Comments by "AlQaisar القيصر" (@hishamalaker491) on "Whatifalthist" channel.

Meanwhile soviet union beating the right wing tsarists, United states, Britian and France while losing land to Germany ( I dont Like Ussr but i am.heing honest):
1
@demyrg9887 implying political differnces are detrimental to the average person is bs, man less than half of the pooulation voted now if you decrease those who can vote its slightly more than half.
1
I guess your great great great great great great great great great great great great great great great great great great great great and some 5 more greats grandmother was either raped by some mongol soldier or was a s*x slave for them same thing raped, assaulted and basically forced to bear children with them horrible yeah this is why I hate them so much these barbarians bringing nothing good to the world.
1
The Orthodox were wiped out of Anatolia but not Syria? Did anyone realize that? 10% of Syria is christian after1400 years of Muslim and some catholic (French and Crusader in western Syria) rule but how were they wiped out of Anatolia especially when they had a stronger grip there. I am talking from a Arab Muslim here, I have a few Arab christian (most likely orthodox) friends but thats beside the point.
1
@shorewall it depends like Syria is recovering and they have enough arable land to feed themselfs infact they import less good than most middle eastern countries and Iraq sure their rivers are drying up but not at a pace where all of their arable lands will say dry up, the gulf is rich and will keep importing food no matter the cost or will use their few Arable lands with some modern technology to become say slightly more self reliant though Saudi has plenty of Arable lands in Hejaz in the mountains and some farm land between the mountains like in Narjan. In Jordan they will continue to accept foreign aid and few arable land near the river makes them slightly self reliable and as long as the goverment is there and country is stable food supply wouldn't be a problem. Israel country which I hate can pretty much support themselfs with ever lasting US support also plenty of arable land and pretty advanced technology the Palestinian territories can make food themselfs and be supported by Israel who would of course keep sending settlers and would keep the goverment in order to control the Palestinian population as its much easier to occupy them and piss them of even more. In Lebanon they have no dessert and are entirely mountainous with farmland that they can utilise upon pulling themselfs out of their crisis. Only real problems are in Egypt with 100m living in the only Arable strip of land with 100s of Miles all around them sand and with small pot of Arable land bring dry's up as Ethiopia build their dam and with Yemen with a high population, few arable lands more than Saudi but still few and is in war torn status with children currently starving to death. That is my take on the situation so these Famines are a possibility and are not all over the middle east only in some countries. Also refugees only went yo Europe because they allowed them or at least thought so and they didn't go to Saudi or try to seek refuge because the Saudi goverment will deport them and they know it so its not really what you think. I am not a evil invader that wants to replace the Germam people if anything I want Germany to restore their empire and make their empire more German ethnically and culturally not by genocide like the nazis but by assimilation and high birth rates among Germans and thats coming from a religious Palestinian-Syrian Arab middle-easterner. Ich mag deutsche: Sprachen, Kulture und volke. I know my German ain't the best but I am learning.
1
Well if the Mongols became christian and dominated the Levant and Mesopitamia they would casually massacre all the Muslims for religious reasons because in Baghdad they massacred the Muslims for non religious reasons this time they would genocide them for religious reasons and all the Muslims would seek refuge in other Muslim territories or be Genocided similar to the Muslims moors who were genocided and forcefully converted in Spain.
1
actually i think i a Muslim would get death threats from people in the comment section
1
I wouldnt say the ''Muslims'' genocided the Armenians since if you are reffering to the Armenian genocide by the Ottomans well at that point the Ottomans were not at all a functionable Islamic caliphate also a few years priors some progressive nationalist Turks did a revolution de-facto controlling the empire.
1
well what if AMerica never existed well then you wouldnt have a Latin America full of Dictators.
1
This might seem weird but as a Palestinian-syrian Arab Muslim I wouldnt mind this, not because I am a western influenced liberal no I am a hardline conservative middle easterner and because of that I hate Iran and its Shia supremacist anti-Sunni and at times anti-Arab policies, this would properly split up Iran where minority oppressed regions will be able to gain independence or have a say. Now on the other hand the bad thing is that Iran (a enemy) had been fighting Israel (another enemy) and there isnt anything better than two enemies fighting and wearing each other off. Thats just my opinion also About Hamas I dont hate him I just dont trust them and I am not really in favour of their policies and strict control. Its even funny how people compare them to ISIS or something when ISIS had actually mocked them and when many ISIS members were imprisoned by Hamas within the Gaza strip due to them fearing of losing control yeah its essentially a dictatorship with its goods and bads.
1
What suprises me as a Palestinian-Syrian Arab Muslim is how people think Iran really cares about Gaza. I mean Israel kicked out Sunni Arabs so did Iran also due to the fact that Iran is shia and have had a history of mass prosecuting the sunnis whether it was during the Safavid era or post-''revolutionary'' Iran, They treat their minority sunni population like crap and there are constant Lynchings of its Arab minority in Ahwaz due to resistance movements and also dont forget that Iran is not only a shia supremacist state but its also a Persian supremacist state yeah they are unsuprisingly very nationalistic as much as they are shia which makes sense since much of Shia theology to some extent extends from old Persian zoroastrian theology. To me Iran is as big a enemy as Israel and it dissapoints me seeing my fellow palestinians viewing Iran as some sort of ally when they are prosecuting Sunnis and Arabs within their territory and have continiously caused disasters to multiple middle eastern nations.
