Comments by "AlQaisar القيصر" (@hishamalaker491) on "Whatifalthist" channel.

  1.  @StephensCrazyHour  Well I mean that's not really the only reason, in all battles against the Arabs both the Byzantium's and the Persians outnumbered the Arabs by a lot and they had much better technologies so it wasn't that the Arabs outnumbered them and had a advantage over them no they were severely disadvantaged even after fighting the Byzantium's the Persian Army outnumbered the Arab Army and had a Numerical superiority as well as a technological one, the Arabs were like the Mongols they were both Nomadic warriors now the Arabs they were mostly led by Urban city people from Mecca and Medina as were the first Muslims but for the most part they were nomadic warriors who were used to the dessert as well as Flat planes so to them going through Egypt, Mesopotamia as well as the Fertile crescent was easy especially since they are familiar with most of the geography its also they were stopped in Anatolia they weren't familiar with the Anatolian Geography.
    1
  2.  @adamnesico  No it wasnt Iranian, because all the Andalusian and Levantin-Greek advancements were not Iranian. It was under the caliphate that texts were translated into arabic and where works of art, literacy and more were done in Arabic. The Caliphate brought the apropriate conditions for innovation to take off so while Iranians did contribute they did so under the banner of either Islam or under the decent circumstances that the Abbasids and Umayyads offered. Why didnt the Iranians under the Sassanids do the same thing? or how come Greek works were better used in the Islamic world that in Byzantium where even they admitted that they lacked behind, so in summary it was the Arabs who were illiterate who then Islamized their conquered subjects who were then able to in one unified central state innovate. Attributing it only the Iranians while ignoring Andalusia or the Translated Greek texts and the will of the caliphs to expand in terms of science and translate foreign texts and work on what was already established and more while ignoring some of the Arabs who contributed would be ignorant.
    1
  3. No offence there a lot of Biases especially when you talk about Western civilization and compare it to the Islamic civilization also you say that Christianity is better for women and Islam is much worse i mean that's a Bias and not a true one i mean did a wife in Britain have a right to inheritance in Britain before 1870? no which is because Britain was applying Christian laws at the time and also in Christianity general a wife does not inherit her Husbands nor does she have any kind of right for inheritance and also i doubt the daughters of a deceased man get any inheritance or property maybe at times but it rarely happens meanwhile in Islam the Quran states that a wife with a deceased Husband with no children she can inherit half of his Property and in general what he owns also in Islam anything of Property that a Woman owns is for her so when a father died and he has sons and daughters his wife would most likely take a quarter then when it comes to his daughters and sons well his son would take double of what his daughter would take thats because the son is expected to spend that money on his family his wife and kids providing them what they need and want from food to a house for them to sleep and stay in to education to Groceries, then on Zakat, then on his relatives if they need help starting from his parents then to his aunts and Uncles and Cousines then to his Close friends while the daughter who inherited half of what her brother inherited gets to keep that money and spend it on what she wants since thats her own personal property that she gets to keep for her and only her meaning no expenses on her maybe just Zakat which is 2.5% of your money to the poor and needy yearly but even that has a specific timing and demands like for a person to give Zakat he needs to have at least this amount of money for a year before he is able to give Zakat also that applies to the mother who inherited the Quarter thats her property as well but to a man no he has to spend it on neccesary things meaning he cant really spend it on what he wants. Also a Muslim woman once married to a Muslim man has a right to a Dowry which can be a Gift or a sum of money or a necklace made of Gold or a Diamond Ring things like this and also he has to pay for the wedding and unlike Western nuclear families the Money a father makes is what he must spend on his wife and Children and if he does not provide enough for them then a wife can complain at him in a Islamic court and allah would judge him that is if he has enough money but is too greedy to spend but if he is Poor in the first place then tough luck i mean no he is not blamed for anything and wife cannot complain or report him in a Islamic court it only applies if a Husband with enough money to provide purposely out of greed doesent provide that he can be charged with prison for that.
    1
  4. Anceint Greek knowledge already survivied and was translated into Arabic during the Islamic golden age many works of Aristotle and other Greek mathematicians was saved, translated and improved on by the Muslims during the Islamic golden age.
    1
  5. I wonder why Americans are pushing their culture and their worldview to the world yeah its like they just expect everyone else in other countries to be just like them.
