Comments by "Cole Behnke" (@colebehnke7767) on "TIKhistory" channel.

  1.  @guerillagardener2237 uh, so the Soviet Union was capitalist?
    4
  2.  @jon82489  you know large corporations and socialists have mutually beneficial relationships, right?
    4
  3. So you didn’t watch any of his other videos?
    4
  4.  @hobbso8508 under that logic we can assume that socialists are all dictators and thiefs.
    4
  5.  @hobbso8508 and since one form of common ownership is state ownership…l
    4
  6.  @hobbso8508  and you don’t see how socialism is authoritarian?
    4
  7. Can you prove that Hitler didn’t fallow the collective will of the German people?
    4
  8. Didn't they describe at the beginning? They own buses and charge people to use them.
    4
  9. How so?
    4
  10.  @coonhound_pharoah but they can just chose to not pay and find someone else.
    4
  11.  @coonhound_pharoah both of our governments come together to a previously agreed upon mediator for this kind of thing. I mean my group just wants my money, but losing fifty bucks a month probably isn’t worth dying over.
    4
  12.  @coonhound_pharoah congratulations you have a war on your hands, and I’m betting that most people under the thumb of your crime syndicate will be willing to pay a lot more money for us to come in and while it out, enough to make the potential of death worth it.
    4
  13. What lies?
    4
  14. You have evidence for that?
    4
  15. Not really, did you even watch the video?
    4
  16.  @BurtReynolds-qp1jk I got to love your ignorance here. If capitalism is the private ownership of the means of production then it can’t be owned by the state because the state is the public.
    4
  17.  @hobbso8508  can you provide contemporary sources that support the claim that the Nazis were privatizing the economy?
    4
  18. So what part of the Nazi party wasn’t socialist?
    4
  19.  @hobbso8508  wasn’t asking you.
    4
  20. Capitalism was a term made up by Marx, so technically your right. That’s because your a socialist your worldview is based off of class. What capitalists say is capitalism most of the time if free market liberalism.
    4
  21. Ok? What has Nazi book burnings have to do with this?
    4
  22. Did you actually watch the video? Cus there is a part where he addresses Nazis were race based socialists, not class based socialists. Putting the working race in charge of the means of production was their main goal, it didn’t matter what class they were.
    4
  23.  @LeeZaslofsky  so you didn’t actually watch the video. Thanks for confirming that.
    4
  24. Did you actually watch the video? Because he hates socialists, and he believes Hitler was a socialist.
    4
  25. What’s wrong with it that isn’t made worse by any other system?
    4
  26. “Cozy with the banks and industry” Uh, you should probably watch some of TIKs other videos on that topic.
    4
  27. How so?
    4
  28. How so?
    4
  29. What makes someone a capitalist?
    4
  30. Did you watch the video?
    4
  31.  @RandomVex  true. I’ve been watching a good bit of WhatIfAltHist and one thing he’s adamant about is how we are in for a era of religiously, wither it be socialism or a new from of Christianity who can tell.
    4
  32. So you didn’t watch the video…
    4
  33. Capitalism doesn’t exist. It was a term made up by Marx to categorize everything he didn’t like about society.
    4
  34. How is he wrong?
    4
  35. Then what is it? And how are Nazis different from literally any other socialist movement?
    4
  36.  @BogdanBogdanovichBogdanov My Brother in Christ! The Nazis where race based socialists. Think about that for a second, they don’t care about class. Everything that you say about class in only an issue for class based socialists, aka marxists. Marxism is the socialist ideology that cares about class and believes in class equality.
    4
  37.  @BogdanBogdanovichBogdanov  “Marxism” and “facts based” are two ideas that are mutually exclusive. Additionally Marx himself points out things like Utopian Socialism that don’t believe in class struggle, signifying that class struggle was added to the concept of socialism, and if class struggle can be added, then why can’t racial struggle?
    4
  38.  @jacobfrancis-burnett6837 so you continue to refuse to watch the video you are commenting under, that addresses all of that? Yeah I can’t help you. Like the video very deliberately points out how Against the Mainstream misrepresents its sources. Like Privatization to whom exactly? Nazi party members who are parts of the government?
    4
  39. Tell me you haven’t watched the video without telling me you haven’t watched the video.
    4
  40.  @ngltbh  yet every socialist movement was funded by capitalists.
    4
  41. So reactionary socialism?
    4
  42. Who wasn’t?
    4
  43.  @hansjalv  you should watch the video, it covers this. Only two individuals whom you could call big money financed the Nazis party before it looked like it had a good chance to win, and at that point it was just people hedging their bets.
    4
  44.  @hansjalv  but when there is no wining option you pick the lest bad option, most of them were bribing the socialists to let them continue operating in the country, but once the war started their properties were nationalized anyways.
    4
  45. Why not?
    4
  46. So Stalin was a conservative?
    4
  47.  @brandonmorel2658 because the vampire economy was written by a socialist, so of course he wouldn’t want to say nazism is socialism. All he does is say something the Nazis did that was socialist, but then say it wasn’t in fact socialist, dispute the Soviet Union doing the exact same things.
    4
  48.  @brandonmorel2658  your conflicting scholar and scientist.
    4
  49.  @brandonmorel2658 so have you actually watched his videos yet?
    4
  50. Dam, did you watch the video? Because he used those sources himself…
    4