Comments by "AlQaisar القيصر" (@hishamalaker491) on "Whatifalthist" channel.

  1. wait how do you have youtube if you live in china and if you are using VPN's then how are they allowed in china.
    14
  2. as an arab myself i just want to say that i wholeheartedly respect and like germans, their culture, language, nation and history. i dont live there i visited Munich in the summer its pretty nice and i am planning to study college there when i grow up i am currently 14.
    13
  3. I WISH WE WON THAT BATTLE!
    9
  4. I am Middle easterner, and you are slightly mistaken yes its a proxy between Saudi and Iran, but neither can or wants to establish a caliphate. The Saudis Islamically can they control the two holy sites excluding Jerusalem the third one but mecca and Medina are more important yet they didn't because the royal family us only concerned about their wealth and staying in power in fact as I would recall there was a international Islamic call for a caliph and the Saudis declined that was in the early 1900s after the collapse of the Ottoman caliphate also Iran is as nationalist as they are religious plus they are Shia only 10-15% of the Muslim population is Shia the rest are sunni so its really just a power struggle between them our caliphate will only inshallah come when the Saudis and Iranians are out of power then we would unite the Muslims and became a powerhouse. And yes I want a caliphate our only time of prosperity was under the caliphate when we are divided and ruled by petty goverments whether pathetic pan Arabic socialist ones (Ba'athists) or religious goverments pretending to care about Islam then proceeding to bomb or start/contribute to a civil war in Said Muslim nation like what the Saudis and Iranians are doing eith Yemen, Syria, Iraq and Libya but they are not as involved in libya with petty western borders we are ultimately going to have civil wars and not be able to educate ourselves and progress in terms of say technology or military not ideologically our belief is the same it doesent change. Anyways I don't hate you or like you feeling is neutral.
    7
  5. As An Arab it always fascinates me how close Middle easterners are to Europeans i mean the indo Europeans literally migrated from the steppes to the Middle east to Europe and even when you look at Arabs mainly Levantines like me a Palestinian-Syrian i have Arabian features like Peninsuilar Features like my Nose, Thick Eyelashes, Round eyes, Having a Moustache at 14 while having some European like features for example very light skin white if you may consider it and Blond or Brown or Dirty blond hair depending on how you see it while my sister is full blond yellow haired and we both have freckles and oddly i dont have the usual thick eyebrows that is found within Arabs and semites instead i have a straight sharp eyebrown that is not too tall or too short with a curve at the end though i dont really care about all that i just care about the fact that we Arabs and semites can grow hair and beards before Westernerbut southern Europeans are of same proportions also we are both caucasoid as in we both have the Caucasoid skull.
    7
  6. As a Palestinian-Syrian, I am telling you Syria wouldnt dare attack Israel, else Israel would be in damascus not in 6 days but 6 hours 💀. Or worse case scenario Syria gets nuked but I doubt Israel would nuke them when they cant just take damascus really fast. I mean I despsie Israel and all but their strength in the 6 day war compared to now plus a weakened Syria shows us that Syria wouldnt mess with them I am not joking when I said that Damscus would fall in 6 hours. 56 years later 1/10th of the time thats their new record also I despise Iran just as much I despise Israel. Iran Prosecutes its Sunni Arab Minority and at time displaces them Israel does the same how does that make Iran my ally? Also they are Shia for allahs sake they are heretics while the Jews are the people of the book. My religious conservative father told me that he would perfer a Christian or a Jew over a Shia I agree with him. Since Christians and Jews are our Abrahahamic brothers following a different religion but with shared values also they dont claim anything from our religion which doesent make them heretics there even quranic verses praising christians while the Shias on the other hand with the insults of the prophets wife and his comapnions plus over-glorification of Ali with some shias like the (alawites in Syria who also rule it look at Bashar Al-assad) Worshipping him. Also I am pretty sure that a Arab Muslim would get more rights in Tel Aviv than in Ahvaz. Quite frankly I am glad that Iran and Israel are fighting to me its two enemies fighting exhausting each other.