    1
  6. Wow.
    1
  7. Declining? Wouldnt say so, its the opposite actually its increasing while it was declining in the past as nationalism was popular, the failure of nationalism made people revert to religion. You wont believe the difference in the amount of people wearing Hijab now and in the past.
    1
  8. True also the British would be cut of their supplies because of the Suez being occupied by the Italians making it harder for the British to fight and making it easier for the Germans because like you said they wouldnt have to deal with the Mediteranean and more focus + more troops and defenses would be conventrated in the Eastern front.
    1
  9. are you blaming the ottomans for ww1? i dont get it i thought it was s european shooting another europeans is what caused ww1 as well as alot of powerful european nations hating each other is also what caused ww1 and ww2 as well.
    1
  10.  @juniorjames7076  Slavs? no also this happened well over the 800's and even then Arabs were the head of the Empire and Arabic was still the main offical langugae and the middle east was still being Arabized
    1
  11.  @davidmays8974  Thats exactly whats going to nd society, de-population and children born out of wedlock a recipe for disaster.
    1
  12. i dont think they can they are just all hardcore Keyboard Warriors Europeans and Indians.
    1
  13. Your forehead is huge.
    1
  14. ​@@gdouble4710 No not, deus vult more like Allahu Akbar also I am not seeking war with christians in-fact I am very okay with them as long as they wish seek peace and not attack or hurt me also I am talking about entire countries not some people who hate me. Also I am seeking war with the Muslims who are causing corruption within Muslim land. A enemy from the inside is a poison while a enemy from the outside is a knife. A knife would cause me a injury or kill me but its avoidable and would cause me less damage than the poison, that would cause me long term affect. Compare Germany post ww2 and Syria post independence. Germany was attacked with a knife in ww2 ( knife being Us, Uk and USSR representing exterior enemies) which made them injured but eventually they recovered from it and now they are stronger than ever while Syria post independence was poisoned (interior enemies like Assad family and the ba'ath party) stealing from the people, killing them, torturing them. Destroying the Syrian spirity and instituions now this damage is like a poison as the damage is more long term than a knife and its from the inside like a parasite. Trust me I couldnt care less about the christians as long as they dont interfere with our countries which they arent but the liberals (western goverments especially America) sure are. These are your real enemies look at how many of you fellow christians became atheists because of them remember what I said a enemy from the outside is a knife which is avoidable and cause injury that you can recover from and a enemy from the inside is a poison destroying everything from within and it causes long term effects and would destroy your ability to recover. We both believe in the god of Abraham we should be at peace.
    1
  15.  rjejrjej  Your calling who a religious bigot me? I have many arab christian friends and they have more in common with me a Arab Muslim than with Western christians. Its true that I want a caliphate for Muslims that extends beyond nationalism but I dont neglect culture as culture is very important and should be perserved with us Arabs our culture is tied with our religion Its our Identity like we cant be nationalists if we arent religious. Also I never wanted trouble with christians I dont know why people think that I hate christians, visited a couple churches I show my upmost respect to them like the Quran commands. Now with atheists no offense but I think some of them are snobs and other atheists are science fanatics and some are just chill i dont hate them either. I dont know since when is wanting a giant Islamic Superstate ( A caliphate) make me a evil religious bigot. I want whats best for us because clearly the western or liberal world order is not doing us any favours nor did western support for the Greedy and Tyranical Saudi family. You have to see through my POV. Destroyed nations divided by petty western borders with divisions and corruption from within the root living in ruins under the American world order while reminiscing the glorious past in the Islamic golden age when we were united in a big Caliphate and were living in prosperity and (most of the time) peace.
    1
  16. your laughter is (no offence) terrifying.
    1
  17. Regarding your point about the 2nd civil war: There is no coherent geography in the Us, the center is dessert, rocks and mountains while other parts are hills or forests or even swamps also the goverment wont just dissapear and people arent basing everything out of right vs left most people dont give a sh*t, I am really losing my respect for you much of this as in what your saying is BS. Also, I am not coping. I am just being realistic. This is really r*tarded, no offence. Keep in mind that the logistics are insane, just becuase tou have rural areas doesent mean you can manage sparsely pooulated mountains of Washington and utah simulatenously there is no coherence here also who said the rural areas control all resources? They dont its private companies and the government also cities arent just useless areas since they have strong manufacturing capacity and are usually ppulated and can easily get foreign aid. Also the military is not entirely conservative and even then they wont abandon their duty for some rebelling rednecks in the mountains. You also severly under estimate technology and how it can outpace old schooled manufacturing In conclusion many edgy losers on the left are just as pathetic on the right they are not tougher if they have a chad or edgy pfp. Also some diabetic middle aged farmers cant really manage a Army nor can degenerates in cities pretty much only smart strong willed people or the goverment.
