying everyday cuz zelensky told them to hold there " Not true. They are dying defending their people and their homeland , when you come to understand this you will understand that this war is for Russia to lose.== they kill and die there because they serve the fascist regime that has been killing Ukrainians for 8 years. and who killed more than one thousand.
1
@ChuckAmadi ==Your losing pal. You've (Orcs) made no significant progress for a Months. We are fully aware of mad season and cold weather etc. Orcs are going to make another Tactical retreat very soon and we'll see your posts about surrounding Bakhmut again and again no doubt.== of course, "they have achieved nothing".. Ukraine is no more. there's a chicken without a head... running around the yard. you have connected ivs to it... you can call it "they have achieved nothing" , you can call it "prosperity" , you can call it "democracy" , you can call it "victory". that's just the fascist regime there is now possible only as long as its owners invest a lot so that Ukraine does not die at all and immediately pay. this is what you wanted.
1
@georgekaradov1274 =please list the dates and the names, my dear boy... be precise. As far as I know, the only entities that have ruled parts of these lands sites the 9th century are: Kiev RUSSIA "Kievan Rus" was invented in 1837... the historian Maximovich. he so designated the southern principalities in the pre - Mongol period of the Old Russian state before that, there was no "Kievan Rus"))
1
@cloudpoint0 =As far as I understand, the Native Americans did not leave anywhere - they decided to divide the land in some sense. = this is called a "ghetto" = Ask an American to make sure. I know that Ukrainians did not give permission to the Russians to occupy Belgorod, etc. Damn squatters.= yes?! and who gave Russia permission to buy Kiev from the Poles in the sixteenth century? ))) first to conquer, and then to redeem again? ))))
1
@Pe3rushka =I am not sure that in this direction either side will be able to break through the defenses of the other very easily, since since the beginning of the war in 2014 defensive lines have been built there (if you have played or know the game hoi4, then let's say that both sides have in this direction there are fortified villages 8/10 - 10/10)= there is no categorical need for a war of attrition.. Russia will clearly win it
1
==Russia🇷🇺 occupied oblast Luhansk, Donetsk, Zaporizhia, Kherson, Crimea. Russia must end occupation & keep peace== "the world..." fascist? Banderovsky? to return Ukrainians who did not agree with your (fact) coup of murderers, to your manual murderers? is this what you call "the world"? you had a chance to fulfill the Minsk agreements. but you wanted to kill-kill-kill-kill-kill-kill...
1
=What you expect if most of them watching russian TV daily.== are there Russian channels in "free" Germany? )))) don't lie... to myself
1
==Who gives a $shit what the Russians think - let them go live in Russia and North Korea, get sent to the front where they belong - let free people alone.== go to Ukraine to fight, to your favorite fascist murderers, according to your own logic
1
simple thoughts reach seventy years?... sorry, apparently they don't reach... they don 't reach politicians
1
==“Ukraine should stick with Russia” this old woman is insane. Ukraine wants to change its mentality and its way. They want to become civilized, they want to get rid of that old soviet mentality. They have rights as a country.== you mean that some part of Ukrainians decided to sell another part.. their history, culture, ancestors and descendants.. and started killing all those who stand in her way with the help of the "civilized" West? on yes, it's "get rid of this old Soviet mentality"
1
@terryhollands2794 ==You can find civilized people everywhere, but nations become uncivilized when they are threatened. No exceptions== criticism of the hegemony of the West?
1
@Hunnid24 ==Like forreal that woman is nuts. If Russia is so great, why is she staying in Germany “the West”== don't worry. many are already returning. and the further it goes, the more it will be
1
@Dave1507 == Because it is easy to love and support Russia from afar, having running water, electricity and heating. Erdogan also enjoys strong support from the German Turks, and the same question arises.== with your speeches about the barbarism of the Russians, did you want to demonstrate that Nazism has not yet outlived the Germans?.. it's not worth it. we are aware of this. and, by the way, what about electricity and heating bills? arrogance!...
1
@andersbergman457 ==ukraine IS russia as taiwan IS china. nothing can change that== горбачев... ельцин...