    5
  7.  @kevinyonan2147  Well yes that is true but the thing if you read about the Islamic golden age most of the innovation and arts/literacy were from the Muslims i mean it wouldn't be called Islamic golden age if most innovations were coming from non-Muslims no its the opposite the Muslims were the ones who were contributing the most in terms of innovation and that is because believe it or not the early Arab Muslims had a liking to science and well knowledge that's why when the Arabs who are mostly illiterate Dessert and town dwellers who conquered vast amounts of the civilized world they would always ask them the educated non-Muslim non-Arabs to teach them how to read, write or how to understand this or that and yes its true that a huge portion of their science was derived from non-Muslims but the thing is that is a good thing since they would take old Greek mathematical or sometimes scientific theories and improve/correct on them while creating new things in terms of biology, math and more also yes a lot of knowledge did also come from non-Muslims with education who eventually converted and had continued their tradition of education truth is many verses in the Quran would praise gaining knowledge first word that Gabriel told the Prophet (pbuh) was read and the prophet (pbuh) i am not a reader since most Arabs and people at that time weren't literate because they didnt have the capability or access so point is this shows the importance of reading and in general gaining knowledge in the Quran and in Islamic Tradition and also in the Islamic golden age its in the Arab Empires/Caliphates that Arabs became the most educated, innovative and prestigious in the world and its where the importance of the Arabic language started to arise as the Muslims would translate many books and works of Science/literature from other countries and languages to Arabic and because of the importance of Arabic within the caliphate many Greeks and Persians with knowledge of other languages started to publish and translate books to Arabic increasing the importance of Arabic in terms of Science and literature so yeah your right i am just giving slightly more details and i am adding into what you were saying i really we hope We Arabs and Muslims as a whole could re-create our amazing civilization that united us instead of Plunging ourselves into more disunity and conflict. Anyways Salam from a Palestinian-Syrian Arab i hope you have a great day sir and thank you for sharing your information/opinion on the matter.
    5
  8. Yeah I saw it, suddenly locked me out.
    4
  9. This is literally Pax Germanica and as a middle easterner I like it better than Pax Americana which screwed us up.
    3
  10. I was born in that year.
    3
  11. As an Arab i couldnt have said it better my self, we are a large group of people united mostly by culture, language and to some extent religion since there are many Arab christians that are treated equally by Arab Muslims they are not considered to be less Arab on the contrary i have a Jordanian most likely Orthodox christian friend that speaks Arabic with the dialect and that celebrates his countries independence day even though a Islamic monarch the Hashemites descendants of the prophet (pbuh) rule it he would even wear Arab clothes and the arab headgear on that day to celebratr his country getting independence from christians (The British) which to me shows that this connection between Arabs also shares the dislike of Europeans and Americans every Arab i know including me hates America and we are justified for it though like you said we also hate the current countries and their ruling elites also the Skyes picot agreement has been another source of trouble when ISIS started invading they on tape were at the Syrian-Iraqi border where they removed the barbed wire seperating the countries then they talked about colonialism and how they are removing Europran drawn borders and are uniting the people which is unironically what most Arabs tried to achieve first with Pan-Arab nationlism post ww2, 50s and 60s with the Ba'ath party lead by Gamal abd al nasser gaining momentum but they failed then after secular nationlism came a strong religious revival in which radicals took advantage of and had tried to unite the Arabs through that and it led to even more chaos. It's apparent that the source of conflict is disunity and Skyes-picot, which divided people and put other people who dont like each other together.
    3
  12. I mean sort of? Because Bosniak Nationalism had Islamic elements, many of the bosniak nationalists were doing Jihad and were supported by Arab Muslims solely on religion so in some way it isnt.
    3
  13.  @aristocraticrebel  Because as a Arab i like the Germans and i have massive respect for Wilhelm II, the Kaiser Reich, Otto Von Bismarck and Preussen they are basically my favorite empires of course after the Rashidun and Abbasid caliphates and are tied with the Ottomans dont ask why i have a fascination with German Culture, people, language and history for the most part. The Germans are my favorite Europeans i hold deep respect and liking towards them they are a great noble people that have innovated, created and dominated their technology is Amazing and their country is beautiful also my hatred towards the French is one reason but its mostly because i really like them (the Germans) I am currently learning German and can speak it to some extent. Hallo, Ich Heisse Hisham und ich bin vier zehn jahre alt. Ich mag deutsch kulture, volk, Sprache und land.
