Comments by "Cole Behnke" (@colebehnke7767) on "TIKhistory" channel.

  1. ​ @peterharris4386 yeah, and it explains how the primary sources for the privatization myth was from a British economics magazine, which described nationalization.
    7
  2. Tell me you didn’t watch the video without telling me you didn’t watch the video…
    7
  3.  @SulliverVittles well the Soviet Union did the exact same thing, so your clam that no socialist community ever did that is blatantly false. According to you the Soviet Union, the socialists that Hitler was raving against, were in fact not socialist? A single nationalized trade union with no democratic control is vary common in socialist countries. Same with banning collective bargaining, because when the collective owns everything then protesting means your protesting against the collective.
    7
  4. So you’re ignoring the whole history of socialism then?
    7
  5.  @surgeland9084 so you didn’t watch the video? Why comment under it then? Like how weren’t the Nazis socialists?
    7
  6. ​ @surgeland9084  yeah doubt. If you did you would know that around 70% of the nazi party were previously socialists. For a group who purged the socialists they sure had a lot of socialists. Basically every other point you make is just like this one, addressed in the video.
    7
  7. He never said it was
    7
  8. ​​ @miasmavoid ok what source do you have for that claim? That Hitler privatized industries?
    7
  9. But his sources are.
    7
  10. Captisilm is the best we got, any other system will be worse. Just check out all other socialist nations and how they handled the environment.
    7
  11. How is it a grift?
    7
  12. You have any evidence for this claim?
    7
  13.  @alexxx4434  and socialism doesn’t allow for centralized state control?
    7
  14.  @alexxx4434  you seem to think that centralized state control makes one exempt from being socialist instead of being a primary objective of it.
    7
  15.  @alexxx4434  your argument, “Fascism is capitalism trying to survive” falls apart when you realize that fascism was born a socialist ideology by socialists that then what on to do socialist things.
    7
  16. Can you provide a contemporary source describing their economic policy as privatization? Checkmate socialists!
    7
  17.  @ntokozosibanyoni1421  well TIK did the research for me, turns out no one at the time called what the Nazis were doing privatization, that was just a myth created by a few people who didn’t understand how nasalization works in the real world.
    7
  18. Wait! You went and checked out someone else because someone told you to under this video, without actually watching this video? Can you be more pathetic?
    7
  19.  @andyknowles772 considering how all your responses have been pathetic, I take it that your haven’t actually watched the video?
    7
  20. TIK was a socialist before he realized that Hitler was a socialist, so all the definitions he used to come to this conclusion are socialist definitions.
    7
  21.  @arnaudaerts1726  you know the Nazis did both of those things, right?
    7
  22. We was a socialist, so if anyone knows it’s him.
    7
  23.  @bananabourbonaenima when has socialism been about equality?
    7
  24. How so?
    7
  25. Did you watch the video?
    7
  26. So what’s wrong in the video?
    7
  27. What’s fascist about it? It literally is against fascism.
    7
  28. Did you actually watch the video?
    7
  29.  @bakters depends, there are a million ways to deal with it.
    7
  30.  @bakters there are a million ways to deal with negative behavior, it’s agreed upon that if you take someone’s rights you leave yourself open to having your own rights taken.
    7
  31. How so?
    7
  32. ​​ @suruxstrawde8322  do you have any evidence for this claim? And did you actually watch the video that showcased how they ruled the same way as other socialists?
    7
  33. I mean all forms of socialism require feelings of superiority over another group.
    7
  34.  @fahrenheigh where do you show that the subject of this video is false? Or are you telling me that without any evidence? Hell you didn’t even watch the video did you?
    7
  35.  @FaustLimbusCompany  the reason we make this argument is because most of Hitler’s bad ideas come directly from socialism. Dehumanizing a segment of the population is wrong, no mater if it is a class or race.
    7
  36.  @nathanbrownmolotov8697 yeah try again…
    7
  37.  @charleymount582 he also ended private property rights…. Tell me you didn’t watch the video without telling me you didn’t watch the video.
    7
  38.  @timfrye3586 dam, maybe you should actually watch to see how he actually proves you wrong…
    7
  39.  @tylerhebron320  like the US, the German government also had the ability to seize private property, but they had to follow a set of procedures. Guess what the Nazis removed? The necessity for procedures. After 1933 all property was on lease from the government as long as you used it to support their goals, it just so happens that they wanted to socialize the people (as all socialists want to do) and once they did that the people were going to support their goals, so you didn’t need to revoke their property.
    7
  40. How so?
    7
  41.  @KeigoUmemura how else are we supposed to know what he wanted to do? Ignoring what he says he believes is ignoring a huge chunk of history.
    7
  42. Tell me you didn’t watch the video without telling me you didn’t watch the video?
    7
  43.  @charliemoore2551 trump is a populist, but he never claimed to be a socialist. Fascists to this day claim to be socialists, where are your arguments against them?
    6
  44.  @imalwaysbluffing then why comment?
    6
  45. The workers owning the means of production isn’t socialism, otherwise it wouldn’t be called that.
    6
  46. How so?
    6
  47. How so?
    6
  48.  @zoidburger2830  so if the Germans killed off all other races and socialized themselves, then you would have an equal state?
    6
  49. So the Soviet Union wasn’t socialist?
    6
  50. Did you actually watch the video?
    6