1
No, I don't recognize France or French people I think they're all in our Imagination.
1
Imagine Islamist or Communist Emu militias.
1
Christianity has been reforming and changing since it started with so many councils and so many European Powers came and also with the catholic church its easily changeable but Islam is the same from start till now and in-fact if anything today i see Arabs around me more conscious of their religion and of themselves than before while some of them would become more westerner (Consumerists, busy on Entertainment and having time for fun only) no offence but thats what most of you are doing for the vast majority of time, so no we will not ''reform'' as in change our holy scripture its the same since it came down from god while the bible was divinely inspired so it will keep changing and by ''reform'' you mean accepting gays and banning all Hijab and being secular thats your definition of it well some Arab countries are applying it and populous sure is demanding a caliphate more than ever before i can say its coming and not it wont be ''secular'' i have no problem with science it does not conflict with the Quran but what does are Gays, immorality and unmodest Men and Women both are equally responsible for modesty.
1
i think its not possible for any Empire or great power to last forever so basically Rome never falling and lasting till today and for thousands of years after today is like saying a zombie apocalypse is possible which we know it isnt unless your a walking dead fan or a conspiracy theorist that thinks it is very much possible and inevitable.
1
I am Palestinian and to me Israel is bad and evil since they're actions at Palestinians are horrifying which makes sense for me to say since I am Palestinian, but to hear Whites joining my side well I don't mind I just don't know why? Like how does this affect you at all?
1
As a Palestinian Syrian yeah nah i am glad that the Islamic invasions happened and that the Arabs took the Levant thats my opinion your probably have a different opinion lets not fight and agree to disagree
1
@JLudwig-c4l they are gaining independece of the US dollar, Big achievement if you ask me.
1
About the Islam part, well as a An arab Muslim let me clarify so you are kind of wrong. What you showed was only regarding Iran who is one of the few shia states while other countries shia or sunni have more rleigiousity. Actually many Syrians and other arabs didnt start wearing hijab properly until recently, now is it (faith/religiousity) lower? Well it fluctuates from time to time but faith in Islam had not crumbled only in iran maybe but other places people are still devoted. From what I am seeing, there is a strong resurgence actually no kidding there is a resurgence from one group in the youth and a decline in another group though overall it varies and fluctuates. Even if there was a decrease religiousity will come back either ways and it will never exceed a certain low especially when we believe that god sends a good righteous believer every 100 years to re-kindle faith in Islam.
1
Well jolly heretic looks like an incel and physicslly unfit.
1
@useful_finds_11 If you Include Communism, fascism that's if you include them as well as Romans and Modern western civilization (renaissance-present) which are a must then Definitely not and if you don't include (communism and fascism) them but only include mass colonization and what the Romans did in terms of you know Genociding the Gaul's, Egyptian natives, the Carthaginians then also not that includes Mass slavery which in treatment was worse than how Modern western Civilization like from 800 years ago to now and some other civilizations at time who practiced slavery had treated their slaves so with Only Romans and modern western civilization which to me is (renaissance-Present) still not most Humane i mean you cant exactly measure by what metric since colonization was at a really massive scales and small or not so major factors like expulsion of Muslims and Arabs from Levant by Massacring them and Jews as well then Expulsion from Iberia them and Jews who were experiencing a golden age of Jewry under Muslim Al-Andalus not saying were always nice were the Arab caliphates and like the major ones like only (Rashidun, Umayyad and Abbasid) were the greatest Islamic empires and most influential in terms of territorial expansion, in Human rights well ignoring Slavery there was a stable and fair court also non-Muslims only those who were middle aged or like young adults who were middle class or wealthy and healthy payed Jizya tax otherwise the Sick, poor, kids, women and old didnt have to pay and to some extent not too much the Turks before ww1 but with Muslims in India who were mostly Turkic not Turkish but Turkic and Afghan Nomads of course Genocided the Indians just like every other Barbarian or nomadic group that invaded India they all did mass Genocide whether Muslim or Christian or whatever affiliation a good example are the Aryans from central Asia Before in 1500 BCE. But still not Sinless of course every Civilization is sinful but to claim that yours is Better and the most humane is just a big Bias.