    1
  18.  @lefterisxanthis3822  I am Arab i can confirm that the Ottoman Empire is indeed Byzantium under Turkish-Islamic management
    1
  19.  @johnnybravo19871  huh? i dont get your point bro most orthodox christians which number from 200-300m are all mostly in Eastern Europe and the caucasus and most so called ''Islamists are in Western Europe and only Muslim countries or places in Eastern Europe are Albania which is by now extremly secular because of 40 years of commie rule, then Bosnia which is half Muslim and other half split by catholics and orthodox but orthodox are more with no prosecution except during war by both sides Bosniak Muslims and Orthodox Serbs though it wasnt religious it was ethnic and Serbs did most of it anyways then well Kosovo which is a basically a ethno-state 95% are Muslims like Albanian Muslim whether you think they are part of Serbia or not they are still Muslim and Albanian majority and if you mean arab christians which number 10-15m well they arent all being prosecuted most Muslim goverments are okay with them yeah even Saudi Arabia they never prosecuted anyone they are just a bit strict while in the Levant, Syria is 10% christian while Lebanon predictions say 40% which equals to say 2.3m-2.6 i think the Math aint mathin anyways Iraq has 500,000 huge decrease because well US invasion then civil war then ISIS popped up but they never really captured the christian parts of Iraq. 100,000 orthodox christians in Jordan where Islam is the state religion christians are treated equally there are churches and no one really discriminates then in Egypt their christians dont consider themselfs to be Arab also most Arab christians are catholic anyways and again most live in Eastern where there are barely any Islamists not even Russia only some small groups in chechnya maybe not even Arab catholics are being prosecuted that much anyways most countries treat it good its only the west popping this idea of oh all Arab and middle eastern christians prosecuted in-fact some of these christians like coptic egyptains were prosecuted under Byzantiums and had welcomed the arabs in the 7th century invasions
    1
  20. Damn the Mongols and the sure have ruined everything for a lot of people imagine how better of Arabs, Armenians, Assyrians and Russians would have been if it wasn't for Tamerlane and the Mongols.
    1
  21. Whats even weirder is that me An Arab, I have grown to really appreciate German culture, language and Empire and to me Bismarck is one of my favourite Historical Generals and is someone who i have alot of respect for and also i really like the German Empire and the one that Formed it as well as its predecessor Pruessen. In conclusion i think Germans are incredible people very intelligent and organized with a great culture and are pretty much the only Europeans that i really like well apart from Bosniaks, Russians and Poles. Sadly today the pathetic republic importing people on a mass scale and refusing to assimilate them is slowly destroying the country yes i do realize many of the migrants are Arabs and yes this is friendly fire but i think that they dont belong there and i think that they dont even want to be there they were forced to go there because of Political instability and civil wars that have been fueled by America and Russia while Germany takes the burden of accepting refugees instead of America which just entered the middle east killed many of my people and tortured them in very inhumane ways then just got out while still being the ''good guys'' if any American wonders why i hate his country well this is why. I think that the German goverment today is a Amercan client/puppet state i mean its the same goverment of Western Germany and if it wasnt directly a client state then pshycologically it is just look at their liberalization process, at the Americanization of their country and their at how they shame their great Monarchs and their founding father (Otto Von Bismarck) i believe Germany at its peak was the KaiserReich not the constant war mongering Nazis and not the extremly liberal and Culture hating Democracy no just Imperial Germany thats the solution at least in my opinion your opinion may differ we all have different opinions and must accept eachothers opinions and not be biased idiots Ich respekt und mag deine culture und volk, du (Deutsche Volke) müsst deine kulture bewahren weils es gerade aussterben wird
    1
  22. In the Arab world here we are the opposite of Europe and in general the Western world (including the US, Oceania and Canada) where you guys are experiencing phsychologicla and societal collapse in addition the breaking of the family unit and constantly changing morality but at least a stable wealthy nation, we are not experiencing that since we have strong family units and our society is far from breaking in-fact there are still millions of Beduoins and tribes throughout the Arab world just like their ancestors millenias ago and even the non-bedouins which make most other people still have a strong sense of culture and religiousity at least when compared to you guys but then you would say that the middle east is not stable, that is correct I said that our society is stable not our pathetic goverments nah we are poor as sh*t unless your in the gulf and our goverments are sh*tter than sh*t it self at least not in the gulf so yeah we are technically the opposite with stable society and all but unstable nations and constant struggle.
