Comments by "Ralph Bernhard" (@ralphbernhard1757) on "Vox" channel.

  1. avi moyal Liar... https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/palestinian-authority-threatens-to-scrap-recognition-of-israel-over-donald-trumps-proposed-us-a7548936.html Palestine recognized Israel right to exist 20 years ago, and are in turn waiting for Israel to acknowledge its right to exist.... Nice try anyway...
    2
  2. chained2it Im still in 1919, the start of the current conflict. Note here, that at ANY particular point in time, nobody can foresee the future. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historian%27s_fallacy Therefore, the people who lived in 1919 ONLY had the world around them to make judgements. Correct? So, what did they see? Correct. Colonialism. White people cutting off the hands of child laborers in the Kongo, Hawaii (an independent Kingdom) being annexed, Native Americans stuffed into dusty desert reservations, Moro Massacres if "naughty natives" refused to pay taxes, chased into to the desert to die of thirst (Herero) or starve (India) , children stuck into concentration camps (Boer War), etc. THAT is what influenced opinions back then, and why local inhabitants did not WANT whites to rule them.
    2
  3. chained2it So, still in 1919. Yes, I'm sure that the Zionists who came to Palestine in...uhm..floods from 1919 were nice people. Im sure the brought bouquets of flowers and baked cookies for the local kids... Irrelevant. It doesn't matter how "nice" they were. Certainly, the first white colonists who showed up in North America were also nice people. The first traders and merchant in the Pacific were also "nice". How "nice" these first encounters were, is IRRELEVANT, because the Palestinians had the world around them to judge what came AFTER the first "nice people", and what could POTENTIALLY happen to them too...
    2
  4. chained2it Still in 1919 Yes. The Zionist who arrived then WERE white Europeans. The Jews evicted from Muslim states after 1948 (ME Jews) are not relevant to the events directly following 1919. (See "Historians fallacy")
    2
  5. chained2it Oh, and finally. Eretz Israel is a wet dream in a SMALL FRACTION of Jew's heads. It's the dream of the right wing (roughly 20% of voters). I never said "all Jews". Yes, I assume you right. How can 8 million make space for all those millions in the diaspora, against millions of Arabs. Sort of like 1948. Kinda stupid for 800,000 Jews to declare independence in the face of much larger and more populous Arab neighbours, who warned them not to do it... Wait a minute.... LOL
    2
  6. Sergio Aguirre The Jews rode into Palestine in the backs of the British Empire. During ww1 the Jews were NOT an entity. The fought for, or worked in the factories of where ever they held citizenship. A German Jew therefore sat in his trench, mowing down British and French Jews storming "his" side, "his" buddies, and fighting "his" cause... Period. Those are the facts. Here are some more concerning Palestine.... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Middle_Eastern_theatre_of_World_War_I Well, well...by golly. It looks as if MORE ARABS fought and died for Palestine than Jews ever did... What was that about "reading books". Thanks for the tip, buddy. I've read a few thousand....
    2
  7. richard wilmot Ph.D ROTFL...
    2
  8. LOL...all they would need to do is go to Dubai, or Qatar...
    2
  9. LOL..."installing pro-American regimes in..."...more like instating pro-American puppets and crooks, and imposing them on the locals...
    1
  10. Good and neutral analyses. The reason there are problems, is the same reason there are problems everywhere a large group of foreigners immigrate (or come as refugees), anywhere in the world. The original inhabitants can simply NOT be expected to accept being overrun by a influx of non-natives. Simple. The Jews were Europeans (foreign passport holders) who came in masses as immigrants and refugees....
    1
  11. "There was this time it was a little scary..." Well, little girl. At least there is nobody using your ass as football practice like these soldiers are doing with a little Palestinian boy. https://youtu.be/gvjAE4KV32Q Consider yourself lucky...
    1
  12. Connolly West So a question to the "white world". Why don't you just hand over Arizona to the Jews? You know, seeing how much land whites have....
    1
  13. You can run away from a baseball bat...
    1
  14.  @crossrhodes14  Tyrannical gobbumints use helicopter gunships and drones whih come at night to where you're sleeping... Welcome to the 21st Century.
    1
  15. Md Lp LOL. Talk about a long winded justification for land grabbing. Simple truth. The people who lived in British Palestine (Semites) in 1919 were the original inhabitants. Palestinians. Sort of like when the USA declared its independence and the people who lived there became "Americans". There was no meed for long-winded explanations about what they were or where they came from. Same counts for hundreds of other countries, made of of culturally mixed inhabitants. Simple.