1
@dylanvogler2165 ==because Russia is threatened by Ukraine lol== puppet fascist Ukraine.... do not forget to add
1
@dylanvogler2165 ==what a bs. Russia itself recognized Ukraine as an independent state, Moskal imperialist. I guess Russia is Mongolian just as Taiwan is China ))== the puppet fascist Ukraine was not officially recognized. recognition of Poroshenko's election was made on numerous assurances of peace from the West
1
@wai828 ==Russia is not threaten. Russian imperial ambitions are. Learn the difference. The only actually threaten nations here are Ukrainian and most European nations by Russia.== the west threatens the whole world "such are imperial ambitions"
1
@tommytomas-fr3sh ==there was no Ukrainian language before Soviet times! The Russian comes from the land that is now Ukraine! that's why the Russians fought in this war, they want to return the land of their ancestors. Russian Russians - Ukraine is a new term that the Soviets invented, they used to be all Russians, and Lenin wants to weaken the influence of Russians by creating people called Ukrainians. == the term "Ukraine" is found in texts of the 13th-14th centuries in Polish and Russian chronicles.. in the sense of the word "edge"... states. the outskirts... the concept of political Ukrainians was developed and implemented by Mykola Mikhnovsky, at the beginning of the twentieth century. The Soviet government intercepted the "Ukrainian concept" popular in the intellectual circles of Ukraine, changing it in its Soviet way . . . . until 1917, there were no Ukrainians. there were Little Russians. (great Russians, little Russians, white Russians. great russia, little russia, white russia - official terms of RI)
1
@eremstemero8823 ==Worse!!! The husband started to beat his ex wife 30 years after divorce.== the wife had been living separately with her family for a long time.. on the next landing (neighbors) and then began to engage in prostitution and beat their (old and new) children to death when they began to object
1
@heathermccall8015 ==Let's not dwell on the past, but let's live in the present with an eye to the future. I know who Ursula is, I'm just kidding with you. The mistaken assumption that you're British, mate.== who has no past. he has no future
1
@dylanvogler2165 ==bro what is the whataboutism xD. Russia and Britain both did colonialism. The fact Russia's colonies directly borders it, doesn't make it less of a horrible act. == of the colonies, Russia had only Alaska ==The results of Russian colonialism in for example central Asia and the caucasus are exactly the same as European colonialism (considering the Russians were considered part of the Western Imperialist colonial powers that makes sense).= and what are the "results"? genocide? robbery is higher than the population of the "ecumene"? assimilation? cultural or religious segregation? tell me, by God! I wonder what kind of fairy tales they stuff you with)) ==You are a hypocrite.== either you are an ignoramus (or a liar)
1
@dylanvogler2165 ==you know other countries have the right to be anti-Russian right? Just as you have the right to be anti-American. Or should the US invade you for that? You are aware that your comment is imperilialist.?== imperialism is when a war is waged in order to rob like yugoslavia iraq afghanistan libya syria and many other places rob and leave ;) Russia is not going to rob, unlike the United States and its lapdogs in Nato Russia is defending itself from fascist murderers, American puppets and protects those who did not agree with your coup of assassins-puppets today's Russia is a capitalist country (unfortunately). so she's robbing. but it robs its population (by the hands of oligarchs). and on the grounds common to all, and no more. (unlike the USA and Co., robbing the whole world) imperialism is a seizure for the purpose of robbery. Russia does not profit from Ukraine, but survives. Russia has been waiting a long time for you to fulfill your guarantees on Ukraine. you didn't need it. you wanted to kill... had to do it yourself do not talk about the right to be "anti-Russia", among your and American puppets (one of which is Germany)
1
@dylanvogler2165 ==yes but the terms of the Russian Empire don't really matter. To the rest of Europe the Ukrainians were known as Ruthenian.== условия европы не имеют значения... ))) украинцы, проживавшие на территории россии, были украинцами проживавшие в австро-венгрии- были русинами вы свое невежество за добродетель зря выдаете для вас до распада ссср, все народы там проживавшие были "русскими" ))) (может быть кроме евреев))) ) ==Little Russians is an imperialist term. Thanks for proving the point Dmitry. You are a classic imperialist== Of course, you will not prove your point of view about the "imperialist" nature of the term... since you have nothing to prove it with
1
@Dave1507 ==but wouldn't an annexation of ukraine boxing russia even closer to NATO territory? and the new member joined because of the aggressions of russia. So actually putin himself is expanding NATO. Looks like someone didn't consider the impacts of his actions...== putin has been "expanding nato" since the nineties, apparently))) it was necessary to wait until the fascist puppet Ukraine itself put a NATO base in the Crimea, wasn't it?
1
@Dave1507 ==which anti-Russian policies would that be?== nato promotion sanctions (long before 2014) restrictions on equality of economic activity (ban on the purchase of Opel car factory) coups ... little?
1
@missesCarmenB ==I personally wonder what took Putin so long. He is sure is patient.== putin is not too much more a subject in politics than Biden (a self-propelled grandfather with dementia) putin, this is the face of the consensus of the Russian raw materials oligarchy it was more profitable for them to sell ... however, even now they are doing the same, if possible , the pipe works... the oligarchs, as befits the big bourgeoisie, will sell their own mother and children, for the sake of a decent kush to trade the country and people?!!.. and what will be the profit?... everywhere and always so "they will sell the rope on which they will be hanged" (C)
1
@Dave1507 == I don't think any country can prohibit a company from selling its plant to another country. == What are "sanctions" in your world is also unknown? ) == And why did opel need to sell the plant at all?== bankruptcy was approaching ==Your words don't make any sense, dude, yet.== well, yes. and there is no senseless ban on selling oil and gas... on your globe , sanctions are meaningless.. what do you impose on this or that country for decades on your own whim is there no sense in your actions? or does your reality not correspond to reality?