    1
  23. ​ @lt851  beo looks and sounds like a incel, I am Arab and 15 year old with a thicker voice than him 💀
    1
  24. yeah tell that to Fascists and communists who would still exist even without Islam and also there would sitll be Nukes as well as Pollution
    1
  25. i am a Muslim and like you people just judge us because Modern Muslim and arab nations are politically unstable because after their succeses back a 1000 years ago they are failing now but they will become powerful again soon. Also no one can predict how good or bad the world would be without Islam i am pretty sure it would be worse but in the end only god knows.
    1
  26. i dont think your predictions of the world being ''600 years more advanced'' are really accurate
    1
  27. And mid-east.
    1
  28. Stop lying about Hamas also unlike the US they wont expell their own people while Israel doesent mind sending of more arabs for jews to replace them.
    1
  29. ​ @Handyman1911 Ah yes podcasters, excited to see the warlord joe rogan take over a couple states and declare his podcasting empire. How tf you know they arent scared they look tough so what? Maybe theh are secretly insecure. You believe whatever bs you see its really misleading.
    1
  30. ​ @joschmo4497 Stfu not everything us about you.
    1
  31. As a middle easterner (Palestinian-Syrian Arab) I just realized something, the west is experiencing Societal collapse which we arent experiencing on the other hand we are experiencing state collapse which the west isnt experiencing now what do I mean by that? Look at Syria and Palestine these countries which I technically come from have a strong culture with strong bonds and a high birth rate but on the other hand Palestine is barely a country and Syria is being ran by a minority dictator that inherited his fathers tradition of massacring the Syrian people while with the west some people think they are women and they are okay with mass migration I mean heck even I am not okay with mass migration to Germany as it should stay German also it became a tradition to hate your country or desecrate your flag like with BLM people also half of western Europe is atheist while the remaning religious are 3/4 liberal and 1/4 religious that means that only 1/8th of the population actally cares about something while in the US 2/3rds are christian but it depends because the US is too big and its difficult to judge like till now the US still remains more traditional somehow than most of western Europe but its okay becuase you have rich nations and you control the world via media (propagating your liberal democracy and liberal values at the world via hollywood) and economy and also products and language why am I a middle eastern semite speaking a mix Germanic-latin-celtic language as if its my first language?
    1
  32.  @kevinyonan2147  well before these 800 years from the 3rd-4th century till the Middle ages and in the post crusades did the Western Christian world really recover also today there isnt any Established Islamic empire and in the last 800 years Turks ruled the Islamic world and coincidentally that was the period of Stagnation yes the west rose in 800 years and the muslims did that in a couple centuries also most scientists and innovators in Islamic golden age were Muslims not christians who took the works of other people from other religions and have used it for own while gradually imrpoving on them and while gradually correcting incomplete and well incorrect greek Mathematical Theories your basically saying the Muslims are useless retards and that only the christians were good while ignoring the fact that it took the muslims less time than the west to become Dominant and the period of stagnation for the west is as much as of that of the Muslims maybe even slightly more in short words your a hypocrite, a liar and a biased hater.
    1
  33. I like your Humor here
    1
  34. Giovonni "Gentile" man I am dead 💀😂
    1
  35. As a middle easterner I declare you as the only American that is actually aware of what is going on.
    1
  36. Just because its good for the Byzantines that doesent make it good for the whole world.
    1
  37. i am pretty sure that all lgbt and social justice people are Fatherless and Godless.
    1
  38. Chad is just too chad.
    1
  39. China: Strong economy, currently united but destroyed society and collapsing birth rate. vs Arab world: Increasing birth rate, divison but strong society and religiousity at least more than the rest of the world. Who will survive or just succeed in the future?
