Comments by "Cole Behnke" (@colebehnke7767) on "TIKhistory" channel.

  1. How so?
    6
  2. Dam, so we can’t consider any extinct form of Christianity to be Christianity because it is dead?
    6
  3.  @Binzob I mean how much free market do we actually have? The things that are the worst are the things that have the most government intervention. Just look at education or healthcare.
    6
  4.  @Effective_tool_of_Satan  so the Nazis hated capitalism, yet they are completely capitalist in nature? Don’t make much sense to me.
    6
  5. Is he wrong?
    6
  6.  @Artixou  socialism isn’t the redistribution of wealth either.
    6
  7. Like what?
    6
  8. Dam, it’s almost like the west absorbed Soviet propaganda to have a united front, then the Marxists who ran to America academia quickly established the “case of war” narrative that are extremely hard to challenge.
    6
  9. Uh, the Nazi Party had the largest trade union at the time.
    6
  10. And who privately owned them?
    6
  11.  @eduard.1917 and he killed capitalists at the same rate, does that make him anti capitalist?
    6
  12.  @xtoll123  I believe socialism was based out of some misconceptions about human nature, mostly the social engineering stuff, and is unfortunately doomed to fail because of that. Additionally I can’t except your definition of capitalism, because under it every socialist regime would’ve been capitalist, basically making it worthless as a word.
    6
  13. So you have any actual arguments against this video?
    6
  14. How so?
    6
  15. Dam, what does far right even mean? Like fascism was a socialist ideology as well. Try actually watching the video before spewing this nonsense.
    6
  16. How so?
    6
  17. Dam, it’s almost like they weren’t communist, they were race based socialists.
    6
  18. So you didn’t watch the video, gotcha. Like I can easily refute all of these arguments, but this is such a gush Gallup that there really is no point.
    6
  19.  @randomuser3481  can you provide a contemporary source that backs up the claim that they privatized the economy?
    6
  20.  @Azazin187 I love most of your excuses here. 1. Ethno-nationalism, social darwinism, or antisemitism don’t make something not socialist. 2. They actively thought the conservative elements to not be threats, which is countered by the fact that conservative elements where the only ones to attempt removing hitter. 3. Did you actually watch the video? TIK quotes from those vary books. Anyone who’s telling you they didn’t centrally plan the economy has clearly not read the sources. 4. Social Darwinism was created by left wing academics. 5. He’s using contemporary sources for this. Basically everyone who has saying the Nazis weren’t socialist just after the war were socialist themselves. The truth is TIK has been debunking most academics because he actually goes to the sources and studies them critically.
    6
  21. The truth on the matter is that the Nazis didn’t have the support of big business until after it looked like they were going to win. So in all actuality it was the reverse that was true, that they used used anti-socialist rhetoric to gain the support of big business in the months leading to them taking power.
    6
  22. How so?
    6
  23. ​ @peterharris4386  who did they privatize them to? Private individuals, or organizations within the nazi party?
    6
  24. So was the Soviet Union…
    6
  25.  @walterbailey2950  so you know nothing of what the Nazis actually believed? Because what you said there was not what they believed at all.
    6
  26. You do understand that there are more kinds of socialism then marxism, right?
    6
  27. ⁠ @SulliverVittles name a socialist country that didn’t purge other socialist parties, in fact the Soviet Union killed off way more socialists then Germany ever did. The Nazis banned private trade unions, consolidating them into the single nationalized trade union, the DAF, witch had 32 million members. This is almost identical to how Cuba and the Soviet Union treated trade unions. The only thing you have here is the halting of wages, witch wouldn’t be possible under a free market system.
    6
  28. Their racism was their socialism.
    6
  29.  @teresacastro1263 they should also call the Soviets union far right if that was the logic they were using.
    6
  30. How so?
    6
  31. Why did the Soviet Union do the same thing?
    6
  32.  @paulsame1124  I mean if the Catholic Church took over the country, suspended all private property rights, and required all businesses to be owned by loyal Catholic Priests, I would say they nationalized their economy.
    6
  33. Did you watch the video? Hitler was a socialist, not a Marxist.
    6
  34. How so?
    6
  35. What lies?
    6
  36. No formal instruction? He has a degree in history.
    6
  37.  @simonbutelerdellepiane5564  so what did he get wrong in this video?
    6
  38. Well socialism isn’t Marxism, but Marxism is socialism.
    6
  39. Na, he is just being a historian, looking at the sources and considering their bias.
    6
  40.  @psychedelicprimate8974  he isn’t saying they are the same thing, he’s saying that Nazism, Fascism, and Marxism are all separate socialist ideologies.
    6
  41. Do you even listen to him yourself? He addresses all of that. Socialism isn’t marxism, but marxism is socialism. Who they are? Socialist academics and the WW2 propaganda machine. Also the Nazis had the largest labor union to date, created massive welfare programs, forced companies owners to support their workers, and their primary economic policy was synchronization, not privatization.
    6
  42. Dam, it’s almost like that was addressed in the video…
    6
  43.  @limitlessapocalypse2702  and?
    6
  44. I would say Stalin did the same thing.
    6
  45. What’s the definition of socialism then?
    6
  46. Why did the Soviet Union jail socialists and trade unionists? When a socialist party takes power, you would do anything to maintain your own power, including supporting the socialist party.
    6
  47. Or maybe the left is becoming the party of the elite college educated thinks to their wealth and specialization are not tied to any country, while the right is the party of the working class trapped in a country people.
    6
  48. Body of work? He barely made anything! He didn’t even complete his second book.
    6
  49. How so?
    6
  50. ⁠ @xxxXOctaneXxxx justify fascism? Fascism was a form of trade unionism and entirely separate from national socialism. Like what fascist things are he trying to justify?
    6