Comments by "Cole Behnke" (@colebehnke7767) on "TIKhistory" channel.

  1. ⁠ @danielsandwhichpants1391 and you used arguments that are addressed in the video. Like Hitler nationalized more then he privatized, and the things that he privatized were done so in name only. Immediately killing your rivals socialists is so common amongst socialists that the nazis doing it fits then trend.
    6
  2.  @GMinus that’s what the Nazis believed, just replace class with race.
    6
  3. TIK has another video debunking that vary fact. There was only one capitalist who supported Hitler before it looked like he was about to win. Communists in Germany were completely distraught when they saw the bloody revolution and famines in the Soviet Union. They split into three camps, the social democrats, the peaceful revolutionaries, and the violent revolutionaries. Hitler was in the third camp until his attempts at a violent revolution failed, then he switched to the peaceful revolution camp. Additionally fascism was a brash of socialism, though Hitler wasn’t a fascist, he was a national socialist.
    6
  4. ⁠@ALFarrell-kv6ok 1. You’re watching a video covering the welfare programs created by Hitler… almost everything he implemented was also implemented by other contemporary socialist nations. 2. Did Hitler actually say that? Or are you telling me you know more about what he believes than he does? 3. What proof do you have for this claim? 4. So did other socialists, was the Soviet union not socialist? 5. So did other socialists, was the Soviet union not socialist? 6. So did other socialists, was the Soviet union not socialist? 7. The Soviet Union also banned other socialist movements, was the Soviet union not socialist? 8. So did other socialists, was the Soviet union not socialist? 9. The great patriotic war, was the Soviet union not socialist? 10. After Russian revolution, many socialists in Germany moved away from the violent revolution idea, and instead wanted a peaceful revolution, where the means of production would be gradually brought under state control. Guess what Hitler and Strasser disagreed on? It definitely wasn’t racism or nationalism. 11. Because the Soviet Union said the Nazis were right wing for propaganda purposes… 12. Source? Because I’m pretty sure the source disagrees with you. 13. If things were slightly different, fascist Italy could’ve gone to war with Germany. Hitler often praised bolshevism, and said that if it wasn’t secretly controlled by the Jews they would be allies. 14. The Soviet Union also banned other socialist movements, was the Soviet union not socialist? 15. Source… 16. Yeah, TIK has another video going over this exact topic. Most historians now admit that Hitler wasn’t financed into power in any meaningful way by capitalists. It was only after he got into power that capitalists tried to bribe him. Question for you. Did you watch the video?
    6
  5.  @bananabourbonaenima dam, that’s the goal of the Nazis, they just thought that you needed a permanent revolution, otherwise socialism would decay back to a previous state, and so a state was required for permanent enforcement of socialism.
    6
  6.  @Kriegserinnerungen  are you serious? Did you actually watch the video?
    6
  7. Tell me you didn’t watch the video without telling me you didn’t watch the video…
    6
  8. What are you talking about? Hitler hated the Aristocracy, who do you think stabbed Germany in the back in said theory?
    6
  9. How is he a nazi? How does someone who believes in free markets equal someone who wants to control markets?
    6
  10.  @randomuser3481  wasn’t their whole deal synchronization? The first step is to get all property under the control of the Germans, then they would voluntarily give it up.
    6
  11. How so?
    6
  12. So you’re didn’t watch the video. What in the world is right-wing, much less ultra right-wing?
    6
  13. So the Soviet Union didn’t have Trade Unions?
    6
  14. How so?
    6
  15. Market economy ran by the government? Are you serious?
    6
  16. Because they were their biggest political rivals? Hitler hated communists because he thought they were not true socialists.
    6
  17. What’s did he get wrong?
    6
  18.  @RandomVex  good thing TIK made a 20 minute video that covers the same things but in less detail, in the case people use this videos length as an excuse.
    6
  19.  @RandomVex  simple, Socialism’s core concept is sacrificing the rights of the individual for the benefit of the collective, turns our the right to vote is generally the first to go, and without that right there is vary little preventing it from becoming authoritarian.