    1
  40. The Slavery topic is complicated because a servant (technically slave) in some Noble/elitist Arab man's palace in say Damascus or Aleppo in the 8th century wouldve probably lived under much better conditions while being treated much better than some 9 year old working in the factories in Victorian Britian and there are many other examples like how many women in the Harems who at times would have it better than prostitutes yet the Prostitues are not Slaves but the Women in the Harems are of are idk Chinese or Turkish or Arab harems, so you are right about slavery and you are right about not judging us to a utopia but again that extends to everything else such as slavery since slavery definetly wasnt the same with the Arabs or Chinese or Europeans. Like My Arab ancestors werent racist they enslaved anyone and had predominantly light skinned women in Harems and I can see why especially since many Arabs are attracted to whites back to the point regarding to the Slavery topic many slaves werent even considered as slaves and also forcing them to work in the marshes in Southern Iraq wasnt really a moral thing for the Arabs especially since it was a Arab who then led a rebellion in these same marshes yet there werent other slave rebellions except for this one as these slaves most of the time had other uses also many slaves like the Saqaliba (eastern European Slavs) were pagans sold by their fellow European Catholics be it French Or Italians to the Arabs, Enemies sure and selling people of your same race sure but trade is trade. I am not saying that by this logic Slavery is good nor am I saying that all kinds of slavery throughout all of human hisotry were pure evil since Free people primarly those who fought in wars had much worse experiences than many slaves by other free people if that is the metrix we are comparing because obviously a Free person who tortures abuses and eventually kills another free person in the worst way possible is no way better than a guy who owned some slaves made them his servants and treated them decently while generally being nice and polite to other people. So Yeah that would be another topic for you to discuss also the fact that Africans want your money not ours is astonishing since we did worser things and also we dont even have the money to repay them for whatever atrocity my ancestors did or ''allegedly'' did.
    1
  41. It Radicalized you to being ''SuperAntichicken''.
    1
  42. When the white calls himself racist and the minority disagrees you know something stupid is going on.
    1
  43.  @Hun_Uinaq  wait so instead of Blaming those who killed your ancestors you blame those who didnt kill your ancestors, the ottomans were enemies with spain and portugal of course they would block the trade route why do you blame Muslims they didnt kill you ANGLO-SAXONS KILLED YOUR ANCESTORS.
    1
  44. Well not really, you see the first contact between the Turks and Muslims was through the Arab Muslims under the Umayyad caliphate and later on the Abbasid, in the beggining the Muslims helped them against the Chinese and from there the Arabs had a Elite Military unit who were the Turks and from there mant Turkic tribes begant to convert from the start of this contact though you can say that their conversion was accelerated with the interaction of Iranians but that definetly wasnt the reason or it wasnt the only reason.
    1
  45. As a Muslim no i would not lose my mind i would just feel like you dont want to repsect us when we ask you to not do that.
    1
  46. Mate as a Muslim myself I am against racism, my religion believe it or not is very anti-racist as it tells us that there are no difference between people no matter the race the only difference is their faith in Allah. Also people might say that my religion hates women but actually it protects women because it says that the man (husband) is the protector and the one who is supposed to provide for the woman also about the Hijab yeah it's a sin if you don't cover your hair infront of strangers although a women has time and must grow up to eventually wear the Hijab also the man has no say he might persuade her but not force her that isn't allowed also the the man and woman must consent and accept the other as their partner so it means that arranged marriages by parents are prohibited if the son/daughter does not consent or want to marry the other and if the husband forces himself on his wife the angels would curse him and he would be sinned as its also prohibited. Yeah but about gays well if Allah makes someone feel gay that is merely a test just like someone who is disabled is also tested by Allah so if your gay and you resist it well its okay and its the right thing to do but if you embrace it and you engage with other men then that is when it becomes sinful because doing that makes you anti-human literally a human as well as mammals have intercourse with the woman never the same sec that doesent make any fucking sense. So yeah I despise and hate woke movement's much more than your average Conservative. Also i think that whatever system a country has that benefits them then they should do that and also public intrest is also really important ad islam doesent say that we must have a Islamic state as the moral values should be used individually more than constitutionally in the goverment.
    1
  47. My country get its majority of food from the US and Russia so i guess thats good.
    1
  48.  @tjmartin8516  True but the country i live in is Rich and can afford to buy expensive food.
    1
  49. I am Muslim Arab if you want add me on a call or something i can tell you some stuff or go to this link its the entire Quran in Arabic-English translation and some YouTube links to Videos about Islam
    1
  50. So we Arabs were barbarians fighting each other then were united under our prophet (peace be upon him) then we had a nice golden age then went back to fighting each other like Barbarians i really dont get it. Maybe after all the Turks would make a good caliphate not us we screwed up big time.
    1