Hearted Youtube comments on The Japan Reporter (@TheJapanReporter) channel.

  1. 84
  2. I really enjoyed this video and hearing what Japanese ppl's impressions are. If i could convey a concept to Japanese ppl that i think would be helpful for them to understand one cultural difference is that it seems that the Japanese mindset is to look at the overall picture and discard the minor annoyances in favor of an overall positive judgement. Westerners do not ignore the minor annoyances and when giving the entire play by play of what they liked and what they didn't etc it's seen not as being negative about Japan but rather than every situation is going to have good and bad things and we see us acknowledging those small negatives as being honest and being genuine. So Japanese may hear these comments and think oh well that's a small thing or something that doesn't always happen and think "wow this is such a tiny thing wow how arrogant for them to bring that up since it's so trivial etc" Westerners hear it and chuckle to themselves and think wow so nowhere is perfect, or well i at least now know this may happen so i'll prepare mentally for it , or wow that's a very interesting thing that is very different and unique to Japan how interesting etc. As a westerner when i see chris broads video my interpretation at times is that he's not giving us the front row experience in favor of not mentioning "the truth" we see those negative experiences as the true full picture without them. We tend to be suspicious or feel that someone is not telling us the whole truth. I hope this makes sense I'm trying to convey how very different our outlook is so that Japanese ppl can understand that we're less likely to think negatively of Japan from these things that they feel are negatively criticizing. I've had way more negative feelings generated by seeing the over the top reaction of Japanese critics of very tiny complaints from my western perspective it reads to me as overbearing , overprotective, and controlling which does not seem comfortable or fun. They have the right to feel how they feel of course as we are different and their opinions are valid but i just wish they were aware of how we see things because i feel alot of the criticisms are based upon the belief that it is showing or judging Japan in a negatively light when it really isn't. I hope i did a good enough job of explaining. Thank you again for your work
    83
  3. 83
  4. 83
  5. 82
  6. As a German, it's always interesting to see how distinct the approaches are with which both of our nations have dealt with our past. On Monday, I will travel to France, where my parents, who are Germans, have retired to. A country that Germany had occupied and humiliated and forced to become complicit in its actions in WWII, but also attacked in two then-recent wars before. one of which cost a sizeable part of the population their lives. A country supposed to be a kind of "hereditary enemy" but today is one of the closest friends on an international level, with open borders that make it virtually pointless to quarrel about who controls which plot of ground. A bit over 50 years ago, a German chancellor who had himself been persecuted by the Nazis, who had himself been a victim, who had lost his birth identity to persecution and adopted a new one to survive, accepted responsibility, as German chancellor for crimes committed in Poland. He himself was not among those involved, but as head of government, he represented the entire nation, everyone, including the guilty. When visiting the Warsaw Ghetto memorial, he dropped to his knees. As one German commentator put it "Then he, who doesn't need to, kneels for all those who'd need to, but do not kneel, because they dare not, cannot, or cannot dare to kneel. Then he acknowledges a guilt that is not his own, and asks for forgiveness that he himself does not need. Then he kneels there for Germany." He himself later said " At the abyss of German history and under the weight of millions of murdered people, I did what people do when language fails." The interesting thing is that the Japanese article on that gesture is but an afterthought and half of it deals with the criticism by the German opposition of the time. More, where the English article on the incident lists a visit by Yukio Hatoyama to Seodaemun Prison in 2015 as a (much later) parallel, that parallel isn't mentioned in the Japanese Wikipedia article, either. It is as if accepting your country has done wrong is anathema.
    82
  7. 82
  8. 82
  9. 82
  10. 81
  11. 81
  12. 81
  13. 81
  14. 81
  15. 80
  16. 79
  17. 79
  18. 78
  19. 78
  20. 78
  21. 78
  22. 78
  23. 77
  24. 77
  25. 77
  26. 77
  27. 77
  28. 76
  29. 76
  30. 76
  31. 76
  32. 75
  33. 75
  34. 75
  35. 75
  36. 74
  37. 74
  38. 74
  39. 74
  40. 74
  41. 73
  42. 72
  43. 72
  44. 72
  45. 72
  46. 71
  47. 71
  48. 71
  49. 71
  50. 70