Comments by "Cole Behnke" (@colebehnke7767) on "TIKhistory" channel.

  1. Less then five minutes in 4:36
    4
  2.  @sturm_wind so let me get this straight, the paper says they primarily sold public organizations to private organizations within the Nazi party, yet the only example was an organization what wasn’t within the Nazi party? Why are you trusting this source again?
    4
  3. It’s more like national socialism is socialism, but socialism isn’t national socialism.
    4
  4.  @fahrenheigh what is false about it?
    4
  5. How not?
    4
  6. Why did he hate the Jew?
    4
  7. What’s wrong? We know that academia is wrong about the Nazi privatization myth.
    4
  8.  Nicholas Time  how are they not?
    4
  9. The problem here dear sir, is the Nazi used a plained economy before wartime. Additionally can you prove that the Reichstag didn’t fallow the will of the people?
    4
  10.  @sumdumbbeats9879  clearly not, because he addressed everything you said.
    4
  11.  @mostbased but did see his 20 minute version of this video right? TIK explains himself vary well, it just so happens that socialization is a meaningless term. Ask five socialists and you will get six different contradicting definitions of socialization.
    4
  12.  @Schnoz42069  but voting is a government structure. The fact that you organized together to decide what should be done, and that there are no organizations above you, makes you the state.
    4
  13.  @Schnoz42069  the problem is your definition of socialism excludes every other form of socialism, if Marxist-Leninist socialism can be included as socialism, so can Nazism be considered socialism. Additionally I see Al kinds of problems with your system, who gets to vote? You say everyone who’s involved, but who decides that exactly? If it’s for the region, who actually tells people there is a conflict needing to be voted on? If you actually watched the video you will see that the Nazis did indeed practice social collectivism. They said the German race was the social, and private individuals couldn’t be trusted to allocate resources, so insisted the government would centrally plan the economy on the behalf of the workers (Germans). The reason strikes and workers rights to protest are always suspended is exactly as you said, if a minority disagrees they can take it up with the majority, and the majority would just say “fuck you, get back to work.” So you could fight back, but the moment you fight back you become a counter revolutionary fighting the will of the people.
    4
  14.  @Schnoz42069 Marxist-Lenient socialism doesn’t have social collectivism and it’s socialist.
    4
  15.  @Schnoz42069  ⁠let me guess, the Soviet Union wasn’t socialist? So your admitting that the Nazis were socialist in the same way the Soviet Union was socialist, witch is the entire point of this video. That Nazism was a socialist ideology, and it doesn’t matter if it actually achieved some arbitrary goal to qualify as socialism as long as the goal was socialism.
    4
  16.  @Schnoz42069  you do understand that Lenin started the central planning that Stalin later expanded, and it was him who nationalized everything into the government? Stalinism and Maoism were other forms of socialism that came after, and both of them advocated for the government controlling everything.
    4
  17. Can you provide actual evidence?
    4
  18. To him?
    4
  19. What group of strong men?
    4
  20.  @miketomlin6040  I would like to see a political scientist who actually believes the political spectrum/compass is a useful tool in describing political ideologies.
    4
  21. So just like every socialist ever?
    4
  22.  @Loqueteron  the made up definition that all socialist use? That the Soviet Union fell under?
    4
  23.  Caesar  but this was a common belief even before the war. What’s up with that?
    4
  24. How so? What facts has he taken out of context?
    4
  25. So one can’t preform cross analysis on history?
    4
  26. How so?
    4
  27. What’s wrong about it?
    4
  28. Did you actually watch the video?
    4
  29. So you didn’t watch the video…
    4
  30.  @rickglorie  Unfortunately a lot of that was discussed in other videos, but I did specifically this video so, Congratulations!
    4
  31.  @Imbalanxd  but the Nazis suspended private property protections in 1933. This is not comparable to what the US did.
    4
  32.  @slaterslater5944  wasn’t asking you.
    4
  33. Do you have a quote for the Nazis saying they wanted domination of all other races? Or was it that they believed that they were the working race?
    4
  34.  @rn6312 yet they haven’t. Every critic so far has been less educated then him.
    4
  35.  @rn6312  what are some of his criticisms of TIK’s work?
    4
  36. Witch video actually backs up its claims with sources?
    4
  37. I mean he did, democracy doesn’t need elections, just the claim of peoples power.
    4
  38. I’ve actually seen some socialist basically make that claim.
    4
  39. Why then?
    4
  40. Can you provide an example of one that wasn’t?
    4
  41. Socialism.
    4
  42. So what is he getting wrong then?
    4
  43. So the Soviet Union wasn’t socialist monarchists? Of course they are at odds with Marxists. They redefined socialism to themselves after the Nazis fell. How can you be capitalist when you suspend private property rights first thing?
    4
  44. The anti communist right who voted for the national socialist party?
    4
  45.  @milasto2 it’s really funny, because people brought up those sources and where shot down…
    4
  46.  @BurtReynolds-qp1jk you do realize that people revolting against socialism are considered counter revolutionaries and are not socialist? There’s a reason all socialist countries ban protests because any protest is working against the workers revolution, not withstanding the fact that the protest is made up of workers.
    4
  47. You must already be marxist to even make the claim that the working class is being exploited. Capitalism doesn’t exist, it was a term made up by Marx to describe everything he didn’t like about society. It basically means bad society, and Marx compares it to his communist “good society”.
    4
  48.  @andyknowles772 so to you, as long as the state says that an organization is privately owned, it is, no matter how much control the state has in the organization.
    4
  49. Have you ever considered that Hitler was lying?
    4
  50.  @diegogbox  TIK went over both of these quotes in his 5 hour video. Hitler had his own definition of socialism, like most socialists.
    4