1
@missesCarmenB ==Ukraine should maybe consider returning the land Gifted by the Russians and also the land stolen from neighbors when Ukraine was a Soviet Republic.== kiev would have been bought by Russia from the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth
1
@Scapestoat ==I am not so sure that that is true. Not only are there documents from a thousand years ago describing the events.== there are no direct sources, as far as I know, basically, it's after 200-300 years "based on" ====AndRurik as a name is very Nose in origin as well.== there are also alternative variants of the origin of the name ==And then there is the genetic evidence. Archaeological evidence, etc.== there is no direct genetic evidence the method of genetic evidence itself, for such cases, has not yet been sufficiently developed after all, naturally, the "gene" of the Scandinavians, as neighbors, must somehow be present in any case. plus marriages in every generation with foreigners-foreigners =That the Russian people are descendant from the Horse is clear.= there are no direct archaeological indirect ones-of course , of course, the Scandinavians were in Russia many times , but, in itself, this does not prove anything except that they were (or their things were :)) ==That the Russian people are descendant from the Norse is clear.== the most developed and probable theory of all , but not the only one == As my intent ws only to make fun of that Russian troll. :)== +++))) I support! trolling a troll is sacred))
1
@Scapestoat ==Norsemen from what is now Sweden founded Kievan Rus== предположительно (Рюрик) с территории нынешней Дании... ...основали Древнерусское государство ("киевскую русь" придумал историк Михаил Максимович в 1837 году. подразумевая под этим Южно-Русские княжества в домонгольской руси. Его коллеги, в последствии данный термин использовали по своему ;)
1
@andersbergman457 == you say that scandinavia and russia should be one. it is OK.== finland, poland.. I also remember Berlin and Paris)))
1
@eremstemero8823 ==Neither Ukrainians nor Byelorussians were so to speak historically able to determine the borders.== bohdan khmelnytsky pereyaslav rada his constant demands of war with the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth. as a result, the liberation of Kiev from Poland and so on. at the moment, they are more than capable of "defining boundaries". they can give away "someone else's")))) ==hey were pushed around because they did not have their own states.== living in peace with neighbors means "pushed around"? an interesting point of view)) == The rules were made in Moscow. == the Russian Empire, and especially the USSR, have been international since the time of Ivan the Terrible and "decisions were made" by representatives of various nationalities. can I tell you who at least the rulers of the USSR were by nationality? ))) ==I understand what you mean but you blame her wrong people. They occupy nothing their borders are as they are because of Russian/Soviet expansionism. == and does someone prevent them from their own desire to remain within these boundaries to give "someone else's" to them? )) ==And as for Volyn Massacre: history of Europe it's a history of Massacres and ethnic cleansings. I'd say let us together end this terrible tradition. Without blaming each other for something that happened before we were born.== it is necessary to "end" the current massacre by the revived Europe and the USA Bandera of those who did not agree with the fascist puppet state coup. or forget about Volyn.. and will we joyfully continue to cut with the hands of the successors of Ukrainian fascism, the next ones with the wrong blood?
1
@eremstemero8823 =="and then began to engage in prostitution (...)" Proof?== proof of what? my metaphor, which I have given as a counterargument to your metaphor? or evidence of interference in internal affairs by the West during the Ukrainian coup d'etat?)))
1
@eremstemero8823 ==Russian historiography is a parallel Universe where history is being written and rewritten many times in accordance with actual political narrative and then served to believers. In Russia there is no such thing like tradition of critical thinking regarded as value.== простите, не вы ли вчера мне полностью слили спор по вопросам российской истории в контексте украинского вопроса, не сумев возразить ни на один из приведенных мною фактов? )))
1
@dylanvogler2165 == about this you are correct as well. Orcs love to blame Ukraine and Belarus for the territories taken from Poland/Romania even though it was Moscow which annexed the territories into these states, not the two countries themselves.== "orcs" know that fascists will never tell the truth but "democrats" love fascists very much, of course of course, the "democratic" fascists will never say that the Russian lands "taken away" from Poland, they can now honestly give back if they consider them "taken away". they will only accuse the USSR (where there were more than enough Ukrainians and Belarusians in power) of "aggression" and will sell what their Soviet ancestors did, spitting on their graves. and the "taken away" will never be given back. and don't even mention such a possibility)) =About Women, they love to bring that up, whilst the USSR itself is responsible for massacres in ww2. Against the same people no less (Katyn Forest), so it is a bit hypocrite of the yeah.== по катыни... разумеется ревнители "свобод" и "демократии", предпочитают версию геббельса, и никакую другую. уж очень явно выглядят предпочтения "демократий" к фашистам.