    3
  14. Even as a Muslim I always found the Christian view to be historically intresting, I of course disagree on many topics but thats not the thing the only thing As christianity and Jesus has a place Islamically and in the Quran, non theless we both worship the god of Abraham in our own way. I have 3 Arab christian Friends in a majority Arab Muslim school and everyone gets along, you can almost tell no difference between the Arab christians and Muslims. They both say well not very apropriate words, they both like football and they both despise Arabic class (yes even us Arabs who know the language find Arabic hard) also both of them always want to play football (the real football where we actually use our foot not our hand for 95% of the game), the local dialects are similar and each one respects the other and oh yeah everyone is racist like they would insult white people, black people, brown people everyone even other Arabs, If I am being honest I might have partaken in the racism but thats another thing. edit: (non of this is relevant to the video I just wanted to share my experience with my fellow Arabs who are: racist, say not very nice words and love football (the actual football)
    3
  15. Well about Islam it clearly respects Science i mean one just has to look at the old Caliphates and the amazing inventions like Algebra, many modern Surgerical tools that we currently use, the study of the Eye which gave way to the invention of the Camera, first continous University in mid 9th century by a Muslim women alot of innovations also first word angel Gabriel told to Mohammed (pbuh) was read which would emphasize the importnace of reading as well as knowledge and there are hadiths and Verses in the Quran that show us the importance of science i mean i come from a religious Muslim family my father is a religious Muslim yet he graduated in Imperial college London with a masters degree on Aeronotics engineering and he really cares about science and well Math but he cares about religion more though that doesent mean he doesent care about knowledge if anything he really cares about it he even teaches my sister math and science since 3rd grade till now she's grade 6 now he knows that she can marry and have her husband provide for her when she grows up yet he is still insistent on teaching and educating her and sending her to college/university same with me also no offence but in the first 400 years of Islam the most important innovations that pretty much affect our world and western civilization since the renaissance started when science as well as arts an literature brought from the crusaders has been one of the factors with the renaissance also the amount of Innovations and things create by the Muslims just after they started in a span of just a few centuries is Insane if you would take a glimpse at it.
    3
  16. From a Arab i want to ask you this, so just like your saying that in the west they need to try and make christianity more compelling with the modern industrial world well can you talk about the same thing but from a middle eastern Islamic perspective, now i have seen your videos but you never directly talked about it i am just asking if you could talk about the problems about the ideology of the middle east in detail and then talk about how the middle east can prosper and how its problems can be solved and also what do you think about Islam? Do you hate it or are you neutral about it or do you see it okay? trust me i wont hate you if you say your opinion just be respectful like dont insult or be rude just be polite and critical i want to hear your opinions on these matters.
    2
  17. James bonds missions are impossible, but not going crazy after watching your videos sure is a impossible mission.
    2
  18. There is nothing called ''Post-apocalyptic Australlia'' since Australlia it self is post-apocalyptic.
    2
  19. Abrahamic what? Why are you denying the truth bud?
    2
  20. Whats even weirder is that me An Arab, I have grown to really appreciate German culture, language and Empire and to me Bismarck is one of my favourite Historical Generals and is someone who i have alot of respect for and also i really like the German Empire and the one that Formed it as well as its predecessor Pruessen. In conclusion i think Germans are incredible people very intelligent and organized with a great culture and are pretty much the only Europeans that i really like well apart from Bosniaks, Russians and Poles. Sadly today the pathetic republic importing people on a mass scale and refusing to assimilate them is slowly destroying the country yes i do realize many of the migrants are Arabs and yes this is friendly fire but i think that they dont belong there and i think that they dont even want to be there they were forced to go there because of Political instability and civil wars that have been fueled by America and Russia while Germany takes the burden of accepting refugees instead of America which just entered the middle east killed many of my people and tortured them in very inhumane ways then just got out while still being the ''good guys'' if any American wonders why i hate his country well this is why. I think that the German goverment today is a Amercan client/puppet state i mean its the same goverment of Western Germany and if it wasnt directly a client state then pshycologically it is just look at their liberalization process, at the Americanization of their country and their at how they shame their great Monarchs and their founding father (Otto Von Bismarck) i believe Germany at its peak was the KaiserReich not the constant war mongering Nazis and not the extremly liberal and Culture hating Democracy no just Imperial Germany thats the solution at least in my opinion your opinion may differ we all have different opinions and must accept eachothers opinions and not be biased idiots Ich respekt und mag deine culture und volk, du (Deutsche Volke) müsst deine kulture bewahren weils es gerade aussterben wird
    2
  21. I live in Dubai yet there are still no food shortages and no instability prices increased of course in the past couple years but Food is still available and everything seems stable. edit: I don't agree with your analysis also my country is great at diplomacy and are rich so they can handle themselves but i don't know about other Middle eastern Nation
    2
  22. I love this, the German people dominate everything they always should have dominated everything.
    2
  23. @Prasanth Thomas thats not true Many Muslims are also educated in the Arab world also Christians in Syria especially are mostly Urbanized and they make a Minority usually 1/10th in places like Syria or egypt while the Muslims spread all over the country in the cities and in the rural areas also under periods of European colonization they were perfered over the Muslims and also they have a higher incentive to go to the christian west than for a Muslim also today at least thats not the case at all in my class for example we have 3 arab christians 1 of them is the very smart guy the next is Average and the other is below Average while with the Muslims who are the majority same pattern smart kids, average and then below Average even in egypt where a scientist won a noble prize was a Muslim not a coptic christian also the Christians themselfs some of whom are descendants of Italians and Greeks whom have settled in the Levant at one point or the other also you lack any evidence i mean that woouldve been believable in the 1900s but today no.