    6
  20.  @suruxstrawde8322 how is that any different from what other socialists did to each other in other socialist countries? Hitler believed his socialism was the one true socialism, and that all the others were fakes.
    6
  21.  @rn6312 well how is it garbage? You have any arguments besides appeal to authority?
    6
  22. 15 minutes in a hour long video. Let’s see what he missed. Oh, TIK was saying what communist in Germany were saying.
    6
  23.  @hobbso8508 no, because feudalism didn’t call themselves socialist.
    6
  24.  @andyknowles772 unfortunately your narrative breaks down once you consider what systemically prosecuting someone is to the Nazis. It was a political move and not an ideological one, otherwise millions of socialists would’ve died in the concentration camps.
    6
  25.  @diegogbox  you should probably watch his other videos, they go into this in much more depth.
    6
  26.  @fahrenheigh what’s false narratives does it create?
    6
  27. Socialists kill other socialists all the time.
    6
  28.  @Schnoz42069  what do you think voting is? Voting doesn’t just spontaneously appear whenever it’s needed, no it becomes an institution with set rules and procedures. Voting is an institution of governing things. Additionally, how would the will of the vote be enforced?
    6
  29. No, he was a socialist.
    6
  30.  @kryoraptor7985  fascism is a distinct ideology form nazism and marxism that views the world through the lens of nationality. Nazism, marxism, and fascism are all distinct ideologies, but they are all forms of socialism.
    6
  31. ​​​​ @omarisawesome1996 care to provide examples? Like the main argument you use is so dumb, of course a socialist will see all other kinds of socialism as fake and bogus. Socialists say that about him in equal measure. He believed Nazism was traditional socialism and that all other forms of socialism were corrupted by the jews, he considered Marxism with its class analysis to be corruption of real socialism meant to divide the working race.
    6
  32. Private property was suspended, so I doubt that. It seems you just don’t know the sources.
    6
  33. ⁠ @charleymount582 I mean, they literally suspended private property rights in the reichstag fire decree in 1933. In the end these owners were in principle, middle managers for the Nazi party. They has a decent say in how their business where run, like any middle manager, but in the end they didn’t own the business or the profits of said business. The fact that you ignore this fact tells me you didn’t watch the video.
    6
  34. But if they were traditionalists, wouldn’t they have brought back the Kaiser?
    6
  35. When you realize that Strasser believed in race based socialism.
    6
  36. Dam, so when the state protects its own property, it must be private property!
    6
  37.  @benmorton8945 how did the capitalist own the profits if they only could spend them on what the state wanted?
    6
  38. How so?
    6
  39.  @auratheevinkian well if I’m so stupid, it should be easy to explain what’s wrong with the video?
    6
  40.  @timfrye3586 dam, so you are so afraid of having your beliefs challenged… It’s funny, most people who disagree with TIK don’t even watch his videos, and so are completely incapable of challenging him. So why is the title wrong? The recycling bin says it’s a recycling bin, and you come along and say it accurately a trash bin because recycling bins are fake. Dam you could prove your point by checking.
    6
  41. And the company owner had to set the hours and wages that the nazi party demanded… And what could the company owners actually do with their profits?
    6
  42.  @TheHandsomeman no, there is no evidence of a painting existing. And claims without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.
    6
  43. Ha, ha, ha! What makes one a historian then?
    6
  44. Did you even watch the video?
    6
  45. How so?
    5
  46. So how did he get it wrong?
    5
  47.  @charliemoore2551 dam, it’s almost like they called themselves socialists and everyone believed them. Like learn basic history for a second.
    5
  48.  @IrishSwede  what is he getting wrong? I’ve yet to see a good argument.
    5
  49.  @markfrederikbaksrensen8574  no you would be a historian and a psychopath. Look, TIK used to be a socialist, it was only after reading the sources and considering their biases that he came to the conclusion that the Nazis were socialist, and now he is standing around saying, “hey the sources don’t say that, just look.”
    5
  50.  @aligindahouse7777 so did you watch the video?
    5