Comments by "Cole Behnke" (@colebehnke7767) on "TIKhistory" channel.

  1.  @ast453000  socialists kill other socialists all the time, nothing new.
    5
  2. It is a justification of the concentration camps, the Nazis justification. TIK doesn’t believe what the Nazis believe, but as a historian you have to find out otherwise your missing a huge part of history, the motive.
    5
  3. Dam what an argument. It’s almost like he was regurgitating his old incorrect socialist beliefs.
    5
  4.  @hobbso8508 wasn’t asking you, so any proof?
    5
  5.  @LeeZaslofsky and your ignoring the numerous sources he used?
    5
  6.  @LeeZaslofsky  you should actually listen to his points, before the war everyone knew they were socialists, it was only during the war when propaganda was blazing that we decided they were not, mostly because we where allied with the Soviets who already created the easy to disseminate propaganda of them being anti-socialist. Most historians then followed the narrative built during the war dispute most of their first person accounts refuting it.
    5
  7. Did you actually watch the video?
    5
  8. I think there was one guy who hated privatization who tried to link what the Nazis did to privatization to discredit it.
    5
  9. Just like the Soviet Union?
    5
  10. Wow, socialism doesn’t allow for free unions.
    5
  11. My boy, the Nazis didn’t privatize things, nor did they call it such, it was a British newspaper that said they were privatizing by describing them nationalizing industries. This was addressed in the video, if you actually watched it.
    5
  12. So your ignoring the rest of the video showing how it’s not a misnomer?
    5
  13. You do know that the DAF had 32 million members, for a ideology that hated unions it’s odd that they had one of the biggest in history.
    5
  14. Yeah, and the Soviet union also killed socialists. So you can’t use that argument to prove or disprove wither the Nazis were socialist.
    5
  15. How is someone who hates socialism and equates Nazism so socialism a Nazi?
    5
  16. How so?
    5
  17.  @fahrenheigh what about the subject of this video is false?
    5
  18.  @GREGORYABUTLER  “pro capitalist” source? “Smashed the trade unions, outlawed strikes, and made socialist and communist parties illegal.” Like every other socialist who got power. “How could they be ‘socialists’ when they sent actual socialists to concentration camps” That’s pretty standard for socialists, putting their political rivals, who just so happen to be socialists, into camps and gulags. “Also the Nazis were EXTREMELY RACIST AND ANTISEMITIC” It’s like you never read Karl Marx. Get out of your fantasy, that’s not socialism, well it’s not the only form of socialism. You follow the one branch of socialism that survived to this day.
    5
  19.  @jajajjajjaajjaa why would anyone here support socialists of any kind, fuck musk.
    5
  20. Who said anything about the name?
    5
  21.  @hobbso8508 yeah, you should actually watch the video. Hitler was in a German military, the Bavarian military, so somehow he was spying on his own team?
    5
  22. How so?
    5
  23. What datapoint? Your very words say that there is no data. Like we should be able to see these wealthy businessmen withdrawing a large amount of money and the Nazis receiving a large amount of money, or at least some other major discrepancy.
    5
  24. That’s addressed in the first five minutes.
    5
  25.  @Schnoz42069  how exactly would that work? Because honestly it looks like a cult leaders paradise.
    5
  26. Uh, the historical definition of socialism is the social ownership of the means of the production, government ownership is a form of social ownership. The real kicker is he started socializing the economy the moment he took power.
    5
  27.  @skepticalextraterrestrial2971  but who? Because before then Nazis didn’t have any support amongst the industrials or aristocracy.
    5
  28.  @joekopsick1540 the Jews were the enemy, like how the capitalist is the enemy in marxism. They were never promised anything.
    5
  29. How so?
    5
  30. So you didn’t watch the video. Good to know.
    5
  31.  @stef65856 no, you just can’t use the fact that they banned strikes to prove they were not socialist.
    5
  32. So what exactly did he get wrong?
    5
  33. How could they have easily have been prevented?
    5
  34.  @Scrubletman632 it isn’t, witch is why he has a 20 minute version of this video…
    5
  35.  @saphy45-uu8rd so what happens when you are wrong?
    5
  36. TIK used to be a socialist, if anyone knows, it would’ve him.
    5
  37.  @leftistadvocate9718 simple, he ran out of money, so to get enough to get elected he lied to the rich industrialists to get their support for a time. Obviously he then immediately betrayed them by suspending private property and arresting the ones who didn’t submit to his rule. The mass privatization wasn’t called privatization then because he was pulling in all these industries directly into his organization. Imagine if the Catholic Church did the same thing, selling every part of the government that wasn’t catholic to priests. No one in their right mind would call that privatization. Executing your political rivals is standard in socialist states, same with suppressing trade unions. And through the entirety of the first year of Nazis rule only 600 socialists were killed.
    5
  38.  @hobbso8508  The law dictating how the government could appropriate private property was suspended, there was no private property.
    5
  39.  @rickglorie  TIK never claimed that Hitler was a Marxist, he claimed that he was a National Socialist, you know, Socialism for the German.
    5
  40. How so?
    5
  41. How so?
    5
  42. Need, as can be seen in The Vampire Economy and Hitler’s Beneficiaries.
    5
  43. How is TIK a fascist?
    5
  44. Marxism is based around class, socialism isn’t based around anything.
    5
  45.  @diegogbox  so it’s fine to chary pick ideas when it’s to prove that Hitler wasn’t a socialist, but wrong when it’s to prove that he was.
    5
  46. Did you watch the video?
    5
  47.  @HellIsInfinite  but it wasn’t just steel and iron, it was everything. Additionally their economic policy wasn’t one of nationalization, it was one of synchronization, a vary socialist idea in concept and in practice.
    5
  48. Odd how every socialist state uses a authoritarian war economy?
    5
  49. Did you watch the video?
    4
  50. Try again?
    4