    2
  24.  @54032Zepol  yes you should shiver since our Pan-Arabic state would most certainly include al-Andalus, i am assuming your Spanish since they obviously hate Arabs and not a Latino since they like them and since millions of Latinos have arab ancestry anyway
    2
  25. In your map of Orthodoxy is wrong, i mean Albania is more than 50% Muslim like half of Muslim the rest are atheist and few Christians same with Bosnia Half Muslim and rest is Serbo-Bosniak orthodox like 25-35% and then the rest in the west is Bosniak-croat Catholic like 15-25% then Kosovo is like 90% + Muslim and alot of Muslims in North Macedonia and Bulgaria.
    2
  26.  @hebahayed363  In his video of Islamic civilization he said that Ali R.A is the Prophet's (pbuh) friend and that the dispute was between the prophets (pbuh) Friend Ali and the prophet's (pbuh) Daughter Fatima R.A which is wrong because Ali R.A is his cousin and his daughter was married to Ali so how would two married people have this kind of dispute?! also the dispute mainly was between Abu Bakr R.A and Ali R.A even that isn't really true as its a Biased View held mostly by Shia's who make only 15% of Muslims unlike the 85% of Sunnis like me and most likely you who disagree or dont really share the same view and for a so called professional historian that doesent have a college degree this is a disgrace also he himself said that he is not a expert on medieval Islamic theology he could have made a collab with various Islamic history channels like Al-Muqadimah like he did before on different video but for this one he decided to solo it.
    2
  27. The title: New Caliphate Me: NICE Please dont take this seriously I am just making a friendly comment
    2
  28. yeah i am a Muslim and i was just curious of the Videos and the comment section, i expected most of the comment section to be toxic at Islam and i was right btw your part of the toxicity in this comment section.
    2
  29. The Ottomans: The Catholics biggest rival but the Protestant's best friend.
    2
  30. I dont like the current thing in the arab world, I want to go back to the 8th or 9th century.
    2
  31. Oh sh*t just realized that lmao.
    2
  32. Don't date or get into relationships before marriage just grow up focus on yourself on your education then get a degree and a job become financially stable then marry you dont have to ''date'' or to ''be in relationships before marriage'' thats sinful just follow what god told us to do and then you would be much happier and more fulfilled.
    2
  33. I am sorry i disliked i mean for a professional Historian to say the Abbasids were once Shia and that there was a split on whether the rule after the death of the prophet (pbuh) was with Ali R.A who you said is his friend and Fatima R.A who is her daughter Bro Ali R.A is his cousin and Fatima R.A his daughter is married to Ali and also thats only a Shia Arguement and also its Between Abu Bakr R.A and Ali R.A which is again only mostly from a shia perspective so yeah i mean my trust in you has declined i mean everytime you make about Arab or Muslim related videos you always get it wrong only some parts right but mostly wrong its sad that you cant depicts my civilization properly without making alot of mistakes and stating incorrect or overexaggerated or just inaccurate statements i mean the Arab world is capable of making a bicycle we do have factories we are not retard religious Fanatics like you picture us to be, You spole so nicely of America and the west and you never make mistakes so please dont talk about Islamic civilizations if you were going to make dumb mistakes and say incorrect or biased viewpoints that have little factual evidence just stick to talking about the West specifically America and the World order.
    2
  34. ​@randlebrowne2048 I am pretty sure its not only Christians I would even say that the Muslims in their golden age had the same or similar thought in mind also science was a term used with many ancient civilizations like the Chinese and Indians I am pretty sure its not just the Christians.
    2
  35.  @prateeksharma6706  true theyforced the Sunni Persia to forcefully become Shia and they oppressed the Jewish/Christian minorities
    2
  36. also not having Nazi's who were Far-right ultra-nationalistic and secular would be nice (well at least for 6 million Jews)
    1
  37.  @autoscoot5964  why dont you ask Anarchists and communists who were the first ones to do sucicide bombings in the Russian Empire as a protest against the Russian empire.
