Comments by "Cole Behnke" (@colebehnke7767) on "TIKhistory" channel.

  1. Most of those have rules on how they can take property, the Nazis suspended those rules.
    170
  2.  @kabedonovan5555  so your arguing that all countries are socialist? I don’t get why you are telling me this.
    47
  3.  @andyknowles772  they abolished private unions and required membership is the sate run union, that’s socialist policy. The DAF had a membership of 32 million. For someone who hates unions they sure created the biggest union at the time. They suspended private property rights in 1933 in the rightstang fire decree, that’s socialist policy. Actually watch the video before you comment under it, for your own sake.
    31
  4.  @andyknowles772  suspending private property? Requiring union membership? Gleichschaltung?
    29
  5.  @andyknowles772  all the socialist policies they did implement, as shown in the video.
    27
  6.  @andyknowles772  my boy, that is dictionary definition of socialist policy, every communists state has had a nationalized union that was controlled by the state. And when a union is controlled by the state its no longer for the workers benefit. I love how your moving the goalposts, btw.
    26
  7.  @andyknowles772 you should actually watch the video? This was addressed.
    25
  8.  @brandonmorel2658  so you didn’t understand a thing I said, Hitler simply combined the two biggest ideologies in Germany at the time. You really should watch the video, he addresses all of that.
    23
  9.  @andyknowles772  you asked for any socialist policies that the Nazis implemented, I provided three, you then shifted the goalposts and said one of those socialist policies weren’t actually socialist when the Nazis did them, disregarding the fact that it was a socialist policy when the Soviet Union did it.
    21
  10.  @executivedirector7467  can you provide a sample?
    19
  11. So you didn’t watch the video…
    18
  12. Did he say that before or after he suspended private property rights?
    16
  13.  @executivedirector7467  so a socialist was in Germany, saw how socialist it was, wrote exactly what he saw, but because he was socialist he couldn’t say it was socialism. TIK addressed this is his 9 hour video.
    15
  14.  @leftistadvocate9718  see the rickstag fire decree.
    15
  15. How is he wrong?
    15
  16. Socialists kill other socialists all the time, so try again.
    13
  17. So you didn’t watch the video? I mean all of your arguments were dismantled in the video. Most of the video goes in depth of what the Nazis actually did.
    13
  18. 1. So the Soviet Union wasn’t socialist? They kill of rival socialist parties and outlawed them. 2. The workers control of the means of production is Marxism, not socialism. And crushed trade unions? Every other socialist attempt did the exact same thing. Class struggle is Marxism, not socialism. Hitler hated a rival version of socialism. 3. Do you have any evidence for the idea that the Nazis used socialism in their name as bait? Or are you assuming what they were doing? 4. He wasn’t capitalist in any sense of the word. He was focused on centralizing the economy into the hands of the Nazi party, aka the state. The rich were only in power as long as they supported him. 5. The Nazi party was largely a grassroots organization until they took power, so to say they were capitalisms most brutal attack dog makes no sense.
    12
  19. Socialism is older then Marx, so to say any forms of socialism that disagree with marxism are not socialist is a perversion of history.
    12
  20. There is nothing about socialism that says it can’t be racist, xenophobic, or narcissistic, and almost every form of socialism hated its sisters.
    11
  21.  @hp5864 I mean, socialists imprisoned and killed other socialists all the time, Hitler isn’t special.
    11
  22. Uh, that’s marxism, which is only one subcategory of socialism.
    11
  23. Dam, it’s almost like Hitler hated communism because it was dividing the working race.
    11
  24. He is an actual historian, how is he not?
    11
  25. So you have any actual arguments?
    11
  26.  @randomuser3481  the most accurate definition of socialism is the collective control over the means of production. Marxism just came up with the idea that workers should be the collective.
    11
  27. Tell me you didn’t watch the video without telling me you didn’t watch the video…
    11
  28. How so?
    11
  29. Tell me you didn’t watch the video without telling me you didn’t watch the video…
    11
  30. What? It had to invade its neighbors and export its inflation to them, it was no way not collapsing.
    11
  31. Tell me you didn’t watch the video without telling me you didn’t watch the video…
    10
  32. How is he sympathetic to Nazis?
    10
  33. It’s funny because TIK is against nazis, you know, cus they are socialists.
    10
  34. Yet he didn’t, as shown by the death tolls, if he wanted socialists dead he would’ve killed them at the same scale as he killed the Jews.
    10
  35.  @thurin84  it’s as coercive as having to pay a farmer for their labor.
    10
  36. Tell me you didn’t watch the video without telling me you didn’t watch the video…
    10
  37. As socialists tend to do.
    10
  38.  @Manny.EscobarJazz links? Ah, there’s your problem. 1. So the Soviet Union wasn’t socialist? They kill of rival socialist parties and outlawed them. 2. The workers control of the means of production is Marxism, not socialism. And crushed trade unions? Every other socialist attempt did the exact same thing. Class struggle is Marxism, not socialism. Hitler hated a rival version of socialism. 3. Do you have any evidence for the idea that the Nazis used socialism in their name as bait? Or are you assuming what they were doing? 4. He wasn’t capitalist in any sense of the word. He was focused on centralizing the economy into the hands of the Nazi party, aka the state. The rich were only in power as long as they supported him. 5. The Nazi party was largely a grassroots organization until they took power, so to say they were capitalisms most brutal attack dog makes no sense.
    10
  39. Did you actually watch the video?
    10
  40. How so?
    10
  41. So no actual arguments?
    10
  42. I mean reality is unfair and any economic system that really goes against that is out of touch with reality.
    9
  43. Dam, did you even watch the video?
    9
  44. What do you think of Utopian Socialism? It was a form of socialism that existed before Marxism that didn’t divide society by class.
    9
  45. ​ @genxploits unfortunately he can't answer because he hasn't watched it.
    9
  46. So they weren’t a totalitarian state?
    9
  47. Socialism divides society by class, Nazism is all about uniting the classes against their true enemies, the other races. At least that’s what the Nazis say.
    9
  48. So you didn’t watch the video?
    9
  49.  @psychedelicprimate8974  so you have no arguments against the contents of the video. Why are you commenting?
    9
  50. Na, he had to invade the rest of Europe otherwise he would’ve ran out of money to spend on all his socialist programs.
    9