General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Cole Behnke
TIKhistory
comments
Comments by "Cole Behnke" (@colebehnke7767) on "TIKhistory" channel.
Previous
6
Next
...
All
@1949-SSSR yeah, witch has nothing to do with capitalism.
5
Was the Roman Catholic Church a part of the government? And did the people doing this call themselves socialists? As I said in another comment, if the Catholic Church took over the country, suspended all private property rights, and required all businesses to be owned by loyal Catholic Priests, I would say they nationalized their economy.
5
Tell me you didn’t watch the video without telling me you didn’t watch the video.
5
@TylerLee-g7f dam, google is so trustworthy, it spews unsubstantiated claim like no other.
5
Dam, you should tell that to the communists in Germany at the time. There is a reason TIK brought it up and didn’t clarify.
5
No.
5
Like how was Hitler not socialist?
5
Even for their time they were socialist.
5
How so?
5
@WhiteWolf126 third position. Literally calls himself a socialist and does everything a socialist would do.
5
The Nazis created the biggest trade union ever, so I don’t know what your thinking about.
5
Capitalists who hated liberals?
5
@1sb3rg34 how so?
5
Please try again. Most of your arguments come from an complete misunderstanding of what socialism is and what it can do. Like collective ownership is by its vary nature authoritarian.
5
So you didn’t watch the video, how can selling a few stocks to nazi party members counteract the fact they nationalized all industry?
5
@andyknowles772 The DAF disagrees with you, it was the largest labor union in the world at the time with a membership of 32 million.
5
@hobbso8508 the job of a historian is to look at the sources and question them. If your not questioning the authenticity of a source then your not a historian.
5
@Scrubletman632 no. I said they ran TO academia in the west. There they spread their ideas and nobody refuted them because why would they?
5
How so?
5
What’s wrong?
5
And nether is it capitalism.
5
Defend private property? They suspended it in 1933!
5
@eduard.1917 he was mostly inspired by marxism and various eugenicists. Hie entire ideology was combining the two most popular ideas in Germany at the time, social wellness through controlling trade, and social wellness through controlling bloodlines. protected private property after suspending it in 1933?
5
@dwizzi1724 my problem is that socialism simultaneously gets rid of all the laws that protect us from abuse. Is it no wonder that every socialist regime fell to dictatorships.
5
These oligarchs became the government, thus the state controlled the means of production.
5
@fiachramaccana280 so you didn’t actually watch any of his videos, you just got offended in the first 5 minutes and refused to listen to the arguments being presented. Yeah, you can’t disprove that the Nazis were socialists.
5
Private property was suspended in 1933, years before war. And did the “owners” actually own the profits?
5
What are you talking about?
5
@alfgarcia965 dam, what a way to completely miss the point, Germanic branches of socialism was always more nationalistic. What Hitler was claiming was that ancient tribal societies practiced socialism, which is identical to what most other socialists of the time were saying. He literally says that his socialism was true ancient socialism, which was extremely tribalistic and raciest but egalitarian to the in group, and that Jews tried corrupting the idea to devide races through class conflict.
5
@SkeeterHowitzer so you didn’t actually watch the video where those arguments are addressed?
5
Try again?
5
@TlsMS93 get this georgism out of here.
5
How so?
5
Well it turns out 78 years of historical consensus are not supported by the sources.
5
@randomuser3481 all of those are the refuted by their actual actions. For someone who loves private property why did he suspend it?
5
@hobbso8508 so Nazi Germany gave all property to the ruling public organization.
5
@hobbso8508 I mean if a church put you in change of a company but could remove you at any time, you would call that company church owned. But if a political party did the same it’s suddenly completely different.
5
@hobbso8508 but the state also determined what your profits could be and how you could spend them, doesn’t seem like you own the profits.
5
@hobbso8508 there’s also the fact that the Nazis were in the process of expropriating almost every sector of the economy.
5
@hobbso8508 then what is socialism? Remember that this definition must also fit the Soviet Union.
5
@hobbso8508 Republics work by having people represent their constituents, so representation is all that required. Can you show me proof that the Soviet Union didn’t represent the wishes of the people?
5
Uh, the Soviet Union aligns with conservative on social values, like learn basic history.
5
You should actually watch the video, all of those points are addressed. Please.
5
Dam, you must hate a third of all socialist than.
5
How did he encourage capitalism, he hated liberals.
5
Uh, when does he change the meaning of words after establishing what they mean?
5
So you don’t watch the video.
5
What makes something a capitalist system?
5
@WolfinLondon2 Marx makes it quite clear that the Jews where capitalist.
5
@SulliverVittles you should watch the video then, it covers the Nazis economic policy in great detail. The Nazis party had such control over the economy that most business owners considered themselves mere managers for the Nazi party.
5
Previous
6
Next
...
All