    1
  38. BS, I would explain to you why if you wanted. I will do it anyways: As a conservative Caliphate-restorationist I am telling you that there isnt anything in Islamic theology that is against industrialization or or technological development (though not too much development where cease to exist). You dont have to be moderate to industrialize but you need to have the will to do it. I envision a well industrialized, Prussia like caliphate where the shariah is applied as the offical legislative system for Muslims and christians can follow what the church tells them or what their bible tells them to do. Some christians might even be goverment officals loyal to the central goverment that being the caliphate. The Quran is not against science also how did they apply scientific values to the quran? Its a religious book, it doesent tell you what particles or the Nucleus is. The work of science can be seperate from that of religion and thats okay so long as scientists dont create nukes or alter ones nature like plastic surgery or cloning or some other messed up things. Also how do you develop a theory which is not even confirmed then apply it to a religious book, you are just rethrashing whatifalthist arguements I hate it when westerners think they know exactly what they are talking about when it comes to us. I envision a caliphate similar to but more traditional to 1950s America and the good thing about shariah is that due it becoming state law and legislation any bad cultural norms can repressed by the word of god which stands supreme.
    1
  39. Yeah tell Hitler, Stalin and European leaders from (1914-18) that.
    1
  40. Even though I am a Arab Muslim living in the middle east and even though i am 15 I also feel the same and the truth is that its not really about missing the past but your childhood i felt much happier in my childhood when I was much more creative bright and I was much more ignorant but now I am aware of history, present, politics, demographics and more and its the self awareness that made me sad and its the change that also made me sad as I miss when things were simpler, for me this "Nostalgia" is just a yourn for the childhood as it occurs when some grows up its basically a negative reaction to growing up in my experience I mean i like to grow up but i also miss oldd things, so in Conclusion its this innocent clueless childhood where we experienced most of our happiness that we miss which is of course a negative or opposite reaction of growing up which is evidenced by newtons third law of motion: "Every action has an equal and opposite reaction"
    1
  41.  @adamthaeer217  and the rest are Muslims mostly refugees yet they are not victims nah they are Muslim they can never be victims to you they are only evil arent they?
    1
  42.  @moonwolf8470  Why? Bruv my mother a Syrian Muslim lived most of her childhood in Syria, she met some Syrian Christians and went to some Churches in Aleppo her home time no Christian is being oppressed and not allowed to practice their religion and if your talking about Human rights well all Syrians are being oppressed and are having their human rights violated by the Alawite dictator also note the dictator is ''ALAWITE'' not Sunni who make the majority of the country so please stfu you ignorant Burger eating materialistic American also he is most likely greek Orthodox as is the case with Syrian christians your mostly likely protestant or Catholic American so you might not like him.
    1
  43.  @pgetheelderscrollsturkiye68  BRUV SYRIA IS RULED BY A ALAWITE LIKE YOU! THE LEADER A ALAWITE HAVE BEEN RULING AND CRACKING DOWN ON THE MAJORITY SUNNI POPULATION!
    1
  44. As a Half-Palestinian Half-Syrian Muslim i respectfully dont want to live in this alt timeline no hate to you btw in-fact i respect Syrian christians and my mother a Syrian told me great things about Syrian christians and she expressed a problem facing all Syrians which is the Dictator Bashar Al-Assad he is a Alawite ruling a Majority sunni nation you dont find that troubling?
    1
  45. Yes like Syriam civil war where united opposition was crushed by another opposition, Isis who spilled from iraq border.
    1
  46. The Americans going to Iraq us the same as Russians going to Ukraine, since The Americans thought their ideology and purpose is liberating and superior just like the Russians just like with all great powers so Naive, dumb and arrogant which is why to me F*ck the US, Russia and France especially France I am glad their being replaced by better people.
    1
  47. Bro your laugh 💀
    1
  48. why is everyone mean to him i dont get it you just always hate on people like him, he is just saying his opinion you dont have to be mean for no reason.
    1
  49. not for everyone just a minority of people.
    1
  50. Damn as an Arab i just realized how f*cking based we are! I am Pale and blond yet i have Arabian like Arabian peninsuilar facial features from that i concluded that my chad Arabian ancestor had multiple Wifes and concubines one of them had light features which makes sense since most Arabs are attracted to white looking people though that might be true the truth is that my grandfather is a blue eyed Palestinian who married my grandma a tanned palestinian and from my Syrian side my grandma is light skinned but brown hair and my grandpa was blond but brown eyed and somehow my mom is blond and somehow i am plus my 2 sisters well we are still based also your right at the part where we have high birth rates i am planning to have on minimum and least likely 3 kids and most likely 4-5 kids because for some reason i have the urge to have kids also religousness is another reason. I used to have a inferiority complex to westerners now i have a superiority complex since i realized that my inferiority complex is bs, in the end its being a Arab that is based and great. Yes i am kind of a Arab nationalist but lets just say religious Arab nationalist.
    1