Comments by "Cole Behnke" (@colebehnke7767) on "TIKhistory" channel.

  1.  @SulliverVittles  how would America be falling down even faster with free market capitalism? It seems to me that ninety percent of all problems facing the country right now stem from government regulation.
    5
  2. Dam, it’s almost like the contents of that video were addressed in this one…
    5
  3.  @teresacastro1263 dam, I didn’t know capitalists were not a group of people.
    5
  4. A corporate state that enforced price controls and centrally determined employment and wages?
    5
  5. They were socialists, they just believed that the collective consciousness couldn’t be awakened naturally and had to be artificially created. Thus their attempt to unite the collective around the concept of race.
    5
  6. Who do you think educates modern Nazis?
    5
  7.  @kabedonovan5555  what?
    5
  8. You should really watch the video.
    5
  9. So what’s your reasoning? And what’s your evidence, do Nazis ever make this claim about themselves?
    5
  10. Did you watch the video?
    5
  11.  @samikatto2851 so you don’t even watch the part where TIK says they weren’t Marxists, you know, the type of socialist that cared about workers?
    5
  12. Dam, it’s almost like he wanted a peaceful revolution instead of a violent one…
    5
  13. So you didn’t watch the video? By this definition the Soviet Union wasn’t socialist, which is absurd.
    5
  14.  @PeterFriedsam how so?
    5
  15. ⁠ @hp5864 un, it’s largely the modern historical conciseness that the Nazis was largely a grassroots organization and wasn’t tied to big capital until just before before they won the elections, far too late to have an impact. Explain the ideology of modern techno fascism. What is the ideology that techno fascists are advocating for. Also actually watch the videos, TIK makes it explicitly clear that Nazism isn’t Marxism.
    5
  16. So you didn’t actually watch the video?
    5
  17. ​ @surgeland9084 ask yourself, where are the millions of killed socialists? Also you sure you watched the video? He covers how the Nazis did not private the economy, in fact the primary sources for this claim were not even there and can be rejected for more contemporary sources.
    5
  18.  @surgeland9084  So what are your arguments against his sectional on privatization 2:10:43? Like the Nazis killing socialists doesn’t make them not socialist, otherwise that would disqualify every socialist state ever. It a fact that the after the night of the long knives, the vast majority of new members of the Nazi party were former socialists. Why would a group who just got done with purging their party of socialists then let more socialists in? Like they had the records, they knew these people used to be socialists. Also look at the beliefs of the socialists that were purged, many of them were fully onboard with the idea of racial socialism. So even if the Nazis weren’t socialist, their ideology clearly was.
    5
  19.  @jonathand3842 and you didn’t watch the video.
    5
  20. Did you watch the video?
    5
  21. ⁠ @hobbso8508 Marx didn’t actually believe that a revolution could be done democratically, he believed democracy in a capitalist society was so corrupt that it could never bring about socialism.
    5
  22.  @psychedelicprimate8974 nd who killed the mensheviks? Hitler did not exterminate the communists. In the first year of Nazi rule only 600 of these communists were killed, all the other communists who were arrested were reeducated in the workcamps. Just like anything else in 3rd grade, most of the important details about the Nazis ideology was left out.
    5
  23. The Nazis centralized the unions into a single national union, just like the Soviets.
    5
  24. How so?
    5
  25.  @hobbso8508 Nether does most unions in socialist states. Turns out when the state give you authority your no longer bound to the workers.
    5
  26. Well what’s wrong?
    5
  27.  @rohanthandi4903 what makes someone a fake historian?
    5
  28. Dam, so you are a worthless ideologue who doesn’t understand that the Nazis were socialists and that any proper right wing American should be fervently against the reds and their genoncidal tendencies.
    5
  29. Did you watch the video?
    5
  30. I didn’t agree with him at first, but he is right, Marxism a a cult.
    5
  31.  @andyknowles772  so have you actually watched the video?
    5
  32. Did you actually watch the video?
    5
  33.  @arnaudaerts1726  so you didn’t watch the video, TIK addressed that.
    5
  34.  @arnaudaerts1726  then you clearly didn’t grasp several fundamental aspects of what he was talking about
    5
  35.  @arnaudaerts1726  what are you talking about in your lest comment? That free markets are not contrary to Nazi beliefs?
    5
  36. True, just most forms of socialism had some form of antisemitism, mainly to prey upon the working class who already where antisemitic at the time.
    5
  37. Did you actually watch the video?
    5
  38. If killing socialist made you not one, wouldn’t Stalin also not be a socialist?
    5
  39.  @Kriegserinnerungen  so your ignoring the hundreds of sources because you have a problem with one?
    5
  40. How so?
    5
  41. Did you actually watch the video?
    5
  42. Lots of things, the Nazis didn’t have private property, didn’t have independent trade unions, didn’t have a private stock exchange, etc. China is ruled by a communist party, so it having socialist policies shouldn’t come at a surprise.
    5
  43.  @shakey3306 how exactly?
    5
  44. The Soviets killed socialists, so that isn’t a big of an argument as you think.
    5
  45. What? I’m pretty sure that’s one socialist policy that most socialists agree that Hitler did.
    5
  46. Dam, maybe you should read the quotes from communists at the time.
    5
  47. Who was he spying on exactly?
    5
  48. The thing is the Nazis considered the aryans to be the workers.
    5
  49. Did you watch the video?
    5
  50.  @coonhound_pharoah what if the government reduced itself to its most basic tasks, thus reducing the costs of taxation to a level that people would be willing to pay for if it was voluntary. Then you could make it voluntary, and if people want to not pay the government they could find a new competitor organization that does what the government does but better.
    5