1
@dylanvogler2165 =="indigenous land stolen by the Europeans" most native American land "stolen" happend when the US was independent)). Also maybe you should learn actual Russian history, maybe you will understand why Russians live in outer manchuria , small hint, they don't originate there ))== "Berlin" is a Slavic name
1
@dylanvogler2165 ==yeah fair enough. It is just frustrating for me as a historian who specialised in it to hear the bs they spread. It is like listening to 19th century Europeans talking about their Colonial Empires. Also hear about the threat thing, I just recently told a Russian friend that nobody here ever thought about Russia before they started invading people. As nobody here would want to conquer them or anything. For a while we even thought we could be friends, against the advice of Eastern European. == tell "liver sausage" scholz (C) about "no one thought" you are puppets. they think for you. in Washington or, "at best," in London. ==As someone who is half Ukrainian, their imperialist bs is just offensive. But yeah they live in an alternative reality where it is okay to deny the existence of an civilization that was first seen as separate 400 years ago and that they as Muscals created it== "civilization" existed from January 1648 to August 1657. and asked to be part of Russia. these are facts that are "offensive" to the Ukrainian nationalists of Bandera tailoring. but you can't refute them. you can only slander them.
1
@dylanvogler2165 == yeah you're right. I shouldn't react on the orcs. Especially not one like him. It is my fault to care to much to try to get in a normal discussion with them. Hopefully in the future there will be Russians without the imperiliast mindset.== among the European exclusives (fascists), any carriers of facts that refute their exclusivity are orcs it's just that you are moral degenerates and intellectual impotents with a swollen ego
1
@eremstemero8823 ==Дима, у меня нет ощущения, что здесь есть какое-то противоречие. Я просто не понимаю, как мы можем здесь, в разделе комментариев Youtube, прийти к согласию относительно элементарных определений. Очень важно, чтобы мы оба знали, о чем говорим. Легко может случиться так, что мы будем использовать такие термины, как истина или факты, но понимать их по-разному. Такая дискуссия была бы не только утомительной, но и бессмысленной. Приветствую== а это всегда довольно сложно. вне зависимости от того в комментариях ютуба происходит процесс или вовсе в реале. везде свои плюсы и минусы. если есть понимание и мотивация к ведению дискуссий на поиск общих понятий, это одно, если есть желание замкнуться в кругу своей секты, это другое. других причин нет пс. тем более, если понимать на сколько высоки ставки.
1
@eremstemero8823 == Дима, мотивация есть. Но нам придется начать с самого начала и объяснить себе, откуда мы знаем то, что, как нам кажется, мы знаем. Например, есть выдающийся российский историк Рой Медведев. В 1991 году он писал: "Печальная правда состоит в том, что у нас нет ни истории как науки, ни историков. У нас есть функционеры, которые 70 лет лгали об истории от имени партии. И они воспитывали других лжецов, которые воспитывали новых лжецов. Я не знаю, как выбраться из этого порочного круга.== рой медведев- выдающийся пропагандист антисоветизма восьмидесятых годов... собственно, этой фразой он характеризовал самого себя, в первую очередь. особенно по той причине, что он историком не был ни в какой степени. "философ", педагог, литературовед... но, по какой-то причине - "историк" ??? он написал массу биографий исторических деятелей.. в основном отталкиваясь на мемуары. и совершенно не большой массив (в сравнении с нынешним), документальных источников. фолк-хистори. так называется этот жанр сейчас на западе. в источниковедении, мемуары имеют "последнее значение" по достоверности. такова их цена. по сути, это литература. в нулевые года (да и ранее, в девяностые. и даже в конце восьмидесятых) был открыт такой массив архивной документации, который обрабатывать десятилетиями. это в россии. с тех пор, историки (именно историки) выдали на горА, такое количество обработанной архивной информации, про советский период, что усвоить ее всю, обычному обывателю, крайне проблематично. но она разбивает сходу подавляющее количество антисоветского бреда, что было пущено в восьмидесятых или девяностых годах. я "знаю" достоверно знаю, что медведев историком не был. он был антисоветским пропагандистом, и с удовольствием делал политический капитал на этом, используя запад. я достоверно "знаю" что те источники, на основе которых он продвигал свои литературные произведения, были более чем не полными. особенно в сравнении с текущим моментом. пс. и да, "партийные функционеры" сиречь, политики, любой партии, часто врут. но вы можете попытаться привести пример исключения из этого правила )
1

Previous
2
Next
...
All