1
Trust me in the middle east we are also dumber than our ancestors, A millenia ago was our glory the height of our civilization now we are just living in western civilization with a western curriculum and for the most part western styled governments. I hate many things that the west had done in terms of politics and say history with you know invasion of Iraq, creation and funding of Israel colonization and betrayl of the British who promised a unified state instead lied to us, split our countries into pathetic borders creating artifical countries and made people loyal to these artifical countries they also did some bad combinations like in Iraq they mixed the Arabs: Sunnis and shias together and also the Kurds as a third minority well look how that played out then in Syria you have the Alawite shia minority (10%) controlling that is 75% sunni and that also ended with a disaster and multiple massacres from the alawite dictator and his father then Israel yeah no comment we all know what they did. On the other hand I really appreciate the west for advances in Science and other fields. I appreciate how they have done extended research about middle eastern history and origins and how they have come with conclusions regarding our history, geography or function that none of us (middle easterners) are aware of. Also I appreciate the US fight against the demonic ideology that is communism sure the US is not religious at least in comparison with any middle eastern, African or Latin American country but in the end the US form of secularism allows for actual freedom like I can freely practice my religion as in I can pray and read the quran and I can wear religious like clothing without any hesitation. Unlike other forms of secularism like how the French think that not letting Christians wear a cross or Muslims wear a hijab in their jobs or in school is a good thing because they believe in ''freedom from religion'', I still cant believe that these guys are the descendants of the crusaders lol not Even crusaders would never do that. I still hate the crusaders for all the massacres and ethno-religious violence towards us be it in Iberia or the Levant or even Sicily but at least they are religious and at least they would have more respect to us and at least they have are disciplined warriors with a strong belief(be it with us or against us) unlike some degenerate atheist redittor in his mothers basement not generalizing atheists but generalizing redditors who overestimate their intelligence and themselfs. Its funny they think they are so tough because they can say a few words behind a computer heh try throwing them in the Arabian dessert to live with bedouins or even with some southern farmer and of course they wouldnt last a day.
1
As a Palestinian-Syrian (Levantine for short) arab Muslim, I believe in modernization as in industrialization and advancement in technology for the sake of the caliphate thats right I dont believe in modernity, we shouldnt give up our social values and change them with not even western ones but post modern western ones. The same people that spoke against European Imperialism in the Arab world like Saddam Hussein or Nasser are European imperialists themselfs for trying to copy the European social order not technological but the social way of Europe. With Technology I believe that it doesent matter who has it be it you or your enemy you can always use it as it technically doesent belong to you or to anyone specifically I believe in the creation being seperate from its creator just because Nazi scientists helped you Americans get to the moon doesent meant you will start following their ideology as you only appreciate the creation not the creator in terms of humanity not god because when we talk about god we praise him the creator not the creation (humans). Technology is unlike culture or social values that are espoused especially to you and only you. I believe in a united caliphate industrialized, militarized with a conservative society. Christians and Muslims (especially those from the same ethnicity) would get along you wont believe how well us Arab Muslims and christians get along at least in my and many other peoples experiences. I am a revivalist I dont believe in the Liberal project or in western (modern secular democratic unity) or in Eastern (Also modern to some extent secular more in the sphere of Russia, China and the eastern nations) I believe in being our own order. America is not strong becuase of their army (well they are but thats not my point) their power comes from their influence. The whole world uses their money, the whole world cares about their election, the whole world follows their youtubers, play their games and wear their clothes. I believe in us becoming that out own order one that influences the world that is real power. The UN what is seen as international is actually a western (more or less American) invention that influences the world. The US is really powerful and I hate/not really hate the US like in terms of goverment I despise every (recent) American politican but in people well there are 336m Americans from all backgrounds and cultures and many of them are actually nice but sadly easily manipulated so no I dont hate the US populace only the goverment and maybe the zionist lobby as well.
1
@adamnesico your right there would be no world peace as long as Russia, America and china still exist.
1
As a Levantine Arab Sunni Muslim I can relate to some extent. I am not struggling my self but my countrymen who are struggling its pretty much our faith what is helping us cope, the quran repeatedly tells us that life is a test and that we must cope and have faith in allah and be thankful no matter what and that hard times are going to occur and that we must just live through him and resist. We dont have any type of hedonistic or saddness but sort of toughness that prepares us for the world I am guessing thats what the American conservative ideology is partially about. We are closer than you think, remember that.
1
@thomasthomas6330 So your Blaming Islam instead of Blaming the Genocidal Serbians? Its like Blaming the Circassians for being Muslims because if they were christian the Russians wouldnt genocide them whats your logic?!
1
I am an arab, so i guess i am gonna get thanos-snapped for that video to happen.
1
@dragonofchaos7843 i know.
1
i dont know about that.
1
seeing you have the Imperial Russian Flag on your logo i can tell your an eastern orthodox slav that obviously hates the ottomans and Muslims so thats why you think what you think.
1
@Hadar1991 Your calling the Germans Evil and the Poles good guys meanwhile there are Millions of Poles living in Germany and many more migrating there yes yes Germany very bad and evil every Pole is so oppressed there that they are coming in the Millions for work and oppuritunity in which the German goverment allowed them through the EU i wonder why there is so much hate from Poles to Germans today even though Millions are going there by open borders and millions of these migrants are working and have rights in the country and are able to make money by living there yet they are still hated by the Poles if you hate them so much THEN WHY THE FUCK ARE YOU POLES STILL MIGRATING THERE?! If you hate Germany and Germans so much THEN STOP GOING TO THERE COUNTRY! SIMPLE AS THAT! I guess the Millions of Poles in Germany who migrated there mostly after Poland joined the EU are all victims eh?
1