    1
  16. Pickle Rickle Yeah I know. God commanded "Thou shalt not steal....unless you win a war...."
    1
  17. Stupid people. Spend the money on the down payment for a house.
    1
  18. Who is going to enforce a "no fly zone" and shoot down Russian planes ignoring it? Honestly. Stop wasting our time with a bunch of well-meaning but incapable and illogical "suggestions"... Imposing a "no fly zone" over the Ukraine without NATO enforcing it, is like imposing a "no crime zone" in a city without cops to enforce it. Bury it. It won't happen.
    1
  19. There's a saying in business: First first generation establishes. The second generation expands. The third squanders it. How's life in the 3rd generation? :-)
    1
  20. John S. Elfrank-Dana Yup. Interests groups, and "ingroup vs. outgroup dynamics"... Religion is simply a tool.
    1
  21. Hmmmm...the making of a "Stalin" or a "Hitler" all over again....
    1
  22. There will never be peace, because the Israeli society is undermined by a minority (I'm assessing 1 of 5) of dreamers who want to create an Eretz Israel stretching from the Nile to the Euphrat. They can only achieve this goal in a situation of eternal war, duress, or by fear mongering (even their own people). Even any Jew who stands in their way, will die... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination_of_Yitzhak_Rabin
    1
  23. Thunkful2 Why don't the Jews go to Arizona, and leave the locals alone?
    1
  24. LOL...you are so fake that you are actually funny. Do you think the rest of the world is stupid enough to fall for fake accounts?
    1
  25. As a nation that once suffered under a colonial master... https://crimesofbritain.com/category/india/ ...why do you sympathize with the cause of the colonial power? Did you know that the waves of immigrants and refugees which arrived in the Levant after 1919 are genetically (DNA evidence) nothing but whites/Europeans? Did you know that every single Israeli leader in the first few decades was also terrorist?
    1
  26. Against the common held belief, the "Muslims" did not steal the land from Jews. That is a popular myth, spread by the propaganda machine of Israel, and by Zionists. The reality is that the Jews were chased out of their holy land in 3 waves, the last wave by Italians (Romans) about 2000 years ago. For more than a 1,000 years, Christian invaders (Byzantine Empire) captured the Levant. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Byzantine_Empire The Ottoman Empire defeated the Byzantine Empire, and then dominated the region for around 500 years, until they were in turn defeated during WW1. Therefore, the erroneous belief that "Muslims" stole the land is incorrect. During the reign of the Ottomans, the population stayed more or less the same, but many converted to Islam because it had obvious advantages (taxation, business, etc.). The Muslims did not "steal" anything. They are for the most part the descendants of people who had lived there for generations. For most of history, the rulers were foreigners (upper classes), but the local population (the simple people) remained more or less the same people (Semites). Of course, there was some immigration, meaning that the Levant, like the Lebanon, had always been a region of mixed ethnicity, religions, and cultures. Here you can see a graph of the demographics of the Levant for the last 2000 years or so. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographic_history_of_Palestine_(region)
    1
  27. UnKnowN So what? The Mayan Empire was established long before Mexico. So? Why not ARTIFICIALLY recreate the Mayan Empire? Mayas would sure be happy....
    1
  28. Wars of conquest are illegal according to international law. Use your brain please....
    1
  29. Laws are not made to stop crime. Laws are made in order to prosecute crimes. That's like saying speed restrictions don't stop speeding, so let's abolish all signs...
    1
  30.  @williambonac8157  Huh? Run that by me again...
    1
  31. Slowly oozing their way onto another man's land...
    1
  32. Let them all go back to their churches... Certainly, Jesus will save them.
    1
  33. Gh0st Because the original inhabitants way back were Semitic tribes of various religions, and religion wasn't too much of a political issue during the days of the Ottoman rule. It wasn't until after 1919, when whites appeared in droves as immigrants and refugees, surfing the wave of a colonial power's victory in WW1, and propagating that they were the real "mastah" and that the locals should move over and obey... What could possibly go wrong?
    1
  34. henrikhansen Oh you mean it would be perfectly OK if Mexican immigrants started fighting back and killing ICE troopers?
    1
  35. Jews won't accept it. Because then there will be too many Arabs and in a democracy you cannot impose yourself on others.
    1
  36.  @jackkessler9876  It's not about religious freedom but political freedom. Look at Israel's declaration of independence, in which white immigrants and refugees dictated their political rule over a 2/3 majority... Before that, religious freedom wasn't an issue in Muslim dominated empires like the Ottoman Empire, where millions of Christian Armenians, Greeks, Jews and many others co-existed in relative peace. That only changed after Europeans came in and dictated their politics to the local population... You should work on your timeline. It all started with the end of WW1.
    1
  37. Carlo Ayars You conveniently leave out that a religion should not and does not (normally) grant land rights. So, if I'm a Christian, I don't (and logically SHOULDN'T )get the right to settle in Christian New Zealand. Especially not if a Kiwi has to get kicked off to make room for me. That is how logical (not indoctrinated) people see it.
    1
  38. Dan Livni In all of history, there has never been a state called South Sudan. Today there is, so your point is moot. The fact that a state has never existed in history, does not mean that it doesn't have a right to exist today, if the inhabitants want it to.
    1
  39. OOO OOO They didn't "give it back". It was illegally occupied land, and ever since the end of WW2 (Nuremberg) "wars of conquest" are illegal according to international law. They therefore simply ended the occupation of occupied territory....
    1
  40. According to the logic of the Zionists, Norwegians have a right to demand living in Nova Scotia, and declare their own state there. All they need to do is recreate some ancient myths, and find some ancestral graves... Then, arrive in droves with guns, and start displacing the local population. All they have to do is cheat enough people into believing that they are just "returning home", and that they are really only "taking back" what "Thor gave his chosen people"... Sorry, Canadians. I really respect you, but...you know, "Thor" and all that...(ROTFL) [Google "Vinland Nova Scotia Vikings]
    1
  41. GO VIKINGS. Take back your historic homelands... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vinland_map
    1
  42. Francis Van Meerbeek White Europeans, following an ancient ideology and an agenda....Slowly oozing their way onto another man's land. Are you South African? You must loooove the way blacks are oozing their way onto white lands, right? Perfectly OK, right?
    1
  43. Francis Van Meerbeek Here, the unbiased and objective history of the Levant, after 1919... https://youtu.be/nufBpHmWhtQ ...without any of the bullshitting and ideology.
    1
  44. Francis Van Meerbeek Of course you do. Because you've been conned by a myth... http://www.latimes.com/science/sciencenow/la-sci-sn-ashkenazi-jews-dna-diseases-20140909-story.html Yes, Francis. In 1919, the Jews were just plain old white men from Europe, with an agenda to steal land in the Levant.... DNA does not lie. People do...
    1
  45. Francis Van Meerbeek Where did I ever write that? They should simply stop stealing, that's all. It's not possible to change history, but this agenda of land theft must stop.
    1
  46. Yes, "Israel" probably sounds to the local Palestinians the same way as "Manifest Destiny" to the Native Americans, or "Lebensraum" to Poles or Ukrainians...
    1
  47. jumpingjflash LOL...you are still in "History Channel" propaganda mode. Ever since Begin admitted in a speech in 1982 that 1967 was a classical "land grab", the ENTIRE world knows that Israel attacked first as "a war of choice" (euphemism for "ah well, we lied. We actually did start it...") Begin also admitted that two other wars were started by Israel (1956 Suez, and 1982 Lebanon). https://theintercept.com/2017/06/05/a-50-year-occupation-israels-six-day-war-started-with-a-lie/
    1
  48. Microphonix Virtual Studio A thief who uses conquest to steal land is still a thief....
    1
  49. Jo Alex Sg What goes around comes around... https://theintercept.com/2018/02/19/hamas-israel-palestine-conflict/ Hamas was funded by Israel as a typical ex-colonial "divide and rule" tool to weaken Fatah in the West Bank, thereby torpedoing the Oslo peace plan... The Bible says "reap what you sow". Sow a good seed, reap a good harvest. Sow an evil seed, reap an evil harvest. Even primitive farmers barely out of the Stone Age understood...
    1
  50. Jo Alex Sg I did not write "create". You did. I wrote "fund". http://www.israeltoday.co.il/NewsItem/tabid/178/nid/16447/Default.aspx Israel funded Hamas for years. It is part of the "divide and rule" policy to split the opposition by strengthening opposing fractions.
    1